← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1187/2024dismissed

Deepak Makkar v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2024-07-05Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji10 pages



          

       

   

 

  !"  !

  

       



 

 !"#$%$

! &!' !"%$$  ("  )( $ *$*$*+,   *  )(*$ *   #

$% & ' 

 () *!  

& &+   & ,) & ----- $*$*-!.-/-01-,'21!3.14& 21' .& #

(

 

      /'

 



0(1 '

 (!

*

(

&&+  $%# 45-!+  $66 4&

& 2

  (

&&2"#3&45567.8  ( ! 9#  3&.77  7:   (     .:&74&77; (1  

'  /*'1 

 1  

  

<#



) ,% (1 

(



#/!

  !

 (1 =  

)  &  (

 

 (

 '  > (



1 !

 1     

!'

? '

    )( ! (

 7:&.7&7.8 ( !1  ! !1 

& 6&  '

 2"#3&@@7.;)'( !9# %..5; ) ( 

 1  

  A !

     

77;   '

      

 *      

   



 







   

   

<#



 

 '   

1 

 (



! >

1 

& :&

 

 0   

 

 '

  !   1    

 

   '

  !& 

( !( (

 

0(   @ !    

 

   !

 =!



, * ! ).@5@ B.@5@ C*  '

1( 

  !<  

* !  ,*

 ,*

& '

 

 * >

!(

 ( !!

     1    '        7:<74&.7&7.8   

     @&76&7   ( 1 !

  ! 

(

*

.@5@ & '

*   #1

!* !2''

 1  (

 !!

!

> '

(! 

 *  1 !



! /'

D2

!*2-2 4 $ $7 $ (-!8 .-!-0* - 2- -,6%%* %##$ !

!  !!

!! 

()!!

)

&  4&  '

 ) (

 

 (

  (

 

 

 1 

)

(

! (

! 

!

'

   (

 

 (  1  !''  1  

 ! ! )  2  

 (   (

 '   (



 * '  

&

1

 

 .7    

    

  (

  '

 

 

!  

*

  ('

)     7:&.7&7.8 

  @&76&7)( !

( !( (





0  '



 



(( 

  !

' !

*(



 (!  .7   

(

>(

&

!( ! /'

D2 

*2-2 4-99&:;- .91 7 $ $;$<-0=& 1-! 2.

,>%?%*5  !

1'

('

'1 ! "

2 )( !(! '

 ! ( !

 ( D

(  

   

 ( (

& 8&





  ( 



 * !   1/  

 &

!! 1 !

$*$*-- - /-9@7 $*2-2 4-910-&65>?* %#(

D2 !  >

'

* !'

 





!

( !

 ) ' (

2 &

$.12.- -!A-(! !: 2.

7 $$-0-B .!-!-! 2.

6>?* 6) 0+ !  E1 D2    ! 

   '

 '

 .@8   1 !

  *

   ,*

 

 .@8@ !  1 !

1

(

.@;& 

!   '(  '

& D2

*.18-*.-!B- ( .-=-2 -7 $*2-2 4

->? *5





'

) 

 1 1      6        !

2  1D

&  *

1*

 $ F@& )

 * (   1*)  

 

'  ! 



1  D

'

D ! 1  ) !

' 1



&

A&& )  2   (

 !  !

 (   



 ( ! '

 D !  6  :   !

)   1 1& )6%:  1  !







!' 

 



1

  ) D

  !

!

/ ')1





!

D

&G

;&

!!

!' !) 

!( !( (

 

% !  !  

 '



'

'

& 5&

  

 ( 1

1* #1

!3

! 75&.7&778

D#%.( !(  (

' 1D

  

 '

& 

 .. 

  1  ! *   ; !    1   

&   (

 

<

  A (   !    

 !  &     9*   !

 2''

 ( !

  1  ,*

 ! '     H

2''

   #

  ! ) ,*

   )

 

 !

=!

)  (

  )

 

   !

 =!

)     0

  

 =!

)     0

   '

 

I!

=!

) &

(!  ( 

1    !

<

   (

 

<

 (  

* ( 1    2''

 1  (  !''    

1  &

 '

 1 * 

 ! ! !''  '



 ! !'' !  ' '

&

+  &

1/!

1 1

(

  .7& !

2  !  1  (  * #1

!* ! 2''

( 1  )(



* 4&7.&7.8 

D %;<.7 (      



        

 1>

 &

@&

!

1 

    !  '! !  '



  !

  !

 / 

 





 1D'

)



           

 

    '

 )   *  % !

 !   (

 

  ) ) ( *   !

'

 

 (

 !"   # $ %&

 '



* !  (

D!

/ 

 

 &

'

( )  #   $       **& % 

 %+%

 (   ' '

 )(* 1

!

 D! 

 

 2  

1 !

! 

& 

 ( 



 ,  !  - #  .  

/, 0 '

 ) ( 12 /,

34     **+

% 

2 =



 (1/!

'

 !

1 !

& !

!1 

1

D2 )(D'

       2  1 

 (

 

 '

1 &    

 ( 1



!1



!& .7&

 

 

   (  *

  !!

  ! 

  !

   ! 

 1  (    1 

!1  

   (

 

  )

)  '



!

1 1

'

'

&2

   !

 1 ' 1

 

>

)( !

 *  !

    

  <#

  

)

) ,

0

<



!  * 

, 0

( 1 ' 1 (  '

 47J ' '

   

, +<#

  

)

 , +   47J1 !

  1   

     !<   

* !  ,*

 ,*

&  *

 @! .@5@  $% F@&.!

* !

1'% !

 ! 

  <#

   !&) & & &, 0

<



!  * 

, 0

%   47J '

 ' '

  

 ,+<#

 

) & & &,+K 

47J1 !

) 

 +   

     !<   

* !  ,*

 ,*

&G ..&

    (  *!

 ( !(  1

 ) ) 1*   ! (  *  

       (  

    

(%1! 7@&74&77; 1 )

!

1 1 

'

'



!1 

0&  D +!1 

0 * 4D ! 

  

 !  '

 (    

) (

 ( ! (  ! ! ) >

 

 +!   =



 

 >

 (  > '

  (

 4  D !

 *  !!

  ( 

   

?

   &  D+ $%

 56(3  

 !'

! >

!'

! 3&  D !)   ) >

 

 !

D !)

 )  



1 !

. 6DDDDDDDDD :

   

+!  *  

<#

 =





D ! 

 

>

' 

 ,%  !

? 

*

   <#





K



 

H *D !

& & &,%+

* !!

 ( 

  

?

 K 

 !

 D !

,*





1 !   

 >

K  * >   (  

.&

! 

 



* >

>

)

!((



#/!

 !

 (1 = 

& .6&

     !

     #( 2''

 (  ( ( 

!  

)1 ( 

'

&

+  

! ((

(

 

9 (

 =



I   

 # /1& !'' 

'1 



     (

  !'' 

   2''

  *

 D

 .;

!(  2 

(

* 

 

 /*'

& '

 1 1

! 2 



 

 

  * 1  !'

(



  ( !*

(



   1( & .:&

'

)( ! (1    

 *4CD !

 <,+   !! 1 ) 

!

 (  1

 !  47J *  '

)  '  D +

 !  !

  !'

! >

  1 !



(   &  !* 47J 1

1( !

1 



( !!'

!>

*1  '

&  

)1 !



* ( 1

  

  ( !



 

 

%A !

 

 

  &3( 1   ! (    

 (   *  

  '

1  1& .4&

 ! !

!' !)  * ( ( !  1   1

 

 0

1  1

 (

     

!



<

A)( ' (  

   

 >

&  

)  

    '



   >$*$*+?   * >  ? %$$   Naveen " 

< $ L "  1 $ 3