Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And ANR v. Kuldeep Singh And ANR.
'&# .- *#6
6)$).% #6#(8#" 94 :
"#$#%& " -." &,
" 7 ! !!
%$%$," &,"+"% ! ! 7 '"()%*#" !)%+,4 *5.6'&# ,# /#&)&).%#"$ "#$/.%*#%& %. %*#"0)& 1'2$,'34 *5.6'&# -."
55555 4
!"#$"% &"%1$%&%$%$,"
"$%,% 1 ++ %+667 ' ""( )* & & + /0 % 3 ""% ,4 + ! %2 % $"+ 2 1 /0 % &%$%$," 1 +$.%+ %, .,"$+ "
"+ &,. % &&!$. %$," ,8 8 &,"+"%",-'
&&!$. "% $"*8,! ,8 % /1!!.,"".%$,"2 &% ! %% $"% .%$," $ + /0 % &%$%$," ! %$"
"# %, % . 3 8, ! ,8 8 % /1!! .,"".%$ ,"2 / % $" +,$"# ,2 $% ! +0 +$# ++ % &&!$. /! $"% .%$," "
"+ , "! && $"# ," / !8 ,8 % &%$%$,") .,"%"+% %% 3 ""%,4 + ! % +$.% %+% &%$%$,"%,.,"$+ "+
&,.% &&!$.
. %$,",8&,"+"%",-8,!
! ,8% % /1!!.,"".%$,"
" &% ! %%$"
"% .%$,"! %$"#%,. 38, ! ,8% /1!!.,"".%$,"
,& %$9& % %,8% ,+ +% :
-
! .
"!# $ %& /
'
%& %& & (
'
!)
*
'
!)
%& !
' $
+ *
"!!!!
+
' $
%& !
!
$
+
'
,
'
'
!)
*
$
'
!)
*
%&
$ '
'
) )
0
1 % %
%& !- *
2
)
3
'
0 4 '
$ 1
'
!) )
'
!) )
"!!!! $
'
$ ' $
! 4
$
$
-
'
!) ) )
5$
6 '
8 . "
"+ ., "! 8, % &%$%$," .,"%"+ % % % ,33.$ !
$.
! %%, ,7;<7-+ %+-=77-# +$"#(%"$,",8 ,!$.08, % 0 7-6)-8 8,$ ".,8% /1!!.,"".%$ $," + "+:
> "? / % %,1,&, % %$,"$3$%+ 88$.: $8 "#$"<,33 .$ !2 %$ ! ,33.$ !$.
! %%,7;<7- * % 9
' ;
01
.5 %
1 0
5
7; 8 :' -!
003.""
*
$.! ." <#!!"
<
& $
$
! ." *
& $ ! ."
5''
(! '
'
5
- ! !
80'
4
'
)
!
80'
4
'
!!
' (!
!)
!) )
!#
!!"
!)
'"!#
) *
'
&
- !! ' '
5''
$ $
785
'
'
5
-)!
'$
'
$
& '
*
'
=4 '
'$
'
&
'
>
'
'
'
'
$
*
$ '
'
*
' '
5''
5
- ! ' '
'
6 $
4 ?
! "
"+., "!8,% &%$%$,"., ,"%"+% % &% 8, $+ ,33.$ !$.
! +1$% % &!08$!+/0 &,"+"%",-%,% 88.%% % % $,1"%,% (%"%,8 .4 " ! "
"+-73 ! $"9$!! #@ 3
1 $2 $! "+ $%$.% % $"+ 2% .! $3,8 8% &%$%$,"1, !+8 !! "+ .!
' *,8% 8, $+.,33.$ !.$.
! "!0% ,3 !!8 31 , &"+$"# & %, 6-% @ . 77 &&!$. %$," 1 7=2 1 %, / $ + % /1!!
