High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12954/2019dismissed

Kirpal Singh Sharma v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli12 pages

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 1

!"!#$ % &!'( )*!#+, -

!#' .'"/" *

'0 #1 ,'" - "(#1#

'"# $2 3'.!4'

5*!#+,617

!#' 3' #4/' 3!

)6 11) 17

)6 '0 8!

, 3'* /'

9,3 +6""!"

) '0 6 ' ,'"(#1# " :, '"

!1 ('"# !" 9!#+ ' '11 ,'/+, 7!1 #'# !#+ "!# (' 1!#+" '9!#+ #1/ 1!#7!'

)/'

; <<<<

! , # '7'"0!#7)71!# ,5

#1'7)7" '/#1

(()!

9!)!

0 * !# :; !+,

!' 5(#"

#"( '# 0 !# = #1 >/!"!

!#6 9!)!

)5# 6 %# ,

" "8,'!# '1/#1'"

!#, = #1 >/!"!

!# ?8 ##/# 1# %?!5' #!7 '"('!' , 55# 5# %# # #1190 !#'6#!

,' ,(""""!# #1!"

4##'

!# , " 9# ( !1@1("!

1 ,''6 (' 1!#+">/ #1!#>/"

!#, 7) ("1!#7!8* !#:;

% , # '7'"0 '((1 /( '/#1 !# '('

!# * :; % 8 " (/

90 , #"

!# # , #A9)*/('5/'

#1!

!# "

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 2

,'90) 0!#+18#('!# !()" '1 ) '!#+ !#151 , 79#) ("1/#1'"

!#:; % , (B /'

, " 1!" /""1 !# 1

!) )) "( # ""

'0 #1')7 '!# '('

!#+"

!#:; %6!# ,!" '+ '1''# !"9!#+5 1 , # )/1!#+( +'

(, ,C/1+5# 8,! ,!"'('1/ 1,'!#9)8$2 D- ! "

$#$ " %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

$#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

) -. -., ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! ! ! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %' " ) 0' "

)

'!"

)

' ) 0

,* 1 1 !"

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ ! !" !

"/ "

! "

! +

) "

"""% !

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

")( 52 !"

#" $

! "/ "("!2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

! & ) 6 %6

! !" ! "/ "

! +

7 " ) "

& $ ! "

' "

"/ "

#$ 2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 3

( "

& $4%% ! ""

%( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! &

) ! "

#$ ! "

$#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :"%)

0( "

! "

! +

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 "

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

! ! )! "

! & " !"' "(! "/ ( % ""

, ! ) " ! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & (

% " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &' '

2) ""

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! ! "

! " "/ . % , B("!

!# ) 8 5 1 !# '"

!1 C/1+5# # 9 "/55 '!E1!# ,))8!#+5 ##''5' ) '!

0# ,('!# !()") !1 18#90 ,#"

!## ,$2 :

; # )) ," "" 8,'!# !# (' "" , 1 9# !#!

19/ '1, "# 9# ##/# 1/#1'"

!# ?6# ,1

55# 5# %! 6 ,'!"#) ("(' 1!#+" 5 8!)) # !#/6 ,87'6 8!

, '!1'

!#, 91 '5!#1/#1' ,('7!"!#" %)) ," ""8,'!# '1/#1'"

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 4

?, "9# ##/# 1('!' 55# 5#

%6 ,('7!"!#" %8/)1, 7 #9 '!#+' (()!

,(' 1!#+"8!)) # !#/!# '"( ," ""6 " !6 , ? , " # 9# '( )1 :9; , 8'1 D'A /"1 !# 9 8# , 9 , # !#+# !" !# :; % !" 9 '

1 " -.' -. 8,! , 5 #"

"4 ) ("!#+ (' 1!#+"9 , # !#+# !"5/"

9/)!))13 #!#+

,'906

! , (""""!# , 1 9#

4# 9/

!# 8 " # ' !716 ,' 8/)1 9 # ) (" *!5!) ')06! 5(#"

!#, "9# 19/ ,(""""!# " # 9#

4#6 ,' 8/)1 9 # ) ("!#+ #!"

&&#$! 3( $ : ; " ' "( 5(#"

!#' >/!'1!" # '#16 , #A9) */('5 /'

#1!

+'!

