High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11045/2023disposed of

Komal v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-08-05Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

!"#$%&#'$'()*+,- ./0123.14565278$&9$:9'$'% ;2</= 9999"10505271> ?1>6@6 A0/0123B/>C/7//7D/720E1> 999F16G27D1706 H I JKL MMMMM ">161708# ,>9A/NN/7A57OEPQDR24/0132>0E1G10505271> ,>9S/G/7;@</>P.QTB/>C/7/ MMMMM

UK 9 SE1 G10505271>P /6G5>57O 02 V1 /GG25701D 02 0E1 G260 23 W@752> X7O5711> /GG=51D 57 0E1 4/01O2>C 23 X4272<54 !1/Y1> A140527 )X!A-P 57 G@>6@/741 23 /DR1>0561<170 Z29$ 23 '$[P D/01D &9$\9'$[P ]E1>1VC '&[ G260623W@752>X7O5711>@7D1>R/>52@64/01O2>51657D5331>170.1G/>0<17069 '9 Q6 G1> 0E1 357/= >16@=0 D/01D $\9$\9'$'$P 6E1 E/D 614@>1D ^% </>Y6 )\[ 57 ]>50017 0160 /7D & 27 0E1 V/656 23 62452 14272<54 4>501>5/-P ]E5=1 0E14@023332>X!A4/01O2>C]/6\$/7D0E/023T171>/=\(9 (9 Z20/V=CP 0E1 G10505271> E/D 35=1D !"#:$$#'$'$P ]E54E 4/<1 02 V1 /==2]1D 27 $(9$:9'$''P 57 01><6 23

_ `a bcK defdgd Lhdii Ljkjlhm`g `__mccm`gdgn`hojec P2V61>R57O0E@68 pSE1 4270>2R1>6CP 57 3/40P 56 /=>1/DC >16 N@D541 R5D1 N@DO<170 D/01D ':9$%9'$'' >17D1>1D 57 !" Z29'\\^#'$'' 050=1D p*< F2N ?69 B/>C/7/ A0/33 A1=140527 2<<566527 /7D 20E1>69q r 711D 720P 0E1>132>1P =/V2@> 02 O5R1 /7 57D1G17D170 2G57527P /6 r /< 57 /O>11<170 ]50E ]E/0E/6/=>1/DCV1172G571D57*<F2NP6@G>/9 %9 *7 / 2@>0 s@1>CP =1/>71D A0/01 42@761= D216 720 D56G@01 !"#'\\^#'$''PD145D1D27':9$%9'$''

! #$% ! % &' ' & (( ) * ' & + &+ , (

+ $ + #$ (% & & ! ' ' + ( ) -) " ' . / / 0 & ' 0(( %

( ' & #12 ' 34)35)3% ( ' & ( ' +% !( , (

, 67 869%

5 + (+ % !( %

+0() 5) 2 % $ + #$ ( & ( & % 2 ! & (( &' + ' ): ;) " <( ( ' ( ' ! % ! ( ' .".=<;-<3% + ( ' !(% ( ! $( & .

% & + 3)>>)3% + + ! ' ( % !0% ?@A ('( ( & % 0+ & ' & ' 3B)>3)3>B% ! ' ( '' )) 3;)3C)3>B% ( ( ' ' ( ( (+ D % !( '.".=' +&! '

& () -) 6++0 '% % ' &' . (

++ ,+ ) 5) 6 ' 67 =< E(

)F% ?@A ('( 3)3;)3>B% ' ' '

3>B<3%

+ + ( ' '

& & ! #)5

( ! E2F EGF) 1 / ( ' &0 ! ( ('(% ! ( ' '

( ! ( & #)%-3%333H< 0' & =! & 1 ) 1 ! '

! &

! !" #"# $%&'$&($'%)

# # * !

+ #!) ,! ,"

# -".#) "-* #"

!.*#"&&$/&$0&($'%& 0& 1 2

3 456 78 "9) "# .# " " !"##") , "# "88.# #

!"* + "# ! !"

"# !"* + ,"

# -".#) ," .. .#

!# " !." "*" " -"!"!+ : ". !"* + "# )

.-" 8"

" , "#; </& ="

# >8+ ?#-!" : ". !# 8 ! "& * " 8 "# ! "88.# #

-# !"* + "# !") ) !# #

* ". !"* +& @

! !" ,"

# -".#)

# * .*.

"# !"* +& @ !.# ) ) !# #

-#!"* + * ".!"* +& A& @"-* "

-". !)

" "88"..* !#!

8# #+* ," -"*# # ?

!. 'B 2 C#") ,!

#!"

8 #!# .,; <'B&

D".+ 88 + " 8.! 8.+;E 7'9& 1 ".. D".+ 88 +

".. !F "

."* 8.+ "88"+

!# "& 7(9& G !F "..) * # .+

.*)

"!) !") H) #!) 8."! )

#! "+ ) .*.

) #!

"# "*"

8! ) "+ 8.+

! # "& 79& G* !. ".. - I"

"J* "+ .", !