.,"".%$," & %, , 6--7- .,"%"+ % % "+$& %+!02 % &,"+"%) ) &&!$. "% /3$%% +% &&!$. %$,"8,! ,8 .,"".%$," "+% &,!$.0 0 ,"--77=$ 8%6-7677= "+ ".2 $ . +$+",%8 !! "+% $+ &,!$.0 8, ! ,8 % % /1!! .,"".%$," ,%1$% % "+$"# % 32 % 3 ""%,4 + + ! % +$.%+% .,"$+ %$ $,",8% .! $3,8% &&!$. "% % "+ %, ! % % /1!! .,"".%$," ., ,"%"+ % % % 1, !+ / ", , #$9 ".,8% $",8 .,"$+ %$," ,8% .! $3,8&,"+"%",- &% ! %%$"
"% .%$,"$.,"."+2 ,19 2% #$9 ".3 " %8,3 3 % 8$"+$"# .,+ ++ /0 % 3 ""% ,4 + ! % $" & ", -- ,8 $% 1 + 1 $"2 $% / /" &.$8$. !!0 % %+ % % % . ,8 % &,"+"% ",-) ) &&!$. "% $ .,9 + "+ % . 3 /%1" ; %, ; . ,8 ! "+ $ 8$"+$"# &, .
. !!"# %, % .,"$+ %$," ,8 % .! $3 $" %3 ,8 % &&!$. /!&,!$.0 , "
"! && $"#,"/ !8,8&, ,"+"%",-) &&!$. "%2 ,192 2 .,"%"+% %% &,"+"%",-) &&!$. "% +"
",%/" %8 !% "+% % + +&,$%+% &&!
!$. %$,"3,"0%,% % ",8 ;2777<) &&,($3 %!0$"% 0 77= "+% % $%$!! 1 $%$"#% ! ,8% .,"".%$,".,"%"+
% %% 8, $+ ,33.$ !$.
! 1 ",% + ++ .+/0% &%$%$,") /8,% 3 "
""%,4 + ! % "+ . 2 , !+",%/&" !$B+8,% ,3$$," .,33$ $%%+ /0 % &%$%$," 8 % /3$$," $ 3 + % % % .,"A "% &," % +% $! 8 "$ + /0 % & %$%$,") 2 % &,"+"% % ",-) &&!$. "%3 +$"9%3"%/01 0,8.,"% % .%$,",8 4,% $"% 8$!+ !,"#1$% % A
$$%% .% "+ % /1!! &% ., "! && $"#8, &,"+"%",-) & &&!$. "%2 $"%$%!+%,/.,3 3&" %+8,% 3 , "
"!8,% &%$%$,") ., "%"+% %% $",.! $3/0 0 % &&!$. "% # +% ! .4,84",1!+# /, %% 8, $+,33.$ !
$.
! +&$% % % &! ,8 % &%$%$," &.$8 8$. %, % $+ 88.% !, , .,"%"+ % % 3 !0 /.
% $+ +,.
3"% % 1 ",% &,+ .+ /8, % 3 ""% ,4 + ! %2 1, !+ ",% ,& % / # $"% 8$"# %, % 8, $+ ,33 .$ ! $.
! &,"+ "% ",-) &&!$. "% "$% +$& %+% $+ ,33.$ !$.
! 21 $!8$!$"
"#% &!02", 8+ %, "0,% 9$+"
".1 $. 1, !+ ,1% %% $+,33.$ !$.
! % "+ &++/0 "0 0,% .,33.$ !.$.
!
2% &&!$. /$!$%0,8% $+ ,33.$ !$.
! . "",%/$#",+ $ ++,.
3"%$",% /A "% % . %$,",8% &% %$%$,"%1 ! +0$"($% %".9" %% %$31 "% &&!$. %$,"1 8$!
!+/0% &,"+"%",-) &&!$ $. "%,"67-7- /3$% % % "0 . 8 $!
, !+",%/ !+ #,
"+%,$#",% "%$ !%3 "+ .,"+$%$," , 8 ,33.$ ! $.