))09"'71

,B('""!#( !1!# ,5 !#( "

!#:; %1"# !# )/1 1("!

!#!# /'

!"'>/!'1 9('71!"

5/# 8 #1'18,! ,, "9#B() !#1 !# &

#1'!#+ 5/# 8/)15 #

5/# !"5 1 !) 9) #18#'

8/)1 9 1!" , '+ ,9)!+

5 4 05# #1!#

7# "/ , ('"# ## 9 (# )!E1 ' , 1 /) !# 4!#+ 05# ,!)'''!#+ "

!#%:;6%:;6% ? #1 5( '!#+ ,58!

, ('7!"!#" ! "

!# F #1 ?

, %6

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 5 #A9)(B/'

" ) '!!1

,#)0 #">/# ##2( 05# 5(#"

!# !" 5 4 , ( 05# !# '"

"('"

!#% ?7# ,#A9) */('5 /'

"/'

,' ) '!!1

# , ( 05#

!# , " 9# '1@ #1'1 /#1' "

!# %:;6

>/!'!#+ ,'!

0 ## 9(# )!E1'##2( 05#

5/# "'5 !#/#( !11/ '/"

) 90 #18#' ) '!0!

,'6 ,#A9)*/('5/'

,'9"'71

! ) #18#', "!)1 ,''# ' ,!+,' 5(#"

!#, ## ) !5

,8 "# ( !1

5/# :1; ,!)'

1!#+ ,('7!" "

!#9( "

!#:;

%6 ,#A9)*/('5/'

" ) '!!1

!# "6 ,''( 05# "9#5 19/ # 1("!

16 )!

9!)!

0 ( 0 5/# )#+ 8!

, !# '"

"/9"!"

#1 ! # 1("!

1 ' 5 C'!

0 ,)1!#+" ' !7 0 '" ' 5'6

!# /#1' , % , 9 ( !1 #18#'" " # , 1

# !!

!# ' ) /#1'"

!# ? + '1!#+ ,1("!

9# ) '!!1!# ,C/1+5#

' ,,!+,'

))86 , 5#0 ",/)1 # , 7 9# 1("!

18!

,= #1 >/!"!

!#)) ''!# "/'0 ' !# , /'

, '"( 5 C'!

0 ) #1 ,)1!#+"6 #!#+ ,'90!!

8 "1("!

1!# #0 ,'51" 8!

,'"( 5 C'!

0,)1!#+"6 ,,!+,' 5(#"

8!))# ))869/ !# '"

/#1'"

!#% ? 8/)19 , #">/#

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 6 :; "'+ '1" ,51

4!#+(""""!#6 ,#A9)*/('5 /'

1 '!!1

8!#+ !#>/"

'('

@ 55'

#1/5 8/)1 5 #

(,0"!

) (""""!# , " 9#

4#,) 88!

,'+ '1 7"

!#+) #1, "# + !#9 '!

1 ,)1

# ,(""""!#, "9#

4#/#1' !# G , ?6 , ) #1 7"

!# , *

,' ## 9 #01!7"

!#+') ("!#+ :; ,!) 5(/ !#+ ,+ (('!1!70 '"9 8# ,1

'1 #1 55# 5# %6 #0!# '!5 '1' "/9"!"

!#+ !" 9 B )/11 8,! , 5 #"

' B )/1!#+ , !# '!5 '1'6 , ('2'>/!"!

+ (('!1 '" !" # ,'6 , ('7!"!#" "

!# :; ## 9 !#741 :+; ,#A9)/'

"/'

,' ) '!!1

! !# #1 , 1 ')!' 9# , ))#+1 !# 8 /(,)16 8,! , 5 #" , (' 1!#+ "

1 # )/116 /59')) ('

!#"

!#:; % ## 9!#74 "!

1"# '7!7"

) !59 ''1 ) !5" :,; # ( %%F6 , #A9) /'

, " 5 1 !

) '

('7!"!# "

!# :; , % !" 5 9 !#74190 ,9#! !

'!"!) #18#'"8,8'' '11 "

!5!""/ # # !!

!#/#1'"

!# ? #0 "/9">/# (/' , "'6 ,)1' ' ,'8!"6 ## !#74 ,('7!"!#""

!#:; %

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 7 " (' " (/ '

, 90 , ( !#'6 , !" 8#' !# (""""!# #15 "/'!#+G ">01" 5('!"1!#4,8

G6 4,

#!#G65/0"

!)#&!)) @:G2F;6@G:2F;3/"

6&!)) G@:F2%;6@:2?;6:?2 ;3/"

&!)) F@@:

2?;"!

1!#.!)) + 14, )6!"

'!1 1/(#8,! , !#' , " #"

'/ 1 "

1,6 *,!7 3 #1!' #1 '5" , "

!1 #1 8 >/!'1 90 , *

'0 7!1 # !!

!#" 1

1 ?F #1 ??!""/1/#1'"

!# #1"

!#G ,= >/!"!

!# 6?6))8190 '11

1 %?' ,(/9)! (/'("# 5)06'17)(5# #1/ !)!E

!#) "!1# ) 55' !

)* '?6

'!1 1 !" "

!#'

1"(!

7!#+ >/!'1 #1!#>/"

!#6 ,*

" !)1

4(""""!# !))1

,!"!#

)(,0"!

)(""""!# #1!# >/"

!# /'

,'!

"9# # #11

!#', "# ' !71

5/# ,/"6 !#(' 1!#+", 7) ("1!# 7!8 * !# :; , % " 9 , # !#+# !" ('" '!91!#"

!#:; % '/)!))1 ' # 3'#4/'3!

)6) '#111!

!# )17

) '0 (( '!#+ ' , *

'0 "/95!

, !#"

8'!

!#!)1

,!#"

# !#'1"'7" 91!"5!""1

/ , ( !#' , " # ) /"2"

#1! 5 !#

!# , ))#+

!#(' 1!#+"9!#+"/9">/# (/' , "'" 15!

1)0 >/ 8,! , ("!#+, "9#"/+, 8 "(/' , "190 !#'7!1 )11"1

1 F?F! '!""/ # # !!

!#/#1'* ? ,/"6 ,"

!1"

)11!"# 9!#1!#+# ,*

#'1' "/9"

,!" # !#6,, "() 1, 70')!

# #

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 8 C/1+5# ( ""190,'C/1+"A9# , ,#A9)*/('5/'

#1!

!# " ; !

7&8 ' 8,'!# , #A9) (B /'

' 1!" /""!#+ #"!"

) 88!

,'"( '!+, "/9">/# (/' , "'6'2 !'51

!#"

) '!""/ # "

!## !!

!#!"7!1 "/ , (/' , "' ## , ))#+ !#(' 1!#+"5/ ,)"" # , ) !5) ("!#+ !#(' 1!#+"/#1'"

!#:; % , " '''1 ( %%F , C/1+5# ( ""1 !# #1' 7)(5# / ,'!

0:*/('

;8,'!# ,#"

!#9# ,, !'51

,C/1+5# ( ""1!#*,!7&/5 'A" " #19"'71

,('7!"!# "

!#:; %!"# 5 9!#741# ,9 "!" 7!1 #"

!#", )"')!1# ,C/1+5# ( ""190 ,!"/'

!# < = 5 7 ! + = > ! ? 8,'!# 1

!)1 1!" /""!# , " 9# 5 1 8!

'"( , '!+, "/9">/# (/' , "' " ' " ) (' 1!#+" ' # '#1 ,/"6 !

!" ,!" "/95!""!#

, ( !#' 9!#+"/9">/# (/' , "' ## "4) ("!#+ !#(' 1!#+"

,('"# ( !#1"'7"5'!

"1!"5!""

)# ,!"+'/#1 )# G /'

,'"/95!

, # !# !#'9!#+ !# ,(""""!# #1!#>/"

!#!"5'!

)"" ,(""""!# #1 8

!5 ##/# 5# '1 !

") 90 ' '1!#+

E# 5 , %1

1 %?""

1!# ,'()067# 5/

!#"

#1""

!#1!# 7/'*.

7!15/

!# F" '+ '1" , 5(#"

!#') #1!#>/"

!#,, '+/1

5/#

!# 8 " 1/)0 #1'1 ! 8 " 5 1 !) 9) , ( !#'

#1 ,' ) #1 8#'" , 1!"9/'"5# 5 C'!

0 5(#"

"/9"

/5 #1' 5(#"

5/# * '

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 9 !#'!" # '#161"(!

