High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/22417/2019dismissed

Anil Gupta v. Sadhu Ram

2019-11-21Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan25 pages

!# !$!!

! !#!

% &'

# ( )) * ++

), -.

/+)) 0- - /+. !* 3"4 +

1 !0# 1 1!5!

! "

# $ % "

&&&&&& !0# 1 1!5!6

+ % ,'

! '() *"+ "

" ')," - . ',,' /" 0

12 " -* ""

-3" 4 5

+ - " * * ""

'6 * -"

-" " + - " " +/2 6

6 6889':68('; )<(';8 )'::'=46 '= '8 8('< )<(<=( <9= ;(46 (, (9 8(':

6 68),::68('; )9,'8< <)((46 8) (= 8('< )9,(9< ');:'= '(46 8) (< 8('< )

6 68),9968('; )9:;:'

'()89( ,(46 ':

(< 8('<

6 68),)868('; )9,(8:

)('8'( 8(46 '< (:

8(';

6 68),';68('; )=(<9;

8'9(:(46 (, '8 8('< <

6 68),),68('; )9,(,'

':(<''

8(46 8:

(< 8('< :

6 68)::;68('; )9,)<8 =;,99 <(46 (, 8('< )9,8;9 :(((((46 8'

8('< )9,8;= ,(((((46 '< (:

8('< ,

6 68),((68('; )9,8,( <9;,8'46 ';

8('< )9,)=) )989'

9(46 (, 8(';

;

6 68),'868('; )9,((8 9<'8( =(46 8) (= 8('< '(

6 68)::868('; )9,;9;

'=;,98 :(46 8:

(< 8('< ''

6 68),))68('; )9,;;, '<;'(< 9(46 8:

(< 8('< '8

6 68):;968('; )9,(', :(9::

8(46 8= (= 8('< )9,'<:

=9((46 (< 8('< ')

6 68),<;68('; )9,(88 <<='8 :(46 8) (= 8('< '9

6 68),9'68('; )9,((, ,9,;8 =(46 8= (= 8('< )9,8), );'846 8< (:

8('< '=

6 68=)::68('; (:;<'( =9889)46 '9 (;

8('< '<

6 68=)<;68('; )9:;<'

9:)=) =(46 8) (= 8('< ':

6 68),==68('; )9,(=, '':<', )(46 ':

(< 8('< )9,)(< 89)=<'46 '8 (, 8('< )9,):'

9,(946 (, 8('< ',

6 68),(=68('; )9,('( '8:;=:

=(46 8( (< 8('< ';

6 68),8<68('; )9,8,= ,9)8;846 ':

(, 8('< )9,)=< 9=<,= ,(46 (, 8('< 8(

6 68);''68('; )9:;=) '9,9(( '(46 8) (< 8('<

7 8'

6 68);(868('; )9,((< ,;<:, :(46 8:

(= 8('< )9,',( 8<):(46 (< 8('<

6 689(;'68('; )<(';9 8)):<946 (, '8 8('< 8)

6 689'''68('; )=(<)9 ';<<'946 ('

'8 8('<

6 689(,,68('; )9:;,8 )(:,) <(46 ', (= 8('< 8=

6 68=),868('; )9:;;= 99:(;

)(46 8) (= 8('< 8<

6 68=9)<68('; )=(';< 89=9<'46 (;

'8 8('< 8:

6 68):::68('; )9,))= <=<=9)46 '= (< 8('< )9,);9 '8(=9 <(46 8( (, 8('< 8,

6 68):,,68('; )9:;;:

=89<, 8(46 8) (= 8('< 8;

6 689'9868('; )9:;=( ',:=(<46 ';

(, 8('< )9,',8 ),8=(46 ';

8('< )(

6 68=;8=68('; )9:;)8 8;(';;

<(46 '< (:

8('< )9,';( 8''=(46 ';

8('< )'

6 689<9'68('; )9,(<= =:,(< '(46 8) (= 8('< )9,')= 9=((46 8) (= 8('< )8

6 68=99868('; )9:;8< :8=('

9<46 (;

(< 8('< )=(';( 8'(8);46 ', ''

8('< ))

6 68),9=68('; )9,((:

,8'(8 =(46 8= (= 8('< )9,'99 <)((46 8< (= 8('< )9

6 68),'<68('; )9,(<, ;););46 8:

(= 8('< )=

6 68=;);68('; )9:,', ',;')= )'46 8( (< 8('< )<

6 68=;8:68('; )9:;,) 98<89 ;(46 ', (= 8('< ):

6 68=;,;68('; )9:;)= ,8:=:

