Gurkirpal Singh Randhawa v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And ANR

   
  



 


 

 !"

#$#%&#'

(

)) * % ( +(,#'

( 

-) ) * ./ 0  





 100 

0 
 /!



 









!



2 / !) 0


  0 /    
        
 
   


     
!  " "    




##45('#% 05(67 89:8;

)

#
 $ %    &#
'(
)'#*'#
#)
)'#*+, #-. #(
'/
)')#+, #0.

%  1 

 "

  " 

%  " %"    

      "  "

 )


      % 2     %  $    3"  +        

4$  4.          

       5
 6

   

   "   % 2)#
'/
)'#&

15 "7  "  " 8
9*/9/:'
; 5 "7  "  % 

"2%  %  "

 1 

(:)('*9
   %   " 

  "
; "    

"   1$  %%       )(
'&
)'#- 1"%    

0(-*09   

(:)('*9
 &
 "

%  1 %  +      4     

  .       "

<<"  
;   1   1  "


 " 1= 1%   17 1 $  5  +7   .
 6    " 1  = 1     

    %     
; 

" 1= 1   % 1   17 1  1 ;6
;  %  

   #*
'-
)'#-
  % 

   )#
':
)'#-
6         % 

 %  

 "   

"



%  "

"

#*/*''9   
6%    %  

  "   "
 ;   1   1 

  
;   1    1%

     % 1 1"

 1  =1    "= 1%    
 -
 ;  = 1               

   = 1    ):
##
)'#/   1     = 1    &#
'(
)'#*       1  "

    "    

    %  "  %  "            

    "

#(
'-
)'#-#:
'/
)'#-%    1     '#
#)
)'#*
 :
      &#
'(
)'#* '#
#)
)'#*          

   #-
#)
)'#*      

 1
; 

% "

1

  1         '-
')
)'#0  +,   #:.
 ;   ,           >
   
        

   


!"
  #  

 $    $   $  % &' " % % %()%*+*,- 

 )%***.

/0121.
/  1/%0+%30/4

)%4** % /%/3%/4  .5    

$    

 #     6    % 57
!




!"
 88#    %&'  " % % %()%*+*,- /+%09%30/9 /*%0,%30/, :

%; "8$<68  <                 

   %&' " % % %)%/0*+*,

  

)%***  1/%0+%30/4   8# 

 8# = /
 ;       '-
')
)'#0+, #:. $ 8
)-)/0)'#0  $ %%  1%   '-
'0
)'#0  '-
')
)'#0

1

 1%  
; "  %  " 2            1    

  1%      "

    1   

%   %"  "      1     

 1   
; , 

1 $ '-
'0
)'#0+,  #/.        >;

  % 1

 1     % "



5?3@57;A;   1                "      " % 

5
B 2   %



5
+$ 8
#':(:/.          8
:::97#'&0&9;#  7 &#
'(
)'#*         8
*::  
#
#)
#*    %   7  9C     $""  1  "% %      " 

   


 CD ;A5 5?3@57;A;

  

  1        

        5
B 2   %



5
+$ 8
#':(:/. "#(
'-
)'#- #:
'/
)'#/ 3?!7
E           %  $   3"        "          %  

*  "  %           5
B 2   

 %



5
$ 8
#':(:/   8
:::

&#
'(
)'#* 

 1  1 

"

  9 F  19;# $3
       

           '-
')
)'#0 +, #:1.

1

 1  1  

2
 ;  =    

      

 1  

   1    %   "      

1    97   1 1"      
 

   





 

 

    
 

!

