High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/48718/2018dismissed

Dalbir Bhardwaj v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2019-08-21Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh14 pages

!"#$ %& '( )&($ "! *"

!"#$ %#& ' %% & +), -."/-!* .0$+(+!(-.,-&($ 11111 %#& ' %%("! 2!*!**!"!(345(!4678 - ""

- 4" & ) 6( !4- +*(! -(") -

-9:-9-9- -

2! 67 # 4" ! 7"$ )4! &0$ )4!-#!!

4"!!44"!)"!()4! #" "'

4")(3!*("'

4&# #!!"""

/4 !"!#"#;+(-/")4!"!"(4!

(

,+(-<( !")("+(/")4!#4"! !0* "!"=*"!> /4 !"!# +( #"$+("&0$)4!-)($)4!".0$7

4"! !(4!,+(!"=*"

?"<( !!" =*" ( > 3 ()("+(-!, +("<( !/#!+( #"$+( "! "" "" :

: *4 " 0(4 : 3 (" /

4 " )(3!*( " 3 0 (" '

4 &# "4!0=("!(4!,(0$+(#@;4"/)4! ",+(#@2)4!#!0*",+("<( !- "(4! )"!( )4! !(4! ! " , +( " <( ! "(4! )"!( )4! !" "> =*" 7 !(

4" ! +( #"$ +(- )(" +(- ,(0$ +(- , +( #@ 2 )4!- ,(0 )4!- <0 " ./ )4! " )! +(0 " A!"

/""*"4!!*(*44 ! """":

:=(" >#>0* ( #4( 0* #! ! &0$ )4! !" =*"

9 " ( #4( 4 !0 / 7 (!

4"!!0* !" >03#!+( #"$ +(#(!#4 !**>5(! !"4" ""

(

? 4!*(! ! !*34 5(!4!67-#

! *( 0"!*"4

0> ""0!67#!!0> "

# )"!()4! ;+(A@ )"!()4! /"

"" )("

"(4! ,+(

"(4! "" ?

<( ! "(4! " > 67 +( #"+( A@/"

**= )($

) $+( A@&0$ &0$

.0$)4!

7"$

)*+ 2! "( *!( 0"!!675( (* #-#!!*#!#)( 4 (4! / /" 0>4("<"( -#! 34 5(!4 ! 67 5( ! "

> 0" !

#4 ( 0 !!*0"!67 ! ! * !" 4" ! "" 4 )( 4 ! *> " ! # 5(" /> (!4(! ""4"4! !**>5(

(

! ! 0 > " 0*0" 04 ! * / !!* "*(")9 !7"4.-#!!"

# B)9!4.-

!4 "" (" ! *>C8 44 !

>(- 0"0" > >!4 4" ! " (" ! *>D / ! ! * ! 0 ) & *(">" > !0"!4! "(>"!4 "" # * ! "(> ! *- ! *(" ! > 0 ! 0*(!> : <"( !*"!00!!" !* " (*$("40!(

! "# $

%&"'(

)* +,

- )

(! 2! " ( (*$("40EF

!)(*0(*"

(! #"

/ /!(

%+ 9

**4!*- ")( !( 0"! !(4!! *0"!67 ("(4/4!("

(

! ! * # /4 #! ! " !"

> / 3" ! 0 * " ! B/"D#!#0*4""* 7!/""/ ( 0""" !(. !!*!!*0"!67- *( !67#( """!#!!

4!/0 >

"4!#0*0 >,(0 +(",+( #@2)4!#!!"0*"* ,+("<( ! "(4!)"!()4!#!,+(!" ">=*" !> ?"<( !!"=*"!>

**=0 > 0(!*=(! "":

:.*0!" 0*-!!("! >+( #"$+( #! /( ! "" # =(" " ! 4 # ,(0 )4!- <0 " ./ )4! " " A )! +(0 E#/-*( !* > " >!)!!*"/ )! +0/ )4!- *(> )(*" & - '4 (( G- +*(! !# ! "(4 /4- ! / /0 *! ("7!* >!*

> " !

#4 B2!"0* #

"8 :"# 5(" > )&- )( /- )( *( <"!- #! ( 0"!5(>*!(",+( #2)4!"(",(0$+(#;4"/ )4! 0*" !0 / ( # ,

(

+( "(4! )"!( )4! " <( ! "(4! )"!()4!"/#!!*"! ("!"=("!"! ""/( +( #"$+(-#!(! "!**>5( (" $+(")($+(7#(!! " !5(>!!0=(!" ""- (" , +( # 2 )4! " ,(0$ +( # ;4"/ )4! !" !" ! * ! # ."! " * ! "> 7 # ( 0"!5(>*!*

!"#$ /" #! ! ! (" "

> "" !3 ! "(0 *4 ! "> ! =(!" "" !=( ! ("( "" 0" / /( +( #"$+( 2!!*67/ /"*(

/ !*"! !/("*0-! 0#3(* >!'4 ((-&($ "! 0#5(" >7*)(")4!'4 (( G- +*(! - #! ( 0" ! 5(> * "" :

- ! ! * *

!"#$- 4 ! 44 .(!> ! / *" 4#! 4 3@;( . ' # "(> (" !3 ! * ! ">"**""#!! ""!0! =( ( !!0"""D 2! " * > !#! / /0 ! * 1( *2

(""(4!(/4#!! ("! ! "" "( / 4"4 " ! /"

(

!(4!-0> "!!)( 4 #!0! "" =("@4" 0> =*" /> ( ! @4(! !/"#!**4 !0- (03""(>(*!0(!0 4"4! ">!/".

!(4!#( " !" >!0 -!#( ""*"(*! "#!0

> <0 "! > (!)( 4#( " =*" 3 ! "(0 " *"(" > ! /" ) ? ? ! 4 .-

- #!! "(> (* 4@)( 4>!0 4"4">=(- "

# B)? ?!4.-

? H5(> 4 >44

===========

=========== ?2!44!

!(*C

H5(#!!(!"(0# =(" >!* >#!0*(* !/ =("I

> !0 ! "> ! * **4 !0 "

44 !!>!/=("!"(0I"

! > * **4 */- 4 4- > !0 ! 4! (! * **D

(

7 ! * "(4 5(> ! (" ! 0* ,(0 +(",+(!"!"!#."!" #!!>**" )( 47!#"-! !!0*!"*"("4""(04"!"> "/ ! )( 4 " #! 1( *2 "(4 5(> !

(" ! ! 0* # >4 ! # "(0 "> ! > 0 (=* " #!> ! 0*( " "" >!)( 4

H/!$("40 "(* >! "( !* 3 2

1- ! ! " ! ! 4@)( 4>!0 4"">!***4

!02! /=0!"$("40"

# A! "(0 *" 4- ! 4@)( 4!!*# 3"> !0 ! ! 5( ! */ " ) - ?- " ?: !/ (

" . **!*("( )? !.-! #0"!44 5( #!!(!"(0#=(" >!*

> #!0 *(* !/ =(" " > !0 !">!***4 !0 "

44!!>!/=("!"(0"! > * */- 4 4- >!0 !4!(!***7 >>!5(0!"*/ "- ! )( 4 ! ! *# ( !

(

4"(0!4("!!#!* !**>"*(2!-("!.-! !)( 4!>*#(!4 ! "" ! 4(" "*(" #!* ! **> ! 4!" > (!> 0" ! ! )( 4 "4 !0 */" (

**(> ! ! * " /" ( ! #!*!"*(" "2!-!"""

9-.=(& """

9.=(& -

"D . ! ! $("40 " (* > ! " ( ! *'(

3 2

1$"-!! ""0(!!"!#!4 "(44!0* >!)( 4#!!* "*!!!0*#>4!#7" #!!#( "!/ >

!"!!>! #-! )( 4!4! ""#!("(4/ !"2!"$("40!(#( ""/! !*!*

. ! ! * ! ! 0 !" 0*0"04!*"!!*5(!4! 67!" " >("+( #"$+("!

-#!/""""

.=(&?-! *#""** !7

544! 0""-! *"( > ")( !

(

!"*""0"!/4 #!"#

2!""" 9?

# B.!/>(- "( !*( 0 !!0> *0"#!"#!*#! > !345(!40 7 /# ! " ( 0- ! * "0"#!"##! >"D ? .*( !""!#!!* "5(!4 67 > ! (" ! 4(" 0*0 # *

> #!"#

! (" !*34 5(!4 0 7 ! #" ** > ! # / " 0*004!* . ! * (" ) 9 7" 4 . "-!"*#( " > /

!("

*/!!" "07!* !#/-!1( *2 (44!=( "" > 0 0* #! ! )( 4 #! 44! """"/"! "#!!! # =*" "( > !0 7 > (! * !/4" ) *- 0"*!!!*! >0#!!!*0>

! >#> "4 /""(4!( "0 3" ! 4 2! 5( #!! / 34 " #

(

#"( 0"""! /" " ! (0 " "4 ! 4" ("=$("(") &EF

! )(*0 ( $("40 " /" ?

!4( 4

5! - )

)* 6- +- -

) $ (!

) )*

$ #! 4!*

# "

)* 0 &, 7!$ 11

"".-

! "

# B 2! * > ! $(" ! ( (" ) &0> ="4/ "("!"I*/ (!* !(I"!#(!"$( 2! ! $("- !(4! #" " =*/- ! ="*4 >-(

>"#!( " > #! (! = $(" > ! *

> " "# ! - ! - 03 " 0> > 4/ > "("!"-*/! (!* >(!#(!"$( 6(") -!" (

"2!$(#!!0 4!!( "

4/-"/ !I!( " * *

" " "( ( " ! !( " = ! */ # > #!! ! *> 44/"( "!/(4! 7 =4 $(" (" ) *0

!(# ( 2! ( > *0 " (

(

=(4("*"44! ("6! 0"*(*-!(/ ( 0 " "(0 "- ( ** ! /" (" #!! ! 0 *"(" ( /4 !(" / 2! E4! ( !( " - = $(" (") -0 3(*5(>#!! !/"

-#!!

** ! /" !

4 (

-!!(! ;("4 / 2! E4! ( 0> !/

4 / (") !"#!0 ! 00" > ! 4 (4 *"*!!!

4"""

( / 2!*#(") &!( " =" 40 *( . ! 0 0-! 4"!

4" 4! - ! 0 *"4 0> 5(!"(") & / A! !

4 ( ! 0* ! !4!"(>-* !E4!(-=4!$("(" ) !"-5(!!"*" >! 4344J! / 2! ! *# (" ) "" */ ! ( ! * ! ( " ( ! " $( )(! *# =" " 0!4 #!! =* > " ("!"D

(

: .!4"4) &"-! " ( " "!4344J" ! 4 ! 67 2! $("40 " (* > ! " ( !*

(! #"

/ /!(

%+ / ! * 0(! ! " $("40! "!! 0) &-!67 "4" "4" 5(!"! !"$("40!*4"4"!4 #!! #( "

> 0 ! =* " !

#4 #" , : 2! 5( 4 ! " (" ) !" > "" !0* "4""!

4 "!2!5(0>>4 ! *"4 2! 5( #!! >0>!/ "0"04 46(!-#!("!. "!) -" 4#!5( *$("! "D 9 2!("!!"1( *2 (44!/ /0! * ! ! / 3" ! * " ! 3B/"D !(4!(")? ?

7"4.- ! # "(> (" > !0 ( ! "> ! * **4 !0-=(4@4"(0

(

.(*!"(0" /-!("">4(" 5(!4!*672!0!** "!0"0"

-.(-/.0 1%#& ' %%2 0! "#'% A!!*34@" K@8 A!!*

K@8