High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/7234/2015allowed

Pakhar Singh And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2015-11-09Mr. Justice Krishna Murari7 pages

! "#$$%&'&()*$+,$-./

"01"-2&(31"(4"(#1$- 5 $#&#&($-' 6' 2#"#$ 7(8","(4"(- 5 $'9(4$(#' ) :; 22

-$'$(#) - "(8"(;"01"(9"</4*%"#$ -#1$9$#&#&($-' -"'1"(9-$$#2&(31// 7(8", - "%1$<=7<4$$92#74<$>/4*%"#$--$'9(4$(#

1&'9$#&#&(1"',$$(9-$$--$47(4$-2$%#&(?- - '$$0&(3 9$-+&''&( # 3 ",-"4 ,> @7"'1&(3 -4$- 4"#$4 %#,$-

/"(($A7-$ ,>*&-#7$B1&%1#1$441&$74&%&"<"3&'#-"#$/ '1&"-97-&("9-&*"#$%+9<"&(#&<$4&(#1$>$"-

?1"'-$7'$4#3-"(# 9$-+&''&(# "01"-2&(31"(41&(4$-="7-#3",-"4,>-$<$"'&(3 #1$&- 9"''9-#' 4&',$<&$*&(3 #1"# "01"- 2&(31 B"' %"(%$- 9"#&$(# 7(4$-

#-$"#+$(# &( 27((> 0 $"<#1 2%&$(%$ $(#-$/ 4$##$ "(%$- $(#-$/ -(# #&'9$-#&($(##,'$-*$1$-$#1"#47-&(3#1$9$(4$(%>#1&' 9$#&#&(/ "01"-2&(311"'4&$4"(4#1$9$#&#&('7-*&*$'(<>-1&(4$- ="7- -&$"%#'-$<$*"(#-#1$4$%&'&(#1$9-$'$(#9$#&#&("-$ #1"# "0'1&'1 ="7- -$'9(4$(# 1"4 &<$4 " 9-&*"#$ %+9<"&(# 7(4$- 2$%#&( C/ /./ (*$+,$-?/

?&(#1$7-# 74&%&"<"3&'#-"#$'#<"''/'1&"-97-##1$$$%##1"#1$-+"--&"3$B"' '<$+(&D$4B&#1 "01"-2&(31(B4$%$"'$4!&(#1$>$"- .

&(*&<<"3$ "01B"<1$"+&<> +$+,$-' "01"-2&(311"4+"<#-$"#$41$-"(4 #7-($41$-7##1$+"#-&+(&"<1+$"''7%1'1$-$+"&($4'#">&(3B&#1 1$-9"-$(#'#&<< .C "01"-2&(311"4&<$4"9$#&#&(7(4$-2$%#&(. #1$&(47"--&"3$%#B1&%1B"'$(4$4&(%+9-+&'$&(#1$>$"- .C (-$7(&(/"$+"<$%1&<4=7<4$$9="7-B"',-(( %#,$-

.C"# 6&<<"3$ 1"00B"< ,7# #1$ %+9<"&("(# -$'9(4$(# -$+"&($4 "# 1$- 9"-$(#'17'$"'#1$%1&<4B"'(#B$<<%%7'$4 "01"-2&(31<$#(4&" - "("4" "#$- '<$+(&D&(3 '$%(4 +"--&"3$ B&#1 1&(4$- ="7- &( 7-4B"-" &"(/ <&%$ 2#"#&( 2"4"-/ &'#-&%# '1&"-97- %%7'$4 *#"-2&(31/,-#1$- "01"-2&(31"(4"%%7'$41&(4"2&(31B$-$ 9-$'$(#"##1$#&+$#1$+"--&"3$ '9$-%+9<"&(#/('9$%&&%4"#$+"--&"3$1"',$$(3&*$( ,7#&#&'+$(#&($4&(9"-"#1$-$#1"#,-#1$- "01"-2&(311"497#

