High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/601/2006dismissed

Bhola Ram & ORS. v. State Of Hry. & ORS.

2023-09-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari19 pages

!"! # $%$&'$() *

+,$"($-.%.)! *

$ %!

!& !

/ ! #

& " !&

$ %! !&

!& !

/ !

% (

!( !&

$ %! !&

!& !

0 !

!( !&

$ %! !&

!& !

1* ! #

) % ("

$ %!

!& !

0 // 1 * !& )'

$ %!

!& !

0 ! !

'+ & "

$ %!

!& !

0 ! !

& "

$ %!

!& !

2 !

$ %!

!& !

# 3 4# 555 6 3 4# 564 , -

, *. "., %/0 , / . 12

, 3. )45, 0 / 6, 3 7.., .

,.0 , / . 12

, .3 88,9:0 / 6, 3 7.., . ;<

=2 .:0 / 6, 3 7.., . >?

, =2 (380 / 6,

, ), , .830 / 6, 3 7.., .

, @3 30 / 6,

4.3 (470 / 6, 3 7.., ! ?

. A? ?

, ,77 !,4:0 / 6, 3 7.., .

, *8 .830 / 6, 3 7.., . A? AA>;

, @4, .:0 :

( 0 ,2 9.3

4,13 80 &(0 ,2

)43:7 )

30 / BBB 55 67

. :: 3 9,. 7.. ,. 6,5 55 .6..0 0 55 :,.0 15 .4 ,7./:2 4, . ; 6 3 C4... 0 ><;

3,.6, ,6,, 3 D 6 ><;E0 0 15 ,7./:2 .4 A ? ?

;

,/,0 . :: 3 9,. 7.. , /, 12 55 3, 9, 0 15 7 12 3 :, C4... ::, ,0 . ,5 6 . 6 3 6 ><;0 3,6,0 32 , 51: 6, 1.8 . 3,483 55 /,. $, 1,/.20 3 6 , 1.8 F, 6,5 3 : 9,. 7..0 .

3 8,4 0 ,. . 3 9,. 7..0 , 3 . . ,:., 3 5@.8 6 3 .6.. 47,0 3 .74 : 9, F57 6,5 C4...0 3,12 3 F:2 .4 .6.. 6, C4...0 5@ 7:71: 5,8 C4 3 :43 C4... 7,.80 ,3, 1.8 ,9 3,483 :4,1: F,. 6 3 79, 6 5. 5.0 12 3 ,7 ,- .. 3 3 1=. 6.: 4, . G 6 3 6 ><; 9, 455,.:2 . 9.34 2 C4 77,4.2 6 3,.8 15.8 .8 3 7..,0 3,6, 3 41C4 3, 7,.80 15 :43 12 3 ,7 ,0 , /..H ... 3 3483 . ,5 6 3 7:.2 .. ,9 <<0 93,.0 57:. 4, 6, C4.,.8 14.: 47 34 ,4 ,0 2 3 . 7:.2 15.8

;

.6,.8

,/,0 . 5@.8 77:.. 6 3 . 7:.20 3 ,7

55..8 ./..4 .,.5..0 .543 0 . 7,.8 ,: : 6 .5.:,:2 .4 3:, ,

3 1/ 5 . 15 12 3 ,7 ,0 3,483 ..4. 6 ,7:2 66./. 3 9,. 7.. . 6,35.8 6,5 3 ,7:2 47,0 3 3 C4... 6 3 .74 : 9 5 6, . /:75 4.:.I.0 34 6, ,..:0 55,.:0

, >0 < 7,0 55,.: , A 7, 9,.

,/,0 . 3 ,7:2 47,0 . 3 : 1 7: 3 ,:., 3 F 5. 15.8 16, 3. 4,0 ! A? 6 15 ..4 16, 3. 4, 3,483 .. 5 3,0 A A0 3 3::8 5 3,.0 3 .6.. 47,0 15 .4

,/,0 . . : ,/: . 3 ,7:2 47,0 3 3 88,./ 6,5 3 . .. ,, 3,8. ,7./:2 1,.8 ! GG 6 <0 ??<A 6 >0 <<? 6 >0 ?> 6 >0 <> 6 <0 AG 6 <0 >GA 6 <0 >G? 6 < >G?? 6 <0 16, 3 E1: 7F 4, 9/,0 3 E1: 7F 4,0 3,483 /,. ,, G < ; 47 3 47,0 6, 7,.8 4: 3 /,. 47,0 15 ,, 12 3. 4,0 ,5 3 :. 3. 4, 6, 5@.8 =4.. :2 . ,7 6 3 3,.6, F, 9 .4-

