High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11766/2010dismissed

Rohit Sharma v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2025-12-09Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

!"#$%%&

' ()* % + *+ ** ) ****

!" #

$ !"

% &'

(

!" #

&) !" *+,--

& $' !" -* +,#!

- ".!/ 01 % 22 3

# %" . / + -01 &

" 2$"$/" $4 &

# %" . / -1 & " 2$"$/"

, #,5 .-1

3 # 2 "

44+ )5 &6 # "

7 6 6 84 488+ . / :1 / 2 # 8:

488+ 7 6 ) & 8488: . / 91/ !2#

& 4* 8;

48-8. /

- 2 -

--1 # 2 "

6 ! 2!

2 $" # " 6 ) & # 8:

488+ "" "" 6 #

"7 2 .41

3 " " < =

> ?6 5

6 %

8+ -4 -,,, 6# -* 3 7 ?6 @@) .?5)1 44888

62 " ) & /@6 " 0- -,,;. / -1 !6 " ! # :+ *8A

& 49 8;

488-

77 " ) & .01

# 6 ?5)< " ( @%' 84884#"

6 2 ) @555 2 "" ' 27 8:

4880 !

" " # "# 6 ) & .*1

") # 2 )B -;-,-488;?6 @@) &6 4* 488+. / *1 "6

-,/@6 C# 6 ) &D #E ! " "

" 0- -,,; . / -1 #" @@ @# 2 " 27/@6 " "

) &. / 91 # #$

- 3 -

::. $61 8488: .;1

35 " -:

4840. / -*1 6#6 44 8+ 488+ "! " "/@6 ) & " @@ @#2 "

# " # # F ! ( # "" - 4 " 6!6 "

6 @ 2 " " &6

.+1

= " " 6

! ! "

-* -+ ) 5 " 26

/@6 "

# . > ?6 1 8+ -4 -,,, !6 "7 7" 7 " ) & 8;

488- 62 604884 2 !@G@! # 2 !2

" 2!

3 2#

# /@6 # 2 "

3 !@G@! #6 6 # " ! 2"#" " @

- 4 - Sr.

No.

Petitioner/ respondent Number Date of death of father Date of issuing appointment letter Seniority list Petitioner 06.12.1999 02.08.2006 Respondent No.3 (Anil Yadav) 07.12.2002 07.07.2006 Respondent No.4 (Arun Gupta) 25.01.2006 07.07.2006 Respondent No.5 (Vikram Singh) 03.03.2002 07.07.2006 Respondent No.6 (Anil Kumar Kamra) 01.04.2005 07.07.2006 Respondent No.7 (Joginder Singh) 08.08.2001 07.07.2006 Respondent No.8 (Ajay Khokhar) 31.12.2000 07.07.2006 Respondent No.9 (Arun Khera) 14.02.2005 07.07.2006 Respondent No.10 (Barjinder Singh) 20.11.2001 07.07.2006 Respondent No.11 (Janesh Kumar) 01.01.2003 27.07.2006 Respondent No.12 (Prem Kumar) 01.01.2004 25.07.2006 Respondent No.13 (Guru Bhakti) 22.02.2003 25.07.2006 Respondent No.14 (Rajesh Kumar) 05.10.2004 27.07.2006 .:1

5 2 "

6 ( @%'

6 "

2 7 " ) & "

6 / " # 2 6 "" ( @% " ! 2$" /@6 C" " #" ! 2 " 3 27 "" @ ) & 6 $ ' # /6 2

) & @"

$ 2

- 5 - .91

3 6 26(! " 0- -,,;. / -1 #

?6 @@)< &6 4* 488+ . / *1 6 /@6 "

2 2! % ""

2 & !

D 27 " /@6 " C" "

" E # "" 2

@@ 2 6 &6 4* 488+. / *1 " ) ""

-, /@6 C# 6 ) & # ! " " #! # "" 40) & -, 8+ 488+ < # "

# 8:

488+ 4;

488+ 4:

488+ " " ! 2! " &6

.,1

= " " --

$ 2 2 " B & % .5

6 '

"1 " ) "

. !") @5551 -,+;. -,+; 1#" # " " 2

2 6 " !" " 2$" " 2 " #!

6 35 "! < "! (?@55'

"4:

488+# &6

488+ # ?(@5'

" " 2 " / "6 < "

- 6 - 2 " 2

& ! 6 ## 62 6 6 " ) & 2 2

@ 8:

488+ " ""! .-81

= 2 /@6 ) & 8488+ " 2 " ?(@5'

"#"" ! " # "

# 6 "6 #"

6!# "

# !26 ! 2! 2 6 "&@ @" " ! " 0- -,,;

.--1

89 484* 2 2 & ) ?6 @@) 5

6 B " % 2

-4 # 2 !

" "" /"

" ! "

6 6 "

-4" " @ ) & 84 488+ 8:

488+ "

! 6 "

" "

! 2 /@6

' 2 < -,,, " DE " "

"" ! #

- 7 - @ /@6 2" " &6 4* 488+ "6

-,/@6 # 6 2 27 ) & 8:

488+ # 6@ "/ "$ ) & .-41

5 2 ) &" 6! /"

! 2 C $6 2 /@6 # 6@ 6 ---,+; -;. 1.21 4880 ?/@6 " 2 #" ! $6

2 6

2 8488: "

" " # $ ) & > 488+ ! 2! # $ 488+ H 2 -, /@6 # 6 2 :: ) & # " #"" 27 .-01

= " -4 488: #

# # " 4I0 6!

6 <# # -4 -8 48-- # "

6 48-8 " 2 "

" " # & " " 2

" "# 2 2 6 .-*1

# !2 2 *+, -- #

9 "6 "

- 8 - 2 ' " 6 ! 84884 !6 ""$ "8: 8;

4880" 6 " 6 6 "" ! ) "%%" (! ?

4880 " " 2 " !""# $%" &'()*

.-;1

" .-+1

3 " " # # <

-,/@6 # 6 ! ) & @ " / @@ C # 6@ 2 " /6 " # " /@6 ) & 2

" 2 C $6 " !" !6/6 8488: 2J .-:1

K 6

# !"

" C " "

! # 3 ) 2" "" "

6 " !" 6! 6 "

-- -,+; ) "

-;. 1.214880?/@6 " ! ! C $6 " !" !6 " 2 /@6 # 6@ 2

! "

- 9 - .-91

" C/@6 ) # "+# ,%- . /0&*'*((12 "

# /"

" ! " "

" D" 2"

6E 2 6 "

!" .-,1

5 !" # $%"0 &*' * (( **2 ) # " "" " 6 6 D 2 " " 6 # "

E " "

6 " 6 # 2 " " .481

#/@6 7 # # & !"$ " " " 5 " # " 2 "

6 #

2 6@ 6 " " " 2 6

"& D" C 6 !"E

6 " 2 2 6 # .4-1

5 " "" ) & 8:C89 488+

#8488: # #"

66 & 48-- "

3) # 2

- 10 - .441

' /@6 ) & "

" 2 C $6 " !" # C !" 3 " 2 !&6 /@6 " # 6@ 2 "

@ 6 ! ) & # "

3 2 # 6

.401

5!# 2! # "" 6 $%%& +,#!

- ".!/ 0

.!/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No