High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13236/2021allowed

Surbhi Jain v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-11-17Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil8 pages

!"#" $% &""

'( )*+'"

, +, ++ '* ****

!"#

$

% !"#

& !'

("!& & !"#

% !"# *+

&& !"# ,- .'/ 0%12 " -./

0 " "% !#**23 4

#

&

&# 1 *+ # # 5# 6& # -0

7.

*7*7

5# 6&& , 8

7.

*7*.

% 9 1 " 1 1

"

:## 1 3&& -#:&3 "#/ 1 *7.2- *7.2/ .+ *7.;-!

*/ .,+

3" "#-' / *7.2- *7.2/

5 *7 *7.; -!

,/ ! 9 1# 7< *7*7-!

</" #

- 2 -

7.

*7*7 -!

+/ % & #/ (#

# #

& & 7.

*7*7 9

&"

"# #/ =.*>

-*/

? # &

& # -0 #/ +7 ..

*7*7 0

6&#1#& # 7.

*7*7-!

+/ " &

6& +.

7@ *7*.

" .,+

3""#-' / *7.2

5 *7 *7.; -!

,/ 1 # 6&& &

-+/

4# .,+*7.2 11" &#

1

# " 3 # (# & 8&& " +-/ 1 .< 1 *7.2 &#

6&1A&# #B

" 1"

#

-,/

)# &

** *7*. 9 ) .+

# # "

% , "

- 3 - -@/

.+ +7 *7*.

% 1 " 1

1& 1 # " 1 1 *7.2 # 1 ) , #

+7 *7*.

-2/

) *+ +7 *7*. " 6 11

# # ##& # #

& ! 3 # - /

&1 1

# & % &

#

6&8& #

8 4

" "

#

#

&1 #

"1 &

-C/

!1 "& & #

& # # & & 1 & 3&& " 1 # 6 3&& " 1 .< +-/ 1 *7.2 "D #& #5# 1 1 '" 53&& &

#& # & ##& -;/

? # & # ) *+

# 9 # 58 # #-0 / #

- 4 - 3&& #/##& & # # " 3&& & % & & #&

# #

4 "& & .,+ *772

3&&

&# 1 *7.2 ## " &

# 3 # 9 1 *7.2

" # ## #&

-</

&& !"# , 7;

7* *7** # # & *6:3

#

:## & !# .<<C

# 9 6(#

# 53 '" & # & % 1 #

# 1

D & .<<< 1 # & #

% # 3 !#

# " 1 :## !# *77+

" 3&& (#

:## 0

6 3&& & "# '"

- 5 - -.7/

? # ,!

* E ..

*7.. & '"

& # 11 #

# & # #"

'" #"

& '"

'"

# -../

4# # "

# #& 5 5& 5# # # & &

0 # "6 # -.*/

0 # " 1

& & -.+/

#

1 1# -.,/

4 &

# 1"

# , # # 1 #

1 1 1& # &

8 11

" 1 !# && # " & :3 1 *7.2 :3 *7** " % 1

#"" &1 #%

#& ##& #

& 4

6&& , :31 *7** &

- 6 - *7.2 "1 :" *7** 1

1 # #&*7*7

*7*.

-.@/

F

) * +

" *C *7*. " ,

& &:31 *7.2 +7 *7*. #

( 1 " #& #

&# ,

1 *7*7 &# 1

8 # 1*7*7*7*. #

*@ 7* *7** -!

6../ 4 #& 9

1 ! 3# - /

.C 7.

*7*7

1 # 1 " "5 # '" -.2/

; 1 *7.2 "

# 3&& #

& 1 ##& &# # 1 +-./ F1 "# & " 1 #&

# 1 .< 3 444 1 *7.2 " "

#

# "

3&&

"

6&& , 3&&

- 7 - # # &

& 0

8 " 1

,& #%

8 1

##

# "

1 1

" 1 #

9 " 1 #" & ,

9& " 1 # #& 5#&##

81 # 1 1 , #

& 9& -.C/

0

# # -0 / & 1 *7**

&1 1

# 1 *7** # " & G " *C *7*. *+ " ,

& & 1 *7.2 .+ *7.;

0

6# # #& & 1 *7** 1 *7.2 0 #

& %#&

& # #% 1 " & 1

& -.;/

! 1 1 1 1 *7.2 " " 6&& " 8

3" "# -' / *7.2 #

'" *7 *7.;

0 ,

- 8 - 6&

'" 1 +* 3 4 1 *7.2 #

# # #& " 1 ) +-/ #"

'! # 1 9 # 3 -/ 1 + 3&&

" # "%9 3 &

3&& -.</

F

# 7< *7*7 -!

</ (# 1 7.

*7*7 -!

+/ & % 1 & #-0 / 9 0 *+ ## B#

&

#-0 /& 7.

*7*7 # 1 # 6&!

#-!## / "

:## 3&& -#

:& 3 "#/ *7.2 9 # 1 & "

"# #

=2>

& & ### -*7/

## 1 .C ..

*7*+ 3,- .'/ 0%14

/ 0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No