M/S Sanjivani Non Ferrous Trading Pvt Ltd v. State Of Haryana And ANR

        


  

 !"#$%#& ''(( # ! ) * +'   ! " #  ! "
" $%&%'(

$)*+,"-)$.)/0,1)(% $(-%)22%33)'(  
,,!))-.  -%2$%&%'()22%)3+& +3%04'0%$"%1(+' 5 (-%)$6)')
)34%00%0)71(/

8 $&-$(/ (-%1( 9):)+'&((-%$0%$0)(%0 ; 

2)&&%0<6(-%)$6)'))7$+<4')3/-)'0+:)$-42-30+':(-% 2%')3(6+.2&%04'0%$"%1(+'

(-%1(33>+':&4<&()'(+)3 ?4%&(+'& 3)>-),%<%%'13)+.%0 @8)9 '(-% )1(&)'01+$14.&()'1%& (-%1)&%>-%(-%$ +(+&*4&()'02$2%$ $(-%)4(-$+(+%&(+.2&%)0,)'1% ()7)'02%')3(6>-%'(-%:0&0%()+'%0>%$%)0.+((%036 )11.2)'+%0<6)33(-%$%?4+$%0014.%'(&)&2%$(-% 2$,+&+'& "%1(+'

8 9 (-%
1(A 8<9'(-% )1(&)'01+$14.&()'1%& (-%1)&%+&+(*4&()'0 2$2%$ $(-%)4(-$+(+%&(+.2&%2%')3(6*4&('(-% <)&+& &()(%.%'( (-%0$+,%$/%,%'(-4:-(-%:0&

  )$%)11.2)'+%0<6:%'4+'%014.%'(&A 819'(-% )1(&)'01+$14.&()'1%& (-%1)&%+&+(*4&()'0 2$2%$  $  (-%  )4(-$+(+%&  (  +.2&%  2%')3(6  >+(-4( .)B+':0%()+3%0+'?4+$6(%&()<3+&-(-)((-%$%>)&)' )((%.2((%,)0%()7 809'(-% )1(&)'01+$14.&()'1%& (-%1)&%+&+(*4&()'0 2$2%$  (  1'&+0%$  )  &%$+%&    (>  &)3%  ($)'&)1(+'& +..%0+)(%36  2$%1%0+':  (-%  +.24:'%0  '%  )&  &)3%  +' ($)'&+( />-%$%)&(-%$%+&'&41-2$,+&+'+'(-%
 1(/

A 8%9'(-% )1(&)'01+$14.&()'1%& (-%1)&%+&+(*4&()'0 2$2%$(-30(-)((-%+',+1%&$%3)(%0(2$%,+4&&)3% ($)'&)1(+'&)$%$%?4+$%0(<%2$041%0)((-%(+.%

$)0&+0%1-%1B+':)3':>+(-+',+1%&->+':14$$%'( &)3%A 9'(-% )1(&)'0(-%1+$14.&()'1%& (-%1)&%+&+(*4&()'0 2$2%$ $(-%$+<4')3)'0(-%4(-$+(+%&<%3>((>+&( )'0.+&+'(%$2$%((-%($4%&()(%.%'( (-%+'1-)$:% (-% :0&(&.%->.)B%4()1)&% $2%')3(64'0%$ "%1(+'

(-%1(AC -% )1(&+'<$+% )$%(-)(' 5

;/&&+&()'(71+&%D )7)(+'

+1%$8'

$1%.%'(9E14.E)7+':4(-$+(6/)3>)38-%$%+') (%$ 0%&1$+<%0)& (-%%')3+&+':

+1%$ 904$+':$)0&+0%1-%1B+':)()3>)3 1-%1B%0  (-%  ,%-+13%  E =E; 5F  1)$$6+':  )34.+'+4. &1$)2  -% 0$+,%$2$041%0 71+&% ',+1%0)(%0 

