High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13009/2019disposed of

Jagtar Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-03-20Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

!"!#!

$!! !!#!

%%&

'()*+,'*-./.+0 11 2(3)(45.036 11111*).).+0*4 7*4/8/ 5)()*+,809(:(0;+)6*4/ 11111<*/=+0;*0)/ !>?@"A> B C!>!!

$ DEFEGH 41IJ.)56(4J(K(0;

4171L1568MN(KI;O+-()*/,+4)6*=*).).+0*41 41I480P8=)(K'IPK809(:1 QQQQ !>!!

$R B SS >TU&VWXTYT%Z%V INN+[*;K (/ =4(\*; ,+41 56+4) 4*=N\ ,.N*; +0 :*6(N, +, 4*/=+0;*0) ]+/1)+./)(M*0+04*-+4;1 >!!C 1 ^6* =4(\*4 J(;* .0 )6* =4*/*0) =*).).+0 ./ )+ _8(/6 )6* .J=830*; +4;*4 ;()*; 1`1 aK I00*b84* `K [6*4*:\ )6* -N(.J +, )6* =*).).+0*4 ,+4 =4+J+).+0 6(/ :**0 4*9*-)*; (0; ,+4 ;.4*-).03 )6* 4*/=+0;*0)/ )+ 34(0) =4+J+).+0 (N+03[.)6-+0/*_8*0).(N:*0*,.)/K,4+J)6*;()*6./980.+4/[*4*=4+J+)*;1 1 c*(40*; -+80/*N /8:J.)/ )6() )6* =*).).+0*4 6(/ 0+) :**0 =4+J+)*; )+ )6* =+/) +, 5+-.(N d;8-().+0 (0; (0-6(\()

,,.-*4 (N+03 [.)6 6./ 980.+4/K /+N*N\ +0 )6* 34+80; +, )6* =*0;*0-\ +, ( -6(43*/6**)K [6.-6 [(/ /8:/*_8*0)N\ ;4+==*; O.;* +4;*4 ;()*; e1 1 ` (0; )68/K ./ *0).)N*; )+ :* 34(0)*; =4+J+).+0 ,4+J )6* ;8* ;()*1 * =N(-*/ 4*N.(0-* +0 )6* 98;3J*0) +, +0f:N* )6* 58=4*J* +84) .0

GghGhiGjgklFBmBnB kGogDkpkG 51 1 c*(40*; 5)()* -+80/*N -+0)*0;/ )6() /.0-* )6* -6(43*/6**) [(/

$ # #

% &"

$ ""() !

( #$"

) ) #"

" # ) ) *%# "( $

#$ !

+$ , -.

# # /""

# ( ) 2

' , !" *#! # !(

''!

$ # !

- !

' !

3)3) -

4 $-

$ # 2)3) ) 5) 6

7 89:977 ;<=>?@<A<=7

- "# - -"

% -

' # B2) C !

$$ D % "% # "" $

" - %!

4 # !

$ . - B "

# !

# E) ! "( # D

# $ -! ! # #! "(F!$"

$ (

# -

$ (

"# "( !

# ' " $

' #$"G

- '

$ (

- !

$ "(

""(

# # $ -! # G C B "

# !

# E #

# -

$ (

$ !

!) #! "(F!$"

# $

% $ # !

$ ' .

# !

# '

# D

) !

' D ) HH HH HH 3) C

$ !

#! -

- !

!" ) I

# $ "( # - J"" I ! # # - !

!" !

# -

) C !

!" ) "#

# $

!) ! - "# $

"( ! $ #! "(F!$"

$ (

) # ( # ' ( $

% $

# - ! $ $ F!

$ (

) C

!( - !

!" )

! "# $%# &"

"#"#$

(# &# # %) ! "* + %) ! # %#"#$ ! "* #

%& ! "# * # "* # ,"*" &" )# ! ,#

+#*( *

$",#

# "

* !

"$ ) * #$ &"

# "*

# &"+ & ( , # % !

# )

(

"*+") "#!-+"%"# ) +"#$* &, %!

+** & ) +"#$* & "*+") "#!

+"%"#

%) ! "#*#+

%) !

+ #+ "# "*+") "#! ) +"#$*

+.(" "# +"%"# ) +"#$* "* &"

# "

(

# ++ (#

# #," " "!

,"#+ ( +* "

( %) ! + /# *(+ +"+(%*#+* + #+# ( ""* %(*

,* &" ) & +" & %) ! *,* #! * !

"#,#"#$ )"

* # &"+ *,* " 0"

"#$ + %) " "* # ) **"

#"+") # #(% (*", ! +"+(%*#+* (# &"+ *(+ + #*""

# %!

+ % #+**! "$# &, *(+ +"+(%*#+* &# ! "* # !

&# # "# "

( "# ,! +* &# # %) ! "* #

% "*+") "#!-+"%"# ) +"#$* * (

#" * !

"#,#"#$ )"

"* (#%"# "*+") "# "# %"#"*"

# # 1 )"* )( "+ "#**

(# $ &" '"

(# #! * ! # %) ! & ( "# +"+(%*#+*

" $ "

# )) ,

*" * *##+ "#

"* *( )$) + (*

"""

)$)

% #(% ,"2 ( # *

)! *

)! "%

# "

# ) "

# )+"#$

+( ) "

#3 & "+ "# ) +

*" *##+

&"#$ *##+

"# % #(% 3 &, &

"+ + #+# &"

#" #! *

# "

# ) "

# )+"#$

+( ) "

# # * & # &"

! + #+# ( "!

! 4"#$ "# + #*""

+* # +"+(%*#+*

"*+") "#! ) +"#$-+"%"# ) *+("

# ( "! #"* *

* !

)

""&" + "** #*

"#$* 3 5 "* # & * *" + #+ (*"

#*") "#6 5 /#7 89:;<=77 >?@AB77 CDE77 F?AB77 GH9:I77 HJ77 K9L?M<I9:N77 JH:77 O<P<DIB<@7

Q 5 )""

# & &* * ,

+"%"# +$* * * # "# )%# #.("! &* #"

+ #*""

" #$

!% & '%() $% *+ , % ! % $% % %$'%%

+ $ - " )%& !% .$ ' "%

%#$ !% + + / (! $ ( #$ ) % $ "% 01

%$& %$'%%%

+ !$

( ' "" + / % #$ )!% 2 3+ & & ' ) !

) ,'$ !

% " - ) '

$ '!

% % (% ! ( "%$&

% ' )( ' %

) % ) ! ' %

( ' '$

%" 4" " )%+2 + / % "%& % " $ - .$ & !% % %("+ 5 $% !% "

+ !(& $) "

" % % " )%&

!% "%

& !

"%% %% #$

! "% + / $ & ) $ ") 6$ $ 7%$ 5('& 8& "$" 0$ & ' +9 8+ & "%

& !% " $ % "( ( !

#$% ! !%

% "% & !

;<=>::

?@A=B::

CD@EF=::

GHI::

;BGJKL:

M=JN:

O P& !%

$ ) &

& "

)% )% !% + + Q% %

$) % % ! %& % % '%$ (%(& %$"

%& "

% '"1 8+P+ & !

% #$% ! + , ) ) P+P+ &

()

!" #$!$ !" %!& $!$' ($ "$%! ) !' & ( "#$! *" +&!+ $++$, $"#'" ', +! ' !" $ )+' "$&+, !+!' +! !"(%$!&($!(!', +)!'"$($$' $!% - " %$++ !$"#! !#&' $'$ ''

. !" $, " "!' / #!!$ &$' !+ "!$!, #, (!0! ' "1!+ (!" $!"!& $($ , #+!& ! % "2 +)$ ! $!3 4567893 ##!' #$!$ ! " +" " ,&$ ! & )! ! #$!' ( ) "

)%$ + $, (!" )+' $ !($ "!'#$!'

;<=<>:?@<AB@<CDE:

FGHGIHFGFJ:

KABLM:

NO% $%" $"#P!&Q$"'R"QS $$#$+R"QS