Birbal v. State Of Haryana

   

   
   



  !

"#
$%%

  & ' (




STATE OF HARYANA '%

!) "*

(+#  ",-.

(%/! %0%1.  ( !

"# (%+  /*2(34*5 

(2 ) (% (%5

"6/+(02

("4 4(3"% 777  





%

 !- "89 "/)

(2 ( "82( /82: *

" "8 */ 

5 *;)"* + %
% (3 ( "2 ) "/"* (0 "$< % !

(8("

)( (( !- . ) ( "!

  %<* *
%=%

4 8 ! */"* (0 "!
>-?@
=@A@

04; 0 3 2-*4 !(  2-*% <%

"
<%=%

42

..

B "8 (* (B!)!!

*# ! - "8 9 /)

( ( "8 2( /82 : *

" "8*/ 

5 *;)"* + % (3 ( " 2 " /"* ( 0 " $< % !

( 8("

 )( (( ! - .  ( " !

  %<4 * * 
%=%

 ( 8 ! * /"* ( 0 "
 >-?@
=@A@4 0 4 ;    0 3  2-*4 !(  2-*% & . "*! 2 2 ( 2! -

+).  * " 2  "!" !

4 !

.3 " 2  -! !

* !.

!/(  ! " +*  -3 /!

* 02 . 6/+( "*  " D  93 + B2 + " 2 ( (( ! 
%=%

4<=%A8(+!

2 "B!(

*"*

E
F 2 3+* * !.

!/( !

25 "8)/(2!

*2 !+ + 2 ( "* 2 )( + 2 

** !.

!/( ! "42  !"

+ ( . ""

 2 ( B 2 2 ++ !!

4 - ! * ! 2  *

! "

 25  "3 2 ( !

8 ! *8 "!2 +/"* (2 04"* !( *3 "*B .. "8 G " "5 ! 8 ""* /..3  ) (  " 2 !+ % & .( !/) "2 *  !

 ",-.

0/)(

/( " H(  2("6/(+  5 (!/! 0

 2(,4 ;A$  >0 ? $ 

"* 2 * !.

!/( @

!!

" -3  /!

* ""

 -  /!

8 "! 2 ( " 2  -!

 - "8 "3

2 ( + ( .  ""

 2 ( B 2 2

++ !!

%

+ "% (% 0"*

) 0 "82 ""4 .

* **.%  4 (3"4  )! "

 "* " "!(/ "! + 0 + !2B( &.4 (+! 2 2 ( 2! -

" +).  * " 2  "!"!

!

.3 "2 -! !

* !.

!/( ! +* -32 /!

*% 2 (( I/ !!

( + 

( ).3% *G /("

* 
$%%

% " 2  + " + 4 2 ( ! * ( *   G "5 ! 8 ""* /..3

) (  "2 !+ % (4 " 2

 (( !4 2 ( -  ( " * ( + )( (( ! - .4 !/-G    2 ! /(" !2 "8 - .@!/( 3 - "*!   ! !



 (( ! "8 @ "5 ! 8 "8

(% 2 ( !2.. - *  -3 2 

"*  "! "5 !8 * /"* ( 0 " $<>
? %4

 . "8 B2 24 2  " ( + )( " 8(" *  ) (4!2..!"*5 *%J

E<F $%  *34 .

.

( 2 ( "*! B2 .

*0 . " "!(/ "! +
  (+! 2)/(!/" (* (

2 !

/(* *
<%=%

42 ) ( * "5 ! 8 "4 /..3

) ( *B 22 ) 4B!( "* ( +)( (( !- ."*22 !/! * . " (( 8 " !"

( I/ ( *% % " 5 B

 !

 .

* 0 .4 (* ( * *
<%=%

4)!!

*-32 !

/(4 !+* -!

./ %2 ) ( !2.. - *  B 2 2 "*  "! "/+ ( * " 0 " $<>
? %  (4"

2 "8! *2 "- !2..- ( *!" K)( !!

) "

"2 + ( !

!

% A%  "!"*! "2 

* (+!%