← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5015/2006dismissed

Ajay Singal v. State Of Hry. & ORS.

2018-08-07Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri13 pages

 

     

!"# $#%&'&() *+*'" ,-

. 

           ) / 0 1    / 0 1201 3#'#(")





  

 !"



   ! 

#

 " $  

%   ! &'

  -    %   !



'''(()

*+,-."

" / /  !0 1 2 !#    3

 0

  !)

/ 4

-,56)  77-"

 



"  8   / 3

9  '5(''(()

*+:-  1 ' # 

0

1 )1

$

+!/+ 1 

- ! 0 ; (<(,,6 ! !

2 ':(5,,6 " / ; =  " 0

  (<('(((

/

 0

  / 

"   "         &<+     %  "  $  !1     /0

   .

/ !  / 

. /

)9-)99-)9- )- " !!

 &<" ; 

 /    "

! "; . 

0  

 

 /    /  /

/ /  ! < !!

  '(5'(('.<<( 

"; !

/.  $  !   1 "

 &<  /  ; ((((>+ /<+:

 

 0  0 .



 /  &< /   "3 ../  

0.  /    ./ *    !  !"

"//  ""

"

   &</

 ! #  ! /

 /!

  "

"; / /     !! "

".

      "

"* / . &<  / . 

0# " "

!

 +  <(('((<  "

 0

1 )1 $

-+!/+ 0 0

 !   

  ! ((((>+/  ;=/



!

5   0  0  !!

!

  !//  // ! ! 

  "       ?

   !  ./         '5(''((#  (<'((

0  "+!

 !  3  "! "

 ?

2 !  .!! 

 !

/

# 

*  /    "+ !  !  / ./     "+!

 !# 

  

. / 

 " "

" 

 

   !" # /  . 

1 : 

 " 

   

 !    /     "            /   /   !    !/     /  !     / !    ./            !

 !  ;    



    

 .        /

   !. /" 

   / / !  ./     "

  "3 .

     

 / 



   /   

! !

 !



 !

 !!

 / "    "

!



    ! !  .  !

6     

3 9 !  

3 " 

   # !  .

"

 !



  !

 /   .   ! ! # 

3 

!        

. !

       "    ..3    ./   ! 

0  !  !  / /. "

!  .;

!  

!    / ".

. &<   

 !!!!

 / 

 !

 " 

 .!  0   

 $ /

 ./  3 ." "

 

/       

  !  "

   ! 3  .   @  

!   !

! !(!+&(+&3#%"3-0-7$#3!8!$  2!3*(!9!3,,<):- 006'6 

 !'6   !

!($* :*':!(;&<#$& 1"!"# :!39:!($!($ !(":#3'(()- 00'65

"

/

 .

   

 !     / 

  ./  "





   

"

 " 

 /

 #  



       /;    !. ! ! #    " "





      /;!/ 

  " 



# "

  !    .;

   "+!  !  "!/  ! * 

"

 &  

!  ./     "+!"

  

 !

 ! /    !  #   /; !

  !    /#     / 

 1   A     !      

A    !"

  !   !             

 "

./ /.   

!  . 

  "

 !

!(&( ($&!3'  :$!=>!(2:!(- ,,)- 0055.  /0 " !

!  "+!  !

"

   

3 ". !     "     "

 !  



 /9 

  

!  "

 

"

 "+!

 !  ";* 

 



  #   "  



 

  "

!   "

  !.;

 ! 

 /   /     "+!  ! 

  # 

  

*  /!/

 

/       A  

    "

    "+!

 !

<(  <(<'((A    .       " 

   



    "

  /   "   ! 

                !  A    . "

./ /.  

 !  

   " 

     "

  .



.

  

 !     / !

  !.  !      



/;!

   ! 6 # *./ /.  

! 

".     

9 

   !

  

0; !





/ !   "! . 

0 #  !

!   

"

  "      

    !         





"

!

  "

, " 

 /9  "

 

" " A ! ./

   .

  

 5 @  

!  "  !!  

!.  ! ! !/ "9 !(&( ($&!!($":#3'

*(!'#9!3!()'(-' 00(  *0  

+'B+

        

           

         

    !

