High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5780/2007disposed of

Mahabir Techno Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2016-08-02Mr. Justice Adarsh Kumar Goel,Mr. Justice Alok Singh7 pages

!"# $% " &

# ' (") " * +

!"# $ %"& !"# "& '"(%'"&% "

"' +,)-./&. " + " # 0".+1)/&, "-.(")

$ %"&) # + " ++" 1"%+12 2

/

31" 4

11 "' (") , "- '- #3 /. 6 4 " ". 7 /7. "

)"

666 666 ." +&-). " 1%"&

$"

1

- " + " 1!%

+ " " )"6660 "% 4

.

0 " " )"666 . %0 "% 4

"' / "-'- #3/.6 " )"

666 666 0"

1 4

/ %"

"% + 2 0" - !) "& -1 ")

1!

81 -) 0"

1

. + " -

.0 0 --0&""

.+ 0"!) -% # +-" !) '"-) 1+ +"&

(") 9-1/#3/.

4.0 ":

# '0 ! "( 7!- '1+"%1"!) - 2&-/++- 6

.( 7!- '1+"%1"0 - ""+

!) 1"."% %"!;

"

1 0 " +"+"& "

+" " -1 " 4 -" "" 2 +"&

' /.

"0 +0" 12 !3" !) 1 " .-"

1

- " + " 1!% - 212+- -) 122

"" --!"& +" "% ""< 1"-%# -;!1

1 0 1 " +" * "" 2 - 212 ' 5 /.-"

1

- " + "

1!% $2 -1" 1

" - 212

0 " " +" " -1

" < 1++" +-."- 0 +-1+ :12%

/ "" (2 1"

66 6'# 5 :12% ( 7!- '1+"%1"

665 64'# 5 " .-"

1

- " ' 1!% %" "%!;!)( 7!- '1+"%1"

"

1 0 " +" +"&1 " / 1"

-% " -1 "& -+" " " " <

!" %

"0 2& "1% " "

-0) -) +" " 1- 0 +"

0--! "1 "

4 ("-"

1

- " +" +"1 ++"

!; = "

1 1

%" .01-!++"+" " ""-& +"&

/'

5. .4 5

/"3"!-0 '>#<?

/''>''>#@*>,<'#>*>>/$>* 4 5 < -". & 1"

"1"

" + +". - %+-)0 "%

1 " 1! .

2 1 ") --.

0 1 +".+"

! :12% %1 31 "% -" < -" 1"

"1"

" +

)+"!) +" "!.

21 ")

--.0 1 +".

"2& 2 -"" !-++"1 ) ! ".+"

. ! :12% . %1 3. ).1 "% -" '>#<4 *>/''>''>#@#/A <

81

"% 0 % +

.

21 ") &"

1"

&" !1

-"

! "

." +

) )".

21 ")%). )%0

")"

-

"" "2& 2 -"" !-++"1 ). +" "!%

". ! 2 ".+""

3+)!- 1"

&"0 "

" +

5 '>#<5

*>9<'< # %%

"%)-- 0 % "

"" ) + 2! "." + !).

)

"++ 1 " 1! 4 /

%" )

21 ")"

++-- 1 "). " #"!1 -. " +1"+

) 2 % - -2-)" +"+") ) +" " ) "" % " %)+

1 "" "- " %) ; B"& "". --! "& "

3+") +" "" B"& 1" " " -%

+" -- ++-)0 " "" %-"

"& " 1- #"!1 -" ) 1" $0C 4 33D /+"1 - +"&

' 5 /.

0 -0

"2 "-" 0 - 212 -1" +"

-"1"

"

" + .

21 ")%)+"

! :12% 0 1 +".0 01-% +"

'%-"-) ' 4 /. 0 +"& "

"

3. & 2 "

81

"% 0 % +

21 ") ! 0 1-!+ 1"

&" !1

-" "

." +

# +"

+"& "

+" 0 ")"

"% -

"" 6 < " " 0+"&

.' /.0 +"& ""& .1 0".7 "& 7

" 0" !) $2 -1" %+" "0

&!2& "1% 2- " 2 - 212

122 "" --!"& +" & )"

""# -)% 20 !

2 - 2121 +" & -10 +

2

""< %"-) +" ""& ' +"& ' / -"2 -% . "&

" 1- ) #"!1 -"1" # %0 %-" - 2121 / ""

, "-'- #3/# "-& +"&

'

4 / "" , "-'- #3/.""+"1 "

E # %%

" %%"-#3 %) 1 %1-- " 3% "" )""+

" +" 2 "" !) ) 1 ").

" "

+"

1!" .1 " +"&

/.

-1 1! . 1 "" " +" 2 "" +":1- " "& 1.%)%; 1 81")."1

1 81")!% 1!: +"&

/.%) +" "& .% )" 1 """+" 2 %)+

1 ""

" " " ;

4 < "- ""

+

1 "

/. +0"

""!) 1!

-- ! 3" !- -) 0 1 +"

3 1")"

0 ""

0 "& -". %) ! +" "!D %+ 1++- - "+" 2 " +"&

.& = / "" (2 1"

1+"+ 3" +0" "& 1- -1! " 1")"

+

2 "".0 12 ! "& *-& +" "% :12% "3"!-0 F/" 2 1" &0 3" +0"

"& %1 % 0 +" 1"

)"

"% +

2 "" !)

1!" 1 ")#

4 /,'#/ 1"+ . "& 21 ") +0"-

!) +" 1")"

-0 "& # 3" +0"

0 -

3 !) +" 1")"

0 "" 1!" 1 ")0 "&

-"D :12% ; 2 "") &0 0 !) -"

1

- " ' 4 < "" -2

-0." ""!&.

+ " " )"666 0 "% 4

" )"666 .0 "%

4

. +" & )"

01- 3+" 4

4

. " " +&0)"

< +1 !) % +" ! -1>& "-""1

-2 . + " -- 2

1

"" " +" %"! " 1" ) "% ) 2" # +" "

"& ""

& -10 +" "" 12 !"& . & 21 "

' /. *& -/1 ") 0 & ) :1" +

"" 5 @" "

% !&. 0"+ --0 # %+12

/

31" 4" 81 *: = - G12

(" "' 2 ' 1 &

G12 " +; 2H" I H "*+"!- I H