! ! "#$"

& &' (

" &))*

&* (

"&)

& + , -

! " +

+ ! "&)*%/ ;

3,6,0 14 1/.4:2 3. 4, . 51,@0 470 5@.8 ..0 933, 3 7.., C4:.62 6, 3., 15.8 .: 3 16. 6 3 7:.2 47,0 14 3 /.:0 3 3 ,4.0 .6 20 4, 3 .74 :0 1 F57 6,5 C4...0 34 3 ,. /. 6450 C4 3., 1.8 5 3, 14 7,., 3 .4 6 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;

$4,3,5,0 3 7.., , : ,C4., 1 1:.3.80 3 . ,5 6 3 /,. ,, 12 3 E1: 7F 4,

!"# 32 , 43 .: :.5 :,. 6,5 3. 4,0 3 3,12 3. 4, 15.8 F :, 3 C4... 7,.80 34 :43 4, 3 6 ><; ,3, 15.8 :7

5@.8 ,5.. 9.3 ,7 3 1/ .40 93.3 , ,C4., 1 ,5. 6,3 12 3. 4,0 . 74,4 3 ,5 6 3 :. 1.8 5 3. 4,0 12 3 E1: 7F 4,0 . . 34 .57,./ 1, . 5. 3 ,7:2 47,0 15 64,.3 3 . 9,. 7..

3 ,7:2 47,0 . . 3 3 .5 6 .4 6 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;0 3 C4., : 9, 57::2 / 3,6,0 . . ,5 6 3 7:.2 47,0 3, 9

.57,./ .2 6 F. 6 ,44, 3 C4., :0 14 7,., 3 .4 6 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;

9/,0 93 . . 1, 4 6,5 3 ,7:2 47,0 3 3 . ,44, 9, . F. 7,., 3 .4 6 .6.. 47,0 3,6, 93 3 . 7,5,0 3,. . 3 ,:/ 7:.20 34 ,5. 1:.3 12 3 3:, ,0 ,3, 15 1:. C40 3 16. 6 3 . 7:.2 1 .8 3 7, 7..,

34830 3 :, 4: 6, 3 7.., 3 70 470 F4, >0 9.3 7@.8 3,.0 3 3 ,4. 93.3 4,0 3 .74 7,7,20 77, 1 34 ,. 3,0 7,., 3 .4 6 3 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;

,/,0 3 :, 4: 6, 3 7..,0 ,7: 3 1/ . ,. . 3 ,7:2 47,0 : ,:. 47 F4, 0 93.3 . :, 5.8 6,5 3 &.,. 9 :, 3 5..,,0 '&0 (4,80 0 9.3 .6,5. 3,.0 3 ,0 3 5 ,4. . ,. 3 C4., : 9/,0 3483 F4, > 5@ 7@.80 3 3 ,:/ ,4. 77, 1 5 7,., 3 .4 6 3 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;0 14 3 . 7@.8 12 3 43,.2 ,0 93 ,9 F4, 0 77,. 3 ,4. 77,.8 1 5 3 C4., :0 7,., 3 .4 6 3 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;0 . 14 1/.4:2 6.,5 :4./ 7..0 430 C4 3 ::8 ,4.0 .6 20 F..8 3 C4., :0 34 15.8 ,. 3,0 34 7,., 3 .4 6 .6.. 47, 3 1 ,

/. 3, 3 3 1/ 14:4 7@.8 4,,.8 . F4, >0 34 15 57,. . . /..0 15.8 5 12 43,.I 66., 6 3 ,70 0 ,4:.8 . 7,7,. 6 450 14 ..8 3,. . 3.80 14 3 ::8 ,4. F..8 3 .74 : 14 7,., 3 .4 6 3 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;

9/,0 3 . 1 /. ,5. 440 3,6,0 , 1 .8 F4, >0 , 3,12 3 ,7:2

47, 5@.8 . 7@.8 3,.0 3 3 .5 6 3 C4... 7,.8 15.8 :430 3 : 9 /0 #,0 9 6, 6,5 2 451, 6 2 ,44, ,. 3,0 . 34 ,,.:2 ,C4., 1 .8 3 9,32 7 ,

3 ,:.0 7: 47 F4, 0 . : .6.,5 ,:. ,3, 6, .7::.8 3 9,3 6 3 ,7:2 47,0 93,.0 3, . 57: .: 14 2 ,4. F..8 3 .74 :0 7,., 3 .4 6 3 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;