"##$ %&'
&(" %

     >(
6   

 14

        1           %  1

"
 0
;        1 $   $  0))!+<7#%=## &$) (5 (

('58 %#4 %>#'

5( "

0

*    "    =   
 #'
D

     % 2%%  1

  "  G    ""<     

A



 = " % "    "      =         "
 8  0)) !+<7#%=##2$ ,8$# $+4%8"



  +   &/. H

;

    1 "

       

   1  %      
H ##
; 

    1 "    "          1 

    "        "
;2  1%% "

   "

1 "

1  1 %%%  1
E   "

 , #:1

1    

   1  %   1      

"

 9 

  1  



   "

%
;"



1 

 1  
 C      %  

 1%  '-
')
)'#0+, #:1.

1

 1  
;"   "

2     



 1  2 "

    1

 


3       

%   %"  "      1        

 1   
 6 %  

   "

E *
 6 

1 $ '-
'0
)'#0 +, #/.$ 8
)-)/0)'#0 



 #*
')
)')'+, #*.%  1



1      %  1  %      ,         

  "#(
'-
)'#-#:
'/
)'#-%   < %   2 
; ,    

    >
                

8

 8#  .     !?8    09%02%/2 



?      #    $    $    $   

   .   %  1/%0+%/4    .  )%4**   %  0/%/3%/4      

 .    

$  

 

 # 

 8

 @        8   8# $  

#   @       

 /+%09%/9 /*%0,%/,  A :

;

 

  /+.09.30/9 

/*.,.30/,  A :

8   
%  . B   #.
 /$ < <$<  %= (
    #*
')
)')'+, #*.%



2     %     $ 0)&&)''' &#
'(
)'#* #*
')
)')'
;  %  % % #)
'#
)')#+, #(.

 "

 #*
')
)')'% = 
;" %

 " 

 1   

    

 1 
6%      

2  

  " "

   %   = 
;  ,           >&
 ;  

   1    % 

    #*
')
)')'+, #*.    %    >            1       

            "      "  % 

  9 &#
'(
#* 98
*:: 
'#
#)
#* % 7  9$   

-  $""  1   %  

,""

    "  "

    1"

    

       1      ,    

           "  #(
'-
#-   #:
'/
#/ 

 < 3?!7E -
!     $C        8   %
     8  



 D   ' %
"

 "  #         )%/  D  '%"$    #     

    @    D#$ "

 "  #D    

    %C  

  8    #  @  8    % *% " #$      

  /4%03%3030("@</4-D%
     "

 "  #        #      %C           '          $         8 8  8D%= 0
 6 

1 $ #)
'#
)')# +, #(. 

 

 #(
'/
)')# +, #0.
; ,       % >
   

    D#% #% .

 

)%40,4 33%0+%/1     8 )%14.3/1%


6E $ 33%/0%/1       8   #%  $   8  

 ' 8     $      8   3+%01%/9%
    

  

  3/%01%30/9# !



 <   8@   D#


   <     # 8'  #    #            D#% 
  

            3/%01%/98   8   #$    

@ #F #  8 D#



   #8# 

% "      #D# 

 D# #  #  @       8      8     #  

   8#    



      

%
 $ '     8  8# 

8 
 

  % 


!"
 88#    

)%/19.

/0121.
/ /4%03%3030 !?8   /3%0/%3/  <)%2311.3030% 57
!




!"
  #

  $    $   $   %&' $" %

()%*+*,-  

)%***.

/0121.
/ 1/%0+%30/4

 )%4** 0/%/3%/4
 

      

$           

   #        6   % 57
!




!"
 88#    %&' $ " %

()%*+*,- /+%09%30/9 /*%0,%30/9 :

%;

"   8$   

 )%/19.