; +&&4%0<6 G&   +BB%+  '0+)  ,(  !(0/  )>)3/  %>)$+  8-%$%+') (%$  0%&1$+<%0  )&  (-%

  1'&+:'$ 9+' ),4$ G&%'(4$6 %()3%163+':,(!(0/,+33):% )()$24$/ +&($+1()3>)38-%$%+') (%$0%&1$+<%0)& (-%1'&+:'%% 9)'0)3&  ;H0)(%0

;+&&4%0<6 G&+1%)$: ,%$&/%>

%3-+ $.,%.%'( :0& $.)>)3()()$24$-%&()(%.%'( (-% 0$+,%$E14.E2%$&'+'E1-)$:% (-%:0&>)&$%1$0%0)'0-%&()(%0(-)( (-%:0&>%$%3)0%0'

;+'(-%,%-+13% )0$+ $ )3>)3&(-%014.%'(&&->%0.,%.%'( :0& $.)>)3( )3>)3/>-+1->)&+'1'($)0+1(+'>+(-(-%&()(%.%'( (-%0$+,%$/(-% ,%-+13%>)&0%()+'%04'0%$"%1(+'

(-%1('$%&2'&%((-%&-> 1)4&%  '(+1%/  $  "-%3%'0%$  )(-)B/  )4(-$+&%0  $%2$%&%'()(+,%    (-% )22%33)'()&>%33)& $(-%1'&+:'%%)22%)$%0)'0:((-%:0&$%3%)&%0 ):)+'&((-%&4$%(6<'0 4$+':2%')3(62$1%%0+':&/$%236>)& +3%0<4(' 014.%'(&>%$%2$041%0+'&2+(% -),+':<%%'>$+((%'+'(-%$%236(-)( (-%$%3%,)'(014.%'(&>%$%23)1%0<% $%(-%%')3+&+':

+1%$'% )22%)$%0'(-% +')30)(%/,+0%

$0%$0)(%0H

;/2%')3(6

H/ =/= GE4'0%$"%1(+'

(-%1(>)&+.2&%0)'0)0,)'1%()7

/ 5/ FHGE1-)$:%022%)3>)&2$% %$$%0<% $%(-%+'(71+&%)'0 )7)(+'..+&&+'%$822%)3&9/)$+0)<)08-%$%+') (%$0%&1$+<%0)& (-% 22%33)(%4(-$+(6 9/(-%&).%>)&0+&.+&&%0' =

54$(-%$)22%)3

+3%0<% $%(-%$+<4')3/>)&)3& 0+&.+&&%0' ; 

/-%'1%(-% 2$%&%'()22%)3 !%)$'%014'&%3 $(-%)22%33)'()$:4%0(-)((-%2%')3(6>)& >$':36  +.2&%0  )'0  42-%30  +'&2+(%    (-%  )1(  (-)(  (-%  :0&  >%$% )11.2)'+%0<62$2%$)'0:%'4+'%014.%'(&-%:$+%,)'1%$)+&%0+&(-)( '2$2%$%'?4+$6>)&-%30<% $%+.2&+':(-%2%')3(6

H -%1'(%'(+'&$)+&%0<63%)$'%014'&%3 $(-%)22%33)'()$% '(>%33 4'0%0-%$%+&'0+&24(%$)+&%0%,%')((-+&&():%(-)((-% &()(%.%'( (-%0$+,%$>)&1$$%1()'0(-)((-%:0&>%$%3)0%0 $.

 )0$+'

; $)3>)3-%&()'0 (-%)22%33)'(>)&(-)( (-%:0&>%$%+.2$(%04( '0+):(13%)$%0'

;/(-%&%>%$% &(1B($)'& %$$%0(+(&<$)'1-)()>)3)'0(-%$%) (%$/&)3%>)&.)0%'

;((-%1'&+:'$>- 4$(-%$'(-%&).%0)6&30(-%:0&( (-%1'&+:'%% (  >430  <%  >$(-  ()B+':  '(%    )(  (-+&  &():%  (-)(  (-% 014.%'(&>+(-$%:)$0(+.2$( :0&/($)'& %$ )0$+((-% 1'&+:'$)'0 4$(-%$&)3%((-%1'&+:'%%>%$%'%,%$2$041%0<% $%(-% %')3+&+':

