← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13455/2021dismissed

M/S Country Colonisers Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of Punjab And Others

2021-12-14Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa,Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj20 pages



        CWP-13455-2021 (O&M)  

 !"## M/S COUNTRY COLONISERS PVT. LTD.

###    $ %$& STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS '

(   )!  *+) # , ,,  *+) # ,% ,# - .....        

   ! " # !

$ " %   &" '( ..... % ,# -/#0 $12 CM-15060-CWP-2021 & CM-18005-CWP-2021

 CM-15060 of 2021    )&*          +& , -   )&*

 CM-18005 of 2021 &           , ).#  )./       .'

#0#. )&* %.

0% #0#.

 " CM-18005 of 2021

 &).#./  +       &      *    

32-   " 23 ).40(0 #0#. && ) 

             ) &*

& * 5   &* #( 0/ #0#. 

  "                          



          

       

!   !          " #$%&' ( )  (   *

  *            & +# ,+, %*

  ' 

*-  ./()(*/ -    

       

 



/     !         

  0,/,&/+++/++1       !                                     /        3  4 - 

        

$$ ,+,+  

6 +, ,+,   7  "    "

   -   %*

 

'  2      

  ,6 +8 ,+,  9  "

 " /   *  * : /  -       

 7 !         

33-     

7 , 6 ; # 6  *     

      

-             *       +    &   *                     & &*    ** ,  * '%748 9:9#0.(

   " #%1.0  &* &, ;#   

           < =    ( 

 7 ,  

       ! 

  

   #$%&' ()(** /,+ 6   /       



                  !   

     * 7        %    : '    <     *                 !            

  (  ,/,&/++/+++1    

   

   

        

! 

       /  

  

 ! 

         ! 

 

 !  

 

34- $   

   

            

         

  !      

  )>()9)<*(3"<2      !  

.

         

     /             

 !       !

 !   )  <              

 

                        !"          !

! ""

"""  #  $% &'

   %  %    !

! ""

"""

 # ( #  )        

#  #  

     !   

     !  

  

 <3? 4

1?  2

  !         (  5/++/+++1                 < =  *-  ./    !  

            

      ()(*

!! ,+          ,+,

                        1  

      

                         /     

  

            

1 1  !

35-      

            .    

  %

  

  ,'! !  5#@,+#

 $58

 8 !   

 #+  !  

   

/ / !           / / 2  

 ?   

 / !  / <   /        -               /           !  ! 

     /       ! !  

!       

      

  !        /           

        

+     ,6 +5 ,+, / 

     /        

 !   

      " #$%&'  () (  *

 * /        & +# ,+, /    !  

     

1

 A 

 !             !        

!  / ! 

 

  

       

 

      ! 

  

   !    

      

/

   *              /  -       

   * !  

        !

36-      !      

     !         !  

1!   < = <    !  

 ! 

 !    

  !     

  .

        

            

       

         

   * +,#( -  .   (  +  /  -  0    $!")  -.. "  (  +' .        ' # '     ( 1 '    (  &'   ' (     & #    (( 

    / ( !!    

    !    

          

  

               < =         

               $$,+,+   

         !

 

!

/!  



    ; %

 3           &*         & *        &   #% ..

#0#. 

 B     



             

       !

 

      

7 # 6 

37- C ! 

  ,

,+,

  !      ; '

+            3  

  " CM-18005 of 2021     &  3             )     &*    *  %.

0% #0#.         &        *    * 9  ./#<4 1'

    ,    - &       9 .4#4% 4(

( +   ,2 * )&**         ,   & 9  .''

1.

 +   &  2 

 *&  *%.

0% #0#0  ,9 #/.

0.

 & &  &  &* & 

  ,   )2&* )&*   )&*&  )

)&       &* / = 3                   

   &*  9 <.%04 /%

   2        9  441/0 ((

 = 3     

38-     &*  

*      *    

     &*          &   &* 

 &  * ***

   <

                +  & *   )3&*3&*>? @    9 3&*  *   *  * 

   &    3&*    ) ?           

       6  &*    &            -,& && ) ?          )    .0    &  >A@       *             * B  @ = C*D71 8>A@&) B )      D    ,  <         

! 

 

39- ..

       *  >A@   3&&  *&  .# ?     *  +   &        &*   

  && ) 8 +*7 & - 8 8   8 "& 8 ? 3 8  * 8 E, 8 3   

      

  &          &* *   *   3&*        3&*  *   ) B                &*       2 9 /.'

1(

" .%   & &      

&*    9 ( 11

+  &9 .%/ (.=

 &*& .#& &9 4.0 (#

    & *

&*    ,  9 #'# 40

    9  %4< 14

  &       

310-      &** &          *         &        &          )  B     & &      *  %.

0% #0#.       

 &     &,    & 9  %% ..

    *   %.

0% #0#.  9 /0 <.

    *   %.

0% #0#.

 &  *   +& ,  &0 ''

 *#0#09 .( #1

 *%.

0% #0#.

 .% 

&&*   )             B            &   &           &       * - ,*&  .'

?

    ,& & &   * &   * & &    ,    *  ,&&&  *& " &

              

    &* *& )  &        

 &    *       * )&*&  )  .4 "   &     & 3      &*)'%748 9:9

311- #004      &           

 ,  & 5@ &3  & -" &C  = 6   3  " (/'4)(/'1 #0#...

..

#0#.  ,  &  2F

4       

  - $)   /   ' #

'  (  #(  (%5

,,  2   !    " #$%&'  *             

   

  -           !   

   

 -           /           $+  

      

     

                !  

   

 

/           !      

 

!  

      / /!   / 

 /    

 

,$             

 

     

 1-    

     

   

     !   !    

       1  !   A     

     *              *

312-

,#  C   

 



     

     *

   -  /      $+

   

 /       !       

              



   

 1-                     !       

 

   

     A 

     

          ! 

  " #$%&' * !          

    

  *  # 

2  

,&  

      

 

     !        *           

         

  "  *   /  

                  / 

   /      /        /       / 

    / 

       /       222   222   * / ,+ 6    !  

       

 

  !  /

     

1         -    *  

    

  E/                 

     

 /           

    !      *

313-

,6  /  A          !        

 1 

,5  2        

    ! !         *  ,+ 6/   

      

  

 !  

1

    !       /!                  

  !   /    

   

1

   

       

  

  

  

        / 

 ! 

   !   

  

  

  

   

          /    /       

1

    

  !         

    

1

    

         

     /   

      

! ! 

,8  *  / !                         

     

  /!          

         /    

  -     

314-

$&    /  

   

        !     



  

$6  2    !



/! 



 /     

   2      

      

 

 - /  !

 ! -  A 

-     ! 

 !     

 *   /       

 !   !     

  / /   *

  A 

$5  2      !/          " #$%&' * /    /  !    !      1

        



 / 

     !  

            

                      " #$%&' * /



        *  # % '%' 

2   .( +       3   &    *          ,  -&    *   3  ,          ./

        &*  3&*  * 

315-          3

 *     2&   )&* *  .<

  &   &    E *    *

'%7489:9 #0.( *  

  * *  & 3  B         &    & .1 

 & 3  &&         &-  6 7 8 9 -'  3    " .'04  #00'   0% .# #00'

  &&* &3 )

' 

 C

F     *

   

 /    /    !  ,' / !/  ! ! /      /     

 

 /    

         

   $'G     !

    -   #'*  !A /   / 

!!   -  !/  /       /      &'   

         ! 

3166' B"

           ) ;/G C < /B

!

  !      !    ;

5'  

        

 ! 

  H2 !    -    !/  

  /  /    8' !       H .

               

!H  !

HI       

                 !        

 

                       



             !  

 

            

     

 

 !

 F #0 +     && 3 &-  : ( / / 8

(7

 / ;  3    " %(0%)%(04  #004   ..

0/ #004

       & 3   *,) F5 2 !

  !  

     

  

   !     *

   C

      

      

3178    



    

    -   

  

      

   C

     %" 2

    *

   91   *  /*2(% 8'" 5#'   

   C

             / ! 

   !    !     * A /  !A    / 

 !  !      -   ! 

    *  !  " /% 8#6'69 / /

 C

F   * /!

  /     !     %"  "

  :

-    .    3  7 -      *  / G % 8' , " ,&$'  2   

          !

 *   

    %""

  ?

G % 'C  /% 58' * )(#8<C' ( 

   

/        

       

  !

 * 

     !     *   CC C    "  9 C    ) / %

+' * ##& %<C'/ A    G

 9-/ 9 J  3 . /*2(% 6,' "8#5'

   A     !        



!   /00"

      ) FF G C  <  / 00

 !

    !      !   FF %"

318C   K /, 8?(&#5'  !!   I 2  .  ? 3:  3: /*2(% +' "8 '

+ 2 3 ( 

  .    3   

  .   /*2(% 55'"8#,/ !   

              

!

   

   

 !     

    ! 

  

       



  

        

 ! 

  2  !    -    !/  

  /  /      %" 

   " / 9       /I-- /L,+++M&" &

'     

    - 

  

$ 2   /00! !!

         /

 

!  /   

!  /     /   ! 

 A  A



FF004

/FF   /00   / !  !   !             /         !        A

/   

 FF%"?

 <  / % 8&8'>29/  $#5' *       

 /   

   / !/        /       

/

319-   A  

   

 /     /  

/

  !         

         

   

 -  

D 00   /FF 4 /G  G  "

 /

 ( &,/00     !/  !   ! FF

#    !/

/ /  /!

    N00 

         !      !                !     

/ ! 

     !   /        /

 FF%":   /% 8&5'6< C  6 ' 

   00   FF

/ !/   ! 

 

00/FF  G/ G /00 !

     - 

/!          / 

  /  ! /     

   -         !   

    4

!

       !  !           ! /   !/ !/      -        FF%" *  3/

/ 4 $58' = #.

+        &    &   '% 748 *   & 3    &  - " &C  =  6   78                 

320- 2&*

 &) 

  ?3 ,&&*&&   *&* &  3 *)

       &   &  &  

  -&

   *  &&&&      &&      * *  '%7489:9#0.(   & 

 ? &     &&         &

     *    &* )  ,&   

&    & &  *&  &* ## ?       & ,  * ,&            )           *&*

   &&  C& 0 ,,2 0% ,# -2      "## "  -44$(5 67$  !7 -44$$($81 !7