3 , 6, 6,5.8 3 1/ .6,0 5 6,5 3 6450 3 3 . ,,70 5@ 2 6.,5 7@.8 14 3 ,4.0 .6 2 F..8 3,0 9, 43 F..8 3,0 14 7,., 3 .4 6 3 .6.. 47,0 93,0 3 1/ 7@.8 3,.0 9 .57,./ 6, 34 1:2.8 3 ,7:2 47, 6 3 ,7 ,

3,6, :0 , 1 .8 F4,

3 . 520 9.3 3. 4, .7::.8 3 /.84, 6 3 1/ . ,. 12 3 3:, ,0 0 ,3, 3. 4, 7,.8 .8 , 3 ,7:2 47, 64,.3 12 3 ,7

,0 9.3 7@.8 3,.0 3 3 ,:/ .50 3 C4., : 9 /0 3,12 14 1/.4:2 3 16. 6 3 7:.2 47, 93.3 ,.0 3 3 ,:/ ,4. 9 1 F..8 3 C4., :0 7,., 3 .4 6 3 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;0 ,3, 15 8, 3 7..,

/ 3,9.0 3 64,3, ::.8 66 6 3 1/0 . 30 93 3 :.5 6, ,:0 . ,5 6 . ;> 6 3 6 ><;0 7,/.. 93,6 15 F, 3,.6,0 , 1 :.0 0 , 15 8, 3 3:, ,0 :2 ,3, 7,., 457. 6, 7. 6 3 C4., :0 #,0 7,., ,5.. 6 3 C4... 7,.80 3,483 3 5@.8 6 9, . ,5 6

. 6 3 6 ><;

% &'( &

( ) &

()**&

0 *2" 3

4 % & 3

" -

% *. 5

666 !

3,6,0 .6 6, 9:: ., ,0 3 1=. 4,

. G 6 3 6 ><;0 15 6.:0 9, ,=0 93,6, 3 9, 9 7 3483 52 1 3 ,, 5 12 3 :, ::, ,0 3,12 .5..8 3 1=.0 6.: 4,

. G 6 3 6 ><;0 9 3::8 7,., 3 5@.8 6 3 9, 47,0 93,120 3483 3 . 3::8 1 5 1 7,57:2 ,. 9/,0 .,,7./ 6 7,57 3::8 1.8 5 3 ,, .5..8 3 1=. 47,0 : ,. 3. 4, ./:. .3, 3 .5.: ,,0 5 12 3 :, ::, ,0 47 3 1=. 47,0 , 3. 4, 94: 7, 4: 3 9, 7 .,:20 6, 3 ,0 3 3 ,, .5..8 3 1=. 47, . 64::2 /.. 12 3 ,7:2 47, 6.,5 12 3 ,7 ,0 93,.0 . 15 F57:.6. 3 3 1=. 6.: . ,5 6 3 7:.2 47,0 9, :.1: 1 .5. 430 3 .57,./ .. 3,.0 6, 3 16. 6 3 . 7:.2 15.8 .8 3 7..,0 .543 0 3 ,4. 3 C4., :0 34 /.:2 F..8 7,., 3 .4 6 3 .6.. 4, . ; 6 3 6 ><;0 ,3, ,5..8 8:2 1:.30 , 15.8 .

,/,0 . . : . ,7:2 47,0 3 3 .74 : , 51: 6, 1.8 ,:0 ,0 15.8 F57 6,5 C4...0 32 , .8,: 7, 6 3 ,:/ 741:. 74,70 3., ,: 15.8 ,, 12 3. 4,0 ,3, 94: 18 3 .:: C4 6 3,12 3 7:.8 6 3 :,. 41. 8,47 34.8 (0 34 15.8 /,:2 66

;

3 ,845 47,0 15 ,. 16, 3. 4,0 3 3 9,. : 9, 51: 6, 15.8 ,74 C4...0 ,:., 3,0 32 15 F57 6,5 C4...0 3 3,120 3 , 74.8 C4... 6 3 C4., : ,3, . 14 6 3 79, 6 5. 5.0 / . 3 C4.,.8 43,.20 ,3, . : 51: 15 ,= 3 7,.5,2 , 6, ,=.8 3 1/ ,8450 . 64 47 3 6450 3 3483 . 3 47,0 15 ,. 8. 3 /,. ,9 12 3. 4, A A0 47 A?0 3483 3 E1: 7F 4, 4:: 3 /,. 47, 6 3. 4,0 14 3 =4.1: .40 9, ,5 3. 4,0 , :2 3 3,.1/ F, 0 14 1/.4:20 3 1/ .4 . 3 =4.1: .4 12 3. 4, !,.:2 3 3. 4, 5 . 6. 77,7,. .8 2 9, 3 1/ ,. ,845

,,.:20 3. 4, .0 14 3 1/ 7,5.0 .:. 9, ,=.8 3 1/ ,845

!9 .6, 3 .4 . ,0 93.3 ,: 3 77:.. 6 3 :7.8 7,/..0 51. . . ;

6 3 .83 $., 57. ,7,2 . C4...0 31.:.. :5 0 ?