#1',, "# 1 , 5(#"

,/"6 "

5 ## 9 '

1 + !#"

, *

,''6 !

!" ,!" #

## , # !#+# !"5# !#1!#* !#:; % '/)!))1 "(""""!# #1"

#1"1/)0

4# 9)!+

!# ,*

( 0 , 5(#"

!#"

#1"1!" , '+18!

#1' 5(#"

!#6,# 6 ,('

0'!"9!#+5 1 1!"5!"" ,8'!

!# F ' , 7!#+ ('/"1 , () 1!#+" 9 , # !#+ !" #1' '1!#+ ,!' # !#"68, 7#,"!

,)1

, #1 !" ">/ ')0 7'1 90 , ('!# !()" ) !1 18# 90 #A9) */('5 /'

#1!

!# " #1' 7)(5# / ,'!

0 :"/('

; , ('

0' , ( !#' ) !5!#+ ) ("!#+

!# (' 1!#+" 1"'7" 1!"5!""

) , !'"

#1 '5"

'>/!'5# ' #

!#!#+ 8'!

( !# !" " 8, ,' , ('"#

((' ,!#+ ,/'

") /" !#74B '1!# '0C/'!"1!

!# ,!" /'

' # , !# (' 1!#+" # 9 , ))#+1 90 #18#'" ' '11 !# , '7#/ ' '1

!5 !""/ # # !!

!#/#1'"

!# ?15!

1)06 !#', 1 (/' , "1 '!""/ # # !!

!#/#1'* !# ?68,! ,!5()!"

,!" D"/9">/# (/' , "'A" # #1190 3'#4/'3!

)6 8 "'+ '1" ,) /" "/9">/# (/' , "' ))#+ !#(' 1!#+"!"8))"

)1 #1 #"!"

)06!

9#,)1

"/9">/# (/' , "', "#'!+, ""

!)'>/"

!# (' 1!#+" , " '''1 , C/1+5# ( ""1 90 ,!" /'

!# "

5 1 7 :*/('

; 8,'!# ,!" /'

' 1!" /""!#+

C/1+5# " # , (!# !# !""/6 '!

"/9">/# (/' , "', "#'!+, ""

!) !#(' 1!#+" !"

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 10 " 9 /" #0 # /59'

# '

1 # , ) ' !""/ # # !!

!# /#1' "

!# , ? 8/)1# 9!#1 , *

=!48!"6! #0 #"

!#"

), "9# ''!18!

,'"( # !!1/#1'"

!# ?6"/ , #"

"9"'7190 (B/'

!#*,!7&/5 ':*/('

;!" D7!1 #"

!#A #1#'!+, # 9"

!1 , 79#)81'5"/ , #"

!#"8,! , '7!1 9!#!

! */ ,7#1, "#'!+, , ))#+ !#(' 1!#+"5/ ,)""

#, ) !5) ("!#+ !#(' 1!#+"/#1'"

!#:; % ? 7# ,/+,6 , /#1!"(/ 1

" , ( !#' 9!#+ "/9">/# (/' , "'6 !" "/! !# ' )" , 1'" ' ,!5 9/ 0 "!# !#', " ) !51,!5") 9!#(,0"!

)(""""!# #1 , " ) !51

!# (' 1!#+", 7 ) ("1 !#7!8 * !#:; %688/)1)!4 ,!" '+/5# !#' # / ,"

# , !# '('

!# 5 1 90 , #A9) */('5/'

#1!

,+/!1!#+('!# !()") !1 ,' ,/+, !#', " # #11

,!"!#

)(,0"!

) (""""!# , ) #1 !# >/"

!#6 ,87'6 "

!1 7'5# 1" # !#1 "/9"

# !#7!8 ,!# '('

!#D(,0"!

)(""""!#A5 190 #A9)(B/'

!##1'7)(5# / ,'!

0:*/('

;8,'!# #A9)/'

+'!

))0,)1

,8'1(""""!#/"1!# ?, ""

55 #!#+

(,0"!

)(""""!#/"1!#* :; %,# ,*

7'#5# >/!'" 1'

8" 55'

#1/5

4!#+ (""""!# 8,! , !# , ('"# " !" 90 ' '1!#+

E# 5 , % 1

1 % ?6

5/#

4!#+ , (,0"!

