Jagmohan Lal And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.
!"#"$% &
'% ()'*')*
!"
!"
!"
$
%% # !"
& ''''
')*+ %
((
) #
*
!
+
, - .
/
0 * #"
!
&11((223 ## !"
# !
4 "" . ) - * !
0 +
(223)
+ 4
! *
* -
5 !
#
"
5 #
!
(223 *
*
6!% " - -78(2&19(212 #"
131((212 .
# "
#
#
-78:19:(223 #" #
- ;
" #" " #
#
#" "
"
"
) "
-
2911(213+ " *
#
!
*
#
- ;
" #
#
!
#
"
!*
- ;
#
#"# 5 "
( "
1 (
6 !
-7 8:19: (223 #
"
" )- 811<39=-7=(213+
*
4 "
#
-
!
1:2:(213 " ;
*
"
#
1 ( #
"
#* % )
+ # *
#* (( (9
4 #
"
"
5
" #% !
& 4 ((
"
&11((223 .
& ,
> - " .
/
0 * * "
! #
(223 *
# "* ! *
# " ! #
)"
(129(22<+
1)&+
* "*
"
# &11((223*
)9+
1
# #
2121(22?
!
>8 #6
- * " >!
1229(22@ 9 4 "
##
2121(22? # !"
&11((223 4 ((
2121(22?
&11((223 " !
."
""
*
!
A
2@2<(22<) B 19#
+ #" "
#
!
#
&11((223*
"
"
# 4
# "
;
,
B =19
#
&11((223 3
# "
"=
" " ,
> - " .
/
0 * )
&+ !
*
#
1:?: 1:@9
#"!
B =1
! !
* &2 &3
!
* &11((223 !
B ?
&#
*
1:??
!*
* #
5* 8 -" ,
>- " . #6 19211:??) B =(+ !"
- &)+
. #
(3C " B
# 3 (3C "
B
B
3C* ?
# # " 3C " 12 # #
# (3C
" B 4 " B
" *
.
# *
@ 4 "
# !
% $!
" 1? * #"
*
#
""
"
"
1<?2D 1? * 1( "
- # *
- #
"
4 # * #
#
0 * - # * *
* "
"
# $!
4 "
# B=" * "
% D * % #
. *
% 4 "" / " 5*)
+
. -" 4 "" / " < 4
# !
"
(2" # !
" # "
# B"
!
#
B"
!
. "
"
B
"" "
# B
#" "
* " *
"
!
#" * %
"
#
"
" * "
"
* # %
"
* %
" "
"
B # )- 11)+
+ 0 *="
)*+- 11
.
"
" B # " " !
" #
!
#
"
"
# " "
#"
"
#
!
$!
= " B
$!
!
"
*!
"
!
"
" *
E$!
"
F "
B
*
# = * "=* !"
* "
!
" !"
!
"
"
"
#" "
#
!
*
#
#"
"
!
"
: 4
2<2?1:<<) B =9+ #
#
8 -" ,
>- " . 8 #6 % $!
"
19211:?? * ""
!
4 5 "
#
# #!
%
& "
* # % !
# # !
$!
# % # !"
*
; ! 12 222A= 4 " B # # *
#
# = + 32C* . > *+ 12C* "
# 21291:@< #
" 4D
"
E
0 * B"
12C
*
"
2<2<1:@& * " B
#
* "
*!
12C* (3C # B *
.
1? % $!
# " (2 * #" "
#
1& * "
- # * #
" # ! # * #
- #
"
"
#
D * # * #
. *
% 4 "" / "
. -" 4 "" / " # "
* % $!
4 "
#
!
19211:?? "
" >
!
>*
#"
"
!B > "
*"
" B
!
1:??
# ! "
""
" -
""
"" 12 4
#
#
8 -" ,
>- " . *#
2<2?1:<<. #
(32&1:<:
2<2?1:<< *
19211:??# "
""
! * "
" %#
1:<: *="
>"> #
"
&
2<2?1:<< #"!
"
# 21291:<: "
#
"
B
3C" B
"
1:@& B"
3C #"" "
#
" B
(3C # B "" "
* *
#!
#
!
*"
! B "
B "
!B > "
"
4 "
>
* % #
/
"
1& 11 *
# "
( 9 11 4
(?2&1::?
#
* $!
) B =?+ !
, - .
/
0 * )
&+#
" "
8 -" ,
>- " . 8 #6 3C " B "
" 1::(=:& "
! "
11 )+ 12 !
19211:?? 2<2?1:<<
!
#
% $!
# "
!
*"
4 "" / " - - "
$!
6 "" / " "
- "
$!
* # 8 $ "
8 -" , - !
"" , - # * % D # !
" 0 * #
# !
" "
#"
* , -
0 * 6 A" 4
* * % $!
"
- #
(2 1( .
"
#
(?2&1::? # " 1::(=:&
! 122C ==
&
* " = " B
" !!
