High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4063/2012allowed

Pawan Chawla v. State Of Haryana

2017-10-11Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan9 pages

!"#"$%&%'()

* '+ *, "-%&%'%&!

."/&0& 1! !" /2 '

'# '!+"/ "&3'#"'!& ( 45

16 5 1

/"&"'!(7

/8 ' , '# /'%,+ /#* 9:#-$ !"&:

//"-%&%'%&!

/ 6 ;; #: /2 '

/+""/ 9+ *, :#-$ !":/$83, %' '! <+"!+"/!+" "3/!"/&,$ ,'"*&3 3"/8 2=" ,,*"#! &""!+"90#>8"'!?

="/""//"#!!+" "3/!"//'! <+"!+"/!+"90#>8"'!&+0,#="/"3/!"#%'!+"#%>"&!? 77 77 5 1 +%&%&/"-%&%' > %'&!!+"90#>8"'!# !"#@A:3 &&"#=2 !+"," /'"###%!%' ,1"&&%'&0#>": /%# = #: %/8%'>!+"90#>8"'! $'-%$!%'# !"#)B '#/#"/&"'!"'$"# !"#A:3 &&"#=2 !+" ," /'"# ##%!%' , +%" 0#%$% , >%&!/ !": /%# = #: *+"/"=2 3/"&"'!/"-%&%'%&! * '+ *, * & $'-%$!"#0'#"/1"$!%' :

'#* &&"'!"'$"#!0'#"/>/%>/0&%83/%&'8"'!/'"2" / '# %'" &: 7:%'#" 0,!!+"/":!0/!+"/0'#"/>&%83,"%83/%&'8"'!/ '"8'!+ +" $!&!+"$ &" /"!+ !

& !,"2'#0&!/%"& /%- !"

5%8%!"#:*+%$+3/"&"'!/"-%&%'%&!* &'"!+"#%/"$!/& ,'>*%!+18! .""'0+ *, : %8%, 3 #+ 2 2 '#&+0!&+ 3 #+ 2 2 $7 $$0&"#

77 =! %'"#"C0%38"'!," &"%' '$" &B), $&/8 /2 ' %' '$% , /3/ !%': /%# = #+"," &" >/""8"'!* &"D"$0!"#'AA &3"/& %#," &" >/""8"'!:!+","&&""* &! $C0%/""C0%38"'!/8!+" &033,%"/

&10'+"/8'>%'""/&: ' ;30/%:"*",+%' 80'!

&:: 7* &/"," &"#%' -0/&033,%"/:-%#"#"8 '##/ !& B@!B@:# !"#AA:#/ *'' '; /# :"*",+% +"#"8 '##/ !&*"/"/"," &"#!&+0!&+ 3 #+ 2 2!%& ,,">"#!+ !

!+","&&""$83 '2:' 8",2:

& !,"2'#0&!/%"& /%- !"5%8%!"##%#'!

30/$+ &"!+"8 $+%'"/2/8&033,%"/

&10'+"/8'>%'""/&: ' ;30/%:

"*",+% !+"/:/ 0#0,"'!,2 ' $$0'!* &>!3"'"#!+/0>+'" 18"&+ "+! : '"83,2""!+"$83 '2:*+* &%'!/#0$"#=2

* '+ *, :%'!+"' 8"

&10'+"/8'>%'""/& '##"8 '##/ !& *"/"$/"#%!"#%'!+"& %# $$0'! '#*"/", !"/'/ 0#0,"'!,2*%!+#/ *' !%&0/!+"/ ,,">"#!+ !1+/%6 8,"&++09 : /2 ' %' '$% , /3/ !%':$'#0$!"#!+"3+2&%$ ,-"/%%$ !%' '#0'#!+ !8 $+%'"/2 - %, =," !&%!"* &,#'" &"$'#+ '#+"8 !!"/* &-"/%%"#/8 !+"&033,%"/*+/"3/!"#'AA)!+ !!+"8 $+%'"/2* &'!&033,%"# =2!+"8!%& ,,">"#!+ !

