High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/427/2012disposed of

Manoj Kumar Etc. v. State Of Haryana

2017-11-29Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

!"!#$%$&'(

&)*+,-$&" .!-% !/$%$&$% % 0!-%+% 1 !-2& !%3&"!&

45 1 * 51 -!%!& '6

- *1$&789"/# !9--!/$%$&$% %

-:& -79 -2& ;.! .!- .!!3- !-%8#8&!:%33!-,2<!88:!" %!! .!)+"7,!& = <!-!!--!" .!!3- !--& > ;.! .!- .!)+"7,!& %.+8"<!-!3- !"$& .!"$7!% = 66 66 * 51 5

+% "2#!- $$# !%$8!"$& +- "2&"%,!-! ?!&& -!#-" .$%-!/$%$&$%$8!"7$&% )+"7,!& " !"93%%!" <2 .!8!-&!"1!%%$&%+"7!9$&"9$-,$&7 .!)+"7,!& #&/$# $& " !"@&"-"!-%!& !&#!" !"@@93%%!"<2 .!8!-&!" 1+<$/$%$&8+"$#$8 7$% - !9-:&9$% -$# $&"9/$"!:.$#.88 .-!!-!/$%$&$% %9&,!829,*+,-9.$%:$! &)*+,-$&".$% &!3.!:8<$-8$%$88+:!-!#&/$# !"+&"!-1!# $&%>> -!":$ .

1!# $&> 9&"+&"!-1!# $&>@ -!":$ .1!# $&> .!2 :!-!%!& !&#!" +&"!-7-$7-+%$,3-$%&,!& - .-!!,& .%!#.

66 +&"!- 1!# $& >> -!" :$ . 1!# $& > .!2:!-! +- .!- %!& !&#!" +&"!-7-$7-+%$,3-$%&,!& -&!2!-!#.&" 32 $&!%@ 6!#.+&"!-1!# $&>@ -!":$ .1!# $&> . .!%!& !&#!%:!-!"$-!# !" -+&#&#+--!& 82 + $&!,+& 9 $ -!#/!-!"9 % 6 :% "$-!# !" <! 3$" $&)+-!" % #,3!&% $&9:.!-!%-!,$&$&7%@ 6%.887 .!1 !%$&! -$!# % .!#%!9%#,$&7+ -, .!% !,!& $&)+-!"%.:-+ A ,"! .!38$#!&(@9-! . .!-! :% "$%3+ ! -!7-"$&7 $&% 88$&7 !8!3.&! #&&!# $& $&% 88!" 33%$ ! .! .+%! , *+,- .! 15 + .-$ $!% 7/! #&&!# $& -, .!38!$&% 88!" 33%$ ! .! .+%!##+%!"

, *+,-&B(@ &@@9:.!&%.:-+ #,38$&& :% 7$&7&.$%<$#2#8!&"-!#.!"$&-& .+%!,*+,-9, *+,-#,!+ #--2$&7&$-&-"&"7/!<8:& .!<#?%.- + #,38$&& !!88":&& .!,!&:.$8!9 &)*+,-$:$! ,*+,-&".$%&!3.!:8<$-8$%$88+ 8%#,! .!-!#--2$&7 8 .$%&"7/!<8:%& .!88!&%.:-+ ,*+,-7/!&$-& -"<8:& .!8! .&"#,38$&& &"& .!-8 .$<8::%7$/!& <2&!3.!:,*+,-,*+,- .!&7/!& .!-$-&-"<8: & .!8! <!8: .!?&!!##+%!",*+,-8%7/!<-$#?< <8:& .!&%!#,38$&& !/$%$&$% -$%!"8-,9&:.$#.?!%. *+,--!#.!" .!%3 &"-!,/!".$, .%3$ 8 !-! .!8:!- +- 9#,38$&& 33!-!" %+33- .$% #%!

1, *-$%.&8%33!-!"&"%+33- !" .!3-%!#+ $&#%! ./!.!-" .!8!-&!"#+&%!8--!/$%$&$% %9 .!8!-&!" 1 !#+&%!8&"./!8%#-!+8827&! .-+7. .!$8!&"8:!

6>6 $8!%:!88 %3!- .!% !,!& -)!%. +3 ;> 988:$&7$/!

$&)+-$!%:!-!+&"& .!3!-%&%.:-+ #,38$&& '6 C <-%$&&&%!:%3-!%!& <-%$&&"%:!88$&78! -!-,:%3-!%!& >

+8 $38!<-%$&%&-$7. -!-,:!-!3-!%!&

+8 $38!<-%$&%&<#?:!-!3-!%!& @

,38$&$&73$&+33!- !! .:%3-!%!& D 88 .!$&)+-$!%:!-!#+%!":$ .<8+& :!3&&" .!"+- $& :%:$ .$&%$A.+-% .!-!:%-# +-!&&%8<&!% :!88% -# +-!& .!8! -$< -*1.-,; 3-/!"88:$&7+-$&)+-$!%& .!

3!-%&*-$%.&:$!%.:-'6 C !""$%.<8+!#& +%$&& .!-$7. %#3+8--!7$& %$E!#,A@#,:$ . !&"!-&!%% !""$%.#& +%$&%$E!B#,A#,& .!8:!- 8 !-8%$"!-$7. <",!& > :-!""$%.#& +%$&%%$E!@DA>#,&"@#,A>#, & .!+33!-&",$"8 !-8%$"!8! .$7. !""$%.#& +%$&%$E!DA>D& .!8! <+ #?:$ . !&"!-&!%%D 88 .!$&)+-$!%:!-!+&" <!%$,38!$&& +-!&"3-<<8! "+- $&:%:$ .$&.+-% #,!%+ . :.!&%$"%.:-+ 33!-!"$& +- 9.!

8%#8$,!" . .$%:$!*-$%.&:%8%7$/!&$&)+-$!%<2##+%!" :!/!-9$& .!$-% &-, $&!3- 9&$&)+-2$%88!7!" ./!<!!& #+%!" %$"*-$%.& .!8!-&!"#+&%!8- -!/$%$&$% %.%-7+!" . &) *+,-$-!/$%$&$% $% !#.!-<23-!%%$&&"%.!.%<!!&8%!82

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

&)+-$!%#+%!" *-$%.&9:$!%.:- + 9:!-!&!/!-88!7!"$& .!#,38$& .!-!-!9 .!$,3-/!"/!-%$& 7$/!&$& .! +- #&& <!<!8$!/!".!-!$% !&"!&#2$& .!3- % .! #+& -2 -3!$& .!-,!,<!-% .!,$828&7:$ .,$&##+%!" .!-!-!9 .!3%%$<$8$ 2-3$&7$& .!:$!,$&##+%!",*+,- &".$%&!3.!:$% .!-!.!-8! -$<+ !" &)*+,-$&"8<$- 8$%$88+$%8%& #--<- !"<2,!"$#8!/$"!&#! !&#!9-!/$%$& F+ &) *+,-$ &" 8<$- 8$% $88+ -!/$%$&$% % &" > -!%3!# $/!82 $%88:!"&" .!2% &"#F+$ !" .!#.-7!%-,!" 7$&% .!,.!$-<$8<&"%&"%+-! 2<&"%% &""$%#.-7!" :9#,$&7 .!-8!##+%!",*+,-9 .!8!-&!" #+&%!8--!/$%$&$% .%#& !&"!" . .!3-!%%!%.$%#%!

&82& .! F+& +,%!& !&#! .!,!"$#8!/$"!&#!9%"$%#+%%!"</!9%.:% . .!-!

6@6 -# +-!& .!&%8<&!&"8! -$<.!%!$&)+-$!%:!-! -$<+ !" ,*+,--!/$%$&$% ##+%!",*+,-.", $/! %%+8 .!#,38$&& 9:.$%+-.$ <23-!%%$&.!-!:!-!8%"$%3+ !% <! :!!& .!3- $!% *!!3$&7$&/$!: .! -# +-!%& .!&%! &" 8! -$<9% "$%#+%%!" </!9 .!-! $% & 7-+&" -!8!%! ##+%!" , *+,- -!/$%$&$% &3-< $&!&#!9-!/$%$&F+##+%!",*+,- -!/$%$&$% $%"$%,$%%!"!<!-!--!% !"&"#,,$ !" )$8 +&"!-7 .!-!,$&$&73- %!& !&#! &/$!:</!9-!/$%$&$%3- 8288:!" * 51

( %)?% ;.! .!-%3!?$&7 -!%&!"

!% ;.! .!-!3- <8!