 "   !  !# 

 

          "        "   !

       ! 

      

 

   $  "    !     "   " !

" $ 

   ! 

  %     " !  !  %                

 " ""  

                   !  



  "                   





 "   ! !    !  !!    "  D &  "    

 !

. "

!.  !  ! "           !  



"

.  !#

  "

  "  

             

 !+!  /  /  

/ .;

. . / ! !!// . / "

 "   .!/

       !  ";

     / /. /. &<

!"  $  !1 "

 .  !" !     &       /         

 !

/ .   !" !

/ "

 

"

 /  !" !

 !9".." !   /  "

 B+ C & '    !

                      

  %  

%    ( 

   ) * 



+,   -, (. /. 01!$ !



  !"   !  

 23  &5'*'. "  6$ &57,



3  ',#'%" *                  )   

' * ( ',#' !! 

  " !

    + 

 %',#'

! 

!

''8  "  

 

? 9!



  +  !!       ! ( ',#'!  

   

   

  !%     )   : '  *  (   " ',#'           !!    !    6$ &57,"   %   "  ',#' ''8!       $ &57,      '  ,#  '  

!    '  6$ &;7, "

    &;  '  ,  '  (%  *   &  ' 0   

   !'     6$ &;7,  '  <(   '%  =  '  '.'.%,

 ) :'  *      

  %''8%'<( '%='     '  *'  .       '        !

 ) :' * 

  

   !

 )  9$  %   

   !'*' .%='  !'<( ' &>  '  '  8%  )   :  '   *          "   !    !    

 !

   "   !' =(  =%  , "

  6$ &>7,%    !  '  ,# '%    !! %  6$ &;7,%     !  '  6$ &;7,%'*'. ='  6$ &>7:6$  &>7)%"  !',  '  6$ &>78%     !  '  ,  '  (

6$ &;78%     !  '  , (  .   6$ &>76%      !  '      

  

3 6$ &>7?"    ! ', (. 

  + 444479 ',#'        &@  =  '         "               !

  '  '  8  

        

   !     !  '         ! ',#'  D , # */

 /$A  B+ C  

    "     6$ &57,        

     6$ &57, ) :' * %  

3   !6$ &57,"

 !        !  

 

9"       (

''8  " 



3        !!        ,

 ) :' *  6$ &57,

   )  :' *  ? !% 9 

   ' ,#'% 6$ &57,

   ) :' * % 

! 

    

   " !  

 ! % 6$ &57,

 9 AB  ,#  '%  "  *   *)"%  

 + ' 



57;% %   

!!   

$ 

  + 444479       B!$  !

%

    !B 

!  .   !

"      

     B  (( "1 

  !  !!     !



   ',#'

$

 6$ &57,     

   ) :

'   * %      

3     " $  ! 

 9 AB

   !6$ &57,    B

 B 

  ) :' * %   

3 1     6$ &57,  "       

!   !!   "  

 !' *  '"  &5*'.   &@=' %,

 ) :'  *     '*'. 

$ &5%   "!  ',#'       

   ) :

' * % %!

  ''8%) :' * ( ',# ' !    "



    + 

    !! 

!   !

' '8  "   

 59;

  +  !!!



       ! (   

  +      

  

 

!''8%) :

' * % %'*'. !       !

 !!  "



!  " 6$ &57,  

"             #        

!! !

  C       '*'.%,

 )  :' * !

 ',#'B                      !                      

 



 (

      9 $               

                   !     DC<E'BDC' D  !"   

    '  ,#  '%    !! %      6$ &57,% !

  ',#'%

  !! %  

    !  + 444479  !

 ' , (. %%  !'  % +  ! %  

$!



   A, (.   " .1 %   

 ! *  D!!  " +5   !0 "   +% F@@  '

!1 ( 

! !

 

 /"

5 ! 

!  /   !! . ./ ((((>+# "   /  .

! !&    !  !

  / .! !      ! !       ! 

    ;   $  !  1    $  !1 9  " /"

;  

! !

 

 "     ! !. "     

/   



A .7

9 "

 /

"  !"/; "

B+ 

 / &!       201  

*+*'" ,-

. /  ;

> B E>&  .B E>&