& !,"2'#0&!/%"& /%- !"5%8%!"#&0=8%!!"# />"#=%,,& '#/ 0#0,"'!,23"'"#!+" $$0'!&033,%"/

&10'+"/8 '>%'""/& '#>!/"," &"#!+""'!%/" 80'!$$/#%'>,2: # !"#AA)0'#"/1"$!%'&:):B: * &/">%&!"/"# > %'&! ,,!+"#%/"$!/& ! ,%$"1! !%'"'!/ , /%# = #&+0!&+

3 #+ 2 2#%"##0/%'>!+"3"'#"'$2!/% ,+"!/% ,0/!$'-%$!"#',2

* '+ ,* 0'#"/1"$!%' '# $C0%!!"#+%8!+"/"8 %'%'> $+ />"&+"/"8 %'%'>!* $$0&"#*"/" $C0%!!"# ,,!+"$+ />"& + -"+" /#!+"," /'"#$0'&",//"-%&%'%&!:!+"," /'"#

77 1! !"$0'&", '#+ -" ,&$ /"0,,2>'"!+/0>+!+"%," '#!+"/%>%' , ,*"/0/!%," &*",, +" ," /'"# $0'&", / /"-%&%'%&! + & />0"# !+ ! !+" ,,"> !%'&3/-"# > %'&!/"-%&%'%&!="/"!+"!/% ,0/! /"!+ !+"+ # 30/$+ &"#,#8 $+%'"/2%'3, $"'"*8 $+%'"/2 '#:!+"/"/":+"+ & $88%!!"#"'$"0'#"/1"$!%' !%&0/!+"/$'!"'#"#!+ !!+"

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

-%#"90#>8"'!# !"#@A:=&"/-"#!+ !!+"#%/"$!/&$83 '2+ # ,/" #23 %# &, $&"&%#"&!+%&:!+"3/3"/!2!+"$83 '2* & ,/" #2 !! $+"#=2 '#3/$""#%'>& /"3"'#%'> > %'&!!+"8+" 33",, !"0/! ,&!;!+"-%"*!+ !!+", '* & #- '$"#!30/$+ &" '"*8 $+%'"/2=0!,#8 $+%'"/2* &30/$+ &"#! ,&=&"/-"#!+ ! !+"/"%&'"-%#"'$"/ 0# '#/>"/2&! !%'>!+ !!+"/"%&'8 !"/% ,' /"$/#!+ !%$!%!%0&=%,,&*"/"3/"&"'!"#! '#*"/"3/"3 /"#=2 $$0&"# "-%&%'%&!+ &=""'$'-%$!"#0'#"/1"$!%' ',2'!+"

77 >/0'#!+ !!+", '* &=! %'"#/'"*8 $+%'"/2:=0!,#8 $+%'"/2 * &30/$+ &"#'," &" +" !%'>%&#"%'"# 0'#"/1"$!%'@'#% ' "' ,#"

*+%$+/" #& &0'#"/(7 E1"$!%'@+" !%'>7<+"-"/:=2#"$"%-%'> '23"/&': / 0#0,"'!,2/#%&+'"&!,2%'#0$"&!+"3"/&'&#"$"%-"#! #",%-"/ '23/3"/!2! '23"/&':/!$'&"'!!+ ! '23"/&' &+ ,,/"! %' '23/3"/!2:/%'!"'!%' ,,2%'#0$"&!+"3"/&'& #"$"%-"#!#/8%!!# '2!+%'>*+%$++"*0,#'!#/ 8%!%+"*"/"'!&#"$"%-"#: '#*+%$+ $!/ 8%&&%' $ 0&"&/%&,%;",2!$ 0&"# 8 >"/+ /8!!+ !3"/&'%' =#2:8%'#:/"30! !%'/3/3"/!2:%&& %#!E$+" !FF +"/"/":!+"'"$"&& /2%'>/"#%"'!&$+" !%'> /"!+ !(7

% $$0&"#/ 0#0,"'!,280&!#"$"%-" '23"/&'G

%% $$0&"# 80&! / 0#0,"'!,2 %'#0$" 3"/&' & #"$"%-"# ! #",%-"/ '23/3"/!2! '23"/&'/!$'&"'!!+ ! '23"/&'&+ ,,/"! %' '23/3"/!2G/

%%% $$0&"#%'!"'!%' ,,2%'#0$"&!+"3"/&'&#"$"%-"#!#/ 8%!!# '2!+%'>*+%$++"*0,#'!#/8%!!#%+"*"/"'!& #"$"%-"#G '#

%- &0$+ $!/8%&&%'$ 0&"&/%&,%;",2!$ 0&"# 8 >"/+ /8 !!+ !3"/&'%'=#2:8%'#:/"30! !%'/3/3"/!2 '/#"/!"D 8%'"*+"!+"/!+"/"* & '2$'#%!%'%'!+"& %# ," &" >/""8"'!!+ !',2'"*8 $+%'"/2'," &"*%,,="30/$+ &"#:!+%& 0/!+ &!>!+/0>+!+"," &" >/""8"'!# !"#AA D < ="!*""'

& !,"2'#0&!/%"& /%- !"5%8%!"#!+/0>+%!&#%/"$!/& '# !+" /2 ' %' '$% ,/3/ !%' %'&+/!4 4 +"3"/0& ,," &" >/""8"'!&+*&!+ ! $$0&"#%/8+ #:

7@7 !+/0>+ %!& #%/"$!/&: 33/ $+"# $ ,,"# ,"&&/ / $C0%/%'> "C0%38"'!

8 $+%'"/2#"! %,"#=",*(7 E111 +/""*, ##%'> '>,"

'"' + -%'>880&"0,*%#!+ B88/,,"/ $"*%!+!'& 3/"&&0/" // '>"8"'!:+%>+"'!/ '$"

""#%'>#"-%$"*%!+$,!+>0%,#"/&:

8 $+%'""C0%33"#*%!+&0%! =," #/%-" '#&2'$+/'%&%'> // '>"8"'!

1!"'!"/ $+%'"

'""#"-%$"

'/" "#!23"&!"'!"/ $,!+""#%'>"-%$" = + 8="/$$"&&/%"& $ 6'%!!%'> '#08%'>"-%$"F !* &&!%30, !"#%'!+"," &" >/""8"'!!+ !!+","&&""*%,, 0!%,%H"!+"& %#"C0%38"'!' '%//"-$ =,"," &"/!+"3"/%#&%D!2 8'!+&3/%8 /2," &"'!+"3 28"'!/"'! ,&&!%30, !"# '##"! %,"# '# 03'!"/8& '#$'#%!%'&$'! %'"#!+"/"%'+" =-"'!"#!"/8& '# $'#%!%'&&+*&!+ !"C0%38"'!

8 $+%'"/2: &#"! %,"# =-":* &!="

30/$+ &"#+"/"* &'&3"$%%$&!%30, !%'!+ !',2'"*8 $+%'"/2*%,, ="30/$+ &"#'," &"*+%$+* &/8'!+& '#/*+%$+/"'! ,* & 3 2 =,"=2,"&&""+" * &!>"!/"'! ,/!+"," &"#8 $+%'"/2/ !+"& %#3"/%#8'!+& 0/!+"/, 0&"& : %: :A :A =:A

$:A #:A " '#A & %#," &" >/""8"'! /"/"3/#0$"# &0'#"// /" #2/""/"'$"(7 E +","&&""+ &&","$!"#=!+%""C0%38"'! 8 $+%'" '# !+"&033,%"//8*+8!+"5"&&/%&!30/$+ &"!+""C0%38"'! '#!+"& 8"%&5"&&""4&*' 90#>8"'! 5"&&""! ;"&!+" "C0%38"'!E &%&F '#"D3/"&&,2#%&$, %8& '2/",% '$"03' '2

77 &! !"8"'!//"3/"&"'! !%'&8 #"=2!+"5"&&/:5"&&"" >/""& !"D"$0!" 'E $;'*,"#>8"'!",%-"/2 '#$$"3! '$"F 03' /"$"%3! "C0%38"'!

8 $+%'" +" 5"&&/ 8 ;"& ' * // '!%"& "D3/"&& / %83,%"# & ! '2 8 !!"/ *+ !&"-"/ %'$,0#%'> !+" $'#%!%' "C0%38"'!

8 $+%'" / %!& 8"/$+ '! =%,%!2/%!'"&& / '23 /!%$0, /30/3&" +" 5"&&""0'#"/&! '#& '# >/""&!+ !'"%!+"/&033,%"/: '#' /"3/"&"'! !%' &!"C0%38"'!

8 $+%'"/ '2!+"/8 !!"/=2 &033,%"/&+ ,,%' '2* 2 "$! 5"&&""4& #0!2!3 2!+" #0"& /"'! ,& '#3"//8%!&!+"/=,%> !%'& &&"!/!+%'!+%& ," &" >/""8"'!

=! + DDDDDD DDDDDD DDDDDD DDDDDD

% +"5"&&""&+ ,,! ;"#",%-"/2!+""C0%38"'! !!+" 3, $"*+"/"!+"5"&&/#%/"$!&!+"5"&&""!! ;"#",%-"/2!+" "C0%38"'! +" ,"&&"" 0/!+"/ >/""& ! #",%-"/ = $; !+" "C0%38"'! ! !+"5"&&/ ! !+""D3%/2 !+"," &" ! !+"%/ /">%&!"/"#%$"&%!0 !"# ! 2&):B '#A:1"$!/) :

+ '#%> /+/ !&0$+!+"/3, $" &!+"5"&&/8 2/"C0%/" '#!=" / ,,!+""D3"'&"&%'$''"$!%'*%!+!/ '&3/! !%': /"%>+!:%'&0/ '$" '# ,,!+"/'"$"&& /2"D3"'&"&%'/"&3"$! !/ '&3/!%'>!+""C0%38"'!/8!+"3, $"! ;%'>#",%-"/2! !+" 3, $" *+"/" %! %& ! =" 0&"# =2 !+" 5"&&"" '# /8 &0$+3, $"!!+"/">%&!"/"#%$"5"&&/ ! 2&):B: '# A:1"$!/7)7:+ '#%> /+/ !&0$+!+"/3, $" &#%/"$!"# =2!+"5"&&/'!+""D3%/2/!"/8%' !%'!+"," &"

9! '

DDDDDD DDDDDD DDDDDD

'$ &"- /% !%'#"3/"$% !%'",%>%=%,%!2#0/%'>!+" %D"#3"/%#," &":!+"/3/ !%'*0,#+ -"!+"/%>+!! %'$/" &"!+"/"'! ,!$83"'& !"/,&&#"3/"$% !%' A +"5"&&"" $;'*,"#>"& '# >/""&*%!+!+"5"&&/(7 + ! !+" "C0%38"'! %& &%H": #"&%>': $ 3 $%!2 '# 8 '0 $!0/"&","$!"#=2!+"5"&&"" = + !!+"5"&&""%&& !%&%"#!+ !!+""C0%38"'!%&&0%! =," /%!&30/3&" $ + !!+"5"&&/%&'!!+"8 '0 $!0/"/!+""C0%38"'!

7)7 '/ #" ,"/ %' &0$+ "C0%38"'! !+ ! + -%'> %'&3"$!"# !+" "C0%38"'!!+"5"&&""+ &&%>'"#!+%& >/""8"'!/",2%'>"'!%/",2 '%!&*'90#>8"'! '#'!' '2&! !"8"'!&8 #"=2!+" 5"&&//!+" >"'!&/&"/- '!&!+"5"&&/ # + ! ' * // '!2 %!'"&& / !+ ! !+"

"C0%38"'!

8 $+%'" %& 8"/$+ '! =,": &+ ,, 33,2 ! !+%& $'!/ $! "

+ !!+""C0%38"'!%& $$"3!"#=2!+"5"&&""*%!+ ,, 0,!& '##""$!& % '2: '##",%-"/2 &+ ,, ="$'$,0&%-"

"-%#"'$": !+ ! !+" "C0%38"'! %& %' ># $'#%!%' '# &0=&! '!% ,*/;%'>/#"/ '#$'#%!%' + !!+"5"&&/+ &'!8 #" '##"&'!+"/"=28 ;" '2 /"3/"&"'! !%' / * // '!2 *%!+ /"&3"$! ! !+" 8"/$+ '! =%,%!2:$'#%!%':C0 ,%!2:&0%! =%,%!2:0&"/3"/ !%' !+""C0%38"'!%' '2/"&3"$! DDDDDD DDDDDD DDDDD DDDDD DDDDDF +"3"/0& ,!+" =-"'!"#$, 0&"&%'!+"," &" >/""8"'! 8 ;"%!$," /!+ !!+"/"* &'&!%30, !%'!+ !',2'"*8 $+%'"/2%&!=" 30/$+ &"#+", '* & #- '$"#/30/$+ &%'>!+"8 $+%'"/2'," &": /*+%$+!+" * &!>"!/"'! ,&!%&'!!+"$, %8 !+ !'/"'!

* &3 %#!!+"8%'!"/8&& %#,D" &" >/""8"'! +"8 $+%'"/2* & 30/$+ &"#'AA!+/0>+%'-%$"

=%,, D < "/"!+",*"/ 0/!:!+"& %#%'-%$"

=%,,* &'!3/-"#!=" ,&"+"$ &"%&= &"# 03'!+"%'&3"$!%'/"3/!1+/%6 8,"&++09 :1"'%/ ' >"/ 5: + '#%> /+ D < # !"#ABAA%" =0!&%D8'!+& !"/!+"& %# 30/$+ &"#8 $+%'"/2!* &=&"/-"#%'!+"-"/%%$ !%'!+"&"$0/%!2 & 0'#"/(7 E."/%%$ !%'!+"1"$0/%!2 DDDD DDDDD DDDDD 6'%!!%'> '#08%'>"-%$"

+" 0,,&"!8 $+%'" 33" /&!="

&"$'#+ '# ,#'"#0=!!+%& 8 $+%'" + & =""' #"&3 !$+"# /8 09/ !=0!!+"=%,,+ &=""'=! %'"#

7B7 /8",+%%/8+"/"%&'8"'!%'

1 ,"&! D08="/%'!+"=%,, '# !+"/#$08"'!&>%-"'=2!+"",+% >"'!: !+" &%>' !0/"& #%"/ '# /"&"8=,"&*%!+'"!+"#%/"$!/& !%&&0>>"&!"#!+ ! !" 8 "$+'%$ , "/&''",& !," &!!*! !+/""8 2="#"30!"#*+8 2$+"$;

!+"8 $+%'"/2 +""D$0&"&>%-"'=2!+"3 /!2 /"> /#%'> !+" 8 $+%'"/2 '# %!& $'#%!%':#'! 33" /!="$//"$!

'# !+"2 /" !/2%'> ! 3/-" !+"%/ 8%&/"3/"&"'! !%'!="!/0" ."/%%$ !%'!+"1"$0/%!2 !+"&"$0/%!2%&%'! $!=0! &8"'!%'"# =-" !+" 8 $+%'" 33" /& ! ="

&"$'# + '# '# &%'>," 8 $+%'"

80'!! &:: 7F DDDDDD DDDDDD DDDDDD

"> /#%'> !+" = , '$" &+""! !+" 3 /!2 '# #"3/"$% !%'> */;%'>/"&0,!&:%!* &/"$/#"# &0'#"/(7 */#'!,">%=,"= , '$"

&+""!!+"3 /!2%'#%$ !%'> */;%'>$ 3%! , +"3 /!2+ &>%-"' = , '$"&+""!

3/-%&%' , & ' )A +"

/"&0,!& /""'$0/ >%'>!+"'"!3/%!

+ &&+*' ! &, $& > %'&!!+"

& ," &A) , $& %'$,0#%'> 9= */; DDDDDD DDDDDD DDDDDDF #8%!!"#,2:'!"$+'%$ ,3"/&''",-%&%!"#!+"&3!!* &',2 !+"3%'%'1+/%6 8,"&++09 :1"'%/ ' >"/ 5: + '#%> /+:

!+ !8 $+%'"/2 33" /&!="&"$'#+ '# ,#'"*"-"/:!+"!"$+'%$ , 3"/&''",* &!$+"$;!+"8 $+%'"/2 '#&0=8%!!+"/"3/!*+"!+"/%!* & ,# '" / '!? +"/"/": %! %& '! 3/-"# !+ ! ,# 8 $+%'"/2 * & 30/$+ &"# /"-"/:!+"/"* &'&!%30, !%'%'!+"," &" >/""8"'!!+ !

7A7 ',2'"*8 $+%'"/2%&!="30/$+ &"#+"8 $+%'"/2* &!="30/$+ &"# /! ;%'>%!'," &" '# $$0&"#%/8* &!3 2/"'! ,!!+"$/3/ !%' ' $!:!+"8 $+%'"/2* &30/$+ &"# '#!+"%/8* &/0''%'>%'!3/%! !

&, $& > %'&!& ," &A), $&:%'$,0#%'>9=*/;+"/"/":%! $ ''! =" & %# !+ ! /"-%&%'%&! %'!"'#"# ! $+" ! !+" /3/ !%' '# #"$"%-"#!+"8!#",%-"/!+", ' /8!+", ':!+"8 $+%'"/2* & 30/$+ &"# '# $$0&"#%/8+ #" /'"#3/%! 80'!%'>! &, $&'

!+"&" $%/$08&! '$"&: *+"' %! %& '! 3/-"# !+ ! ,# 8 $+%'"/2 * & 30/$+ &"# '#!+ !,#8 $+%'"/2$0,#'!="30/$+ &"#:%!$ ''!="& %# !+ !"'$"$+" !%'> &#"%'"#0'#"/1"$!%'@ '#30'%&+ =,"

0'#"/1"$!%' %&3/-"# $$/#%'>,2:3/"&"'!/"-%&%'%& ,,*"# '#!+"90#>8"'!# !"#@A:3 &&"#=2!+"," /'"###%!%' , 1"&&%'&0#>": /%# = #: '#!+"90#>8"'!$'-%$!%'# !"#)B '#/#"/&"'!"'$"# !"#A:3 &&"#=2!+"," /'"# ##%!%' , +%" 0#%$% , >%&!/ !": /%# = #: /" +"/"=2 &"! &%#" "-%&%'%&!

* '+ *, &! '#& $C0%!!"#!+"$+ />"&/ 8"# > %'&!+%8 %, ='# '#&0/"!2='#0/'%&+"#=2/"-%&%'%&!&! '##%&$+ />"#+"%'":% '2:3 %#=2/"-%&%'%&!="/"0'#"#!+%8

5 1 ) &9;& <+"!+"/&3" ;%'> /" &'"# ( "& <+"!+"/ "3/! =,"

( "&