← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/481/2004dismissed

Malkiat Singh Etc. v. State Of Pb.

2026-01-13Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat,Mrs. Justice Sukhvinder Kaur15 pages

 

         

 

  !

"# #

$  

%& & '!(# #

)  

           *!

 '+,-.#/ &% #0#01213  '+,-.

#/ &%0/21 &'45/  







 !

    

  "# 

     "! $ %   &&&

#0#01213# ' "(!(        ) 

)           *+*',**-

 (  

  .

) (         ))         /0- /*, ,*'1

         , # 21345 6,7!       )   345 7  )   (  8   9      #  )       $ ) :  ; :'

< = 

  ) 

    !

>



?  

  

   

 

          

 

  



 

 

      

   

       

 

 

 

  



 

 

  !"#!!

 



  

 $

% # 

 % %   

          &#'

 



( )

( )  





 *



)  + ) 

     ,   

( )  

        



    )    

   

      -

-$

%     

 $

%  

    

   -

- $

%  $   .

'&/""/)     

               -

-$

%  

 

 0  '&/""/)                   -

-    

  

    1

    

 



  

 2  )   



    % %    1

      -

-      

     



 #*

 

3 + #   ,   # 

  (         -

-  $

 %



            

       

  

  





 )

 

 2 )  



              

    %



 #*  $ 

  + #   

     

 

    4     5- 6 

)

( 7 

45 /

    21        !)( ))  <   5       6  !   8<  ( 

# (!           )  (!   

 :'6 

 )     () @   !

) (         =  

  (  )( =  :,6  ) )    

) @!(                                 )  

  (#  )    $ (

A!)  )     (    (   (  "

 45  !   45     %

 

     (    

 :'

  () @! 

! (   (91!   (  

  ! ( 45  4 % 

         ()( 

)  @!     =  :,

  (   (  A! ))    () @!    #       (   (! 

     ))5)    (!



        )(             )            /0- /*, ,*'

/-1 ! 

    !(        ))      ) -

 )) #  )      /0- /*, ,*'1 !)      ( !    >    ("   (  (  !    (         B #                         5)  8 9  )  ;>'

 )  345 7     (     1

 >5)   ) @! 

!

 

 :'  )     ,B6,0))8!    )(

 :'#    5) 

;>,! $ !    )) =  *C ** *0*-,**,

 :') )     )  )8! 

  

  )   !! ) (;

  !    = :,6  !  )  ! 

 ) @     # ( )  (!

      ! )! B60 (  ) ! ) @   #    5)  ;>/  )$)      45")(

$   5)  %

   ;>-        !5  45>C>'0 ! 45>'45>+#    5) 

1): ;>B !  1<    

                45>'  >'0 #    5)   "

 :#  ;>0 

   ( 'B*-,**,  )  )      "   !  !

       

  () @ !     )               (  !  !   (     !1!   (    ()) 454 ! ( )1   >5)      (!

! !   )!

   (  ) @ !  8   !

!                      (  #        5)  ;>D 

) 

  !)   )(   5)  1 )  

 " ;>+ ! 8<    8   ) 345 7  )        45%!   )   4          (   )            )       (   ) 458

!            (   !   (  #   (!   (9   ) @ !   (  

) )(            )  4586'

   =      

 45>'D   )!    (  4     (45:!      ( 

 45:>'!  ( )8   ())5)  

)   ! 0 #    5)  $ ! 

   < ;>C      ))5)    

 () @ 'B*-,**,     )    !    *0*-,**,#  5  ) (     !

> ?2             '

89  4    

 

         

  :"

:    

       



  

;      6

 

 2   

2     

  *      

  7

 <

                  ( 

    1    2   

  

:"

:"           

       



    )     



   3  

   ;

          2

     

     

 4 

       



 4 



     



   )  )

    



  

   



  2  

 

   



  

 )



     0 



$  ! 



   



  

  2

6       

$                    8!" 0      

                  ) 

)  

 ! !& 3        

  



      6  

 

     



        

 



     

 

  2           1  1 

6  %      1   

  6  %#!       

1     

     

   

  5 1   >5)       (!    (

   )   D 1  

  5)  

;>'*    '-*-,**,       ) ) ( ! !  )   )    # (

   (   (  5)  

) @  =   )<          ) @! ( )



   (!       (A

)  )      A  !   8 )      )8<1

 >5)    !    'CDC 8!$ 

)   9  "  

!$   4     ) 

  '*6'B(8!)       

      ) # 

 :'6   ) )      =  :,6   ) 8   )     )    )     8

 A (       !      +

                          !   6     )    /'/   C "      ( !  2  (

 )

 )  ( )  ) (

 (      #      (

    '* 9                    ) (     !    )       ! ()       !   ) (  !  !           !  (     9           !       ;>,! $      ) (  

)) (   2    !     ;>'* 

) 5      )4 !)           ! )     (4 !      )

"

      )  !)      )   !  ! )(  ( #  '' <   

     ) (             )        4    ) 5     ;>'* 

       ( !   (  4     

  () @     45            (     ! ) ) (;>,! $ *C ** *0*-,**,       ) (    )    @            )) (  ) @!)  (     ! ) ) (;>'8 9    !    !      )

@ !)  (  )    (!    #  ) 

)   (   ', ;             (E!   '/ 1  )    ! (!                   )     '- # !       )     ! !  (   8 F )      )



?  

    ( ! > 90   





  

  

      

        

= >!?

       

  

   

              

 3  

    

    

  9     9       9   9  

2 

    

  9  9 9    9

 

3

 $  (       

  = 3 

)



 

    

               

  @ @ @  

       $        



9 >/?   

  

    

   )

 )    

   

   

  >:?   

           

        ) >&?   



    ) >'?    

                       

  

      

                     

               9 'B ) !) ( 8 F)  )

   

! "#$%%&'

 ! > /:       



   )

       

  

 

)



 ) 

6                    

   7 ) 









      



  

    

               

    )   $                

 ) 1     

      

  

  

 

     ) 

    0     



  )

 

  

              

 



  

   )    

         

 

      2 3     

     9 '0 # 8 F)   !        )       ) ?( )*

+   ,

#  -$.% ! > >?

     

   

        

 

A >? 

  

   

 

    A > ?

  )         

   

     

  

      

     



  A ?

   

   

         

      

              

      



  

   'D :!

!!     (          

 >  ) (8 F )      ) #  ) !!  ) (;>'8 9  ) ) 45         )2145 6,8 (    ) @!) =   :,'*6''(     :' )( 

 5) !  :, )( = ) @   =  :,     8!      *B*-,**,   )     (!

 ! 

      !    9   

) @ *+*-,**, !      !   ! 

  :'!) )  )G)(   

;>'* 

 '-*-,**, A )   )   1 ) ) (;>'*

 ! !    )  $ 

)   9  "   !$         )    

( '*6'B(4     A ( !

   !   #    

)! !  )    )   '+

 ( ;>'*

          (    )            :'

       (   )    @   !   )          (!   (9 ) @4 

   45>'D!     =   :,    ! (        45        ;>0     "

  :  #    1   

 "

 45  !    !       !  )        (       (                   !    

 )    (  !     'C

)     )    ) (1         ) ( ;>'

8 9  ) @  =  :,  )

    !         4  8   9    (           !    !     )  @          4     ;>'*

 ( ) (  5)   !  ( )  @#        

 )     ))  ) )          5)  ;>,! $ 

  !    )) = *C **  *0*-,**,8 

 :'    8 )  )     )   ! ! ) (8!    =

 :,! ) !    )( ) @

    ( )  (!  )!

     ! )! B60 (  ) ! ) @

  4 ;>,! >5)  (     

 ) (       () # )    !   !  (    (     ) (    ;>C $ ! 

  <       )) 5)      () @   (!

(   (9 "! 

  ) !  )/*5/ )     )

 !          !  (  (5  (:'

!

!        (  #  !        ) @ 

  ))  )      (!

  (    !)(      (#       (          (                    )       )  (          (!

 )(  !) (  (      

$ ) 4  !)     "



45       !              (  (  ,* 4   !  !    (      

        ( #        !              !;    )      ( # 

      ) 

)    ( #  ,'

 ( ) 

)        

*+*',**-  ( 

  .

)      (      

)  ,, <    ( ,/ #  )(    ( !

    )     7 #0#0589        705:

59     (# #

)  ;

  6 

H6: ;

 

H6: