High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4192/2012dismissed

Resham Lal @ Resham Singh v. Shangara Singh & ORS

2019-11-19Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan13 pages

! "# $%&' "%(%) $%&

!*+,-+./ !*+, 0%1* 2020% "

3 "!(!

*+%1+"+ 0%1* 2* "! !4%$ %2!

& 5-

3 6 ! "# $%&'())! "#

* (( $ +* '* !,'! - . 3 67 /(*("(( ((( (+ ( *

./ * ( ) ! "( 0*(#* ("

1 0 #2 ( *#* + (*( 345

! &#(6 6!6 !7! *4!

+( )(#& (, / !,((#8*( 9 0)) * - +

./*)0

)) (((+

./* (( (* - + #2 ( ) %(

# *# *

! (#)+ ;

( ( (- * < )! = < ) &0 , 0 # # &4 )0( &(+* )+ 0(* * )(#

(#( ) "(( *("()8 ( )!, / # (+*( =* # / #) )) * (- ( > =*

((1# * &(+*

#* *(

()./ (

. 7

!* )+0(* *() .*= &(+* *(&0 0+(+ *(* 0 * ?**/ #* * () 8 -( &(+*!*)#(#)(+* * .0)) #**

)&(+*0

* 0* &* + &(+*! 0(* !<

( 0(* !

(* * 0(*!&0 0(*!$ +-(&(+*

0(*!<

( -(&(+* 0(*!0 *?**# *(.* #* *!

&* + &(+* ( * *#

/. +* ) "(+

)

)(# ( ( * =*

-(&(+*+ " .)0= &(+*0*(#**(*( ## %* + )+ " .)0&0 0*(#**(*( *( ## &* + &(+*+ "

.)0# 0*(#* *(*(*( *

## <

(+ " .)0# 0*(#**(*(*

0** )) 0 <

(! ))

&0 # *((- (0*(#**(*(*(

. / =*# ( * #/ *(0( * )# * ) / *# !* (".*( *## #0 * (2 (/

> )) 0 (+(* &,!, / +(+

" (* (2 (/!*# *

1 &* +

&(+*!*0"!(**# )

" *# ((2 (/ */*.

( * # !* 34 # 0 +( ("(+ (0 # #

6 # )( * ("(+ (! ( *

0 *

# (* .) &#( 6!6 !7 *4 #* +0 ## (+)/ , (+ ( )! * # ( ;

( * < )1# 1(- ?!= < ?

!&0 ?6!

, * ?!8=-( &(+* ?:!, (

?@!,&** - ?5 *

!"( # *

# (0 #) ./ #) # ("( #! *

&#(660 # !0*(*/ ( )) *(#(( (+ # ("( # )

*((##

)( )(# ( 4 #!* ;

( 8 -(&(+*

,?!& >*0( &(+*!)> *

(# &,!, / ! ,?

-* !& ))>!=*() );!, / ,?6!4 # * &(+* ,? *

!*/#) *( #"( # =*

!"( ( +

!*( !

* (+ .* *

(

#( (+ *"( # # ! (#* + 1 ("

./ >(+*

))0(+."

( A=* ( ))+ ( # (/ *

))* 0 . ) .)/ 0 0(*

)/0

( * # *( # .-## ( ) 0)) +(" (- ( * )!= < &0 % 4 + 0(**#( *) ## )* # (*

.(+*+ () *

./ /*

0 .?*

!* )+0(**(

&0 .*= < )0 * #*) *( "()) + 0* */ )) *

0(*0

*## &* +

&(+* ( ) )> *

)) *

# (- (*% (*#;

( (!

*(0(* * >0*

*0 )#(#(/# 8* * *"( )( (*# (##8* * *# ))*

))* 0 )

/ *8# ) ))*)+*

(** &* + &(+* ?

= < )* (

*# *

# ((*(;

( ((#*( &* + &(+* -(&(+*0* "(+

( *(* . *# ) ))*(B

=* .**0(* ". .)))* (B

# (/. ( 8* * *# ) ))* *0 /

+.)00+("./(* &(+*(+( )/!*(0(* *

)

/+(".)0*(.** < ) 0* *

.# ##( . * * 0( * " =* ( #

(#((* # (0( ?

( &* + &(+**

1 *(.** ). *# ) ))*

* *

)* +*

/0 #(" (*( #& *(0(*

#( ))/ "*(

# *

10 . ./

&* + &(+* * )=* *("( # " ?6&0 )

( (*(#;

( (*# )) ( #.0## "()) + *'=

*(0(0 * !*# )

" ()/))* ( #.0%* (, (

*'=

=* * # *(0(( )

. * =*(0(* *

(.)00 +("./&* + &(+* *#

.)00 +("./ &* + &(+*** !* )?* (0.)0 0+("./&* + &(+*0*(#**(*(*(

?6 * *

( -(&(+*+ "

.)00*(#**(= < 0* ?* )(()* .)0 +(" ./ -( &(+* =* )) * 0( (#

* *(- ( # ./* 0*(#*(

)* # ( /?, * * ( )/ * # # (# )+ ))/ ;

( ( (-

: * &0 ?:8=-( &(+* ( )0(0** *(+ (*

?@, ( ( ) )0( 0** )/ " *C / D;?@1!D; ?@1% D;?@1 ** /*(+

(* ?5,&* ( )

) 0( 0* * ( )/ "

(- * )D;0*(#*0 # ./&4 % )0( &(+*! *( D; ?51

) 34 D;?51% ( D;?51

./* #+ (+* ( * (- > D;?51, D;?513!. ** /*(+ (*

*** *) ## ) ;

( 0( # *( # *0* &* + &(+*0

/ ,?

& >*0( * #( ))/

&* + &(+*0 )#( /* )"

/ *0 /())

# D;, 1 (+( )/! *( 0( *

! &* + &(+* / :

*( / ( *

(# &,

#( )/ *))*0( ;

( ./ * # # ) ( * &* + &(+*0 *( / *# ) #* * # (- (*# )) * 0( ;

( ./ * ) # # ) 0 # ;

( )+* . *(+ + *(#;

( (0*(#*# ) +("

* # (,?* &(+** (+*((2 (/! $ +-(&(+*!%* ) #**

) 0 (# =* *

# &* + &(+* 0*

))+ )/# (- (*# *

( . )=* !(# . *

# * . .) "(# (*

./ / *

0 . =* )

## )* > #( (# ) * # * .+# ./*#

"( (/0(** =*( #(*( #( *) # ) *) # # )* " "

( # " "( (/.0*# 4 + 0(**#( *) ## )* * # ( * ( .)/

## *

0(** ))+ #(=* # (

# "( # (* ## (+)/!

# (*

##* 0(* * ))+ #( 4 ( 0)) ) ) 0 * *

# (( /. .(+**+ () *

./ /*

0 .4( )#

(#( ) #(( )- ( #* . ( .!

/! +* ## (+)/!4;* . ( .* #2 (* * #* + (*E =* ((1# ! ( ( ( 0(* *

). *)0

)) !0*(#*0 )

(( !"( ( + - +

=* ("

A =*) # ) *

)) 1#

)

* ) ( ) * 0+)/

#2 ( * 1 =* # (*

(#("( #* () "+ ()

./ .) *

0 . 0* "(++("# (- ( *

)) !*(.*= < &0 !

. 7

# ( "(!&* + &(+*0 0(*

! -( &(+*0 0(*

((+ 0

0(*

+ =*/ )) )

.)/0(*.-## (- (*

))

*(- 0(**( #("0

D" *( (/ ( )/ .)(* * () D" * ) "( # * ))/

# (# <!*# *

#(" (- (!= < )*

#(" (- (

&0 &(+**

#(" (- (=*( )

#( *"( #

# * ()./ # (=* (++("./*( ) *./ #2 ((+* .

#-#

(8#!(( /

) />( )/ . ))0 1 .#"(#

) "(( ) 0 ** * ! * ) # ) * 1 )

*(+ ( (*0)) - +

./* ) ( ) 4( ))+ (# *

# ()/*( 0(

*(( #. (* D" (/ ( .)(* * () ## #* > # ))+

)# * . ( * =* ( #

(#((* # (0(

#*! * )( .)

5 3 *! (+ 2 (/! # # ./ 4 # * &(+*! %* + )! #**

)!$ +-(&(+*

&0 0 (#4( ) "

* ()* &*(+ &(+*0 )#( /

* 2 ( *( # *

( )),) /() +(+ 34( ;

* ()8#!(( /

/>( )/. (( 6 ( )/!*

)* . ./ * # 1

)) ( * - +

#2 (

./*) )0 3( ))!

((.* 0* (*# *

)) ( )(+ 0(* - + )0

#2 ( )4 ) - + (

(# ()

!*8F.) ; ) 0*+ ( )(.." (

( #2 ( ) 4 0 *) ! * (

( (## (

" * ( (## 0 * ( # ./*( #2 ( )./*( ) ! *

(+ *( ) 0*(#**

(+*0( * (+*("( ## ) . " )/ "/ . ( # ))(+

=* (#( ). ))0 ./*

)) #( (+*

(- + #2 ( )( ( )/0** # ))(+ . ( (+ 6(# ( + - (#0*(#* / ( #2 ( ) *+ ()/()* * #"(#( (#& "(00 >./* 8F.) ; ( !"#$$ %&

' !"#$#(! %

)#(

*$(# () +

, % - 4"(0 *) 0 0(*#( (!((#) * 0*0"(0 (.)

( ) * "( #

# (*# *# .)0* > "(00*(#*( (.)!*

)) # )+ ))/( 0(* #2 ( )"( ( * ((* *"(0 >./* .)0 (#( ( *"( #( 4* " () *( ) 0(**

( #

) *& *)

## )"/# ))/ *# *

# (! * ## # *

> #

. 7

=* (#( * ) ## )(* ( (/ ( .)(* * ()=*) ## ) 0 ( *( 0 * # ;

( ( ?* )!0**

( (

7 *( # ;

( ( * * 0**

. 7

!*0 )#(#(/# 4 *0 )#(#(/#

. 7

!*((

#) ./*(0(* *0**

( ( ( * ?

= < )*

( (*(#;

( (* *

)+0(*&0 * 0>(+ () , / 8 *

( */ *

#) *(* 5

0*(* 4

*/*

+*(*

#)(+*(* 5

!**0*## #*

> #

. 7

&(() )/ ## # "(+ > #

. 7

(

. )("(0 #;

( ( ?6&0

, 8*

( ("(0 #;

( (* */ *(* 7

#)* 5

00 *(* *(#/#)8 *

( ( > . 1:( #**(* 8 *

(

(+*(* !*/> ) ( > . * *

*/ *( * 4 ((# )# ) +("./*(!**/ 0 ) * " *(* . 7: *

?* ))*0( (#

. *

# * 0** ## # *

> #

!*# ()/. ( . +* : 3 *! )) * 0( >(+ #

(#/ + (+ (

(# )

*## #?* )( ))+(+* */ *(*

(*(+

#) ./5

!0* ?6&0 ( ))+(+ * */ *(* 7

( 5

?* ( #.0 % *0> % ( , ( ( . > ?* ?6&0 * * >00* (* ( #.0"()) +%* (,

( '=

D"?* * >0( +*( ( )/

( *.# ##( # )) * 0**

( )(# 0* (- / 0*(#* &(() )/!?

* (*(#;

( (* *# /* *0 /(- (0( )(# ./ (* *(8( >(+"

+ ))+ (* )) ( )(# (- (*(0(*

% *( #( ))/ ))+(+* 0*(#*(- /0 )(# ./0*?6&0 ( ))+(+* *( * .*G+ -!0 ) * *

( )(# /(- /* 8 * "*(* .**

( # *( **(

((*

?6 &0 , ))/ * * #

# (.# (( .)("

.)* *

).* *(0(0 */ /# *( *#) #* =* ( )#

(#((*"( # * ( 0(#) )/*0* */ (+

))/ .(+ #) ) (" * " .

))/ ( )(# (*(# @ 3 *!*((" * )(#(- (* # *(*

()/ . =* (" ))+ ./ *

# ((* *0 ( + (+

1.0* &*(+ &(+* =*(#((0(* /(?( ))+(+ * * *

1 &*(+ &(+*

% *( # * () " *(

./* < )&*(+ &(+*?

= < )* ) ))+

* &*(+ &(+**

*(.*. *# ))*

* 0**( 0 >8 * * (!* 0 0* 0

&*(+ &(+*=* !("

(((+( # 5 3 *!*) ## )* ))+

!&*(+ &(+*0 . /( / *0)#( ** .

))/( )(#

( * # 4 " *(

#! *

## )* ;

( ,?

& >*0( &(+* 0** #( ))/ &*(+ &(+*0 )#( /*)"

*0 /())

)D;, 18* * &*(+ &(+* / :

*( /(*

(# &, * #( )/ * =*( 0( * # +(# ))/ &*(+ &(+*0 *( / *# ) #* * # (- ( * # 4 ) # . + (+# # (.# #

# (!&*(+ &(+*0 (( )( # (+ (- ( * ?* &*(+ &(+* 0

(# &,! )#( /!* ./ /#* ( +( (!(( (.)* /

(#( )# .; (+*((+(

/ (+)#( ( =* #

&*(+ &(+** "(+# (- (#

* ( . ) =* ) # # )* ) 0/ (0 "

(

# * () " "( (/.0

* # * #*!

) ( )(# ( ( * # # . ) 7 4(* (#( * * *(( ) /() +(+34!0*(#*(

) *# # (=*( .((* (

) /() +(+34( )/;

* ()!*( (

)*# # (80"!(

) / ( )/ ;

./ # (! *

) /() +(+34(*(+*)/ . )=*)

# ) * )( . .

) , )/ / ))

!(0*(#*(* .*) ./* 8F.) ; * ) /() +(+34( ;

( (#( .) .+ (+* + ( *# ( *" #(/ * "( # *# 4 /' %

0 , ) & )

#.!

(* .*) ./*8F.) ; * 34(

#(( )#

(# ) )/( # ("(

.) (# "( # *

#. (+*"( #) *( )=*.-#

(((+ ) +(+ 34(. ( )/ (+ (+*#(# #(0*(#** #(0 #( (#) (+* # # ) (!

/ ./*!*0

!( /

) */0(!( /,) /( ) +(+ 34 )(.))(*0*(#*( #

* +* ## ) /!*34 )/+.

+ (/!

+ )# ( *( #( *#)

"(;

++ /& "(00 >./ *8F.) ; ( * $ ( # () %

=*) 0)

0(*(#( (( ))/

)(# .)*

# (* ( )/!(* # !340 +( * # * ) 4(;

* ()./# * ( * ## #*

> #

!*0*/*

0 ( ())

) +(+* 34 2 )/!

) /() +(+ 34( )/ ;

()./ # ( #*((

) *# # ( 3 *!(() (( ) 0* 0*

) ( ( #2 ( )! *

)) # )/ ( 0* * # ))(+ . ( ) (+ *)

0, !

) ?**.

( "( #

(+ * ()! 0 "(0 (.)! *

() . ( .=*)

# ) *

)) *

"* 0* *())+ )(/(+ ) (/(*- +!

./ * ) ( ) ! 0*./ ( #2 ( *

./+("(+*. ( .=* # ))(+ . ( ) ( (+(* - + #2 (

./*) )0

=* ! ( ( #) * # ( *

( .)/.(+**+ () ./

/ .)*

0 . #( (+*

#!*) ( ) #2 (

*#* + (*=*(())+ )(/ (+ ) (/(*( + - + *(* .

( 0)) .)(* (#( )

0 **(

)( "( /(

4"(0

(# (!((#) *

)) *

" ( # ## (+)/!

) ./ * # 1

)) ( *./

(( .(+ "( /( *- + * ( ) ( *./

( =* #

) ( ) . .

) () . #(+ *# E < # ) * ((* + .** # .)0 * " 0+)/ (#* + * 1 ("

#* * # ("( #!(* # # */ ) .)/ # (- (

((1# * )!*(.*= < &0

, < # ) * (( * * + (- 1"(#(* " )( )(- ( ** #

!* !# ) "(0 #. ./* )"( # < # ) * (( * + * (- 10(* " )+(" ()(0*(#* *(- (0 # * *0 (" (. 0

# (+(- (*(- 1"(#( 4 )/!) & # )* .( .**

# .)0* "

0))

#( (+ ))* "( # *# ( #./*( (* "((

((()(( 0 )/( /

())+ )(/!*.

(

*# !(#( ./* .)0 * (+) # ) *

( (+* )0# F# !4 ((* "(( (( %**# .)0* "

- ++("(+ 0)) (+* * # ! *( (#( * # ## #!( . )!* !(( "

* */* "# (- (*(- 1"(#( =*# .)0* " )# (+* (* # (* # * * .0***0 )#(#(/# *)"

(0**/ (- (!* !

*( ( ( (( . =*# .)0* " )# (+* * ( )#

(#((* # 1?*

*(?6&0 + (+* (0*(#**(- ( 0# * =* # (* )

"*(" ))+ ./ (* *0 ( .0# *

&* + &(+*+ (+

1 *("( ## *0 * * 0

./ * ((1# &* + &(+* *# ) +(" /

) (+* / 4"(0 *## (+# ./*# .)0

#2 ((+* ("

)#( (+*)((

6 # * "(( ((! 4 * (

(##+(

" ("

*( # ))(+ . ( )

0(** (+# ./* # .)0 (# ( + - (#* (0*() #2 ((+*

## (+)/!* "(( (((*./ (( 3 6