Manohar Joshi And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

    


    


   

 

  

 !" #$"% !&'"(#$ ('%'%!(#$ )(#$*$ +' '( *!, - !& !'"(# ($.!&(!'$  *#$"%!&(#+%!/" !&'"(#$ ('%'%!(#$ )(#$*$ +' '( *!, - !&'"(#$ ($.!&(!'$  

  !" " "# "
 #($(!'0 #+ !,(()12%#34 &)5 '(

#'"(.('%'%!(#$6


 7 !&

#'"(#($.!&(!'$6


  7 #+ !&((.1*8 #4

4*!, - #+ !,(() *// 94 &)5 '(

##($.!&(!'$:;6


 7 !&

#'"(.('%'%!(#$6


  7 " "# "
 $ % "%$  588!  #&(#  $" 99  &%$.$(    -)(  !'(&  '< .('%'%!$ $'"(= #%$(*' '"()(#$%! !&5#$$)(#$%! "($(.('%'%!$" )(-((! %9(&*!&(#+(5'%!  '"(
&( 
#%8%! 9#5(&*#(4 >; #?* $"%!/   & '(&

 4*!&(#+(5'%!$;;4;

4

4 > '"(!&% !(! 9
&( !&%'$5#$$)(#$%!#(5#&(&)%&((.#';& '(&  *!&(#

 +(5'%!$  ; 4  ;;4  ; 4 

4  >  
 #(/%$'(#(&  '  9%5(  +' '%!

" /< # 
%'= 9!/<%'" 99$*-$(?*(!'.#5((&%!/$ #%$%!/'"(#( #84 !'"(- $%$ 58.#8%$(& '(&

 (!'(#(&%!'-('<((!'"( . #'%($%(.('%'%!(#$ $<(99 $#($.!&(!' "%$
*#'4! ;;

. $$(&'"( 99<%!/#&(#0  
    

    
     
      !"!

  
"!

!#$"
%%&% &

& ' &" (
$#""
   )  
"  !  ((  $  "
(  * $!
  

 "

 +&)
(


  & *
  
  * " %!"!

 

!#$"
% &%%&% &

& ' 
   !"!

  
"! !#$"
%%& % &

& ' &" (
$#""
  )
"&!

(($  "
(* $!
 

 "

 +& "

 ,
    $ +* +
  )
$   , "!
"

,")"

*"
   

"
"

$ ""
  (! $ (  "

 *"
  "

"  !


  "

  *!$    "

  $&   $ +* +
 ,"!
" ,")"

*"
     "

(

" "


!$ +* +
&    "

  *"
  )"  "  *    "


  *$"
- $ +*(
"!&"

 &)""

+""" ,""(!

!"

 (  )
"

(($  "
(* $!
 "

,  !

."  "

  *"
  **  ,   "

  / !
$
( 
"" "(&  )& 

&"

!" 
0!, "


! "&" 
-"


""+")
"

$" "

$ +* +
)
$ ,"!

" ,")"

*"
!" , -

  
"" 
  !
$"!  "  $ !  "

 ""+" (("

!&$ +*(
"2
3 !!

; -
$"
+& 
    !   ,+
"    * "  (   )
"

 "

 $ !!  ""+"  ,   "

  0"  !"    


$ "

 "

 (( )
 
 +"
4

"

"

""+" "

*"
 , 
! ! " (" *  $ $
"$ 
 +6

"

"

$ +* +
$"!,")"

*"

 
!-(
!6 "

(("

!&$ +*(
"!
3 ! *"  "  "

  $ +* +
  ! 
   "&  "

 !"
(2*"
$ (  $ * 78

"

 "

$
*!
  
"
"

  "

*"
  "&
&"

!"
("

 

"

      "

  *  
- (-! 
  "

 $2!
* "    ,  !$(!    * $(
+!

!

1 $ + *, "

 " 

 


 * "

 !,"" 
""$ $!

 "

)
"

 
 +"
!$ +*(
$

 * "

 !,*($! "


( $ $"!

$ 9 !'(#8$ '"( -)(#&(#4$' '(8(!'$ '"(. #'%($<(#( #(5#&(&-='"(9( #!(&+*- %)%$%! 9*&%5% 9 /%$'# '(4" /< #  !& $*-8%''(& #(.#'& '(& > 

"(.(# '%)(. #' '"($ 8(#( &$ $*!&(#0 :"
 "



"

, -""+"&"

 "
 "

!