=(46 8= (= 8('< )9,'<= '9)'(46 8'

(< 8('< ),

6 68=;8;68('; )9,(,< ''<88<46 ':

(< 8('< )9,):< '8;(46 (, 8('< );

6 68);')68('; )9,'() ==)=(46 '< (= 8('< 9(

6 68<)('68('; )9:;:= );:(< 8(46 ', (= 8('< 9'

6 68=8,;68('; )9:;=:

':)8<( ,(46 8:

(< 8('<

6 68=;8968('; )9,);, )<9;46 8( (, 8('< )9,));

',9;,=46 (:

8('< 9)

6 68=;<)68('; )9,8<< )9:;;846 8:

(= 8('< )9:;9< '=8;9= '(46 8) (< 8('< )9,)99 '(();

=(46 ', (, 8('<

6 68=':'68('; )9::<= ),')'= ()46 8< (< 8('< 9=

6 6)(;9(68('; )9,(<) 8'<=), 8(46 8) (, 8('< )9,89= '99((46 8< (:

8('< 9<

6 68),=868('; )9,)';

,(((((46 8;

(< 8('< )9,',, '9:)46 ';

8('< )9:;<) =8,)=< :(46 8'

8('< 9:

6 68),8,68('; )9,8;8)9 8<=;('46 '8 (, 8('< ,)<'

=(''( )(46 (, 8('< )9,('< 88''<( <(46 8) (, 8('< 9,

6 68);(968('; )9,8:= :,)<,)46 ''

(, 8('< )9,)=( <)<(:

=(46 ', (, 8('< 9;

6 68<)((68('; )9,8,= ,9)8;846 ':

(, 8('< )9,)=< 9=<,= ,(46 (, 8('< =(

6 68:)8,68('; )9:;;) ;<,8) ,(46 8:

(= 8('< ='

6 6)'';,68('; )9,(,:

'9=)9('(46 8) (< 8('< )9,)') :,:'')46 8) (= 8('< )9,):, 8(=9< '(46 (, 8('< =8

6 6)'(8(68('; )9,(<:

,=8(9 ,(46 8= (= 8('< =)

6 6)(;=;68('; )9:;,'

8'('99 <(46 ';

(, 8('< )9,)=9)9 )=8=46 (, 8('< ,8,) '98,':46 (:

8('< =9

6 6)(;<'68('; )9,)89 :(((((46 8'

8('< )9,),) ))'() ,(46 8< (, 8('< ==

6 6)'8)(68('; )9,';:

;(((46 (:

8('< )9,(::

):=:'( 9(46 '< (:

8('< =<

6 6)'',868('; )9,(:< ,)9),< 9(46 '< (, 8('< =:

6 6)'88,68('; )9,()) ';='<= ;(46 ';

(, 8('< =,

6 6)'(:)68('; )9,8:8 ;=9,=)46 8( (= 8('< =;

6 6)'(8=68('; )9:;);

:,=), <(46 8= (= 8('< <(

6 6)'('=68('; )9::=, )=)9,< <:46 (< 8('< <'

6 6)'()'68('; )9,';, 9=((46 (:

8('< )9:;,;

88,;<9 =(46 8) (, 8('< <8

6 6)'(9)68('; )9,))< 8=<=='46 '8 (, 8('< )9,);= 9==9 ;(46 8( (, 8('<

8 <)

6 6)'';;68('; )9,)'( )8'))846 ', (, 8('< )9,(,) 8(<::=46 ';

(, 8('< )9,):= ,=<< 8(46 (, 8('< <9

6 6)'(:=68('; )9,(=) :,9:'

;(46 8= ( < 8('< <=

6 6)(;<,68('; )9,(8, '9;;9;46 8) (< 8('< <<

6 6)'(8;68('; )9,),( ==)88 '(46 8< (, 8('< )9,)':

:<=9;<46 ''

(, 8('< <:

6 6)(;9:68('; )=(<8;

=:;89,46 '8 ('

8(':

)<(<,9 ')'''

8(46 (, (9 8(':

6 6)(;,968('; (:;::, '=8)))46 8:

8('< <;

6 6)'((=68('; )9,8,'

'((((((46 8'

(< 8('< )9:;:, ':::(( =(46 8:

(< 8('< :(

6 6)'((,68('; )9,('= ,:8):

;(46 8) (= 8('< :'

6 6)'(8,68('; )9:;<< )(<('

,(46 ', (= 8('< :8

6 6)'(:868('; )9,')9 9<(846 8) (= 8('< )9,(<9 ';)=8:

;(46 ';

(, 8('< :)

