← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25508/2022allowed

Naveen Choudhary v. Serious Fraud Investigation Office

2023-03-29Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

 

      

!"#$%&%&

!"!'"( !"#)%&%&  

  



  

  #  *+,% - ,- ,, + ****  

 !

  "#  

    # $

$#%  -."

/!' 0123 % &   '    

 ($   $ (     )*)+,-.   -/,*+,-.# $  (  

  */ #*/ #+--012#++1#3+/#+44   #-.*3# 15042#13 #55/#-51#551#55/#-54#-55#-5-04202     # +,-4     -+,67  8    5,3# 5-1# 5-/#5+,#531#53/#51-#511 #515 #  (

  $9

# :

 " &  

       ' 

 $  8 

 ""(    "$    

     (   "  ;

    

   < = 0 

# > 

 ?2      $$ "

  $$   "

 $   

    "(  "

 -,,8   ' 



  $8  @ 

  

   $    8  8          "

  $$   "   

 8 



- 2 - <

$

     8   

  " &"    ! <  

  " ,*,++,,/   4--,+,-+   8  

 $ 

 

 

!< 

 

",1--+,-- +.,/+,-4       $ 

"# $ ")($  

  

      &       " (     (

 551    #+,-4"

 &  

     551    #+,-48  " (8-+,.+,-4 &  

  $

$ 

      14      # +,-4     */6      # -.*3    ')

    "$      6   ' 

8  "

$+0(2   0   @

2

$#-.1*#

   # 8

>

? 

8

 $$  

  

8    $8 "   $  " $$ 

      #  #$  $

$# %  



6 ("   # (   

 $ " '   7 $ < # 0%2#

$   " <(8  

$   "  

$  $   

  8     -1,,

8 $$$$  " <  8  $$ 1,  :

- 3 -       ($    

#         $  

 (       (     "   

6  

  (

   (  "

)  )@ 

    (  #  "  

  $$$$

(    

 $   "   

   (   ($   :

A



:

#  (



 $)$ 

" (" ) ( @ 

    8    <

$ 

 

     8  #

 (  +-+032    #+,-4          $ $    



  

  #8    B

$8      $$   

$($     ($

  5*    <  # +,,+8    ('    $

8 +-+032

   #+,-4   

  ( $

$ 

      

     6C6 

$"

 

$  8   $( $ B  

)8

 ( 

   

#8  $8$

8         !!

" #   $  % 

&&#   $   $ 

($

- 4 - D

 $

$ 

     

   

 $

      ' 

 ($      "$

 #    

$        $   $( #    (

$+-      D 8 #    8$$ (

$ ( 



($  ($8& 

"$





$ $(         (

 8

8

 " 

"    8  8$$  

E  )   

 8

8

 "

D 8 # 

        

$    ( ' "  

# 

 ( 

 $

8  54/ 7  

8   (B   $( 

#'  8   "  "  8           66 $$ $$  "

#    

 #   8

 (

$ "

 & 

 "8     ($

$

       '

8    "

$ +0(2    0    @

2

$# -.1* &  8

 >

?   

        $   "  $$   # " (   B "

$ 

  $$  F

( 

#$

$

 

#



 #

"     $  $

- 5 -        

    (    "               

 

 

    #   $ ( 

          ( "

#" # 

  

($ G               (

  $ (   (  "

)  )@ 

    "  +,,*$$+,-1D 8 ##  

      $  "  "

 (

  (       8  !

  (      ( 

$  

 $  6 "  $ $ (   #8     8

($($

 # (!" $  

#  8 

   

    8  & 

     $ "   "



   (   

 

  6($($  & 

'

  

  

(

  $

 

 

8 $8D# 

8 #  

      $     

 

(   ( #     $  $$         $$    F



# 

 (

 $  (' 

   # $"$

 $(  $

# 8

(            

   "  

 8  $8 7  

- 6 -

 (  ($ "' "     (

  !

  $#  $ $8     (  $ ((

" #8 $B"  $

( 





 0

2 

$'     # +,-4#     "

6$  <  # 8      $ $$ #   $ "  ;

$"=# ;$     "

        $

=   ;

       F  

 =      F  "   $      

 ' 



'   

$$           "#8

"    (  

"  

   &    #    $    $ 

  ($  " <   8   8 (

 

 

 (  



  $ 

  "   &    

" 8$$  (  "   "

     "#8 $   

$ 

($# 

8$$  $8  "#(  

$$ "   & 

$  $     $$     " # 

$ ($

(        (     $ "   (   $$

 

   ($ !





  & ( # 

   $ 

- 7 - 8$$ ( (

   

 $

$ ($

  " ( 

 $      $ (   (  )

!!    * %

"    +      * , " %-' .! 

/  +

0 1!

!

"2 "

1

!  (

 

 "  

  +*,/+,++#   

" 

     



8 !

"

  0

2# 

 +*,/+,++ $$ 8 6  

        

                 

      

          

 

         

!  !

 "

 !     

         # #  8  

$   +-+032  #+,-4$  (



#8  

$ " 

 +3-,+,+-  ( 

            3   !4!  ""1 ' 5     * 677- "% "  

 +3-,+,+-  (  

#    8  "

  (!

8  

          

 ($#       " 

       

      $$   $

"  $  " $8   "   (  $       

 ($#  $ $ 

- 8 - "  8

$ "

     

" $# 

$  $  

     ( "   "        $# 

 (!



 

 (   $



(   " #  #  $# 

"$"

$ 8

(     

   F   

 #(   8

 (   ( 

F     8

# #8  

($8

  ($( 8    6  $    8

( 

  ( 

  (

 

   

 8    & 

 !

!!

"!!   5   * &,, "%  -3,/+,+-8 $ (    $  $ E($A 6($($  '   

 " $ $   6  $$8     





  # $   6 $%   %         &         



    

  

%    %    

       %    !%                  '         ( 

- 9 -                    )

   

 

 *                 %          

      

       %        #  !

 . $ !   

!   #   "   !4! 188 1! * %-, "% 8 1 5 

!! *  (5 *  &% % " %#   

" 

(          

 #  #    $88  * -&797  +,,4+,+48    F  8 

$8 

($ 8    

 8   (  

       ( $   ( $ 8 # $$ F $$ 

$  

($  $     ($   F $$ "

          6  9"



   

 "$

$ 35, +,++   



 -/,5+,++ ($    (    ;          + ,-.    /  ' 0+           %   %     

                  %    %     

  &          

    =

- 10 - 6 #"$#    8$$  $$  

  -/-++,++   8     

!    

($ #(

 

<0 $2 -+155 +,++8   8 $$ 8  

  -4,-+,+4    

6  "  &  $   6 $ ($#   ( 

( 

#  $$ 8 6 02 

($ 7  

( 



 -*-,+,-. 02

 $  ($   ' D  (   

" 

 

 -1-++,+, 02  $ ($  '

( 



 ,1,++,++  8  (                $H  "

 (  "   H 

 $     $$ 

  8    H  "  '(

 

       8$ !

  # H $ ' 8 

 #    

 #   $'$ $ " 

 !

        

              

($# 8

$ 8 H    " $#   $ $  "

 (

     #   

        8    

  (    

($#  

- 11 - 

$#     $$ 8  &    $$ (

$  ($#    # (    $ 

  

  ($ ( )

  &   $$

(

  $

(

 B    8  ##8$$$ 

  $$

 

 8 $ $8"

  



$ +.,4+,+4 1  -."

/!' 012

' 0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No