) (""""!# , ) #1 # , (""""!# !"

4#6 ,'!" 9")/ 7"

!#+ #1!# ,*

'7#!

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 11 #18#' '

!#" , (""""!# , ) #16 , !" '"( ""'6 #1 "/ , (""""!# '"( ""'#/'"',!"9#!

#1#9, ) ,8#'! *

,''6 "9"'71 97 ,(""""!# #1!#>/"

4# 90 ' '1!#+

E# 5 , % 1

1 % ?6

,''6 ,(""""!# #1"

#1"1/)0

4# #1"

57"

"!# *

''5 ))# /59'

# ",''68, 7#,"!

,)1

,(,0"!

)(""""!# #1!#>/"

!#"

#1"

4# ,/"6!

!"# !) 9) !#' #

,!""

!))!#(""""!# #1!#>/"

!# " ' "( 5(#"

!#!" # '#16!

!""( !!

#1 ,'"(#1#

, 5(#"

5/# 8 "1/)0 #1'1

#18 "5 1 !) 9) #18#'"!# )/1!#+ !#'"#'1'

"/9"

5 ''# , " 9# 5 1 ,

)

5/# "666F?@26 # 5/# "6G6%6@2 !5 C'!

0 , 5(#"

!#, "9#1!"9/'"1,!"

!""/! !#

",8

, 5(#"

!# 8 " 1/)0 #1'16 , ( !#' , ,"## ' !7 ,"

568,! ,,!"

)!9'

0 ' !7 # !

!" "6 ," #1 # !#+# 0('" '!91!#"

!#:; % )" +" ,/"6 "## , # !#+# !"('" '!91!#"

!#:; % !" /)!))16 , 15!#+ !

!# ) ("!#+ ('7!11 /#1' !#:; % ## 9!#741 3'#4/'3!

)# ,"

'#+ , ,

"() 11!# 8'!

5# "7,5# )0 # #11

>/!'1 ' ,(/9)! (/'("'/ !)!E

!#) #1' "!1# ) #155' !

) * '?6

'!1 1,) #1!#>/"

!#!"7'05/ ,""# ) ,!7

, (/9)! (/'(" #1 !

, () ##!#+ '" () " +'/( ,/"!#+" !

06?5 '8!1!# '# )"

'' 1"6##/59'"!

CWP No. 12954 of 2019 (O&M) 12 ')!+!/" 9/!)1!#+6 () " '" " (' , ) 0/ () # , 7 #"!1'1 ,!" ( '+/5# '

!"1 90 , '"(#1# #1 8 ' !# 5() +'5# 8!

5 ,!"!" #!5('

' 94( !# 5!#18,!)1 )!#+8!

" '!"!#+/ !#)

,!7 ,(/9)! (/'(" #1!

!" ,"

,'!

08,!"!# ,9"

("!

1 !1 9/ / !)!E

!# >/!'16 '!

7!#+9# 7"

1!#*

" ">/) 97 1!" /""!# #1 !# 7!8 ) 8 "/55 '!E1 !# ( %G% #1' 7)(5# / ,'!

0 :"/('

;6 "( !!

))0 ', 7!#+' '11

!# "!#, #16 !#'!" "/9">/# (/' , "'6 ,(,0"!

)(""""!# #1!#>/"

!#, 7!#+ 9#

4#6 ,9)!+

!#'( 05# 5(#"

!#"

#1"1!" , '+1

)" #"!1'!#+

, ) #1 !# >/"

!# !" 7'0 5/ , ""# )

,!7 ,(/9)! (/'("68, 7#,"!

,)1

!# ,!#"

"6 ,"

"/))01!" , '+1!

"9)!+

!#>/ 9 , # !#+# !" /''!#+!#"

!#:; % #1!

9!#+"6 ,('"# ( 5'!

"1!"5!""

) #1,# 6 ,!#"

( !#!"1!"5!""1 % 7!#+ 1!"5!""1 , 5 !# 8'!

( !#6 )) (#1!#+

(()!

!#"6! #0 )"5 ,"

,8'!

( !#!"1!"5!""1 *

/">/6! #06"

#1"7

1 :

.*& ; * :

==;

% 7!#1' , ,'"( 4!#+@'

"#1 "@ , ,''('

9) "@