! .," $+$"# % % 8$. ! !$ /$!$%0 ,8 8 /$+0$8 %" + !%,(3&%$,".
"/. 9+, %8,&,"+"% % ",-) &&!$. "% "+ +9"% !!0$3$! /"8$%3
%/ !,3 + 9 $! /!%, !!
,% $3$! !0 &!
.+ &," 8 % .,"".%$ $," $ ! + %, ," &&!$. "% % 9" 8% % .
% ,88 + %2 !! ,% $3$! !0 &! .+ &," 1, !+ !, / "%$%!+%, 3% %3"%,"& $%0 !,8 %,% & ",6,8% &!0 0
8$!+%,% &&!$.
%$," "+ .%$,"'.*,8% # ! 9$. % ,$%$ .%2 2 -C=21 $"$% /" /3$%%+% %% &, ,"+"%) &&!$. "%1 8, "+%,/ ",%"%$%!+8, "0 0% /1!!.,"".%$," ,,% % # 3"% 9/" $+ 9 9 +! "+., "!8,% & %$ "+ 9#,"% , # % +,.
3"% 9 9 $! /! ," .,+ 1!! % $3& #"+ 1 +2 1$% % $ $% ". & ! ,8 % /,9 "+$& %+ 8 .% ! &,$%$," ,1 % % ", , .,33.$ !.$.
!
! /"$ +$" & $,",8$.
! %,;,87- # +$"#(%"$, ,",8 ,!$.08,% 0 7-6 6)- /,9 ,33.$ !
$.
! 1 " (%"$," ,8 ,33.$ ! $ $.
! ", 6 ,8 7-6 + %+ --7D7-6 & % $+.$.
! 23 !!8 3 ,1"$"#! "+8,3; .%, , ; . "+1 , &&!$. %$,"1&"+$"# &%, ,6-%@ . 77=1"%$%!+ %,#%.,"".%$," &%,6-%@ . 7- & % ., "!8,% &%$%$,"2 2 &,"+"%",-) & &&!$. "% +,$#$" !!0 /3$%% +% &&!$. %$,"8,! ,8 8 .,"".%$," "+ % . %#,0,8!% "; .21 2 &% &!0 0 "$ + /0 $32 2 $ % ,1" %, % (%"% ,8 . %1, . " ! "+ %"
" 3 ! ,8! "+ "
"+ . "+$& %+!0.,3 3 "+% . %#,0,83 !!
8 31 ,,1" ! "+8,3; .%,; . &% %3 "+.,"+$%$," ,8 % /,9 , ,33.$ ! $.
! 2 $" ,+ %, , / !$#$/! 8, % ! ,8 8 !.%$.$%0.,"".% %$," "+% $+. %#,02,"
"!0% , &&!$. %$," /3$%%+ /8, 6-677= 1 %, / .,"$++ & &&!$. %$," $" A %$," + /"
" /3$%%+ 8% 6 -% @ . 77= "+$& %+!
!0 % &&!$. %$," $" "+ 1 /3$%%+,"--% &$!77=$ 8%% .
%),88+ + %
2% &,"+"%",-) ) &&!$. "%+,",% %8 !!8$!!% %3 "+.,"+$%$," ,8,33.$ !$.
! %% ,;,87-%, /!$#$/!8,% ! ,8.,"
"".%$," "+% . %#,0
9"% , # 2% $ , %$.,".$, ,8% 8 .%% % % &&!$. %$,"$"A %$," + 3 $"+&"+$"# 1$% % &%$%$,"8," !0- -=0 2 ,192% !,%, , / " % % % % /1!! .,"".%$," $ /$"# # .! $3+ "+ /$+$B+ .,"".%$," "+ . "",% / ! + % % 3 3 4$"# ,8 % &&!$. "% % ",%1$% % "+$"#% 8$" ".$ !$3&!$. %$," "+% 3 " #3"%,8% /$+$%, , / #$9" /0 %
% % ,9"3"% % $ ,"!0 1 " " &&!$. "% 8 !8$!! % .,"+$%$,"&.$/ /+/0% % % ,9"3"%%, ! % .,"".%$," "+% /$+$B+. %#, 0% %% &%$%$,"+$%$/ %$, ")!$.". "# "%% /"8$% %
"+% !9 "%
. 3 .,
%$A $+%,3 $".,".$, , ,8% 8 .%% %% 3 0/ 3 "0,% $3$!
!0&! .+&," 1 $%$"#! ,8!.%$.$%0.,"".%$," .
%),88+ %+% 3$"+/0% % %. "",%/, ,/!$% %+ "+ ., ".% % . .%$"8$($"# # "!$#$/$!$%0%$",3 !!0"
",%%,/$#",+ "+ %,/ #$9"88.%%,$"+ +%3$"$"#% !$#$/$!$%0 8 8$" ".$ !!$ /$!$%08 %"+ ,"%
% %1, !+8!,1, ,"%,% /!$. (. A "+% % % . 8$" ".$ !/ +"1, !+ ",%,+$" $!0/ . %+/0% , % % % 9"+,",% &&"%,/ & %0$"% &,. +$"#/8,% 3 ""%,4 4 + ! %
9" % , # ,& %$9 & % ,8 % 1 + +$.%$"# % &%$%$,") ) %, .,"$+ % .! $3 ,8 % &&!$. "% 8, 8, % ! ,8 % !.%$.$%0 0 .,"".%$,"+,",% A $3 . $"%8".2 ,1 19% 8$"+$"# .,++$"
" & "
3/--'
& *,8% 1 +"+%,/.
! $8$+
& &"%1$%&%$%$,"$ ..,+$"
"#!0& %!0 !!,1+ 8$"+$"# # .,++$"& "
"
3/--,8% $3& #"+ 1 +2%,% (%"%,8 ,!+$"#% &,"+"%",-) & &&!$. "%!$#$/!8,# "%,8!.
.%$.$%0.,"".%$,"2$,++%, , /(& "#+ &%$%$,") $ ..,+$"# #!0+$.%+%,.,"$+% .
,8% &,"+"% ",-) &&!$. "%8,! ,8 % /1!!.,"".%$," &$% &&!$. /!&,!$.0 "+% !$#$/$!$%0.,"+$%$,"& .$/+% $" + !%,3"%$,"% %$"% 9"
"%% &,"+"%",-) &&!$. "% % /$"#8, "+%,/ $"!$#$/! "+% &&!$. /! ,33.$ !$.
! 8,! ,8 !.%$.$%0 .,"
"".%$,"2 % 3, "% ! +0 + +&,$%+ /0 &,"+"% ",-) ) &&!$. "% 8, ! ,8 % !.%$.$%0 .,"".% %$," !! / ! + %, $3 3 !,"#1$% $"%% 28,3% + %,8$%+&,$%%$!!
!$%+$/ 3"%2 &.$/+ /0% &&,&$ % .,33$$,"21$% $" &$,+, ,867+ 0,8& $"#,8 . "
" ,+ " , , 8 /3$$," ,8 % &,"+"%) &&!$. "% 8, # "% ,8 8 .,3&" %$,"8, % $"9%3"%3 +/0 $3$.
.,"."+2% $+ &.% $ +$& %+A %$," ,88 .% "+. "",%/#,"$"%, ,/0% $# , %$" ?
+$.$ !
9$1 "+3 0/ /& +$" " !%" %$9.,3 3&%"%8, 3 &$,+&"% % $"& $"#% & "%&,.+$"# !!2 ,19 2/(3&%+1 $! $"# # !$3$% %$," 8, .,"
"$+$"# &&!$. "%E & 0 8, 4$"# .,3&" %$," 8, !!#+!,.
+ +%, $3 %$%$ ,"$+$&,+,8/$"#& %!0 !!
!,1+ #6#(8#" 94 $%
% % !
7 :
F<, F<, & 4$"#< ,"+ &,% /!: