High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/613/2012dismissed

Satish Kumar v. Yash Pal & ANR

2017-10-11Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan9 pages

$" % #& ' #"

"( ") *+ " ''&

) *+ "

"#"'

, ) *+ " "'

! % '&) **-) ."/ "+ ' 2 & 2/ !'&'") !' ,, 3 ,! ' 2/ &" ( ,) & 4 "2/ "' 5 4 6 7" 8"! '" 5 9 :) "," "

;:9*) ;< 8 #& #& 3 2" &, "," '" 78 " &) ) 4 !"" 4 "' 5 '" . : 4"/ 4 ,+ !&/ "' ! !"", 2 / 4"

''/ 4 4"/ ,+ " ", " *2 + /

'"" " ) / " '"& ! "!

: : :) "' 5 &'

&&/ & !'& 2" " & 2 3 ) " " !"!& !) " "' 5 ! " 4" ", " '"! 1 !'& " " &&, ", " / !"!& !) 4 = 2/ "' 5 " " 4

+, 4 ' !) & 2 """ !

" " "' 5 & = ,+ ! "+ 2/ " "!

" "&"

2 +"

4 & = 2", 34&&"/ "!

" '"&

" " !'& 2", && ! "" !) 4 & 2 1 !'& ! =4 9 : "' ! = ' & " ! 4"/ 4 &&& *" "," ) +, 4 && 4 '" " 2 4 ", + "" :::) 4

'& , &/ &! "& 8 "" '"+ ) '" >! #? " 3+ -",) #? * 8 ! # &) #? @. " A&) #?;

. & !") #?B #&) "!) #? #"+ !") #?

!") !'&) #?9 " ! A) #?: ! # &) " &) #? 8 4"

, ) "

#? 8 - ! & + ?

>! "

"#) '& 8 ) >! ? $3"

, ? <" ! #"= *"

", &" & " '" '" , + 2" , "") &" "& " 6 ", "! , ! 7&, ,,"+) !'&C'" & '" "+ ' 1 ' & / "+C''& , 3 ,! 6 & . '" "+ ' A" & " '" !'& ""

;:9* ; < 8# 2! '" &&/ '"+ "! + & 2 "& ' & = '& !"!& ! 4 4 /" !"", 1 &" "& " "" ''", ! #?

!'& #?: !'

&) 4 &"&/ '"+ & 4 &/ " 2/ 2) "' 5 = ) ! "&4 " ", " 2", !" 4"/ 4&& """, '"'"/ 2D ! 1 '"

'" "&+ + ''" 4

2 ""2" 2/ 4/ !& + 2/ >!, #?9) "

! A) 4 4 !!2" !& 2") 4

;

'!"! >! 2/ & ' 4 !' & ! ! '

', . " " ", ", +,) 4 "!) 4 2/ 4 &/,) 4 2& "! 44 D(&D 4 ! !, + 2 2/ " !, "! " ' , 2/ ) 4 2" + 4&& !'", "!

) &" & ''", 2 & "' 5 2! " 4 + "" '"+ "' 5 &" "& " " ''", +"/ ' !") ", &/ 6 "' 5 ." '" "" 8 ) ! !"", 24 "' 5 & 4 &!E :) '" . " "! & !! 9 : " !, & ! ! '

1 '" &&, (& 44 4 ) #?

8 - ! ' #? 8 8 4"

, + ! != "/ " , 44 " !=, & D(&D " ", '" & D(&D " "! " , 44 ' " "

2&, ! "! 8 ') !

D(&D 4 4 / , " ! 1 ) 4 & &) 4 4 & + 2& " "! "! " 2+ " 4 !! 2/ !, & ! ! '

A" "& " 4 & 6 , 2"+ " F;

& 4 '" ' G ! '"" *", ! ! 4 "!+ "!

" ""/ 2&" . " " ' '" 4 > .'&) ' 8 4 & ! 2/ ! ! '" !' 2/ "D

& , " 1 , 4 2 ", " & '& * ' ! & / !'& ,

& +& " ,"+ , ) ) 2/ 4/ ''" , " "/ 1 4 & !, /) !) + "!

/6 !, + 2 2& = ! . 4 & '" !'&/ & & "" 7"! && " !) &=

"& 2& 3 "& 4 +"!) !/ 2 &&, " !!

4 & ", "! &! " 4 ", '"

&"/ 2 +" 2/ 4 '"

"&/ " " "!

" '"& "

/ " !'/ #?

#?: " / * 2/ !"

" " !"& ! && & 2/ 2 1 4 && +"/ , 4 ,, +"/ 4&& !"& ! 8 &= ! , "'" 24 4 #?) !/ 2 4 D ! ") ", " / 4 ! "

/ 8 4 &=, .+, "& 2 2& !'"! 4 ! + = " ' " & 2/ !!, 2/ !, & ! ! '

@+ 2 " &+ 4" 2 " 2" !!, . 2 ,,"+ &/ , ! + & ! 4" , &, , " &/ 4) /) 23 2/

4 4&& &/ ?

4" 4 & 2 " &"&/ 4 & ,"+ , 8 4 " " 2/ " 4 ,+ & 2/ , &, @># 2/

& +"/ 4&& " " " !"& & , 4 ''" , ," " & !'/ < ''&/ +& "&/ " " !"& & && & 2/ 2 *"

+, " " "! " 4 + 2 23 / " &/ " " 4 ! 4"/ 2 = 2" " 4 23 " &/ " " 4 ! 4"/ 2/ 8

'" !' "

< 8 @+ * 2 "4 ;; * " & !/ ",, 4 !", & '" !"2&/ & 2& , ", "

;:9 * ;< 8# 2/ &, , +, + 1 !/ " 4

! # & #?:) 4 4" "& 2" " " &) '" " " "" "2+ & &4 & 4 2/ '> " """

"2+ 8 2 / " " !

+, 2" , " & 2", 4 !2 2+ ",) 8 ! " +4 "+ 2 6 2+ ", " >, ! 2 2H 8

!"# !

$ %&'( !")) *+,-+.-/,+) .D2& '"! " & " F ?

6 "!& ",) ", + ! 2 " E " +"/ =, 4/ ", '" !' " " ", 2/ 6 & " " "!& 3 "'" 1 "

+ & 4 +4 " '2& + ) + "2& ) !/ 2 ' 2/ "

.4+") '"'& ! 2 ''& =', +4 " ! !2 " & 4 " '" '"+ 2/ "2& 2 8 '"

",, ) """ ''" + ''" "" " "" 3 ,! 6 & " 3 " ! & ' " 4 !" "!& 3 "+&+ ; 8 & '"'& "!& 3 "'" 2 " '" & '" '"+ ", 2/ "2& 2 1 '" !' ", " "& " 4 , " +&2& " " "!& 3 /! 2 '" '"+ + & 2/ '" ) 3 4

+ " + "") ) ' ""2&/ & , &/ " "" + 4 3 ,! 6 & 1 3 ,! 6 & !, 2 2 ' !''" + " ''" +& & "!&

3 "'" H 8 & &4 2 & " "0' 1

2!#"($+,,+*3. *$(%("4.56, + +4 ''" + '2&) " 4&& "" 6 & 8 6 &) " 2& '" !' I &/) +, " 6 &) " 4&& "" & 4 & +&/ " , & ""2& 8 '" ) '" & '"+ , C "' 5 " '+&/ , &, / 3 & / , & !" / "" 2/ " *",&/) , !" "+ ') ! "2/ !

* .

,+ 7!

$ 8 9("2:$ "

$$ $=4 <