6 6)(;<<68('; )9,)() '8;8,(46 ', (< 8('< )9,();

8( (< 8('< ')8(<( <(46 )9,';< (:

8('< =;9(46 :9

6 6)'(9968('; )9:;)< '8<;(, '(46 8( (< 8('< :=

6 6)'(<<68('; :);:8) 8,<9<946 8= (:

8('< (:;:;'

8,<)(=46 8, (:

8('< (:;:;;

=(((((46 )( (:

8('< :<

6 6)'(<(68('; )9,)9, 8',:'

,(46 ', (, 8('< )9:;=9 8'(9') :(46 ';

(, 8('< ::

6 68=;;'68('; )9::<:

'='=8) ;:46 '< (< 8('< :,

6 68),,'68('; )9:;)) ;8==( <(46 8:

(= 8('< :;

6 68),<<68('; )9,(9;

<=<8946 8) (= 8('< )9,8(( 9=((46 (:

8('< ,(

6 68=)8<68('; )=(8(< =',')946 ', ''

8('< ,'

6 68=;8,68('; )9,(<< =:('(9 '(46 8'

8('< ,8

6 68=;'<68('; )9,8:) ;(((((46 8, (< 8('< )9,8=( '::846 8< (:

8('<

9 ,)

6 68=;:)68('; (:;,8= :8:<8<46 )'

8('< )9::;= ),;<;( (,46 8< (< 8('< ,9

6 68=;8(68('; )9,((9 9,,,<( 8(46 ':

(, 8('< ,=

6 68):<;68('; )=(<)8 <8=<;946 ';

8(':

)<(<);

')'<9 )(46 (, (9 8(':

6 68=;;868('; )9,(== '9=8))46 8) (< 8('< ,:

6 68=':'68('; )=(8(8 ),9('=46 (9 ''

8('< ,,

6 68):,868('; )=(<8) ,9<=;=46 ';

8(':

)=(<9= ;(((((46 '< (8 8(':

)=(89'

;(((((46 (8 () 8(':

)<(<<9 :',:= :(46 (, (9 8(':

6 68=;;968('; )9);9) =':<<846 8'

8('< ;(

6 68),)(68('; )9,(8) )=,8(8 :(46 '< (:

8('< )9,',= 9=8(46 ';

8('< ;'

6 689'==68('; )9,(=;

=:):8 =(46 8) (= 8('< ;8

6 68),<,68('; )9,(;( '=(,=9 9(46 8) (< 8('< )9,8(= ''<'46 (:

8('< ;)

6 68)::968('; )=(<(, =<)'=:46 '= '8 8('< )<(<)) '8:9:

<(46 (, (9 8(':

6 689'9'68('; )9,8:9 ;(((((46 8( (:

8('< )9:;== );<')< ,(46 ':

(, 8('< )9,)9;

<::99 ,(46 ', (, 8('< ;=

6 68),('68('; )9,',9 '8='(46 ';

8('< ;<

6 68=;)868('; )9,''< ,==(46 '< (= 8('< :);(':

8988,46 8( (:

8('< ;:

6 68=;;)68('; )9,8(:

,==(46 (:

8('< )9,8<= 8;:<<)46 ', (, 8('< )9,;98 ';(8;'

=(46 ';

(, 8('< ;,

6 68);'=68('; )9,()'

'(('=:

9(46 ':

(< 8('< ;;

6 68),<'68('; )9,)8( )8=,;=46 ', (, 8('< )9,),'

,:98 <(46 8< (, 8('< '(( 6 689'9(68('; )=(<'9 '(::=<=46 (;

() 8(':

'('

6 68),<968('; )9:;=< '):,,:

8(46 8( (< 8('<

'(8 6 68),<)68('; )9,8;( 8::<8946 '8 (, 8('< )9,)=;

<'') :(46 (, 8('< )9:;;< '99(=:

<(46 8) (, 8('< '() 6 68=),'68('; )=(8(8 ),9('=46 (9 ''

8('< "

" 6 6889':68(';

" '),"

" 6

" #

$%&

''('( ) * (( *+,

- '(,'.

) * (( *+,

/'%'( ''( -

) * . (''.

0 ) (/((+,

) ( //(+,

! ) * 1 +,

*'*'. *'*'.

'( '. '.,'12'1, '

3 ."

" - * + -

" "

" *

6 0

5 *%

1'/

.'1

) * .+, "

*1'1.'

'%'('

) 1*(./'

! #

" " 8

49,

:#49+0 :#4 :#4 !

