← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/28476/2021allowed

Yadwinder Kaur v. State Of Haryana And Others

2021-08-25Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi15 pages



     



 !"#$%$ &'())



       

 '  *+ ) ,

-     



  !   

" # $%    & '  (

) $   !   & *  +

&   & ,

-.  

#



" /01 

%   / /1

#!  2 # 

   /! /3 2##  1! #



-  .) 53 !   .       !!6

'

3   #     '7 :8:'

 ! *;:   2  2"# !  '79( 5  < 2

<6  !  & :  (  ! !     ! =/ & (79  87 '8 :8:8   ! (97   / # 2 ';+8 5  < / 2<6 

#!  2 #

:

 #.   " #.  

 /$00 123 .4%$0 & .$% 5$# $&" 5 & +6   #!  $ 6- $ 0  "  !"#   1 #!  2 # /   !"# 

#. ##     !

#   !!

  # .    .

     ) 5 & *6   >" $!       " !  "  ! )   " " "

)    3 =    & ?:+?

=?9'9' 5    < !<6   @ " !.   "  !   )  !" 

!# 2 !# #  " .

1   )  "  .     !    "   .

      . )    !   )   !.

         !       )  "  "      !   )             1 A    !"  .   !    #  5!! "    # 6  

. 5!! "  

. 6

)  @     ! "  "   !!# A    " "   ! 

(

/    !"# =/    ! (97   / 2       ! (97   / 2  #  ! *8+  *''   / 2  

*

3 #!    ! !   ! "          #   )

7 !  !#  "  "    1 !"#    1 #!  2 # # #! 0!##  ! '9(5:6   2

  & ,?)  ::

:8:'  #      '7 :8:'

,

3   #          !     "   ? & *    !   "      ? 3)#    ! # )? & ,   "    9+88880?      !        3 #    !  ? & *       #   !  #  # #   A # #  <& 1)! 2!<   "     & 1      ? !

"   #      #  $! 

.      !   "    A   3 "  !  "  1!     #    <& 1)! 2!<  !!##      & 3  <& 1)! 2!<     "      !!##   & *  +  !!   #   !

" 3  & * #  !   #.? & +   !? ## !   # #              ! !    !    # ! "  &      

  ! !   #!  #   & +   #  !    !""   ! 3  A   & (?1 #!  2 #  ! !      !  ! "   #   !     "  & +  !?!!

 3  # "   8+ :8:'

& !   .             ! !      #   !!#   @     "

+

3       ?  "  # #       $#    $ 5B26 #  #   & '  ( /  #     "   #! !   ! "              #  !   #    !   " $ ! &   #.? & +          !  ? & *  )       "  ! '+'   2

 !  !  5 ? & *6    #  ! #   & +? #.     .#   !  <& 1)! 2!<      

 5 6     #    &. &  3" 

.

) 1 :+ 8( :8:'  & ,?)  # )      " !#  "    " !   & *?

    .  ! "  & *?

(        !   & *?    & *?      "  "

"    5 & ,?)6 % 0"  4  # 5 

 5%$"&  !

"

/  #       "   !"#    #   ! '9(5:6   2

   "   2   ::

:8:'

   8( 8;

:8:' !0! !   !? #  !

" !#      A  "  !! 2    !"#!   !  !?  !

" !#   "       2   # $!   > 

#

;

/   



 # 2 #    " # #  2 #   & '  (  ) $  # 2 #   & *  +        #  !

- 2 #         #!   ! !        ! 3  A   & (?1 #!  2 #  ! !       !  ! "   #   !     "  & +  !?!!

    # "   8+ :8:'    3 /  1!   ! !      !

"  # @!

         #   #   & +  

 !!   !? ##   & *   ##       !  !    "  # !  9+88880?