3,.6, ,6,, J3 6 ?K0 /. L/.0 3 3:, ,0 ,3, 94: 15 .: 3 16. 6 3 :7.8 7,/.. 47,0 :2 93 8 /. 5,8 . .7:20 3 .3, 7 7. 6 3 C4., :0 15 45 12 3 ,7 ,0 , 3 ,5. 57.0 34 15 ,0 4, . ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 15.8 :.5 , ,: 3 3:,

9/,0 . 3 1/ ,8,0 . . . 7,8,73 ; 6 3 ,7:2 47,0 15 64,.3 12 3 ,7 ,0 3 9,. 7..0 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15 45 3,483 7 ! ?G? ,9 0 1. . . : 46: 3,.0 3 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6 . ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, , C40 93 3 ,7 , 3 7,/0 3 3,12 3 3:, , , .: :.5 3 5@.8 6 :,. 12 3. 4,0 3 3 ,:., ,9 C4... 7,.8 4, 3 6 ><;0 1 :, 15 :7 3,6,0 3 . ,:.6 . :.

/ ! #

3 :.5 ,. . 3 . 7.. , .5.:, 3 15 /.: . 3 : 7.. . 9/,0 6, , .5.:, 3 0 15 .8 . 0 34 3. 4, . ,. : .5. 3 . 7.. 47,

573.::2 :0 3 7. 5..8 93.3 4, . 3 ,7:2 66./.0 , 3 3 C4., :0 34 , .8,: 7, 6 3 /:75: ./..0 93.3 , 15 ,,. 3,0 3 . 6 3 , 3,6,0 . 3, . ., .2 6 ,. 6 3 C4., :0 3,47 3 ,:/ 741:. 74,7 94: 15 41,/0 3,47 . 3 41,/.8 6 741:. 74,7 47, 7,5. 3 41,/.8 6 7,./ ../.4: ., 4::2 3 :.5 6, ,: 6 3 C4., : . 6:.5.:2 , 7,F4::2 ,.0 0 .

,C4., 1 .4

,/,0 6, 3 3, .8 , . 3 : 7..0 34 3 . , 477, 3 : 12 8.1: /.0 15 3 93.3 : :.@9. ,. 3. 4, .5. 3 . 9,. 7..

3 :/,8 6 3 77. :7.8 5 51. .

. ;

6 3 6 ?0 : 15 1:2 .8 3 7.., 3 , 1.8 3 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15 /.:2 45 3,483 7 ! ?G? ,9 0 1. 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6 . ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, ,

/ !

3 :.5 ,. . 3 . 7.. , .5.:, 3 15 /.: . 3 : 7.. . 9/,0 6, , .5.:, 3 0 15 .8 . 0 34 3. 4, . ,. : .5. 3 . 7.. 47,

,/,0 6, 3 3, .8 , . 3 : 7..0 34 3 . , 477, 3 : 12 8.1: /.0 15 3 93.3 : :.@9. ,. 3. 4, .5. 3 . 9,. 7..

;

3 :/,8 6 3 77. :7.8 5 51. .

. ;

6 3 6 ?0 : 15 1:2 .8 3 7.., 3 , 1.8 3 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15 /.:2 45 3,483 7 ! ?G ?G? ,9 0 1. 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6

. ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, ,

3 :.5 ,. . 3 . 7.. , .5.:, 3 15 /.: . 3 : 7.. . 9/,0 6, , .5.:, 3 0 15 .8 . 0 34 3. 4, . ,. : .5. 3 . 7.. 47,

,/,0 6, 3 3, .8 , . 3 : 7..0 34

;

3 . , 477, 3 : 12 8.1: /.0 15 3 93.3 : :.@9. ,. 3. 4, .5. 3 . 9,. 7..

3 :/,8 6 3 77. :7.8 5 51. .

. ;

6 3 6 ?0 : 15 1:2 .8 3 7.., 3 , 1.8 3 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15 /.:2 45 3,483 7 ! ?G? ,9 0 1. 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6 . ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, ,

1* ! #

3 :.5 ,. . 3 . 7.. , .5.:, 3 15 /.: . 3 : 7.. . 9/,0 6, , .5.:, 3 0 15 .8 . 0 34 3. 4, . ,. : .5. 3 . 7.. 47,

,/,0 6, 3 3, .8 , . 3 : 7..0 34 3 . , 477, 3 : 12 8.1: /.0 15 3

93.3 : :.@9. ,. 3. 4, .5. 3 . 9,. 7..

3 :/,8 6 3 77. :7.8 5 51. .

. ;

6 3 6 ?0 : 15 1:2 .8 3 7.., 3 , 1.8 3 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15 /.:2 45 3,483 7 ! ?G? ,9 0 1. 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6 . ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, ,

// 1 ??

3 :.5 ,. . 3 . 7.. , .5.:, 3 15 /.: . 3 : 7.. . 9/,0 6, , .5.:, 3 0 15 .8 . 0 34 3. 4, . ,. : .5. 3 . 7.. 47,

,/,0 6, 3 3, .8 , . 3 : 7..0 34 3 . , 477, 3 : 12 8.1: /.0 15 3 93.3 : :.@9. ,. 3. 4, .5. 3 . 9,. 7..

3 :/,8 6 3 77. :7.8 5 51. .

. ;

6 3 6 ?0 : 15 1:2 .8 3 7.., 3 , 1.8 3 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15 /.:2 45 3,483 7 ! ?G? ,9 0 1. 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6 . ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, ,

! !

3 :.5 ,. . 3 . 7.. , .5.:, 3 15 /.: . 3 : 7.. . 9/,0 6, , .5.:, 3 0 15 .8 . 0 34 3. 4, . ,. : .5. 3 . 7.. 47,

,/,0 6, 3 3, .8 , . 3 : 7..0 34 3 . , 477, 3 : 12 8.1: /.0 15 3 93.3 : :.@9. ,. 3. 4, .5. 3 . 9,. 7..

;

3 :/,8 6 3 77. :7.8 5 51. .

. ;

6 3 6 ?0 : 15 1:2 .8 3 7.., 3 , 1.8 3 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15 /.:2 45 3,483 7 ! ?;G ,9 0 1. 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6 . ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, ,

! !

;

3 :.5 ,. . 3 . 7.. , .5.:, 3 15 /.: . 3 : 7.. . 9/,0 6, , .5.:, 3 0 15 .8 . 0 34 3. 4, . ,. : .5. 3 . 7.. 47,

;

,/,0 6, 3 3, .8 , . 3 : 7..0 34 3 . , 477, 3 : 12 8.1: /.0 15 3 93.3 : :.@9. ,. 3. 4, .5. 3 . 9,. 7..

;;

3 :/,8 6 3 77. :7.8 5 51. .

. ;

6 3 6 ?0 : 15 1:2 .8 3

7.., 3 , 1.8 3 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15 /.:2 45 3,483 7 ! ?G? ,9 0 1. 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6 . ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, ,

3 :.5 ,. . 3 . 7.. , .5.:, 3 15 /.: . 3 : 7.. . 9/,0 6, , .5.:, 3 0 15 .8 . 0 34 3. 4, . ,. : .5. 3 . 7.. 47,

;

,/,0 6, 3 3, .8 , . 3 : 7..0 34 3 . , 477, 3 : 12 8.1: /.0 15 3 93.3 : :.@9. ,. 3. 4, .5. 3 . 9,. 7..

3 :/,8 6 3 77. :7.8 5 51. .

. ;

6 3 6 ?0 : 15 1:2 .8 3 7.., 3 , 1.8 3 3 7. 6 3 C4., : 15

/.:2 45 3,483 7 ! ?G?0 ?;G ?A ,9 0 1. 3 ,5. 57. 54 15 , . ,5 6

. ? 6 3 6 ><;0 6, 3,12 . 15.8 /.:1: 6, 1.8 :.5 12 3 3:, ,

4 49.

In consequence, after assigning answers adversarial to the petitioners, upon the hereinabove extracted issue(s), this Court is constrained to dismiss the writ petition(s). Accordingly, the writ petitions are dismissed 9.3 6 G0# 30 47 3 7.., . 3 0 1 6,39.3 7. 12 3 7.., 9.3 3 D+ & ,( -( ./E 6, 5..8.8 3 4,: ., . 3 ,

55 6

! * ($'.)($& 4 7 897:

897: