Phoolwati And ORS, v. State Of Haryana And ORS.
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 1
! "#
$%&
"' )
* (!+! ,
(- "' (! )
!."'
#/ 0(,
.,$ (1 2'3
2(
(! 0("4+(0
%2''%'3
%2 (- $ 0(, +( 5$0 62!! !
'3
% (- ( !."'
! 7$ ( ' .( ! 5 "6 ( ('
$(+6$ 3 '
" " "6 ! "
.(
' "6! "6 "'+
' "3 ( %+( 8
$ "
(3 (!- "3%3 ' " 1
$ "' ( 3%3
(+"' ..% 5 % -,
6$
(1.
( "!.
" - " :
"' ;+ !
"2
5 %
"
! &$ & ('+"'
"$ :
"' ;+ !
" <9& ""+"
'" 1( " 3 -
(!.( ( 11 "9
(!2 .!!
!! " "' ";+ " !"
"5- ,
$ 1.
"$
"(
(!$ ( 2"%-6(+"'5 '"&$ $ .! "6 .(
' "6! $ ! 5
" % ' ! "
" " ,
.$-!
%.!!
!! " "' ";+ "
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 2 $ "
(3 (!- (..
'+. (+"' "
(.(
" ,
978 & ! .+
( 5- "!
" " $ "=5% ,+.( +( "'
5-% - "6'&".( " .% ('
( "6 "'
$
"% .!
'+"'
"978 $ .
> +( $ ! ' ! +!!
' " '
% %%
(- "'( ( "
(.(
"6!
"978 2 "' "
$ !( (' !5 "61 " %+' "6.
6( .$ ?+'61 &$ $ !( .('+ '$ "5 %&#/ @) ! "
# $#$ " %
!"
" !"
! &' ! "(
) !"
! & " % ) % %% !! *"
( " ) ! " ' "(
"
"
# $#)$! "
! & "
!
! ) & , % -. "
#$ ) %
"
) -. -., ! "/ "( "
#$ ! "
! & 0
" % "
! ! ! "
" ! "
' ! ) 0"
) %' " ) 0' "
)
'!"
)
' ) 0
,* 1 1 !"
#$ ! "
! & "
! "
" , "/" ! 2
"
#$ " ) % "
3 ! (
)!" # %$ ! !" !
"/ "
! "
!
) "
"""% !
"
! &" ) ( "
& ! 4 "/ "
!
) ! !
' "
& ! "
")( 52 !"
#" $
! "/ "("!2 % "
3 ! (!! '"
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 3 "
! & ) 6 %6
! !" ! "/ "
!
"
!
7 " ) "
"
& # $ ! "
!
' "
"/ "
#$ 2 2 ! "
" , ) ( "
)
( "
& # $4%% ! ""
"
%( !" ! ( "
' " "
"/
"( "
#$! "
! & , "
#$! "
! &
) ! "
#$ ! "
# $#)$ 8 , ! 0( "
!
"
"
#$)%(! / 9 :"%)
0( "
! "
!
' ( "
#$ ! "
! &'" ) 0 "
#$ + , ! "
#$ ( ! ! "(
") " ! "
0 "
! ! )! "
! & " !"' "(! "/ ( % ""
, ! ) " ! ) " ) *"
"
!!
"
#$! "
! & (
% " ! "
/ ( ! ""
"( ! "/ "
"( ( !!" ! "
! &' '
2) ""
"(
%
% / ( ! ! 0(
"( ! ! "
! " "/ . $ >.!
" &1 5- .
>+( "5 !+11 ( A %%& "61 ""
((1( % -" .( " .% !% ''&"5- "!
" " $#/
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 4 8 " %% $!
! &$ " .( !! $ ' 5
'5+ & ('$ !"
""+"
'+"'
" <92" '
11 92 ! " % .!
.(
' "6! & %% "
"+ 2 $& (2 & ( '
1.
"$ 5 '
(1 "
'+"'
.(3 ! "! %% $!
!&$ & ('+"'
"
<9$
""+"
'.( ( 11
2 .(3 ! "! &+%'$ "
( "6 ( ..%
.(
' "6! & %% "
"+ "
$!
!2 ! 2 <9 $ ! " 5
' 758 $ &(' @(= +!
' " 5
&
5 "
"6 !
! 5
!-.( !-. &$ $1
"!
!
4% .! "6 ".(
' "6! 5 "
"6 !1+!
+% %% '0
" "6 5-2
.!!
!! " $ ' 5
" 5+ 1.
" & ! "
'2 &+%'5 "% .!
, 1 % (%-2 1.
"$
'5+ .!!
!! "$ !"
"2 &+%' " % .! "6 #!"
& &#$ ! 3( 7 8 !
1.
" ( % ;+ ( ' ! ("
'2 "=5% ,+.( +( "'
6( %%- 5!
(3
>.( !! " .
' " 1 " .
!
978 ' ! " " %+'
'
.!
1.
" " +( $
!( ;+ ( 5 .(3 ' !
1.
'&$ $$
>.% ' "
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 5
&
( "6 &+%'1
!1 5% "'&"
&+%'5 ' ! $ (6 5% 6
1 -1 "' "
!+ $ (!" "" % A '( '
+% "1 4 "6 -1 $ % (( "6 !
"7827829 <9 "' 1.
( "6 1& 1
.(3 ! "!
"B "'< 2 "=5% .
>+( ! % (
"%- "!
;+ ""/.
-1 1.
" ! 1 -1 "
!.
9 <93 "=5% ,$ !+( ( % (
-1 1.
'C
' +"'
( !
" 782 ;+ ( "6 $( -
"" % A '(""/.
-1 !( +".
''+ ( +!
%
5- "'&"
( % ( - +( (2 "=5% ,$ !+( (5!
(3
"'&"
! % ($ 6$ ( 1.
"$ "" % 1
!" 7'8 $ %
' "6 .(3 ! !
"5 !
2 "=5% ,+.( +( ! % (
( ( .
-1 $ ! 5
" 1 5+ " '
.!
'2 5 % - .
- %"6 & $ "
!+5! !
"' " .!
' ( 1 ?( - $%' "6! ( 3 -
(! ( 1( 1.
" +"'
$ 5 "'&"
! " '
"
" ( % +"'
"9 <9
(' "6 '
.!
" % ( ' " ?+'61
( $ 6$ 1.
%%&2 1"
- !$+%' " $ 5
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 6 .!
'& :
"' ;+ !
"%%
(( "
!+(- ( " +( & $ (
1 ?( - % "' $%' "6!2
" "6 5- !'
.!
' " "- $(
1'
& $ (
1 ?( - $%' "6!2 $ 6$ ( 1.
& %%" %%&25+ "
+"'
"9 <9 &+%'5 "!
;+ 8 !( ('! 1'
4 "6.!!
!! "2 "=5% ,+.( +( ' % (
'( & "6 ";+ .( C1 1( "'+1 &+%' 1
.$-!
% .!!
!! " $ ! 5
" $ % & & $( (' 3 "6% "'$ !"
"5
$%'
"
.!!
!! "$
"+"'
"D <92 "'3 ,
"" "- ' 3 "6(% .! "6 78 $ % 1.+ "6 6 ..
( ' 3 -
(!5
&
'
& (' "' 11 2 "- "
( 1('
!+5! !
"6 ! 5 > %+'
'&$ $1
"!
> %+' "6
( 1('
(2 .( /(
6 ..
( 'E-
(! !"
.(3 ! "!!
"978 "" "34 ' 768 $ "=5% +( !+( ( % (
" "'$
(% (5
" $ %% "6 "& !+.$ %'2 &$ $ 1
"! .(
' "6 !
' " %+'
'2 +15( %% .(
"!
"" "34
' !" 3 3 !
(( ' % 1! 7$8 " .
B2 "=5% +( $ ! 1 %
.(3 ! " !
" 978 ! 1
5 "34 ! % "'&"
(!&$& ('
!
!!+ "
"+"'
"9
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 7 <9 "- !+5!
;+ .+( $ (2 $%'
( ( (& !
"" "34 .(3 ! "!!
9 !.
.+ ( $5-
(!2 - &"
( " .!!
!! " "' 1.( !
' "F$ !( DC1
!+( "65 6$ !& ! !
' " ( "+
* %% F$ "'!
2 !
+(6 " $ !
' % "' & ;+ ( ' 5- ,
(- $(+6$ (5 " !
3 '
"
"! '
' D<< 9< !!+ '+"'
"9 "'!
"D :
"' ;+ !
" <92%%& & (''
'( .+5% .+(.!
"
%-2 ( '
%.1 "' + % A
" % ! "'+!
% (
,
( B2 +(6 " !
'
$ 3 "6 ;+ ( "' ";+ "2 ,
!
.!!
!! " %%
-
%.$-!
%.!!
!! " "' ";+ " +(
" "
(!$
' 1.
&$ $ - (
'- '
.!
5 4 $+!2 !
4 "6 % .! "6
".(
' "6!" 6(+"'""/
4 "6.$-!
%.!!
!! " "' ";+ "$
(!$
(% ( % ' BBD E!
4 "6! 1 % (( &$ $& !' !.!
'5- $ !+( 3 '
('
' <BE &$ " ' (
"! & !!+ ( !."'
.(
" %
(!& $ " ( '91"
$! (1 '
(
( .(
" ,+5!
;+
2
4 "6('
('
'9B 5 !."'
!3 '
&$ $ .(
"
(!!
4 "6% .! "6 .(
' "6! & ! ( ?
' 5- 5!
(3 "6
.!!
!! " % "' " ;+ "&
"" "!$ '!;-'! "'5+"'
(- & !1
! '
+"
$( A '%- +( (2 !5!
(3 ',$
1
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 8 !"
1
"&$& ('
'&"
!.
('$
1.
$ !
'('
($ !"
' "
.( &(
"5-
(! E
( "
0( "4+( 0
%2 %
("
' ''
% '3
% (- ..
( "6 ( ,
(- !+51
"
(! 5 "6 " .!!
!! " % "' " ;+ " ! '
3 ' 1 .!!
!! " % "' &
" 5- (' "6
A"
1 $ "D'
' "'!
!$ 3 5 (- '
+( (2 $ "
"'!
1.
" ( % "' " ;+ " & ! '+%-
' 2 & ! 1
5%
"' !
'1
'%- !
"'! (
' 5- $+!5 "' .
( " "'
( .
( " 9 &$ & ('
'&"
!!+ "
"+"'
(,
"9$ - %! % '( +"'
(,
"< <9 5-!
4 "6
"$ 1.
& ('
:
"' ;+ !
%%
( +( (!+51
!".(3 ! " " <9 .!
4 1.
"$ ( !!+51
! "
""
"
"6 ! 1 ' " ,
" 9 78 +% %% !.!!
!! " "'!
"'!'+%-
5% 6
" ,
.
- 1.
"!
"'!' ! $ (6 '&
(C.
-1 1.
"G .(
"1 !' !1 !!
% D
( $ 3 "6 .
(+!
.%
' "6! 5 "
"6
"'( (' "6 ( "
"!2& "$
" %+'
1
"' !!;+ %- 3 .( " .% !% ''&"5- "=5% ,+.( +( "'
" "'( %.1 + $( - 7!+.( 8 .( - (
(! % 1 "6 % .! "6
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 9
" .(
' "6! '
(3 ! ' !1 !!
% " 3 & %%& "6
!"!#/
8$+6$
(!$ "
-
% .$-!
%.!!
!! " "' ";+ "2$& (2 !
(1 ! "
5% " 3 & "
(.(
" @
= 1 5- "=5% .
> +( " "'( %.1 + $( - 7,+.( 8 &$ "=5% +(
6( %%-$ %'
&('.!!
!! "+!
' "
<9 $ ! !
1
" "6
.$-!
% .!!
!! " +!
' " ,
" 9 78 $ ,
3 ("1 ;+ ( "''( &!1 1( "'+1
4 "6 .!!
!! " &$ $ " .( ! 5- ( (' "6
A"
1 $ "D'
'2
4 "6 .$-!
% .!!
!! " % "' "
.!!
!! " !
"2 ! 5!%+
3 "6 "' " ,
$
" "'&"
((
"! .!!
!! " "'2$ ! (2 "'!+ $.!!
!! "
"+( ! ( $ ! 5 "' " 5 % &"
( ,
, "
.!!
!! " $ ! 5
" 5- ( (' "6
A"
1 $ "D'
'2 ( .$-!
% .!!
!! " "'!
"'!'+%-
"5- ,
$ .%
- " .$-!
% .!!
!! " "' ! $+!2 $ 5- ( ?
'
%% .!!
!! " $ ! 5
12 !"%- "'" !&"
(!!
"!
;+ "
%! ( % 1 "6 .! "6 ".(
' "6!6 !
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 10 58!
1.
" ! "
("
'2 '1
'%- 1.
"$
"(
(!&$ $ % !$&!
1.
&
! 5
" " "
" " .
,
$(
! " ' ! $ (6 "6 !5% 6
!( ('!.
-1 1.
" ! !2 !
"' "
"6 " - .( ! ( 5 ' " !
978 %! 6 $+!2 ! ""
"6 ! .( ! ( 5 ' " !
" 978 ! +% %% '2 '
1 "6 "% .! "6.(3 '
'+"'
978 "" "34 '! .%
'
.!
5 4 1.
! ("
'2& 6(
"
" :' +"!
% ( ,
! " .(3 ! " "
" '
.!
4 1.
"'$
!
'.%
! %!( ?
' B 0( "4+( 0
% " !
"6 $
! .%
' " &(
"!
!3 %- "
,
;+ ( ( .+5% .+(.!
.+5% .+(.!
(+ % A
"% "'("'+!
% (
2,
(B2+(+6( 1$ "' ";+ " !3 (-1+ $
%
.+5% .+(.!
.% "" "6"'+!
%,
( -+ .% " "! '
$ !.
(6+1 !."'
"'& " 1.%
6(
!
$ ! ! 1.(
( 5 4 "1 "'&$ % '
% "6& ( ! "6+
"% .+5% .+(.!
! !
$( -&$ ! " .!
'
5+ + % A
"
;+ ( '2
3 "65
"3
' ",
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 11 < $ ! " ( % 15 .%
' "6! 1 "
&$ $ $+6$$ !" ((
"& .! "6!+6$ +"'
(,
"978 5+ ! "
(!$ $!
.%
''
%%- !
4% .! "62& .(.!
'
%& !
! (6 (1 .%
' "6! 1
(! $ ( (( ?+'61 "=5% ,+.( +( "'
'.( ( 1 "6 "
& 9&$ $'" !+..%
(! " "-1 ""
!
'?+'
%.("+"
&$ & !" "( .
(1( %- "6+." '?+'61 !2
(!$ %!(
".%
' "6!&$ $
% "' " 3+(!1 "'&"
(!(% !6(
.( 3
5+ %'
!& %% .% -( ,
((
% (1 "$
1 -
($ %!5
'
"' !.+
'%-2 "!
"$
".( ((
( 1 "6 "
%%- "34 "6 .(3 ! "!!
2&$ "2 ;+ ( !.(3 '
'5-% & !"%- &%' .$-!
%.!!
!! "$ !"
1.
"$ !"
' "- (
% "' " 3+( "- % "' &"
"- ?+'61 ' " 3+(% "'&"
%%-.( ( 1 "6 "
"
& "" 5 ( ' +." % 1 % .!
$ 3 6+ .%
' ! ( 1 "
"5 "6( ' ! (& !
5% 5 ?
'(
!"
!!+ " $ ! ( (' ! " 1(
! "
6( "' !
"'! !
' " .%
$( ?+'61
.%
'' ! ( 1 "
"2 &.
(!"!!$+%'" "%-5 ! 1 % (%-.%
'5+ '
%%-.%
'.
(1 $ !2 .%
' ! ( 1 "
"5 "6( '1+!
'
1"!
"
&$.%
'!
"+! % ! +." "
&$ .%
'! ' ! ( 1 "
(-
$ (+!
% .%
' "6!1
"' !"
"
'+5
CWP No. 13011 of 2019 (O&M) 12
.%
' ! ( 1 "
"$
'3 6+ %- !1+ $ +%' $+!2 !% 5% 5 ?
'&$ $ (& !
!$ %'5-+!2 !"
5%
(&$' '"
!
'.%
&$
%%-2 5
'2
%%
(!$ ' ' ! ( 1 "
"2
" % '!
4 "6% .! "6 "+"'
(,
! !
;+ % 53 ' ! +!! " "' " 3 & % & !+11 ( A ' " .
D "'( %.1 + $( - 7!+.( 82 %%-
( $ 3 "6 ( ('
" " $ "'2 .$-!
% .!!
!! " % "' " ;+ " $ 3 "6 5
"2 5% 6
" ( -1 1.
" !
"'! ' ! $ (6 %! "! '
( "6
"' ";+ " !3 (- 1+ $
% .+5% .+(.!
2& " $
$%'
" "!
!
$ ! +%%- ' ! $ (6 !5% 6
";+ 5 "
"6 ! +(( "6 "!
"9 78 "6!2 .(
" 1 !' !1 !!
% "!
" ! ' !1 !!
' (' "6%-2 !.
4 "6 ('
'9B !$ 5- (1 "'+.$ %' 3 "6 ' !1 !!
1 " &(
"2 %% .
"' "6
..%
"!2 "- %!1
!
$ &(
" !' !1 !!
' ,
+!;+2 "-2!
"'!3
' 7 *,F 8 , 7
::8 3 "'
( $
(!.
4 "6C(
!"
!C $
(( .(
5% !C