7
8#""+" "

*"
, 
!! "

 (" *  $ $
"$ 
+;

7

8 $ +* +
  !"!      <:    , $"!,")"

*"
)
"

"


)
((!

, -$ +* +

 
;

7


8:*""+" $ +*(
"&
3 !/ "
)


       / 

   "  "

  *" 
  "

  , - $ +* +
;

7
-8 : * ""+"   $ +*(
"&   "  $ ,")
+!"

, -$$ !
*!
 ;

7-8 "

&*"

* " :

(+!& $$ !

,!$(!* $(
+! !
"

$ "(#( '(#4'"%$
*#')%&(#&(#& '(&



4 99<(& '"(%!,*#(&4! 8(9=4='%$"%'-(%8.9( &(& $. #'=#($.!&(!';
!$(?*(!'9=4"(#$' '(8(!'" $ 9$-((!#(5#&(&-='"(9( #!(&+*-

%)%$%! 9*&%5% 9 /%$'# '(4" /< # !



 !&'"(#( '(#4 #(.#'& '(&>



" $-((!#(5(%)(&%!'"%$#(/ #&<"%5"$ =$'" ' 8 ''(#" $-((!58.#8%$(& +' '(8(!'8 &(-=%!,*#(&='%$"% #( &$ $*!&(#0 #""!"

"*"$ $  !"!

  2  %%&  % &  

&   '      * (
$ ""
&
"  )
"! 
"= 
! #


&>
 (1 < &>
 (?

+&:
 ?

+& @ *(A !
! !3
"# < "

""+"

>
 !/ 
 "

$  -$
-!
3 


5  -  $ !  $ +* +
  = 
!  #


& >
 (1 < &>
 (?

+&:
 ?

+&@ *( !
 !  !3
"  # <  )
"

 +    )
((& - ( "
( )
"

"<
!  !


( $  $ $
!
, 
! B0 :
"

* " ""$ * +:!

!

  "

$
*!
 ,") +!"

, -
!$$ !

  -  ,3$"

 "

*" 
  ! 
"(("

!

+!
"

  9 @( #!(&  +' '( 
*!$(94  !  %!$'#*5'%!$  #8 +  9&() +%!/"4" $ 53!<9(&/(&'"( -)( 5' !& *#'"(#$' '(&'" '"(" $! -,(5'%! %! 5 $( '"( .#($(!'   $ <(99  $  99 '"(# 5!$(?*(!'% 9

  .#5((&%!/$ #(?* $"(&!'"(- $%$ '"(58.#8%$((

(5'(&-('<((!

'"(. #'%($)(!-( #('"%$
*#' 9$4'"(#(%$!-,(5'%!-=(%'"(# '"(. #'%($%!5 $('"(.#($(!'%$?* $"(& !)%(<   -)(4 '"%$
*#'%$ *99=5!)%!5(& '" ' '"( 

(!5($ #((!'%#(9=.(#$! 9%!! '*#( !&&!'

(5' !=.*-9%5.( 5( #  '# !?*%99%'= !&  '"*$  ?* $"%!/      %!  ?*($'%!  9!/  <%'"  99 5!$(?*(!'% 9.#5((&%!/$!'"(- $%$ 58.#8%$(<*9&-#%!/.( 5( !&  " #8!=  '  $(5*#(  '"(  (!&$    ,*$'%5( 
!$(?*(!'9=4  -'"  '"( .('%'%!$  #(  99<(&  !&  '"(      & '(&   4  *!&(# +(5'%!$;;4;

4

4 > '"(!&% !(! 9
&( !&%'$5#$$)(#$%!

#(5#&(&)%&((.#';& '(&  *!&(#+(5'%!$; 4;;4 ; 4

4 >
#(/%$'(#(& '9%5(+' '%!" /< # 
%'= 9!/<%'" 995!$(?*(!'% 9.#5((&%!/$#($*9'%!/'"(#( #8 #(?* $"(&?* '"( .('%'%!(#$ $" "# "
%  
#

 


""

A"('"(#$.( 3%!/B#( $!(&0 ($B A"('"(##(.#' -9(0 ($B