Major Singh Bhinder v. State Of Punjab And Others
-1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Date of Decision: 17.05.2024 Major Singh Bhinder
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others
...Respondents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMAN CHAUDHARY ****
Present:
Mr. Nirmal Singh, Advocate, for the petitioner.
Mr. Satnampreet Singh, DAG, Punjab.
**** AMAN CHAUDHARY, J. (Oral) 1.
The prayer in the present petition is for directing the respondents to grant annual increment to the petitioner for the service, that he rendered continuously for one year before his superannuation and grant him all consequential benefits including revised pension and pensionary benefits, for which reliance was placed on the judgment of a Coordinate Bench passed in CWP-32598 of 2019, titled Gurdev Singh and others vs. State of Punjab and another, decided on 16.03.2022, Annexure P-1, against which the LPA-9222022, stands decided on 09.04.2024, wherein a batch of petitions with lead LPA-696-2022, titled as State of Punjab and another vs. Malagar Singh were dismissed, the relevant paras thereof reads thus:
! !
"
#$% &
!
'%( &
)
#
+ !
,*
(- #
!
" ( ./)#0&1
-2- 2
3 /0
* 2 ) *#
#2( 4 /)'%/#0451 067 /(*
8.09%#':
#%;
*
2
,*
! 3
14!" *
*
-
!
"2 !
*
*
*
2
! *
"!
" ,
*
<
(2 *
2
*
! 2 *
2
!
*
! * *
= ! " *
2 ! > " **
2 *
2
2 ! " *
"
*
*
2 ! "
"
*
2
2 2
/ 0 !
; " 2 *
2
2 - "!
*
!
>
2 !
------------
2! 2
2" 72 + 8#
*
!
!
2 2
*
*
! 2
$ *
*
! 2!
= 72 + 8# ?
*
"
2
8!2 "
*
"
@ /0 " ) *# #%;
*
/ 0
*
* !
*
*
-3- /10 2! ! !
) *#
#%;
*
/ 0"!
) A **
! !
/0 2"
*
/ 04
@ -- -- -- 1.
"
!
@ '
)
2
!
2
*
,*
!
2!
"
* ,*
" "/ 0 (AMAN CHAUDHARY) JUDGE 17.05.2024 dinesh Whether speaking :Yes/No Whether reportable:Yes/No