← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12367/2020allowed

Shivdev Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2021-02-22Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia25 pages



      

      

      

    



   



                 !  ""

      # $ "

   %&                   ' (   !"

#!!$%!

     $     "   "))* '  +$,

  

              -                  $ "$  " 

 

     .    '

 /             010))203% 4 5)(   """$    "$""$"""    $

"    ) /        

  

    .    '

  /   $  

    -       

"   

   " $      $      $  " '       '

  

063*%    7063* 7( '

   %  " $ ""  '       '

.  / (

)203%

  7)203 7(

8 +   7      " $  9)

 '

 .    

"'

   

" )80))206% 4 5,(   $   +     

  

),23)2)2"    $     $       "     

260))2)2   200))2)2% 4  50(

  

$  90  $  "    :  

 &  

  $   "    





"$  " 

  $ -   ; &                            

 ""$   "$     "

81 $           "     & ' &()  *  +) " "

" " 

$  + )0<))26)2)2% 4 50(              '

    .    '

           ""                   '

   )206%     79  7(      " 

 "



     "    """

     

""$ 

     : $""   "     "$     " )0<))26)2)2   

  " 

 ""   )206  1 '  "   "

"      

2320)2)0% 4  50( 8)      "          .    '

  .  

 

"/        "     5 "$ 4 022))2)0 * &

            -        

         $   "

           

" 

 : ""$$    6%(02063*   $ 

  

"$ 

    9  +    '  "    " 4    " "$      $     $  "" $ "   4'  ",  -)&& &(.-))&)/)01'

 

22   33  *

 ()/)) )(.4 5% )33  6  ,

'  "

  

 



""      "

 

&  200))2)2 

 "$ 

     "    "" 

      " $  "$   "  "$    :   . 7    %

 (   "       4'  22  5'

))&( .42(-02)     66 3 +  "$   4' 

""

 

 $ $ ""= "   "$ +      010))203% 4 5)( "     0,

 .  /     "    063*   >     

02         "$  & "'      063*

 901      "$

   4     "  ""$ " -      9, " $  :  .  '

 /  "$     " "$    9*    "

    "$        +             4"$  822  

       "   

         "



 " +   02063*   .  /   "  - "  

5"

50      



          $                   "  '            '

5' ?   $ # .      $ + . "  '

    "        @ 02' .  / 5A%0(B .  /  "" 5 %(  

     - ".   !

   ""   ?

A%(  

  ""   

"" "" - "

"$5 %("

 $5 $ 

%(

" 7     

 $ %(  "$  $    - : "4 "  $ "  "  "

"    $ 

 $  "         "" - "    5 %(               "

 "  ? %(     "

? %(      " $  ? %(     

      $      ""$  ? %(

   

 "      ":"$



  ""$  $     ? %(

  - " $    $   ?CC A%0 (B  $  

5 %0( "" $                  

" ""  "$5 %(   '

 5' 

%(   $ # .   5

%(   $  .  " 

    5 C A       '



 $             "      

'  "'     $   '!

D'        !

      D  '       

' CE 6

" "$ )203

  "         .              "                   .    /   ""    

$    '

   *        $  

   

        "  "

 "

       '

$    "1%1(       "   .   /  ""$ "'    

5

%0 ( 02 & "' 

 " "           ":     

  " 

      4   :      ' "<                 ""  "'"   " 02$  + 

     "

 -  )



$""

   "

      

5 "

%6(  "'  "                       F 

5"

%02(       $    "

                  

  $' "

<"  >

       :       

""  $"   



":"$  ""$   +    ""

5'"

6    "   

9) " $      )80))206% 4 5,( "1    @1 "   .  / 55 %0(  "  

.    "" 

$    '

 %)(& 

 """  4    $   %8(+  ""

               

 ""  """$ 



 ""      $ %;(&   $  "    ""  "" " "   "

 "

       '

$   %1( "   .  /  "" $ "'    

5  %0 ( 02  %*(  

$"   """ 

  "

" ""

"      " ""    "     

"' %,(& "' ""  5" "  ""  "$5 %(    ":         "  

$

 ?

%(   4   :

 ' "   $       :  ' "   

      ""  " '"   " $   4  "  " ?