# " !." !." 8.+ "88 "

! # :- ) "+ .!". " + ,) " " K

+) "+

D "

#! , " " K

+ ! 8.+ "88& 7/9& G* !. ".. - "

"J* "+ -

-" "88 8

"- "+ "!J,"

# !." !F ,!) 8 ")

!" #$ %&'$ ( ) "

**" * + + "

! ",- * **" "" + **

) , ,,- * )! ) - *

)

) -))

" ,$. /$ 0

- "

!1 + "

- + - " * * 1 *

* , ) ")

- * * , ,

! ")

- "

) $ 2$

* , 1 " ,

* ) ") * "1 +

! ") " )-1 - - ) ,

" " ) ") 1 !

) *

, ) ") $ 0

" 1 ""

)

56# ")

" *

" , ,

" " ) ") $ 7 1 ! * )! -* * 56#

!1 + )- - " 9 :) ) , , $$ 2; , )

" " ) ") 1 + " 2<, $ =$ 0

-) "!

- # " *

1 "

* )- *

) - ,1

- " ! %9 ' :) $ >

, ) ) ! "*?

"@/* : $. %5,

' =$ A * 56# " *" !) - * * *

", * *, : 1 " "

+ , ,

,$ #

" + + )

1 * *) ", 56# ") 1 ) :,,

) ! ) * ,

$ B ,1

" <C$<=$D<DD1

! E FGHE 1 ,

" #$% &$ &

"& $"' " " & $ $( ' ) $ "'% $"

" !* & + ($" '' ,-.,-,./0% "(' ) &

&" 1$ % # 2 3 #"" & 451 $'"' $ ) '"'

"& $2 " ( #' #$$ - 6& )# $( ' !"& & 7('2 " & $

8 9:; <( =% !&"$& ! (& ' ) & >"#"" ?$& " @ABC/DC,.,D% "

' ) & 3 1 1 $"

22""% #"' 7('2 '' D/-./-,.,E ' " )($& ""% !"&

' @ABC/,.DC,.,,%!&"$& '&(F G- 6& ! " " & & "" '% &(& &#" $ 7$' &2 # 451 $ % !( ' ) (' 2 & $" (' & $ % &#" )"' 2 2 * & &

$' $'"' " & "' $ - + !* !&"$&% !& $"' '% &

' 1" H(' &

"& & ' &2 ) " ' " 2 #"" "$ / &

"("%

$"# & $ & & ) ' & 451 $ - + &"

'% " !( ' ) ! &!&"

H"'

I(2 1"& #- 1 J-A-% <,./.= D

//0% $ !& " 3K) & 1( 2

( & ' &% G+ ) "

#' $ " " $' & )" 2 " " $2"" !"& $ $'"'% & & !"

) '7(' ! '

#' $ % & "% & &

) '2' &# ) '7(' " & ( #' #$$"- + &

) "22 " & & & #"

' $"

L" < "*

L" "

"2"= #"

)

#' $ -M - N $(2( "# $"' "% & $'"' ) " $ " # "$

#" )" " ' ) $' " $ % & " (' )

" & "2(' 7('2- 6& )" 2 "% & ) '"2"'-M 0- 6& "" % &(&% !( ' ) " ' & 2 * $" $2"$ $ " "% " #"! & 7('2 " OPQRSTS UVSQ WXY OTUTZ :[

!" #$ %&'( )*

!&#&#)$ $"

!+ ,(!-!#$ &(! .-$& )* %)$/ 0-1 , (!+" &) %! 2#)+&#2! )* 3-&#'+! 46 $" 4 )* &(! 7)$ &#&/&#)$ )* 8$"# $" &(! 9:; .#$ & ,(#'( *#+!" %< &(! 9&&! ,!-! + ) "# 0# !")$=5>?>=?=5 > 4?> 8$ 2#!, )* &(! *)-! "# '/ #)$ $" *++ &(!-!)* &(# 7)/-& *#$" #& &) %! #$ &(! #$&!-! & )* @/ &#'! &) "#-!'& &(! -!

)$"!$& &) ')$ #"!- &(!

!&#&#)$!- !#&(!- #$ &(! AB9 '&!.)-< )- C!$!-+ $" /%@!'& &) (!- 0!-#&

) #&#)$

)#$& (!- *)- ,(#'( #* -!D/#-!"

/ !-$/0!--<

) & %! '-!&!"> 9(! ,)/+" %! !$&#&+!" &) $)&#)$+ %!$!*#& *-)0 &(! "&!

'$"#"&! +),!- &($ (!- #$ 0!-#& '0! &) %!

)#$&!"> E!!"*/+ %! ")$! ,#&(#$

!-#)" )* &,) 0)$&( *-)0,(!$'!-&#*#!"') <)*&(# @/".0!$&# -!'!#2!"%<&(!0> 44> F# ) !")* '')-"#$.+<>

GGHGIJGKL MIJNO PQP R>S0-T ()1 B(!&(!- !1#$.T-! )$!" U V! TE) B(!&(!--!

)-&%+! U V! TE) = 7B;W46XW=?=5 "!'#"!")$X4>?6>=?=5