High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13292/2022disposed of

Mohinder Singh Chahal v. State Of Haryana And Another

2025-07-17Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj12 pages

$%& '()($* +,-,.-./ 0+1.2.0.-..

$ 0+1.3-0.-..

!"',!&%-%.$/ (%0 0"-

+"-%.$/ (%.

%-"'%-%1%.$/ (%.

1! %1.$/ (%%$

#-%-%.$/ (%

- ""

%-!' /.$$'

%2% % 33333

!"# % ( && #"/%( &%%"# & - %& $ %&%'

($"#%$%''#"#" $"% %$'%2"-$"4!&

-2-

"%'$!.4 -- ""

-%/4" "!$%$%-(4"# $" $

42- -"( && $

" ( %( ". - - 0/. 4"# &%$ & "'$%

- ""

.0- 0/"#

!4 "/""

%' #"(!'!%'

"(. 0 % "$ % & &4

% -&&4 ) &&"( "!$

4%""#%'$8!

&-'

(%'&%7. "( & '"%(

- $$%$ 5" !$42- !2 "( . #"(!'!. - -"0%"

- ( "!"

- %"$ ) &&". - !2 "(

. #"(!'!. -"0%" -%$.

/"$ ( &&!"(%"

$%$

5. %$$ $$ ( &&!"(%"

/% "

/& %#(" 7"#"

&% %"

% 0---"&

$ 4 (!$0 %/%"'%4' 0"- -& %"'! %$ !% %' 42 - %"$

/& %#(" "$"

"(%%/%"'%4"'"2

-8!"" (7. - %

$ ) &&"0% "!$ ''2

%$"('

'2'"&"$ 4%""#%'$ 8!

& "/%%#("

& '"%( 0"- - %

"$ &%$%. - ) &&"

4%"$%'$ 8!

&$"

%# ("%$$!'2!4&"$- %& -

"( (

!2 "( .#"(!'!

!.-"0%"

!4 48!'2. % !(-% $ 0 0% '%($ 42 - !2 "( . #"(!

!'!. -"0%" 9 5 " %/ !

; #"

-3-

)'""(<#" !").-"0%"

*%.

%( & '%"0% ! $'2 ("/$"'% "

-%"$ (!&.0- !

- !2 "( . #"(!'!. - -"0%". /"$ ( &&!"(%"

$% $ 5 5 %$$$ -$$""

%' !2) &&""

.('%"

"$ -% "#!'%"2-%$4 &&"$42- -!(-%) &&""- (!&

-&$"(" = (2('">

/-'.% '"&"%2 8!"20%"""%$."0-"(- - ""

0 0% "- % ("%$ %

$$ %2

!"2

-%"# ?

/ !%''2.%(-%#-$%$5

50%/$!

- ""

42 - "(" %' (%2.

%2%%. %&

#"(!'! / - !#-. - ""

0% $! "

& /"(. %%""# - %#

! % !%"

. 5 - ""

$!'2

"'$%$%"'$%$( & - "/ '2 -%"$(-%# - 0/ . 0"-%$"# - %&.

- $%!- "" ($$ %

" % #!'% 8!"2

"( ( $!( % $ %&%' 8!"2" - %"$(-%# -(-%#

&4 4@@'&%$-!

% &'()**'+,

-4-

, - 8!"2

"( ( $!($ % % $%"'$ 8!"2 " &%%$!4& &"$-" $%$ 5E 5 9.0-"% ("

"( "$"# 0% ( $$ -

( -% - (-%# %""# %''#%"

&4@@'&

!$42-&&4

-) ) &&"" /$ - . - 0/ . $ -% % "%("%' '

. % $ % :.555;. -%$ %''#$'2 ((! $ - "$"#%$( ('!"

%( $$42- 8!"2

"("-" $%$ 5E 59%

$!($-"4'

%$2 (A -

.+/

$ "

)0'''+,1(2''''+23

*% %$ ( !'

- ""

!4&" -% % ( 2

%"$ 8!"2

0% /$ !

- ""

/"$ &&

69 #"C:D59;

;B:: $%$ 5:

5 5:. "! $ 42 - $$""

%' )-"

(%2 - -

%2%%. %&

#"(!'!.

-5-

0-" " 0% /2$ -% - ( & %!- "2 ( (! 0"- - ('!"

%"/ /$%42- 8!"2

- ""

.-% .!4&"$ $%$%"'$ '2" -

0/ . "%'$(""

0%%74 42- $%!- "" " (

- - %"$ $"(" '"%2 ($"# !"' 5?

55. - %& -%/"# 4 $ $ 6

55 "

!- ( $$ -% - ""

>" %'4 "0/!%''2'% %$ '2"-2%5

F- -"' "& !#"# - $

!"-&. " " %$$""

%''2 !4&"$ -% - $"4!&

- ""

> "%' $! 0% !1!"

"%4'20" --'$

%" $"% "

%'2"#-2%.%$- ""

". - -

. "'$ "

- %"$ %& !

- $!%"

!(- -$'%2 *% %$( !'

- ""

( $-%-$'%2"- ('!"

- - $"(" '"%2 ($"# 0% "'2 %"4!%4' $%!- - "". 0-"(- %"'$ %( 0"- $! $"'"#( %$ & "!$ " !4&"$ -% - " $"% %$ !G '%"$ $'%2 "

"%'"@"# - %"$ ($"# / % #$ "

$ -% !'$ " "$%4' " %("%''

%$ 1!$"( - ""

$"# -%4 /.'%$

%) !'( $-% - "%' $! !'$ 4 '%$ ""

%. - $%

! %!%"

$"(" '"%2 ($"# 0 $"# %#%" -& - "-" #%$0%!4&"$42-8!

!"2

"( '2"-2%

-6-

59.0-"(-0% %! '"$ -$'"8!

"("%'"4!%25:.%$ %- "%'$("

-%&( !'$ 4 %7.- $0 "'$ 0"-- - '$-"%'4 ""''-$"

"(" '"%2 ($"#(%& % $ 0% %!

- %"#

"% %' $

( /2 -%- 4 "0 '%$ - ""

0"- !

!%2" $"%$'%2.% &%7"#%%

"%%$1!&

!- !4&" -% - $'%2 2 " - ( ('!"

$"(" '"%2 ($"#"8!%''2%"4!%4' - ""

-&'/. "%&!(-%&!

!'" '

!""

'-%"#0%

$$.0"- - &% 4"

"# '"$ 9 5:

5:. 6 5?. ?

5E. %$ 5 55 0/.- ""

%"'$ % % %2

%"$ $%.$ "- %/"# ("

"(%''2 !#-%

!"2

-%"# "" /"0

-(" (!&%(-%- "%'$(""

$$ $ -$'%2. 4"#%( 8!

- ""

> 0'% %$ &""

%/%"'-

!"" # %$. !#- !' " "& ""

%2 "%("%' '"%4"'"2!

- $ %

%' '%( '"%(

!' E 9

)"/"' /"( !' #%$"##%"

%24 "%$ '%('"%(

!'E 9 C(D%0''%- -

"(&& %$!&"!$42 2-"%( %& 5 5 550-"( (-%$-! "

# ' #

$ %

# % & &

(#)

-7-

/ .

(' #5 "

3 (:;'

1 1

3 1

3 0

. ! * + & !

, % #

& !!% &&

& !

(! ! *

# ! & ) 06

+ .

7 899 999 999 999 999 999

3 4

-8-

)

! :

-% %/ '%$ ) !' % %"#

4-%'

- ("/ %" %$ -%/ / # - !#- - $ (!& % $$ %'

#0"- - 0" "

% % - (-%''# -

!"-& $%$ 5?

55.% $ $ 6

55.0-4 42( /2

%%& !

6.:55; 0%$%''#$ "%("%''

-% 4$"($."( ($. -%& %" %&%

"/"%' "%("% %'( 8!(.%$

-% % . -" )

! " "('"$ G(" " 0" 1!"$"("

" 0"-- -%"$ $

( /2%'- !# --&%24 &

(" -!4&""

-%- ""

08!" $ '2 4%"-%'$ 8!

0 %$/"# - "! %

0-- - ""

" "'$ " $'%2$ $"4!&

"%("%' 4 " -%

-9-

%((!$ " -"

%/ ! !

"&. " &%" !$" !$ -% - ""

! % %!%$ &/"(

5%$-%%(-%#- -%$ 4 / $ !

-"& 5 5

!(-. - $"(" '"%2 ($"# 0 $"# %#%" -"& - $%

"&. %$ 8!'2. - '%

"%("%' 4

$ $ $ $"# ('!"

- -%"$ ($"#

". - 0/. % &%

( $ -% - 8!"2

"( !4&"$-" 5E 59.%$-%& &0%$!'2%(( $42- & %!- - "2 /"$ $ & $%$ :

5 5:

-% . - &%( "!$ $ &%" $"#

%"# #

% "%' $ F-"'- %! 2 &4% # '%

"%' 4 " $!"# $(2

$"(" '"%2

($"#" "$" !."" 8!%''2"(!&4!

- & %!-

""%$%! 2 !("

%" !"&'2( ('!"

!(-$ %& &%' ($"# 2" $"% %%$!G '%"$$'%2 - %

- $"(" '"%2 %!- "2 " " %'"@"# ( ('!$"# - ($"#!

!'"%/ "$%4' "%("%'-%$- -" "$& '

!#- - $ % -% % - ""

-%$ -"&'

8!$

% %'-%"#4! %"'$ % % -$% "G$."" %' %%$&"$ $ ""

-%- "%' $0% %$ '2 5?

55. $"("#( / 2

-%''#$ "%("%''

-%%"&%2." %% - " $%

-%"# "

9 5:

5: " (

($. - ""

-% ("

"(%''2 %/ $ " - 0" ""

-% - ( &&!"(%"

& '2 E 5:

5:. %$ /2"# - %"$ $% 0% ("/$ 42 -"&

-10-

"&&$"%'2 !

!(- (" . - !4&" $ % %"

& %!-

"2-"#-'"#-"#-$'%2" /"(

"(%$7"# (-$!'"#

--%"# 5

! - ( -% %' 4 &%$ - '%$"# " "<#/()&-'

'&'&&."'$ / 6 . 0-"

" % (%# "(%' %"

0% &%$ -

( -% - ""

-%$% %$ %''-$%

"G$

-%"#%$-% %(-!(- ((% "

.-0%"

&$42-%! - ""-%-&%

$ $ $ %$ - -% - G $% 0 !'$ 4 " "&%$ " $! ( ! - &&!"(%"

" -" #%$. 0-"(- (

%- %"$ %"

.-%/ 4 '%($ ( $%$% ("

"(%''2 '%$ $$" %%#% -: 5

- 0 " ""

%4'2. - %"$ $ '%$"# -%/ 4 %/$.$" ! $. $"$42- $ "-"0"%&

!- &# & - ( $ $ -% % - " -%"#

"G$ 9 5:

5:.-G$%0%'"$ '2 6 5?.% %#%

2%%$

"/& - -!48!- %"#0%(-$!'$% % "/%'

- 2%%$0 & -. ?

5E.

0$42-G $% 5 55 -% . - "& !#$ $ $ 0% %$ 42 - $% % !-'%

& -. $!"#0-"(- -%"#0% -'$ "(" !$ - ""

- ("

"(%''2 '%$$(%

-0" ""

""<# / ()&-' & &'&&. "'$ /

6 "-% / -$%0--&% 0%'"$

-%"#.

-11-

("/-%"# #

7 '%(%$-%&0% %$1 !$ %$&""%"/ # !$. " ('% %'2 '( -% - %!- "" -%$ 4 !("

"# " % '%(7%$%""(%'&% %.%("#%-" 0'"! .%--%G-"4""#- 8!""""/ /"2 -"!%-%$ %7 7"#%G $""

!$(""

. ("%''2"/" 0

- %(-%- ""

-%$%'%$2! %!%$ % -%/"#$ $$'

#2%

/"(

/ - !#--% '"(%4'!'$ $ ("4%2 ("

"( "&'"0"-" 0-"(--( & %!- "2 "8!"$ %7%$(""

$"#$"( (" '"%2 ($"#.""/ -'-&%$%

'%0 -%."-%4 (

!(- ("4$"&'"&" .%''!(-$(""

&!4 %7 0"-" % % %4' "

$ &2 (

"$$ ""

. ( - $%!- - "2 4(%& "@$

- & &% :

5 5:. !

! '2

- 8!"2 %$-%/"#( $ $( (!(-0"-.- % %4' "

"%' %$1!$"(%"

- $"# $"(" '"%2 ($"#( & &&($ &-%$% 9

%%$&"%"

% % %4'"&"( ($.- -%/4/%"

!"%(.$ $"# %( (% (%4%".0-- "

$%#"#

&"G 0'/& --%4 4-'$ 4%% %4' "&

%$1!$"( %"

%"!4 !#-4

-( & %!- "2 :

/ /"0

-%4 /.%&

- ""

-%-% %4' "&0"-"0-"

"(-%$"(" '"%2 ($"# !

!#- 4 "%''2$("$$42 -( & %!

!- "2. (%''&%"%'"4

".""G& - &- %( $"42%- 0 ("

- "

"%'8!"2 %$"%((

-12-

(%! "( - %"$ "

"G & - " - "% (% 0 !'$ &&( & & - $%

"!%(

- - 0 (%! "(

"%'"@%"

- $"(" '"%2 ($"#

"( - %"$ "

$. " - (%.0

!'$( & %$"!#!.

.5:%$%(-.5:.- ""

CD0 !

!'$%(( $"#'24"'$ ('% %"&"%-%

?H %!& 0"- -

( & !#!. 5: " )FE5 %$ 0"-

( & % %(-. 5: " )FB55 C "( "( -"& 0% /$" & &4.59D!"'$"4!&

- "%'4 " ?

* - %

%"$ " 4 '%$ " %/ !

CD0" -"% "

5& -

( ("

"$( 2

$. %"'"#0- -"(-- ""

-%''4( & "'$ ('%"&"I :H %!& &0-"(-!(-%$$""

%' "%("% %''"%4"'"2&%24( /$ 42-

/& & &-

"(0- "

!$ "4'

$'%2" !(-$"4!& - ""

% %'2%''

0$ " #+,.-./ =

F-- %7"#;% $ F-- %4'

; ;