+1%$ -%&()'0()B%'<6(-%)22%33)'(<% $%(-%%')3+&+':

+1%$

%33  3)(/  +$&(36 $  (-%  $%)&'  (-)(   (-%  )22%33)'(  '%,%$  2$041%0  (-% 014.%'(&>+(-$%:)$0((-%%)$3+%$($)'&)1(+'>-+1->%$%<4'0(<%+' 2&&%&&+' (-%)22%33)'("%1'036(-%:0&>%$%13%)$%0 /

)0$+'

;)'0(-%'&30<6(-%1'&+:'$((-%1'&+:'%%'

;/(-%$%>)&0%3)6 &+70)6&+'<%(>%%'(-%&)+0&)3%)'0(-% 0)(% 1-%1B+':%723)')(+'>)&24( $(- $(-%&)+00%3)6!)&(36(-% &()'0()B%'>)&1'($)0+1(%0<6(-%&()(%.%'( (-%0$+,%$ -%)22%33)'(+'$0%$( $(+ 6(-%&()'02$041%0<% $%(-% 22%33)(%4(-$+(6)'0(-%$+<4')3

0)(%0

;+&&4%0 <6 G&+1%)$: ,%$&/%> %3-+$.(-%/+($)(-%$%&()<3+&-%0 (-)((-%&()'0()B%'>)&) (%$E(-4:-(

0)(%0

;>)&

$(-%%)$3+%$($)'&)1(+'>-%$%)&(-%:0&>%$%<%+':)11.2)'+%0<6  ;H0)(%0

; $(-%&4<&%?4%'(&)3%(&->&(-)((-%

;   2$041%0  +'  )22%)3  >)&  :(  +&&4%0  ) (%$>)$0&  )&  $  (-%  %)$3+%$ ($)'&)1(+' &4<&%?4%'(&%$+)3'4.<%$>)&+&&4%0 -%$%+&)'(-%$)&2%1( (-%.)((%$(-)(+'1)&%(-%)22%33)'( -)0  &30  (-%  :0&  (  (-%  1'&+:'$/  (-%$%  >)&  '  11)&+'  $  (-% $%2$%&%'()(+,% (-%)22%33)'()'0 (-%1'&+:'%%()22%)$+'(-%2%')3(6 2$1%%0+':&)'0(:%((-%:0&$%3%)&%0-%)

%1(%02)$(+%&>430-),% <%%'(-%1'&+:'$$(-%1'&+:'%%)'0'((-%)22%33)'( % $%(-%$+<4')3/(-%)22%33)'(1-)':%0+(&&()'0)'0&()(%0 (-)((-%:0&>%$%&30+'($)'&+(<6+(&)>)3<$)'1-((-%1'&+:'$>-

4$(-%$&30(-%:0&((-%1'&+:'%% -%1)&%&%(42<6(-%)22%33)'(<% $%(-%$+<4')3+&'( )11%2()<3%'1)&%+(>)&&)3%.)0%+'($)'&+(/(-%$%>430-),%<%%' %'0$&%.%'('(-% $%,%$/(-%0$+,%$+'(-)(1)&%>430<%1)$$6+': (-%014.%'(&>+(-$%:)$0(.,%.%'( :0& )0$+( )>)3 ',+%> (-%)<,%/'+'(%$ %$%'1%+&1)33%0 $+'(-%$0%$  (-%$+<4')3?4%&(+' 3)>.41-3%&&)&4<&()'(+)3?4%&(+' 3)> )$+&%& -%)22%)3+&0+&.+&&%0 /
,,!))-.0/1,2+-0 3.,3., )'4)$6 ;/

.B #-%(-%$&2%)B+':G$%)&'%0

%&G #-%(-%$$%2$()<3%

%&G