5 *%

;

0 ('' +, 5-<=+5

3 "" -" " ', (8 8(';

7 " " " " 6 <

''*'/ 4

''*'/ #

)

3 " " ) "

" " 6 * * 4 5 #

8('< 5

3.6''

" )( ('

8('< 5

3.6'8

- " -* * >" 6 * ?* * * .

" + - - 7 " "

8< (9 8(';-* " 6 !

" *1'/ *1'1.'

.'1

'%'('

4 +

'1'1

-!)7

)

*'''1 -!)7

)

'1!

-!)7

'1'1

" "

" " #

*% !07

*'''%

8 ? @ 8 8 4 4)=,=,*1%1/,'%

* )

,- 4 = - < = - A

" !

! " # " #$$ %&$ ' (

) * + , ( ! ' "- # . / " ') 0 !

2 , 3 4 , 5)

7 ' 0 3 + 7

2 3 8 9 / 7 )

7* # :

$9 ; 1

21 0 // . ') 0 </5 ., 0 1 17 #. 7 # ;

#/ ') 0 * = / , " (*-2 # ;

$ "- ' " 3 0 '

!(2 0 #:

) 72 , 1 4

*''1 -!)7 ,

'1 - 0 @

" # ' / >

+9/ !* + ' ' . ') 0 7 * (( '9 ;

$ "- # $ ') 0

! +9 , " 2 #$& :

(1 "- $ ;

$ ?@ "- 4 '5 0 > )

'1 " " !

(''.

) * .+,

8 +

B -

# " 0

8 ? 0 #4

7 8 ? @

9 8 8 4 4)=,=,*1%1/,'%

*'''% #

=>,

-" "+ "

" 4"

" " -" + *

# "

" " 6 *

8('< + -+ * " - - . "

- " " 5 3.6'' * >" 6 *

" 5 3.6'8

" " 6 *

8('< .

- " * *-" *

* . @

> *" + " -

: # "

? ;

<) #<)

) 0+ 1 (

6 8 %7'

1 %)<),'

7:6

=-2 #+ 0+ > ),

=,?

+6 %7'

1 786 + !

)

0+ !..

, @. 2)

- ),

6 %'

%)<),'

), = A)B ,

0+ 1 %< 2 ( ( #,)'

%7'

%,+'

A1-

6@" *

" + - ." -* A1-

" *

- " " - " * - "" 7 A1-

5)8-* " "" " " +/2 # "

" !

0+ C ?

) -,)?

%,+'

7::

" 6 * 4 5 #

" + +

# " 6

8" " *

" 6 *

*" "" " * -*6. . " *

"+ * - "@ " """ * -

- " * * ""

" 6 *

." )"

*" /2- "

" * 8('968('= /2 "

" * 8('968('=

* " /2 7 " "

6 *" * 8('968('=8('=68('< 8('<68(':

# - "

8="

6 *

*" - " " " * "8('968('=

- *

/2"

6 *

" * .@

* "

# " 6

- " "

6 *

+ # "

5 -* (B

" --* .-

"" - +""

5 3.6'8 -*

*-* 88 (:

8('<

" "

8('< + # "

* " "

" "

- * "

/2 -

* "

"" ."

- 6 5 " ? - * -

"+ *

- " *"

6 * 4 5 #

- *

# *

" " ."

?" AC- -* "

" +/2 - - "

- " "-"

6 * .

5 )8-* " "" " A " "

" ."

* " " 6 /

* 5 )8

-* " '<" /

D " "32 8('9/" C "

8('9C2 " * "

5 3.6'' "

" '=E'," "8('9 * " " 5

3.6'8 " -

" 5 3.6'8 -*

-* @ 38) (= 8('<

*-* * * ?*

7 " "

" . " * " -*

- 6 " -* - *

/-2 /2"

-" "

*" " """ "

/2 /2 /2

" *

6 *

*" " 4"

-*6.

7 " 8"

- -

'6 *"@"

7 """ 6 *" *-

- " * * ""

" *

" * "" *

/2"

"" *

- " @

* " * "

F " " * 8('968('=8('=68('< 8('<68(': -*

" -* * * 8('968('=8('=68('< 8('<68(': + +

* - - "

/"2

" /2"

*" +-

+ "" /2"

/2 " " - ?" !

C / 2

" * * 8((< +

* 8(':

5 3.6''

* 8((< " "'(*

" /2 "

- "

/ /2"

" " 6 * - *

- -

" ?""

-" /2" -* /2

. " - +"

--* " " " 6

8 4@ " "

/2 5 3.6'8 "+ /2 "

!0# 1 1!5! 8'

8('; #

4 H4 - H4