Commissioner Of Central Excise, Delhi Iii v. Suzuki Powertrain India Ltd.
!""#
!
" # $! %&$ " '"'"'(& %&$'" '&
$ % " &' "
(
" % " ( )
" ***** "'"') *)+), )-" +
,-.'/
0122.
3 4/ ( 5 ) +
+ &
67"7,"6708 . ,/
&9
"
( & )
+ ) ( )
( ) : ) . / ) ) % ( ) ' + ): )# &; )# % ). /+ + ) ) ) & &9 & " 6" + ( (
..
// 0 1 20), 3
/ 4/" ,20)2 * . 2 &2 "- & 56 .7)8
9 )
) &9 &
(
& ) & )
"+
9 ( ( (
( ) & )
<
9 ) & ) 9 " & )
&
&
<
9 " ," % " ' )
9 &
< ( ,20)2 *. 2&2 "/9:0)
" + ( ( & &9 + &
&9
( (
& "
#"0==72012; ( & ) )
) #"0,,021,>; ( (
) &
9
9
" 2" 20),3
/4/",,/
)92 .: 2/
) " &2 "- # ' # &9 ) ? ""'""
@ & " ( 9
&(
9 &
(
9
" :
( 9
& ( # 6.
/ )
# 6772.
36772 # 4/"
< ( Page No.2
20), 3
/ 4/" $)092 '9;9<
) &2 "- = #6' )?< ( "+ ( ()
)
% A( ) # & ) &<
,20)2 *. 2&2 " /9:0) & " -
(
) ) ) 9 &
&
(
( 9 & " ( 9 )
6,"76"6700 . 6/
(
9 677- 6778
) 9&
&9 & )
9
9
&9
" #
,,/
) 92 .: 2/ /9:0)
& &9
& &9 <
)
( & )
" >" 6.
/ 6772# $ B,> :92/0?
@.) /) 8/0?
./ &9 )
) ) ( )C ./ &9
9
9
D
)
EF Page No.3
="
%; % &((
&
@ 9( ( &
9 ) & &9 9 9 & 9
& )
( & (
9
9 &9
)
)" ( 9 )
)
) ) 9
9
9
" 8" ,,/
) 92 .: 2/ /9:0)
)
)
&
9 &( &9
)
9 &9
9
& & " # ) < ( $ B>"+
) (& )
( 9 ) 9
(
9" +
(
9" +
" +( B )F ) )
9 & 9 &
C
9 ) 9 ) 9 &
&9 B )F
& )
3
9
94 3
4 &9 ") Page No.4
) (
"
( )
) G 0112 &
)
) 9 (
9" ) 9 3 )4 3( 4" )
"
)
) ) ) 9 &<
9
)
" ( ?
72"70"6778" +
)
) B )F
( )
9
9
""
" ="H 9 ( % " (4 & &
)
) & &9
)
# " % " ( (
9 6.
/&9 ) (
( 3 4
3 4
&
(9 ( ) ) &(
9
9 9 )
4
" 8" +
9" +
9
" +
9 I
9)
9
)
"?
9
) &
9 &
"+
9 &9
9)
Page No.5
9
"+ 4
# 6.
/
9 &9 % " ( B
F" 1"+ 4
# 6.
/"" B )F
"+
B )F
9 )
(
9" % " ( (
9
4
)
(
9"+ & (
&9
6.
/./ & 3 )4
(
9 ) )"+ )
9 ) &9 )
(
9 &9 & "
( ( 6.
/./
)
)" + B )F
"
9&((
"F 1"
(
9(
& &
677= 6707"
9 6700 # 6.
/ 6772#
)
3 )4
) ) &9 )&
"+
(
9 ) ( )
3 )4 ) " Page No.6
07" 20),3
/4/"$)092 '9;9<
)&2 /9:0)- ) ? ( & % A( ) # & ) 9( < ( ) ,)
) ?2" &2 " ?/" ..
// 0 1 20), 3
/- 6 ' = 3 )4 &9
&
( &
( ( )
) & ( )
"
..
// 0 1 20),3
/-,* 4/"$)092 '9;9<
)&2 "-5$=#- (
?
( ))
(
" 00" #
9 ( ) &)
&
I
&9
"+
( 9" "'"'(& & ""#
H
(; $ J K H #
$ J K Page No.7