'8

- 2 #     !!#  "   #  #   #! "     ?   "  !  !## !  " "  

''

1    #  2 #   & '  (  # 2 #   & *  +    "         ! !   #!   !"#    #   ! '9(5:6   2

  #   & ,?)

&    !  ! *;:   2

 "  

':

-  2 #  # 2 #   & *  +   !!#  "    "  "

'(

1 !    " "  # 2 #    #  2 #  # 2 #   & *  +   #   "#  ! / "

  !          ##

'*

/     

     

          /  1!  #    !.   #  #

',

/  

 

      ! <#  " 2       

 "

     ) !      ""

" A "   #  #

'+

<#  " 2     "#$$%#

 &    

 '%(  !  )*  ) ! " !"  !"       

'9

/ +  , 

 )     %$ -  . /  0 !

       <#  " 2    ?



      

  

              

   

      

   

    



  

        

            

               !         

        

      

  

     

"  

       !     !

                             

!          

 

 



   

 

  

         

         !

         

# 

 

 !     #

$% &$   

     





  

' ';

/ --1  /23

4&  *  <#  " 2    & (*   

 ?

$()  

   

       !    

      

  

 

    *         + *    !           

    

         

    , 

  $-./$0     

       , 

$-./(0    

  

 

 1 2 / 0      

 /

0+  

 /

0+    3  

 $%         

        

    

 



    

 

 + *,   

    



    , 

$4(/&0   

1      



    

  

           

   

      5 



  , 

$-./(0   $-  +   

           "

     

      

     , 

$4(/0    6   

     

      

   

  !

 !    

            

 

,     

 



     

  

        

  7   

 

            ,                

7  

 

             



         

  

  #    

   

       

      

 

     

         1    

  

  

                      

 

                            

   

     

   !          

     

   

   

!  

 

 $.  ) !               

!

  

     

                               



 

!    !         8       9                  

 

        

               

       

  :    

   5

        



  

    

 

     

      

9  

      5   

         

 5 

 

            

  

     

 

    #

&$&&    

   ;  

 

 ! !   1    !

      

        

!  !              #     

!       ! !

  

     

      7     <      

    

1 5

  

        !                                   7      

           

 

      5  

, 3 678!  

    

     !

       

         

    

     

        #  7

                          



      

   

       

     

 

  

       

  

    

 

    



    7

7    

  



          

          

  

      '%% :

 ;< 5 . /;< 67

 * 8!    

    3

  

 

 

7     

 

!      

           



          

    

    

   5 



     

  5

    

    

 !   

      +!            6 50

5  

 .

67

!%44 !8!





 

 

!     

  

             

     

!



      5

" 

!

     

 5 



 

    

     

          

 

    5        " 



 3    

 

     !

 

 

 

  

!  

  5 



     



    5 





     

' '7

/   ! =/  ##   ! (97   / 2  !"# "   & +?

#.  ##      !  "     & ,?)   @ " !.   "  ! :8:8   !    

!# 2 !# #  " .

      "   & ,?) 1!  ! (97   / 2   "     ##   !"#   # #   !        ##       ! "   & ,?

) !  ! *8+   / 2  "   !  #    =/  A # #  ! *''   /

:8

3 #!    !  !   ! "               #  !   #    !   " $

! &   #.? & +          !  ? & *  )       "  ! '+'   2

 !  !  5 ? & *6    #  ! #   & +     .#    <& 1)! 2!< !      "    5 6 1 :+ 8( :8:'  & ,?

)  # )      " !#  "    " !   & *?



     .  ! "  & *?        "   & *?      "  " " 5 & ,?)6    5 & ,?)6 % 0" 4# 5 

5%$"&  !

"

1 !"#    1 #!  2 # # #! 0!##  ! '9(5:6   2

  & ,?)

:'

   !   # @"#  !    /  !"#  "   & +?

#. #   "    "  #   !"#  !   <5:$&"2 0  5%$"&  !  ;< %

5.  ;&= 8*

 & +? #.  !  2!   !  !   !        !

3  2!  C   #!  ""  ':

'8 :8:8 3 /  1!   ! !   !  '* '8 :8:8 "          5 6     #  1 !!.  !  /  1!     2! #   !  !   0     &# 5 & *6  !       ! 3 !    2!  .    

#!   !  /   2 #   C  ""  '* '8 :8:8 /        ! ! #       . "     

#     /  1!   "   !  ""      . " "    )

  "    3   !#"   !   !   "      ?3)#    ! # )? & ,   "    9+88880?      !        3 #    !  ? & *       #   !  #  # #   A # #  <& 1)! 2!<   "     & 1      ? !

"   #      #  $! 

.      !   "    A   3 "  !  "  1!     #    <& 1)! 2!<  !!##      & 3  <& 1)! 2!<     "      !!##   & *  +  !!   #   !

"    & * #  !   #.? & +   !? ## !   # #    3   # !#"    A   & (?1 #!  2 #  ! !      !  ! "   #   !     "  & +  !?!!

  "   87 8+ :8:'    "#  #!   ! !      !#" "       !   !    3)#     & ,?)  # !   9+88880? @!

    # # 

 7 " & :; :7  (8   & *?   !  &12          &  #    !!##   &12       & 3 /  1! "# ! "   & *?     #  ! #   & +? #.         .#   &12 /   # #  " & :;

:7  (8  @!

   & *?           & *?  ! #  ##  !   & +? #.

/  !    #  ##   34 455%2 &"&  )

148$5  0$<  3 %  #4

"  86  5%2 &"&   )

&"4$5  ,$&14  86 !5 ;";0& 06  >#;

$&1  4  " #;?& %  $&  @;% $ &  0 "$&1 

&%!5  !  51$%

$ &  !  4  # 5  $&  !

: ;5  !  5%2 &"&  

148$5 0$<   ##   34 455%2 &"&  )

&"4$5  ,$&14  # &%2$5"  3$ 4  5%2 &"&   )(

=%4  &"

5%2 &"&   )

148$5   0$<  ! 5  !5 ;";0&  &%!5  !

51$%

$ & ! 4# 5$&!

: ;5 !5%2 &"&  )

148$5 0$<

35 &1!;006"25$: 42 $ $ &5 ! 4# 52;5#4 %"! 5% # &%$"5

$ & ! %)..A  A         #! /   # #  " & :; :7  (8      ?          @!

   & *?    # !  "     ? ! "     !  #  ! *:8 *+9 *+;  *9'   / 2  # "     ! /    # ## 

  $ 45  2 $ $ &5 "3$&"5  - ;5  4 :$&1  8&  #4

"  86 5%2 &"&  )(

=%4 &"4$% ## ?20$#% 5 "3$&"5- ;5

0 &13$ 45%2 &"&  )(

=%4 &" 4$5 ## ?20$#%4 :$&1 #4

"  5%2 &"&   )

&"4$5  ,$&14  &"  5%2 &"&   )

148$5 0$<  A      3 #!   ".      "# !   ! /  # #  #    & '  (     "     !#  !  "   87 8+ :8:'    !   !  &12      

 5 6    "   & *?  !  ! '+'   2

  #! 3 #  !     # "   #!    #   5 6 3 !  !!

"!   ! ".# #  #   # !!#     #  #      /  1!  ! !        "# !   ! 1 #!  2 #  # #! 0!## #  ! '9(5:6   2

         "

 ! '+'   2

"   & *?   !#  " "   & ,?)          # !     &    !          !#"  @!     # #  " & :; :7  (8   & *?

         3 ! 

 (          "    #! 0!## #  ! '9(5:6   2

 1 #!  2 # 3 !  !!

"!   !   !   !   2   @!  ) !  ! *;:   2

      !   !

    ) !  ?    !  "  !0!## !  "

::

/      !

    ## #! 0!## #  ! '9(5:6   2

 1

#!  2 #     ?    !   3    #! #  !  !  !#   "   !  #  .  /!  !"  #! 1! ## "  $! A   "  #!  3 !#   "  !  ## ! !     ##  #  "# !   ! !#   A   # ) !    # #   ! '9(5:6   2

  " "    !  !    3    #! #  # !  .  !# !   /  1!   !  !    ! !  "  ##     "# !   !     

())

5

-  6 .#     D .0 0& D # 0&