High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/198/2019dismissed

M/S Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And Another

2020-01-15Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan7 pages

!"#$%& %%## ' ( ) * +% ! " # ! "" $%&%'(

$")'*%%+,)-.*/0)(% $(1%)++%--)'( ,,())!- 1%)++%)-2'*%$"%0(3'45 (1%)$,)'))-2%**%*)6 0(. 47 $8$%/3(,. (1% 40( 93& 3-%*):)3'&($*%$*)(%*;4

+)&&%*8,)$,)'))6$382')-.1)'*3:)$17 $&1$(. (1%$382')- 9 *3&<3&&3':(1%$%/3%=)++-30)(3')&(3<%>8)$$%*'(1%)++%)-. --=3':

&28&()'(3)-?2%&(3'& -)=1)/%8%%'0-)3<%* @739 #1%(1%$'(1% )0(&)'*3'(1%03$02<&()'0%& 0)&%.

(1% !* $382')- 3& A2&(3 3%* 3' *3&<3&&3': (1% %/3%= %(3(3')&(3<%8)$$%*8,1-*3':(1%'&2

303%'(:$2'* 1)&8%%':3/%'3'(1%++-30)(3' *%-),B 7339#1%(1%$'(1% )0(&)'*3'(1%03$02<&()'0%& (1%0)&%.

(1% )&&%&&<%'( $)<%* 3' (1% +$%&%'( 0)&% 3& 8)$$%* 8, -3<3()(3'3'(1%-3:1( :3/%'A2*:<%'(&BC

1% )0(&'%0%&&)$, $)*A2*30)(3' (1%)++%)-)$%(1)((1% )&&%&&<%'(,%)$3'/-/%*3& > (30%3'(1% $< "> ; $

$)<3':(1%)&&%&&<%'(=)&3&&2%*' ; 51%$%=)&)'3&&2%=3(1 $%:)$*(8$)'01($)'& %$&<)*%8,(1%)++%--)'(>0<+)',1%)&&%&&<%'( =)& 3')-3&%*' .)')**3(3')-*%<)'* 44.5 .45. 45D>=)& 0$%)(%*::$3%/%* (1%)&&%&&<%'($*%$.(1%)++%--)'(+$% %$$%*(1% )++%)-1%3'(603&%E)6)(3'<<3&&3'%$79.1()F71%$%3') (%$ $% %$$%* ( )& (1% &( ++%--)(% 2(1$3(, 9 *3&<3&&%* (1% )++%)- '

4 2$(1%$)++%)-=)& 3-%*8% $%(1%$382')-1%3&&2%

8$)'01($)'& %$&=)&)-&&28A%0(><)((%$3'(1%)++%)- $(1%)&&%&&<%'( ,%)$ 4>G$(1%&)3*)&&%&&<%'(,%)$./3*%$*%$*)(%* G H.(1% <)((%$=)&$%<)'*%*8)0F8,(1%$382')-((1%&&%&&3':2(1$3(,( ()F%)*%03&3') $%&13'/3%= (1%8&%$/)(3'&<)*%8,%'($)-")-%& )6++%--)(%2(1$3(,3'0)&% (1%)++%--)'(3(&%- 1%)++%)- $(1% )&&%&&<%'(,%)$ > )-':=3(1)++%)-& $(1%$)&&%&&<%'(,%)$&

(1% )++%--)'( =%$% *3&+&%* ' H H 3' (%$<& $*%$ *)(%* G H1%)++%)-&=%$%*3&+&%* 3'(1%+$%&%'0% 02'&%- $(1% )++%--)'( 1%)++%--)'(+&%*'01)--%':%($*%$*)(%* H H *3&+&3': (1%)++%)-&3'(%$<& (1%$*%$*)(%* G H $(1% )&&%&&<%'(,%)$ 4>G=%/%$.) (%$$%0%3+( '(30%*)(%*

3&&2%*8,(1%&&%&&3':2(1$3(,(*%03*%(1%$%<)'*+$0%%*3':&.(1% )++%--)'( 3-%* $%/3%= )++-30)(3' ' H )00<+)'3%* 8, )'

)++-30)(3' *%-), ;;*),&1%$382')-$%A%0(%*(1% )++-30)(3' *%-),)'**3&<3&&%*(1%$%/3%=)++-30)(3'

)&(3<%>8)$$%*.1%'0%(1%+$%&%'()++%)-

4 !%)$'%*02'&%- $(1%)++%--)'()$:2%*(1)((1%$382')-%$$%* 3''(0'*'3':(1%*%-),(3&0'(%'*%*(1)((1%$%=)&&2

303%'(0)2&%

$ '( 3-3': (1% $%/3%= )++-30)(3' =3(13' (1% +$%&0$38%* +%$3*

-3<3()(3'1%&28<3&&3'<)*%3&(1)((1%)++%)-&=%$%*3&+&%* /3*%) 0<<'$*%$)'*(1%3&&2%(1)(3'&+3(% (1%$%8%3':' -3<3()(3'

+$%&0$38%*2'*%$(1%)$,)')%'%$)-")-%&)60(. H47 $&1$(. (1%

H40( 9.(1%)&&%&&<%'(&12-*1)/%8%%'0<+-%(%*=3(13'$%)&')8-% (3<%3%=3(13' 3/%,%)$&(12:1$)3&%*3'(1%:$2'*& )++%)-=)&'( +$%&&%*)((1%(3<% 3')-*3&+&)- ( =2-* 8% +%$(3'%'( ( '(% 1%$% (1)( (1% H4 0( =)& $%+%)-%*=% 4 4 4)'*(1% 40(=)&%'

$0%* $< G 4 1%$%/3%=)++-30)(3'=)& 3-%*2'*%$"%0(3'4; (1% 40()'*(1% -3<3()(3' $ 3-3':(1%$%/3%=)++-30)(3'3& *),& 1%)++%--)'(1)&'(*3&+2(%*$)(1%$)*<3((%*(1)((1%3&&2%

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

G )++-30)(3'=3(13'(1%-3<3()(3'$ *%-), ;;*),& 1%'-,:$2'*()F%'3&(1)(3(=)&'-,) (%$$%0%3+( '(30%3'(1% $%<)'*+$0%%*3':&(1)(3(=)&$%)-3&%*(1)((1%3&&2% '( 3')-3&3':(1% )&&%&&<%'(=3(13'(1%$%)&')8-%(3<%=)&'(+$%&&%*3'(1%)++%)-1% %6+-)')(3'+2( $(13&'(&2

303%'( $0'*'3':(1%*%-),.$)(1%$3( %&()8-3&1%&'%:-3:%'0%'(1%+)$( (1%)++%--)'(1%$%)&'&<%'(3'%* 3'(1%)++-30)(3' *%-),)$%$%+$*20%*8%-= @41)((1%*%-),3'(1%+$%&%'(0)&%1)&002$$%* $(1% $%)&'(1)((1%)++%)- $(1%,%)$3'0'&3*%$)(3'=)& *%03*%*)-':=3(182'01 )++%)-&8,(13&' 8-%02$(3'

=1301&3<3-)$3&&2%=)&3'/-/%*)-':=3(1(1%3&&2%

-3<3()(3'1%$%) (%$.3'$%<)'*+$0%%*3':&.(1%!*603&% )')6)(3'

30%$1)*3&&2%*(30%& $ $)<3': $%&1 )&&%&&<%'(3'/3%= (1%$*%$ (13&' 8-%2$( $ *3

%$%'()&&%&&<%'(,%)$&1% )0( -3<3()(3'0)<%((1% '(30% (1%

303)-& (1%)&&%&&%%=13-%&0$2(3'3I3':(1%

3-%& %)01,%)$ )'*3(=)&$%)-3&%*(1)((1%3&&2%

-3<3()(3'=)&'(*%03*%*8,(13&' 8-%2$(C ((13&&():%.3(<),8%'(%*(1)(8% $%(1% &( ++%--)(% 2(1$3(,)-&.(1%)++%)-=)&*3&+&%* 8%3':&3<3-)$()++%)- $(1% )&&%&&<%'(,%)$ 4>G 1%&)3*)&+%0(3&'(8%3':*3&+2(%*)((13& &():%1%'-,0'(%'(3'3&(1)((1%$%=)&)')**3(3')-3&&2%=1301=)& '(2$:%*)((1%(3<% *3&+&)- (1%)++%)- 1%$%3&-3<3()(3' +$%&0$38%* $&36<'(1& $ 3-3': (1% $%/3%=)++-30)(3'/%'(1%$%) (%$. $<$%(1)';*),&.(1%$%/3%= )++-30)(3'=)&'( 3-%*1%3&&2)'0% '(30%3'(1%$%<)'*+$0%%*3':&

; 8,(1%&&%&&3':2(1$3(,3(&%- 0)''(8%):$2'* $0'*'3':(1% *%-),1%3&&2%(1)((1%)&&%&&<%'(=)&'( 3')-3&%*=3(13'(1%$%)&')8-% (3<%3&'()+2$%?2%&(3' -)=82(=2-**%+%'*2+'(1% )0(2)-)&+%0( %)010)&% 1%*%-),3&'((8%0'*'%*<%01)'30)--,1%$%3&)-&' ?2388-%'(1%+$+&3(3'(1)()-38%$)-)++$)01&12-*8%)*+(%*( 0'*'%(1%*%-),. 1=%/%$ (1%)++$)01 =3-- 8% *3

%$%'( 3' 0)&%

3'$*3')(%*%-), 1% "2+$%<% 2$( 3' "# . $*.# !&'-/!#'#%.$% * 0 1+$+0$'#1

21%-*)&2'*%$ @ #%1)/%0'&3*%$%*(1%$%&+%0(3/%&28<3&&3'&1%-)= -3<3()(3'3& 2'*%*'+28-30+-30,1%-%:3&-)(2$% *%&'(+$%&0$38%-3<3()(3'=3(1(1%8A%0( *%&($,3':

(1%$3:1(& (1%+)$(3%&82((%'&2$%(1)((1%,*'($%&$( (*3-)($,()0(30&)'*&%%F$%<%*,=3(12(*%-),1%3*%)3& (1)(%/%$,-%:)-$%<%*,<2&(8%F%+()-3/% $)+%$3* 36%* 8,(1%-%:3&-)(2$%+2(3(*3

%$%'(-,.(1%-)= -3<3()(3'

+$%&0$38%&)+%$3*=3(13'=1301-%:)-$%<%*,0)'8%)/)3-%*

$$%*$%&& (1%-%:)-3'A2$,((1%&)<%(3<%.(1%02$(& )$% 8%&(=%* =3(1 (1% +=%$ ( 0'*'% (1% *%-),. 3

303%'(0)2&%3&&1=' $'()/)3-3':(1%$%<%*,=3(13'

(1% &(3+2-)(%* (3<% 1% %6+$%&&3' J&2

303%'( 0)2&%J %<+-,%*3'"%0(3'; (1%'*3)'!3<3()(3'0(. )'*&3<3-)$(1%$&()(2(%&3&%-)&(30%'2:1(%')8-%(1% 02$(&()++-,(1%-)=3')<%)'3':

2-<)''%$=1301&28 &%$/%&(1%%'*& A2&(30% -(12:1.'1)$*)'* )&($2-%

5 0)' 8% -)3* *=' 3' *%)-3': =3(1 (1% )++-30)(3'& $ 0'*')(3' *%-),.(13&2$(1)&A2&(3 3)8-,)*/0)(%* )*+(3' )-38%$)-)++$)013'0'*'3':(1%*%-),

&1$(*2$)(3')'*)&($30(%$)++$)01=1%$%(1%*%-),3& 3'$*3')(%C

1%+1$)&% &2

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

303%'( 0)2&% =2-* :%( 3' (1% )0(2)- <)($36 ):3/%'0)&%=2-*-)$:%-,*%+%'*'8') 3*% ')(2$% (1%%6+-)')(3' (1%2$( 3'*&(1)((1%$%1)& 8%%'''%:-3:%'0%'(1%+)$( (1%)++-30)'()'*(1%0)2&% &1=' $(1%*%-),*%&'(-)0F8') 3*%&.(1%'3(<), 0'*'%(1%*%-), .'(1%(1%$1)'*.(1%%6+-)')(3'

:3/%'8,(1%)++-30)'(3& 2'*(8%0'00(%*$1%3& (1$2:1-,'%:-3:%'(3'+$&%02(3':13&0)2&%.(1%'3(=2-*

H 8%)-%:3(3<)(%%6%$03&% *3&0$%(3''((0'*'%(1% *%-), ' 0)&%& 3'/-/3': (1% "()(% )'* 3(& ):%'03%&D3'&($2<%'()-3(3%&.(1%2$(0)'()F%'(% (1% )0( (1)(&2

303%'((3<%3&()F%'3'(1%*%03&3'<)F3':+$0%&& 82( '+$%<32<0)' 8%:3/%' $(()--%(1)$:,$2((%$ '%:-3:%'0%'(1%+)$( (1%

30%$& (1%"()(%)'*D$3(& ):%'03%& D 3'&($2<%'()-3(3%& )'* (1% )++-30)(3'& 3-%* 8, (1%< *%-),0)''(8%)--=%*)&)<)((%$ 02$&%8,)00%+(3':(1%+-%)(1)(*3&<3&&)- (1%<)((%$ '(1%:$2'* 8)$ -3<3()(3'=3--0)2&%3'A2$,((1% +28-303'(%$%&(C '(1%+$%&%'(0)&%.)+)$( $<&36<'(1&+$%&0$38%*-3<3()(3'.

(1%$%3&*%-), ;;*),&.(1%%6+-)')(3'+2( $(13&'(=$(1)00%+()'0% '/3%= (1%)8/%.?2%&(3'7390-)3<%*8,(1%)++%--)'( 3&)'&=%$%*):)3'&(3( K2%&(3'73390-)3<%**%&'()$3&%2( (1%$*%$ (1% $382')-)&(1%&)<%$)3&%&3&&2%'<%$3(&=1%$%)&(1%$%/3%=)++-30)(3' =)&*3&<3&&%*8,(1%$382')-'(1%:$2'* -3<3()(3')-'% 1%)++%)-3&*3&<3&&%* 0,,())!-1 07,8+!1 9-,9-, )'2)$, ;. <F #1%(1%$&+%)F3':D$%)&'%*

%&D #1%(1%$$%+$()8-%

%&D