/0121.
/     /4%03%3030    <68     <   <       

    

 8     (/+%09%/9 /*%0,%/9- :

8 6      #% C    8              


 %-%= #'
               &#
'(
)'#*

 '#
#)
)'#* #(
'/
)')#     % 


 ##
 3       "     #(
'/
)')#+, #0.

1

 1 % %   1  

 2  %  


6       

 #(
'/
)')# +, #0. " 

#*
')
)')'+,  #*.% =  1 $  "

     = 
 #)
 3     

 " 

#(
'/
)')#

1

 1  % %
;  %      

1  

%     

 
 #&
 6           %  


 #-
     #(
'/
)')#% %   1

 1%  

 %1  1  

             % 1
 6    %   %    %   



 1   % %

    "
 B    %        

  

  ""     

;  

 = "%  "   " 



 %  


;  % 2 A4  "$  ) * 
 +, -"##$ %(' 
  %!
'  ./&
 ;    

   "   1    A4  "$   / " "4  + .%  1%        ;
 #       8  

#%


   #D8# #?  6           #       

    @ %
 6:B%

  G   /2%%%  8  # %     $ 8   %= #:
 % %=  "  %  "   =    = "              %            A4  "$  %         

  ) * 

  

  0   

1%"#(#'$
/$.
; 

  "   -*  "% 1

1       H-*
"" <  

 $ 

+.66     %1       "         1

 1
 + .=   1"     

    

  +.6      "   %    " 1   "  

    %
+ .            1

   1,    =    "   %
+.  

    ,  1

 "2       

  1    ,    
+.      1  "    

    "

       "2  

   

 

    1 =   

1 "   
+.  

  % 1    
+.;     ""   %       

   
;   1     "2 1      
+.F  =      1  

      %  "
           ""    %    

"    1                1   
;    "

        4   1 "
+.  6            = "         1  

 1
+2.6F  =   1    9   "2 

 "

 2%%       

     " "

 +. 

    "   


    4 

  "

  4   = %  "2 

+".6     

 1  =     %
; 

 1   "21"2    "2 

   "2 "    1
+7   7F $  .
+. = "    "  "

       

    "2    = " % 1"

"  %           

   F 


  A
6% 5A

:/)  )0 "#%7 #

@ % $     /5   $A"  % =  H =   "       H
+'.6""% 

  " 1               
 ;    

 "    %  = "        

         

       1         H 



H
#/
 "%%   "A4  "$      





   

     
 

  

1  "##$%/' 
  "/#1 2"##$%&' 
  &("  %
'3
 ;           "  

    H:
6     " 

           "           "       1 

% 
6    71B       

  

 

"
   % 

"  1   1 "     "   

 1
A%      " 1  
;  "  "    2%% 

 1

  " % "     1 1
 /
;%% 2% 2 1 $  *

4  5++   0   %* 
"#1 ($'   0 ) 7  

 8

 +7


 9

0+  +7



 8

 +7

%* 
.17.'
*
6   

 14 

1     %1

 "
(
 ;                  1   $   $  %)%E'6 %7 C   "    =   
D

     %  2%%  1

  " G           ""         

A 

 = "  % "    "          =                       "
0
8  
8
2   

   +$$
/#&  &/. H&/



;

    1 "

                    

    1  % 

     
E

* ; 

    1"    "     

     1    "         "
;2  1%% " 

   "

1 "

1     1     %    %      %  1
#'
C  "     $   @


  + 6  #:.    ,  1 
##
A% %A$      

 14 %   1A$          1   1    

          

 
E #*
     #(
'/
)')#

1

  1% % "    

%

 #*
')
)')'
     1

 1

#(
'/
)')#  ,"%

 

    "

  %  "

    

       

      

   

2       " "1  

%

  4

%   1 %
5 %      % %= 1 %

  "

 1 %  +    4 

 .
6  " 

 % 1

 1 

,""



 %"     
6 

 "  1 

," "   "

  "
;2     = 1           "
 #(
6% 2  

1 $ #)
'#
)')#

$ 8
0)&&)')'  "

    &#
'(
)'#* '#
#)
)'#*   #(
'/
)')#     1= 
;         %  " % =    %   % "  "       1 
;

   1     

#''''9         1  

 %    C B65 $   %   
#0
 ;%   %    "

 )'
  

 1  

 1

  0 /"

 

-) ) *

"

 

29   I 98      I 98