← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15045/2009dismissed

Improvement Trust Gurdaspur v. Kashmir Singh And ORS.

2019-02-25Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari15 pages



    

 !"# "#$%&

$&"$'&($( $&!'$'

)**  

 

   



   

    +)  ,-+ * .*.*.-

 

    

  



!

 

  

"

 



  "# $$$$ *.*. '#  ! /*0 %

  

""

 %& #   

# '

( )* + %,-., %,-,/ %,-0/ %,%-1 %,%%, %,%,1 %,%', %,2'& 2--1  " 

   ( )* + %1%0' %1,&. %1,', %1&0. %1&', 2-%2, 2-/,%  2-/1/ 2--1 )* +1/1 2-%-  " "#

( 4   * 2,34% 5$3$ "%6("6%'(46%7(* 8(#3!%.!

# ' "#$%(, )""   #    # 

5

 

( "     2,-/2--'

8 9/:

#(3 



8 ;

/,'.--<9  7 22.- ":

  2 "4  7 %2,- ":

"" "" 5 

5

  )""  /.



 ="  +,

 !(

# 

%122

      4      #   -'%22--- 7>8  9%':         -.-.%11, #(3 "" ? 8 ;

0.----<9 

@   #

# %-A   3  "3 

  /-A

 

  (  "  "



<+ "

B#3

 "# !    "3   3        /0     -&-,%11/ 

   

""

C  % " %0 "  "

"#



!

(  #   "" 4     

8" "" (    



 

""

""3  

(        (    (   

8 3 



( 

7>8 9% 9%0:

   ""   ! "" ?(#"

  "3 !     3

""

 3   3  #3

(   "

 

     



   

( "

 

(  

3 "#  ( # -,-,%11& 2.%-%11'

  "#   "  

   3  

3  " "

 # 7>8

9%':

 "   #

     # " 

" "3 "

 >8 9% 9%0

( "#

  ( # 0----<9 &----<9      # 2 "4  "("   

( "

#"3    

 

#

  

 "#

"" 3 4#  "     "

     3

 #

 "" 5      "

" "3

  "

4   (

" ;

.----<9 "



   " 3 " "# 8( 

 9" 7>8 %2

9%.:



     )"4  (

 ) 8

*92 ( 

("  ("#

.* * . $ $$'( "$ %$ 08+1

%!&$93% 0!

(*1

%!&$9&%$ 0!

(*1 % >8

9, &/'.

7:

-9% 0---<9 10----<9 2 >8

,/'.

7:

-9'

/---<9 .'----<9 / >8

9& /-112 7:

-9%- %----<9 %0-----<9 . >8

9'

2-%1/ 7:

-9, ,---<9 '-----<9 , >8

%221/ 7:

-9%, ,2,-<9 '.----<9 0 >8

9%- 21%21/ 7 : -9%0 ,---<9 '-----<9 B    # 8

*9.

#  

4 -'-&%110  3 C 7>8  9%%:

B  (  (   "

   4

# ""

D"

   # 

"

"   

  >8  >  

%--   =  0--   #3

( ""

 (

  "

! "

(

3 +



"

   '-    = )

 %--     = )

  3  "

"8  !(    >"  3 ?

8  # "3   =  %,-   "

 

98 

   

  "  ) "

#   

B(!  

*9&

    9= + 

# 

"

"

 >8  >

   # E  !

 "

) B

)"8

( #   5 " F"# "

( "  3

B

  "" 3 %,---92----<9 " 3

" >8  9& "" 3

    

     (4 ;

&,---<9 "

""

""

   ""  

 

98    ""

  % 4 "" ?(#"

    ?(#"

 4"

    "" ?(#"

 

*9' =   3  "

   ""

# "" 

"" ""



 3 #  .9,- "4

#    D"

 >8  9%/ >8 

#

" ;

/---<9 " 3 %1'.

 

    /----9.----<9 "

""3

*91   

"  >8 9'

9%-

   "#     ( # %,---9 2----<9 "

*9%-

! 7 :

    "

 &, 4"

%% " #  9     D"

 54  "" ?(#"



   " 3  "

#""

"

( "

B

 

(#""

""

 9" 7>8  9%&:

?  > )""  , 4

 "       >8 

9%'



"  "3

  ( # '9 %- "4  +   ("



8      "



    3 # 

8  3

 9" (  

# " 

#  3  3 "  # (   

( "

""

  #" "3

 >8  9%'     "   

    

  3



 

 "   , 4   (

  "" # 

"

"



 " " 

"("

    "   "" (4 #



    ""

"

5 (  



    (

 9"  

#

"

    >8 9% 9%0 "  ""  "   +

:863%; "#$%(7(*.""$ 2%< ; "#$%(=01  0!5!

1= # "

G%,

#  (     (   "3 # 

  ""#  (""3 (("3

    6 " 3    

(

#3 #3   ( 

" 

 

  !

     6  

6 "H

  ""       94"   3 4  "

   5 (  B#3 3    (

  ""

%0



# <!

 "3     

  

" 3  

 <# 6  "4 3   8"  

#<!

 ( 8"

 

"  (" 

#<!

 

(    

 "3 !  

  4

 #    ""#    3  """ 3      #<!

 #""3 "  %&

 3  



  3

 ""#  # 

   (  %- %2 3  (   (    " 

"      # 

  



      "(" "3 #  ( 

   ( 

    

  .

    

 "     ""3  

 

  "

"

3     "

   #

      

 3

        %'

(      

#<     

 < #  (" 3 "

  

"3     #  <

!

 3

3   

 

 4 """ 3

  

#<!

 4    <

   (     

#<!

 (  9   ""#

"  ""

 9 "3 !     8" "   3

# (

"

   "3

"  "3    3I

 

# ""# - 5$ $$ 863%; "#$%( 7(*.""$ 2%< ; "#$%(=0>1.& $?

# "

G& B     "

        #      #""

B    

 ("

       



 " ( 

"    ("

   "

    "

  " "" B 

"   ( " "

""

#  " 8 3 !

  .

      

  #3 B   #"  "

  

  

   B



   

I

  

 9"

3   "

"  (  D"

 ""

 ?(#"

""

(3

"

"" ?(#"

 

 (  

D"





2 '!7(*%4".!

#; "#$%(01 .@>

8   #

 3 =" ( "   3   (" ( "   "(" 

"   

G2.

(" (



  "   ?

  (  = ? B  ( "

+@=

"3 " "    %1'-

B 

    (

"" =""



"  # "3   5"



/.,<9

3     2.'2--%

   J72--%:

1.

=5

/&'K

B    %'

     " 

    " 3     "  

( #

"" =""



     "

 (     

""  ( 

"" )""  ?

"" =""

 (

  #    ?"   #  

 2, * #  

    "3

  "" ==

"     "   ""  

""3 " (

 "  3 # 

#  #

"  "

"

*    4 # 8 3 =" "" "

    "    &0,,

6 3  



""

(   %-A  ) "3

3 (  "

  

#I

#  (

# >8 9, 

90   3 %1'.

 "3



      3     3   

  /--1%112 7>8  9&:

 "3 "

 #(3 %- "

" ;

%----<9 "

  ?"( 

*9, "  "    

 

"    ( " 

"  "  >8  9%2

#  # ( 

""3 " "3

>8 9'

9%- 

#   ( # ,---<9 ,2--<9 " ( # 2--%%11/ 21%2%11/ 3 3  

>8  9&  ?"(  # ?

  !( + "

?4     " " 2--    "" D"

  .9,  "

# 

 "

"     "

( # "

 8 

  "

 " 7>8  9&:

""

(  "       

  "

" "  (

  ,---9,2,-<9 "

  



" #4

'-----9'.----<9  >8 9'



4     , " %, "  "3  8 2--%%11/ %2-2%11/ (   (    /0    

-&-,%11/

 

 

( "

   

""

  4     "3  

   ""

# 

"

"   

("  "   (

"

 " ( (   3

"  "

 

8 * * 6(!

 %'7(*#%".*$!; "#$%(01.= # .-A     "

 %</

8  

""3

38 %; "#$%(7(*.""$ 2%< ;

"#$%01  0!5!

1@

"   

"

"     " 

(    

 "3    

 

 "3 "   #""   3 #""

""  3    8    8   

8 ,%!(# !

 '

"#$%7(*.""$

  

""% &#  '

"#$%,0?1.>

 "

""

4    " 4

 

 ,+$#%   8#$ :!  %6("  0 $'*1/  %!'A "   '

"#$%(7(*.""$ 2 :B ' "#$%(,01..@ "    (  

8"  

"  

 

G%,:

 " # 

"

8"  

" "

" 

8"

   (        * (  "

"3 4 #3    " 

" "" 3

#    (         ( # #""   #""

""  (

    #

 "3  #

      

" ("

        

 

"



  

 3    

 (" 4   

" (   3< 8   I

"3 



8"   >8  1 "

4 

 %, "    ( 

  #4

;

   '.----<9    "3 %</ " 

2'----<9

""

" "

#4

,0----<9  "#  ""

3 ( 



"  "3 

( "

 "("  

 

 

3 -,,%11& ""

2.%-%11'

   4 # "#  "" 3   

 #  

3  -,-,%11& (

 "#

3 (  3 "3





  -'-&%110    (        (   



 " " #""

      8 G

  ( I

*  

9

"("

  "#

   =  #(3 .'''--<9 " =    (8  ;

2&.-&.-<9

      

 

 &%%%11.

 "

 (  5

  )"" 



  (" "

 

 

     "

   #

#""

  "" (4   

3 .!

#;

"#$%  7(*  :B  .""$  ;  "#$%(  >  01  -  $% '  @@ #(3 2,A 

 

9

)"" 

( "      

"3     # 5

  )""  (

9

 2,A

 #  " ( 

"   "

  2/ 7% :

  2/ 72:

#""

  "#

" # 

8 

,.""$ 2 :B7(*3%:!".!

#,/ 01.>@/#

3 (  "("

;

,0----<9 

"3 #    ""# "# 







 "#/ 0*.*.-1