%( 

         "" 

&- "$ :

  "" 12G  &

9 4.

   :

 5+%( "H " > 022)

  &$ %(H " '  + %(H "  



'

  "#   "  5++%(>B

$  .   0228

  

  '  

  "

  "  %(>  $ 

     " "$     %3(  &  "    ""     ""   "         :

 $                   "$  "      4 

: "" " 

   

:  %6(& " "" "

         $               %02(&    ""  $ 

    "

    %00(B  $     ""





 $ "

4  $ "

 .   ">  %0)(I   "" ""      :  "" $

"      ":"$  ""$        E 02 +              

          % 4   5)(      "

   "        7&  &  7     "    "       "$  

  9)                "    "

    ""$        - "

 "   ""  /

" . >2*2*)206    $ "'

                 '

?  #"

     $     90  "   $    .  / 

"    '

  

 "$     H  

="  8 

  "1 ,%(%(%()203

     ""   & "    "

"="     "    

 5" 

 )203

 ""    &     7 4 5)<)7   "$  9)&   

  "0126)206   " "" 0300)206    8200)206% 4 5;( 00 >   "' )8 "   5"    3   

  "

00    ""     "'    :

  "" $8    

"

" 

"  " 8200)206% 4 5; 51(    '

+"

  



     "  

""$        )80))206% 4 5*(    

       " 4    "

  "$    02   5 " 3

  8  ""      "$)     "    .  '

 /  "/  +   "

  "

           00              .   '

 $ 4 53 &    "

  "  !

"  '

 

   .  '

 /  )80))206% 4 5,(  $     9)    -         

  

 $       $

"' 0) 

""$         *      082,)2)2 % 4 56(        .  '

 .    

"/  "  



  &

    " 0323)2)2  :    $    "

  "" "   

 08 &    "$

"   $ . / ' "

" '







        "$                $ " '   "          &     $ "      ""  

 &  

  $      "   



  "$    "



 $ "

"     "   ""$   /        "                        " "   

 "    4'  ! 

"    

 )000)20*% 4 508("  "

 " "66   "7(08 -02) ()2). &)&509)1&(   ""     .  /     +     

       $   "  "

   

 0,0))2)2& 

:    )206 $' "    ""  063*       "             .    '

    



 

"/  ""  " ))26)2)2

$  + " 

  

"  "       



"     "                  $    $  +

  0; &

   $ ""    

            010))203  $  

    -   % 4 5)(    

02%0(%(    "  " $ "'       02%0 ( 063*      & - 

  ":        -   - "$    ""            ""$              &        - "

 )203   "

    '"

0, ""$"      '

  %  "

""  '      

'

.  / (

)203  ""  /

 +   



    822"   "  

  $  5 +



"

 "    

" 

    .  /    "

     "

    $          "$      

 "

"$ 

    .  '

 /  

  "$  9)5  '

    "

 "  

7&&  7010))203% 4 5)<0( 

"   "                         ""        ""$   - "  ""       "     ""          ""   /

   " ""   '

    :

&

 $"      $)120)206     5 01

  "              

    

 &"    

   $ "'      '

?   $ # .     $   ." J'

  

: 2*2*)206% 4 5)<)(   ""  "  8 

     "1%,(%(%(%(     :            "            



""$  ""   & 

    "0126)206  "     " ""0300)206""    8200)206 90    $  H  :    ""                        

"'    " "$ " "         "" " 

+        "     "$  !    "   $ 2;0))2)2

"

  " "            " 4   :& 

       202))2)0        "       $   $ $"   $ :

   

"""),00)2)2 4   

 : 

 :"

  0* &           '       "       "   

     "  $ "  & ""$  

$     "     " " 

     200))2)2 

  

$   H 



   "'&

 "

    " :   

  ""    .  '

 /  &   "      " 

    """

$                                    200))2)2&    "$

$

"""  

 

""$   $""   

4  '     :   .

 %

 (   "              @,+   $       -   

   

 " -   "  ""$ >  "$ "$    - " "$   

"$-  $  F"

 "         "" $"" "" $  D      "    $ & ""   

:       

  $ ""         

 "        &     "$"" $

'  $   

 D $ 

 '   9"

"  D $  ! H      E .   $   0,

         '     "          $       $                     .  /                  " 

 "$    $ ' 

  

"  " 8200)206 % 4  5;    51(                   '

    "

     & 

"  " 

 "  "$  !

"  '

 "

           .    '

  /     .                    "$          .  '

 /   >" 

"    "'"8200)206        

   90 &  $  082,)2)2 % 4 56( '

   063*   9 "   ""    $ "        #$   *  4 $ +    ":



  5

!

">   " "$""$  

"  

    .  / 

  "    

" "

 03   "        "".  /  " $

4 5)    "   "     .  /  0)    "$     ;2  .  / 

);   "$    02 222   

   

.  / 

     0)  " $  &

       "

$ $ 4  

5 "$   "     .  /    "

       $ 

> " 

 "    "

          " 

"    "":        >"$   

  "  

   " 

       )80))206  "    

$5   

  ""$  * $     .  /  

   



    "          

  $ &         )206 

  $

              $  "       "     <#$ 

"    "

   200))2)2 06 &" "   -   $     "1%)(  

  " *   $     +                   "$     

 "$   *     "      "              $     $  ""                       .  /     + "

""  "    " "   ""$"$  

 "  $  $          "   +                  

  $8)   "  .  '

  

"/      "   2320)2)0

5   022))2)0& -    



 $I$   "$     "$"$ 

 

   :  $  & 4'  (  :( '')&(.,(( 5 ;' & 22  <"= '( &(3   6 *"     "    

"$     $ $ &

    ""  

8)/7)1) ))&(. &)&5 09))&&( 6  *    &)&509)1.> 7)8 :(&(   6 &

   200))2)2:     "$ $   B9     )2 '

        9  )206   " 

$  +))26)2)2  "   ' "   )2$!

"$

)2)2 9    " + "  ))26)2)2                "   

 

  "    "  """

      9  "D  

" "     02,  "  $ :    :  063*            " :   :   &     

 



@02,%0(  &  '

      063*     $ " %)(9  

 "

$ $ :     :    $ " ""

             :         %8(&  "  

5 %)( ""

"    ""

* "'"

036,     "E )0 &   063*  " $      93 

" )3  "    .  '

 /    

.  '

 .    

"'

:   .  '

    

     "

) & "      .  !

F )2)2 

- "       .  '

 "$     ";%)(%(

4 02$  01$ "  : ""'

     $ " "$

  ";%8(       .   '

 "" &

 5  - "

    



 " 

  " $"""

5"

%6(  1 "       "$  $



 "

                "    : "  / "" "   "       "    $""   "$  

 $ : "  " ))26)2)2  "  " 

" $"""    9&.   H %

 (       4  '   "                    5             "        $      $ ""=  " &$$  "

         $ " $    9  &

" " 7           "              "      $   "

 "        "       @00  &     $           -   J       

     "         $  

   4 

"$   " ""      4           > 

     



   4       

 

 " 

 

              4          >    '    "$                 -               "         "

  5     "        $    ""$                    $ "           "     5  

           "

           +               "$     $ "   "

"             J    

         "$  "       " " &" "    $ 4 

   $

 $"          "5

  "           . 

- " "$                "           #        $ 

    ""::"  :"  

   -  $    "  

""   - "   "    5 

    -                  

"   $4   D  "   $



"  "

                 E )) &

:    "

 

 4'  '     

   " $ 

   $ "' : 

 " " 

       " $  +    $        "

  

$   

 )8 &  " $ '  " F   %

 (  " "+   4 '   " 

   

"  & 

$."D'         "       "    " """ 5   >I'

 $ $  " +  

"$

    

   

  

"+   

  $  

 " " 

     $   $

"'      ""       ); &  $  " -  "$  $   $



      $  " 

  :                   '

  '

    

"   

   "        $  

  $ "' >"$ ": "

    

 "$     "" &  200))2)2% 4  50(   

 $   $  90 -     

   $

 )    $

  + ""

   

"    

5"

%02(  %0)(   "1 )203  

       ))2))2)0     !"

#!!$%! 

 ?4 ;

   

 !   " # !