Iqbal Singh v. State Of Punjab

   

     

 !"#$!%&'&"()*
*
 +,-.&(/0 ********! & &"(!1 '

2!1'3'

.  !"#3(4, *******!'5"($!(  '

)  67 * . 8 7.  1!'!( ) 1***.*!"-9.!(&"1$:"% !9;& 09 1**.*!"-9$:"% !9 #"15! & &"(!1* 1*81(,&1.&(/09 3(4,9 ''&' !$,<./&1.&(/0* 1***.*0! 0&9$:"% !9 #"1%"=5-&(( * * * 7. 9*

7

!1$* "-&%!0'#&-!$$! &-!$'  3'1!5"1 ,<;<"###&$:& "# :&($!1.&(/09.9!53 <.35!1&( !($!( "#"-&%! 31- 9 0&($9 &( !1='"#-' "1$!195''!$,< 0&' "31 "(*
*
9($'=!&' >!( "(1!%"1$* 0&'"1$!1;&--$&'5"'!"#55-&% &"(#&-!$,<5! & &"(!13($!1 .!% &"( 1** *#"1/1( "#( &%&5 "1<,&-&(%'!"*??9$ !$ **
91!/&' !1!$3($!1.!% &"(@ ($3($!1.!% &"(
A"#1='

% 9A9 "-&%!.  &"(8" # 9&' 1&%  0&($* --!/ &"('  -!:!--!$  &(  %"=5-&(  ,<  =($!!5  .&(/0

%"=5-&(( 1! 0 "(
**
90!-"(/;& 00&'3(%-!81(&-.&(/0 ;'  /"&(/  &(  0&'  4!!59  ,!1&(/  1!/&' 1 &"(  "*  
@A
 #1"= 0=(;-#&!-$'9 " 0!&10"=! :&--/!8" # *!!5;'$1&:!(,<


 %"=5-&(( *1"3($@)A5=9;0!( 0!<1!%0!$ 0!$1&((!15"($&( 0!&1:&--/!91!BB%19,!1&(/1!/&' 1 &"("*7%=!&( #1"( '&$!9 ,!&(/ $1&:!( ,<+,- .&(/0 5! & &"(!1 * +,- .&(/0 ;'

%%"=5(&!$,<0&''"(.($!!5.&(/0($ 31;&($!1.&(/0'

"14& .&(/0*+,-.&(/0,(/!$0&'%1&( "4!!5"#%"=5-&(( ($-'"#&1!$ #1"=&('&$!0&'%1 ";1$'0&=;& 0(&( !( &"( ">&--  %"=5-&(( * 0!1!# !19+,-.&(/0%=!"3 "#%1#1"=$1&:!1'! ;& 00&'5&' "-&( 0&'0($*!;',!&(/!C0"1 !$,<0&''"(.($!!5.&(/0* ( 0&'90!

#&1!$'0" #1"=0&'5&' "-9,3 %"=5-&(( ':!$0&='!-#,< $3%>&(/ $";(* !#&1!$(" 0!1'0" * ";!:!19'!%"($'0"  0&  1&/0 0($"# %"=5-&(( *0!1!# !19%"=5-&(( ($0&'%"=5(&"(1&'!$03!($ %1<9"(;0&%0+,-.&(/0#&1!$(" 0!1'0" ;0&%0$&$(" 0& %"=5-&(( * 0!1!# !19 31;&($!1.&(/0%=!"3 "#1!!B%1($1&'!$!C0"1  &"( "% %00"-$"#%"=5-&(( * %%311!(%! 1% !$83-;&($!1.&(/0'"("#

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

 $&' (%!"#,"3 
#!! "1-!''9 0!1!&',-%>!(&(/9&($&% &(/ 0 '0" ;' #&1!$#1"=%-"'!1(/!*! & &"(!1$!(&!$ "0:!#&1!$'0" #1"=0&'5&' "- "(;1&' "#%"=5-&(( * "-&%!&( 0!:!1&#&% &"(1!5"1 0''  !$ 0 ," 0:!0&%-!' ;!1!%0!%>!$* (!!=5 <%1 1&$/!"#*
,"1!;'1!%":!1!$#1"= 0! = 3($!1$1&:!1'! #1"=1!BB%1($"(!,3--! ;'1!%":!1!$#1"= 4!!53($!1%"($3% "1'! * "-&%!# !1:!1&#&% &"("# ";!1-"% &"("# =",&-!50"(!'($

2#"" /!%=! "%"(%-3'&"( 0  =($!!5 .&(/0 %"=5-&((  -"(/;& 081(&-.&(/0;!1!%"=&(/,%>#1"= /1&%3- 31!#&!-$' " 0!&10"3'!&(4!!5*(#% +,-.&(/0 5! & &"(!1 ;'

%"=&(/;& 00&'/1($'"(1=!'0;1.&(/09/!$,"3 <!1'9&(0&'%1 #"1 >&(/%'0#1"=5! 1"-53=5*+311!- "">5-%!(!15"($*"-&%! &'3(,-! "$!%&$!' ";0&%0:!0&%-!0&  0!" 0!1:!0&%-!*0" "/150' "(5"-&%!#&-!'0";' 0 $1&:!1'&$!"#1!!B%1;'0& ,<4!!5*2!1'&"( "#+,-.&(/0&' 0 0!';=($!!5.&(/0 %"=5-&(( %"=&(/#1"= #1"( '&$!*!' "55!$0&'4!!5&(#1"( "#0&'%19&(;0&%08-.&(/0($

3151!! .&(/0;!1!-'"51!'!( * # !1' "55&(/0&'4!!590!' 1 !$ ,3'&(/0&=*$=& !$-<9&( 0&'%'!9+,-.&(/0;'%%"=5(&!$,<0&' /1($'"(1=!'0;1.&(/09/!$,"3 <!1'9;0&%0& '!-#/&:!'(" 0!1 &($&% &"(' ";0! 0!1 0!%1&=!;'51!5-((!$"1(" D  &''"( .($!!5.&(/0($ 31;&($!1.&(/0'

"14& .&(/00:!,!!(#"3($ &(("%!( ,< 0!5"-&%!* 0&'  #%  (!!$  ("  "  ,!  %"==!( !$  35"(    0&'  ' /!* ";!:!190& &(/$1&:!1
1&/0 '&$!"#1!BB%1& '!-#/&:!'&($&% &"( 0 4!!50$&(#% 0& 1!!B%1*"-&%!0'-'"#"3($0"-!&(;&($'%1!!( "#1!!B%1($(!=5 <%1 1&$/!;'1!%":!1!$3($!1$1&:!1'! "# 1!!B%19&($&% &(/ 0 +,-.&(/00$#&1!$'0" ;0&-!

 '& &(/&('&$!1!!B%1;0&%05''!$ 01"3/0;&($'%1!!(* '5!1 5"-&%!:!1&#&% &"(9#"31'0" ';!1!#&1!$9 ;"'0" ' ;!(  &(  &19  "(!  '0"  0&  5&--1  "#  4!!5  ($  " 0!1  '0"  0&  ;1&'  "# %"=5-&(( *'5!15"-&%!:!1&#&% &"(9(",-""$' &(;'#"3($&(4!!5 ($ '5" *

('5!%&#&%+3!1<9 0&' "31 0',!!(&(#"1=!$ 0 !:!( ,-""$' &(!$%-" 0!';!1!(" 51"$3%!$!& 0!1,<%"=5-&(( "1,<$"% "1* ( 0&';<9 0!1!&'(" 0&(/"(#&-! "'0"; 0 ,-""$'5&--!$"3 "#'&$ &(431<  0!'5" * "-&%!  &'  <!  "  :!1&#<  ;0! 0!1  &(431<  "(  ;1&'  "#  0! %"=5-&(( ;'&(#-&% !$;& 0*
,"1!5&' "-"#5! & &"(!1"1;& 0'"=! " 0!1;!5"(($;0! 0!1& ;'&(#-&% !$  0!'5" '(",-""$;'#"3($ &(4!!5"1  0!'5" *  &'%'!"#:!1'&"(($%1"'':!1'&"(*1&=#%&!9& 55!1' 0 "%%311!(%! "">5-%!--"#'3$$!(* 0!-!1(!$%"3('!-#"11!'5"($!( %"=5-&(( 0'%"( !($!$ 0 5! & &"(!1;'$!%-1!$51"%-&=!$"##!($!1*";!:!19& %"=!'"3 0 '&$51"%-&=!$"##!($!1"1$!1;'5''!$# !10&'( &%&5 "1<,&- ;'$&'=&''!$,< 1&- "31 ($,!#"1!0!0'#&-!$( &%&5 "1<,&-,!#"1! 0&' "31 *0!1!#"1!9'&$#% &'&== !1&-*

"('&$!1&(/   0!  %&1%3=' (%!'9  &(  ;0&%0  "%%311!(%!  ""> 5-%!9& &'(" $!!=!$51"5!1 "%"==!( 35"(;0! 0!15! & &"(!1+,- .&(/0#&1!$&(0&''!-#$!#!(%!"1;'//1!''"1"1& ;':&%!:!1'*

"('&$!1&(/ 0!#% '($%&1%3=' (%!'"#%'!($-'" 0! #%  0 51 "#:!1'&"("#%"=5-&(( 0',!!(#"3($!& 0!1 ",!#-'!"1 ("  %"11","1 !$ ,<%1&=!'%!(!($ #%  0 5&' "- 0' -1!$<,!!( 1!%":!1!$#1"=5! & &"(!1($0!0'-1!$<4"&(!$&(:!' &/ &"(($0'

 ,!!( 0"1"3/0-<&( !11"/ !$9 0!1!&'("/1"3($#"1%3' "$&-&( !11"/ &"( "#5! & &"(!1* ,!&(/'"9&( !1&=( &%&5 "1<,&-9/1( !$,< 0&' "31 9 :&$!"1$!1$ !$?**
9&'=$!,'"-3 !*! & &"(&'--";!$* 

7. 

 

*
*
 '4>' E0! 0!1'5!>&(/"1$!1 ) !'

"

E0! 0!11!5"1 ,-!

) !'

"