Gursimerjeet Singh v. Arun Sekhri And ORS
!"#$ %$$&'"()* +$&"&",($ -$ ! ! ('$.* "/(0,&*$ ! +$!1,(0$(&!
2
/ 3*/ /('"()* +$&"&",($ -$ ! ! ('$.* "/(0,&*$ ! +$!1,(0$(&!
4
/ 1 $$&'"()* +$&"&",($ -$ ! ! ('$.* "/(0,&*$ ! +$!1,(0$(&! COCP-1488-2021
/#/(0$$1'"()* +$&"&",($ 5$ ! ! ('$.* "/(0,&*$ ! +$!1,(0$(&!
:2: 6 COCP-1489-2021
/!*/(0$$1'"()* +$&"&",($ -$ ! ! ('$.* "/(0,&*$ ! +$!1,(0$(&! 2 COCP-1490-2021 (O&M) Date of Decision :22.02.2022 / 7"(0$ '"()* +$&"&",($ -$ ! ! ('$.* "/(0,&*$ ! +$!1,(0$(&!
, /#8 ,(9:;$ !&"3$'</;"/ $!$(&8
'/1/(*" =0-,3/&$>, &*$1$&"&",($
0"&?/'*/ 0/= = (%/: @@@
AB
/!$! / $ :$"() &/.$( 1 >, *$/ "() &* , )* 5"0$,
,(>$ $(3"()0 $&, ,-"0C1/(0$#"3 AB *"!, 0$ !*/;;0$3"0$
=
2=
4=
=
C /(0
C=/!/;;&*$3/!$!/ "!$, &,>3,##,(, 0$ , &*$!/.$,> : $-"&?=>/3&!/ $:$"()&/.$(> ,#
AB /?$ "( &*$ "(!&/(& 1$&"&",( "! >, "("&"/&"() 1 ,3$$0"()! /)/"(!&&*$ $!1,(0$(&!>, "(&$(&",(/;7";;> ;-",;/&",(,>% 0)#$(&/(0
:3:
, 0$ (($D $E0/&$06"( <,4,> AB 1$ !/;,>, 0$ 0/&$06(($D $ $-$/;! &*/& "-"; < "& $&"&",( ,4 ,> /(0 3,(($3&$0 #/&&$ ! 7$ $ 0"!1,!$0,>7"&*&*$>,;;,7"(), 0$ !8 "(i) Relevant impugned orders dated 20.08.2018 (Annexure P12) in CWP No. 29808/2018 and CWP No.29810/2018, orders dated 08.08.2018 (Annexure P-10) in CWPs No. 38030/2018 and 38033/2018and order dated 20.08.2018 (Annexure P-10) in CWP No. 38037/2018rejecting the claim the petitioners for appointment as constables against 2% quota meant for the wards of the police personnel are set aside (ii) It is directed that subject to their eligibility at the time of selection in 2011 and fulfilling other relevant procedural requirements, the respondents shall issue letters of appointment to the petitioners as constables against 2% quota meant for the wards of the police personnel.
iii) Needful as at (ii) be done by the respondents within two months of the receipt of certified copy of this order." A6B F$/ ($03, (!$;>, &*$1$&"&",($ !
3,(&$(0!&*/&&*$"(!&/(& 1$&"&",(! 7$ $ >";$0 ,( /33, (& ,> >/"; $ ,> &*$ $!1,(0$(&! &, 0, &*$ ($$0> ; A2B ,0/?= ;$/ ($0 */! 1 ,0 3$0 3,1? ,> , 0$ 0/&$0 C= 1/!!$0 :? &*$ " $3&, $($ /; ,> ,;"3$= (%/:= "!! "() 0" $3&",(! &, &*$ 3,(3$ ($0 ''! &, "!! $ /11,"(&#$(& ;$&&$ ! &, &*$ 1$&"&",($ !
"( &$ #! ,> &*$ , 0$ /(0 % 0)#$(& 0/&$0 6 (($D $ "( "-"; < "& $&"&",( ,4 ,> /(0 ,&*$ 3,(($3&$0#/&&$ !*$!/#$"!&/.$(,( $3, 0 ,1?&*$ $,>! 11;"$0&,
:4:
;$/ ($03, (!$;>, &*$1$&"&",($ =7*,,(1$ !/;,>&*$!/#$!&/&$!&*/& "(&*$3" 3 #!&/(3$!&*$1$&"&",($ !
"!E/ $(,&"(&$ $!&$0"(1 ! "()&*$ 1 $!$(&1$&"&",(!/(0&*$!/#$:$0"!1,!$0,>/!! 3* A4B F$/ ($0 3,(&$(0!&*/&($$0> ;3, ;0(,&:$0,($7"&*"( &*$!&"1 ;/&$01$ ",0,>&"#$,(/33, (&,>3,(0"&",(!1 $-/";"()0 $&,
,-"0C1/(0$#"3/!7$;;/!&*$ $!1,(0$(&!*/-"()>";$0F=&*, )* &*$ $ 7/! (, !&/? /)/"(!& &*$ ,1$ /&",( ,> % 0)#$(& /(0 , 0$ 0/&$0 6"( "-";< "&$&"&",(,4,>/(0,&*$ 3,(($3&$0 #/&&$ !"( &*$ F F$/ ($0 = 3,(&$(0!&*/& "( -"$7,>&*$, 0$ ! */-"():$$(3,#1;"$07"&*=&*$3,(&$#1&1$&"&",(!:$0"!1,!$0,>/!! 3* /!(,&>/;;"()>, /(?/3&",(/)/"(!&&*$ $!1,(0$(&! (0$ &*$3,(&$#1& ,> , &!3&=C4 AB 0#"&&$0;?, 0$ 0/&$0C*/!:$$(1/!!$0"!! "() 0" $3&",(! &, &*$ 3,(3$ ($0 ''! &, "!! $ /11,"(&#$(& ;$&&$ ! &, &*$ 1$&"&",($ !
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
:5:
AB 33, 0"();?=&*$3,(&$#1&1$&"&",(!
"!E/ $0"!1,!$0,>/! ! 3* 7*";$ 0" $3&"() &*$ $!1,(0$(&! &, $(! $ "!! /(3$ ,> /11,"(&#$(& ;$&&$ ! &, &*$ 1$&"&",($ !
/! /;!, /;; ,&*$ !"#";/ ;? !"& /&$0 3/(0"0/&$! 7"&*"( &7, 7$$.! > ,# &,0/? F":$ &? &, &*$ 1$&"&",($ ! &, #,-$ /( /11;"3/&",(>, $-"-/;,>&*$"(!&/(&1$&"&",(!">&*$($$0> ;"!(,&0,($ 7"&*"(&*$!&"1 ;/&$01$ ",0,>&"#$ AB ;$0"!3*/ )$0