Subhash Kataria v. Ut Of Chandigarh

        
 



"#$# % &'
'


()*+ $+ ,

-#

'''''''' # # %- .-$)$

/%# % --# -0 + %1#2 -+3

''''''''$4 %1%

5

67 5'

(  ( 

 




 

  


 
 
 



 
! 
"
 
#


%%%%
 ( 8 '

/73

& 







'

*(&*

+
"

, 


-

'



(* *((/

+
, "


"


0
1
&2/

(.

*(((


&&

 "
'
34

# 
5 6

&/)&3 
7 
86


"



-

"

 

9 '


-
' 

-



:

!!%"

(% %"


&&

 

'"
''

.
' 




&(((;:

 "

'"
''

&
+

7 ,
*'






 
 

-
"
"

<)&

.*




 
"

*( &//=
>

*=?


' '


""'
"
-
 

'

*( (& &/)2 >-
 

"

+
+
""'
 
9 "+

"
-
""

(.

&/)@

"
*(

 

A
>"



B "
"
&/).


'
-


 
4
5








<

 

-
 

 

5
&< (= &/@&




=36

 
-
 


-
 

&2 &/@*
1
$ "

 
"
  

 
 

 
"

""""+

 
' 
"

+
 

 
'

-
'

-
 




 


 
' .



0
-
"

 
'"
'


#

+
 



A
9 
5: ': 
"
 
 
C'

'+

<
-




""
'

-


 
: 



'



.&.

 
- 

"
"
'"

"'

-



"
+




 5

""
'"
""


 

-

+
 
"
"
 


'

(* *((/ 
+
 
'
 



"

 
"-
""
 
-
-
"+
""-


'

() *(&*


'


-

"
 



-
'


'"
''

.
' 

''




&&

 
 


 

-
 
+
 
 
 

+

 





&/ *(&* (

A
 "

 


 



"

'



'



(* *((/

'




+

'

 


9 '



 

 
"+

+
 



"+




&<
+

 +
1
 




'


 

 

'"




"

+
 
'"


 




 


+
 
 



&/ *(&* 

"

 "

 
+

 

 
"
"
 



-"":

'






""


- 


"
+
 
"
"-
""
  


 


"+

 
+
 
"
"-
""
 


  



+
"+ (.(  7(( )



"
 "

 


 
 
:


-
 
"
 @


  #% %1 :'

 /
3 ;

( ;


, 


 
>8"
 '
 


 
-





'
'"+

'"

D 

''

'

'C'

'
'


+
 
 
-


 




+
"'



 
 
B  





-
"



" 
+

 

'

-
 

''


 
 
  "


- "
'
 
9 '



 






"+

- '""+


""
"



 "

-


'
 
"

"+

 



 
C"+




'


"  

-
, 
B

 
>8"
 '
 

 :

$#<

:'

 
;

( 



 
 
'


"


"







+
' 
  
"
 
'
 

"+

 
'
 
"

 
+

" 
"-

 


-""
"
 
 

'
'





 




C
+
" 
""

 '



+

 
 

 
'
 '

-
 
'
-
''

 
 

 
 

 

"
-
 
+

"-

 
 

'


  / 

 
 +

 
+
 
"

 "
"

 +


 


 "

:
(-  '

#")9 -$ -# 1 )-

# % &  +

"
:
:
*  +


*(&*

*( *(&*
&<
+
.

'
"
:
:
<  "
 +



*(&*

*( *(&*
&<
+
 "


*(&*

*( *(&*
&<
+

4
'
:
:
) $"

"


'
*(&*

*( *(&*
&<
+
&( 
 "



'



+
 
"
"
 

 
"
"-
""
 


+

 


 
'







""


A
 "

 



"


'



'
 



+
"+
9 
9 '

 7(
&&


0

 


-
"

(.

*(((




 


-


"-:
E



"

 "
"
>


"

+
 
'"
+




 



 
 
+

 





 +

 


 
'"



'

5 

 
"


.
' 


 "


&<
+
"+
 
 


 

 

- "


 





 


'"
''

.
' 
-

 


 

 

"+

+

'

9 "+
 






 
""-
':
36

'

() *(&*

+
 
"

, 

'
 






"
-
 




'

 
C
 
 


'"

''

.
' 
"
-
 "
' '
-

 


 

 



"+

+
'

36 





' 

 &(((;:
'


 

+
 
"
 



&((((;:







 
' 



 
"
 
- 

'
'
 





+

 





 "

+'


 
 ""

""


 

 +

'


 
''


'

&.


'"" 
"36

+
 ""
"


 (HARPREET SINGH BRAR) February 08, 2024 JUDGE
 (i)  
 ;
F;1
36  
"
F;1