'1"37("(49$--+$4%$-$+(>+&<(&"%%7'$4 "01"-2&(31/ 4$%$"'$49$#&#&($- "<(3B&#19$#&#&($-B$-$+"--&$4&(#1$>$"-

. &(6&<<"3$&"("(41"4<$#-"("4",>3&*&(3"<'$&(-+"#&(# #1$"("4&"(+,"''>,>,#"&(&(3 &"(%$$6&'" $#&#&($-"%%7'$4 "01"- 2&(31 97-%1"'$4 9-9$-#> &( #1$ ("+$ 1&' +#1$- ,7# <"#$- (/ 1$ #-"('$--$4#1$'"+$&(#1$("+$1&(4$-="7-,>"E&<<$A$%7#$4,> +#1$- "01"-2&(31B->"-#&%<$'"-$&(#1$%7'#4>"%%7'$4' "(4 1$#-&"<7-#1"4'7++($4#1$9$#&#&($-'"'"%%7'$47(4$- 2$%#&( . -$"4 B&#1 2$%#&( *&4$ -4$- 4"#$4 7<>

1$> B$-$ 4$%<"-$4 9-%<"&+$4 $(4$-' 1"*&(3 (# ,$$( '$-*$4 ,$&(3-$'&4$(#'"("4"1$&-9-9$-#>B"'"##"%1$4"(497##"7%#&( "(4B"''<4-%('&4$-"#&( '<"%'E1$(#1$9$#&#&($-'*&'&#$4 (4&"&(-4$-#3$##1$&-9-9$-#>-$<$"'$4/#1$>B$-$"--$'#$4,>#1$9<&%$ -+ #1$ &-9-# "(4 #1$> -$+"&($4 &( 874&%&"< %7'#4> 1$-$"#$- #1$> B$-$ -$<$"'$4 ( ,"&< 1$ 9$#&#&($-' B$-$ (# ",<$ # <$"*$ (4&" ( "%%7(#9$(4$(%>#1$%-&+&("<9-%$$4&(3'1$9$#&#&($-'+*$4"( "99<&%"#&( &( #1$ >$"-

- 9$-+&''&( # 3 ",-"4 ,7# #1$ '"&4 "99<&%"#&(1"4,$$(4&'+&''$4*&4$-4$-4"#$4 %#,$-

1$#-&"< 7-#4&'+&''$4#1$"99<&%"#&(4&',$<&$*&(3#1"#4$%$"'$4 "01"-2&(31B"' '7$-&(3-+"(%$-4$'9&#$#1$"%##1"#+$4&%"<$*&4$(%$B"'9-47%$4 &(4&%"#&(3#1"#1$B"''7$-&(3-+7<#&9<$>$<+";$'&('&(;"(4

;

*$-#,-"< ,4&$' 4%7+$(# &(4&%"#&(3 #1"# #1$ 4$%$"'$4 1"4 "( "99&(#+$(#B&#1 4$##$"(%$-$(#-$&("("4"B"'"<'(#,$<&$*$4 # &' 9$-#&($(# # ,'$-*$ 1$-$ #1"# #1$ +"&( 3-&$*"(%$ #1$ %+9<"&("(#&(#1$%+9<"&(#&<$4&(#1$>$"-

?&'#1"#&(#1$>$"- . 4$%$"'$4 "01"-2&(311"''<$+(&D$4'$%(4+"--&"3$"#$0(B<$43$ +"--&"3$ 1"' (# ,$$( +$(#&($4 ,> #1$ %+9<"&("(# &( #1$ %+9<"&(# "(($A7-$ ,7#&#&'"("4+&##$4"%##1"##1$%+9<"&(#B"'&<$4&(#1$ >$"-

?"#$-"9$-&4",7#>$"-'#1$"<<$3$4$(%$1"*&(3,$$( %++&##$47(4$-2$%#&(. #&'(#"*$--$4&(#1$%+9<"&(##1"# 1&(4$- ="7- 1"4 0(B<$43$ ",7# #1$ &-'# +"--&"3$ "01"- 2&(31 29$%&&%4">/4"#$"(4#&+$&-'#"(4'$%(4+"--&"3$1"'"<'(#,$$( 3&*$( 7('$< - #1$ 9$#&#&($-' 1"' 9-">$4 - @7"'1&(3 -4$- 4"#$4 %#,$-

/%<"&+&(3#1"#&#&'"(",7'$#1$9-%$''7-# "(4&(#1$&(#$-$'#87'#&%$/#1$9$#&#&($-''17<41"*$,$$(9$-+&##$4# <$"*$(4&" (#1$#1$-1"(4/%7('$<--$'9(4$(#1"'*$1$+$(#<> 7-3$4#1"#9$#&#&($-1"4+*$4"+&'%"99<&%"#&(-<$"*&(3(4&" "#$-#1$4$"#11$-17',"(4 "01"-2&(31B1&%11"',$$(4&'+&''$4,>"( &(#$-&+-4$-4"#$47<>

/-$7'&(3#9$-+&#9$#&#&($-##"0$ #1$,4>1$-17',"(4#"("4"(#1$3-7(4#1"##1$-$B"'",'<7#$ 9-,",&<&#>#1"#'1$B7<4(#-$#7-(-+#1$-$$'9$%&"<<>B1$(#1$-$&'(

9-9$-#>&(1$-("+$1$-$"(4"<<1$--$<"#&*$'"-$&("("4"/#1$-$-$/'7%1 9$-+&''&(B"'4$%<&($4#1$- 1"*$%('&4$-$4"<<#1$"%#'"(4%&-%7+'#"(%$'#1$%"'$# &'"<'(#7#9<"%$#,'$-*$1$-$#1"##1$%+9<"&("(#"<(3B&#11$- 4"731#$-1"4"99$"-$4&(#1$7-#&(9$-'("<(3B&#1#1$&-%7('$<"##1$ #&+$1$"-&(3#&(-+#1&'7-##1"#"%&*&<<&#&3"#&(&'9$(4&(3,$#B$$( #1$%+9<"&("(#"(41$&-' "01"-2&(31&( 2

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

/-$'9(4$(#&<$4"+&'%"99<&%"#&(

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

$'#",<&'1&(3#1$"<<$3"#&('#<3&%"<$(4/4$$+&#"99-9-&"#$#9$-+&# 9$#&#&($-/"<"4>/#<$"*$(4&"-"9$-&4'&A+(#1'&(-4$-# $(",<$1$-#*&'&#1$-1+$&("("4"#&'-4$-$4#1"#9$#&#&($-B&<< ,$-$@7&-$4#4$9'&#"'7+ ' <"%'B&#1#1$#-&"<7-#"(4'7-$#> ,(4-"'7+ ' <"%##1$'"#&'"%#&(#1$7-##-$#7-("#$-'&A +(#1' B1&%1 B&<< ,$ 4$#$-+&($4 ,> #1$ 7-# $- 9"''9-# B&<< ,$ -$<$"'$4#1$-(7-(&'1&(3#1$",*$'"&4'7-$#>"(4'$%7-&#>#&'-4$-$4 #1"##1$"+7(# ' <"%'4$9'&#$4&(#1$7-#B7<4,$-$<$"'$4##1$ %+9<"&("(#,$'&4$'#1$-&31##1$2#"#$#-$&##1$"+7(#&(%"'$#1$ %(4&#&('#1$,(4"-$*&<"#$4,>9$#&#&($-1&(4$-="7-"(4 '1$4$'(#-$#7-(,"%0"#$-"9$-&4'&A+(#1' #&'7-#1$-,'$-*$4#1"#"(>&(#$-&+-4$-9"''$4,>#1&'7-# B7<4(#$$%##1$4&'9'"<#1$%+9<"&(#"#&("<'#"3$ <<B$4 &( #1$ "-$'"&4 #$-+' '$##&(3 "'&4$ #1$ -4$- 4"#$4 %#,$-

*$+,$-./

2! '"(8">