" # *
$!
1& 4
"! #
8 -" , - .
#
!
4 #
"
292<1:::*
-! ) 6!+ 0 * #"
"
!
" "
"
=
!
#
-! #
8 -" , - . % $!
)
&+
" =
#""
"
4 #""
"
19 D(92&(222 (
6 4 ""
/ " ""
"
!
! *
" !
#
!
*
* " A "
$!
0 ! #
""
#" " .
"
* "*
!
*2&29(222 !
*
"
" !
*
"
*
!
*
.
1?@
1?9
"
! * !
*
"
13 .
#
"
! # ;
*
"=
1 (
!
4 !
#= 00.6 .4 . HHHHHHHHHHHH AA7AA6A HHHHHHHHHHHHHH
# HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH , - .
/
0 * *
= 4 . "
!
!
, - .
/
0 * *$!
#"" .
!
*
A "
.
*
*
"
$!
# .#
"
*
* , - .
/
0 * $!
% #""
$!
-! !"
6
!"
#" "*
$!
D 4 . > "
$!
/ !
, - .
/
0 * *$!
" .
=!
*$!
.
" * !
*
"
*, - .
/
0 * !
*
.
"
* #""" "
"
6/D8/84 6
"
"
!
" #
*
""
"
6/D8/84 6
I J.
*
"
*
*!
#
&
#
."
" *
*
"
.
K 1? #
!
.
! !*
;
!"
"=
#
!
"=
-78&919(221
!
*
#
&#
!
*
$!
(?2&1::?
" ; * " * "
!
#"
"#
4 *## *
"!
)
&+
G"" /0 0 1:3( *
1?2:1:::I 4 #
#
*6!% " - (@23(22&
!"
$
#
"
"
, - .
#
"
"#
#
4 !
"
= G. #
!
;
**
. #
*
81 ( *
"
"* $!
#
"
$!
"
"
"
"
, - .
/
0 *
"
#
"
.
*
"
5
! .
#
!
, - .
/
0 * "
""
.
" #
!
&112(221 #
"
!
"
#
.
#
$!
# "
!
! "
/
" 1::3
.
!
" ;
;!
,
>" * !
# 4
" *
81 (*
"
*
#
"
.! #
!
*
" #
* " "
"#
"
"
#
* * " - "
"" "
#I 1@ 4 # #
#
&#
"
$!
#
"
#" # "
"
*
&112(221 #
"
!
"
#
!
.
#
"
5
)
&+#
! 1< 4
" ! *
#
"
#
#" "
(129(22< #
(223 * #"
" *
&
.
*"
"
#
*#"
## !"
&11((223 !
-
1:
#
* "
(329(22@) B =1(#
+ *#" #
# #
2121(22?
#
!
G8 #6
- * " I
0"
6 1229(22@4
"
#
##
2121(22?## !
#" * " ##
4 " #
" !
=!
A
"
" ""
"
" "
# 11231::< "
"
"
&11((223 "
(2 .
#
"" *
"
* "
# (?2&1::?
" "
" "*
* *5
"
A " $!
"
(1
"
1@2@(22@) B =13+ *
"
#
!
"
!
*
#
!
!"
"
# *
!
""
* "
"
*
> " * !
# 12C "
"
1@2@(22@ "
.
"*
4"
"=
# !"
#
!
#
* "
!"
&121(223 !
!
"
!
(223 (( . #
#
*
"
#
-78&919(221 (@23(22&
#"
#
#
-781:9: (223 #"
- (& 4
)
&+*
!
#"
" # *
*
#
#
, - 1:?? 1:<< 1:<:
*
* #
#
232(1:<2 #" #! " * !
" * !
#"
#"
"* !
.
*
# , - #!
,
!
#*
E!
# 1?2:(22: #
* !
E!
"
#
> !
" *
*
#
& & <( (2 1&(A=4 * "
#
3:3
"B
0
"".
-
"".
"" 6 , #
!
!
D *
!
3:
"".
93 -
"".
(&
, 8 .
4
1(@
#
!
#"#
* &:2:" $!
" * 1<?" (9 ,
"
;
"
"
$!
* #
=" (3
"
*
- " 0 "#11 $ 23*
$
$ 1 2# )-7 8(2&19 (212+ #" "
#
131((212#
#* ! = G7 !
"
! # "
B
*
B "
"
"
* ! !
"
19 1?
- . "
&22:(223#
"
!
#!
&11((223 "" "
&)(+)+
! !
"
19 1? )1+ - #
"
*
* !
*
8& 9 .! #*!
" #
&)(+)+
#
# *
"
I (? 5 0
% " - "51" *1 3*
7$8 1::@)1+339 *
"
"
!
B"
#
# " " "
"
=!
""
#
""
5 - $" *"$01 3 :7275#1 $"3 2#"
.(22?-(122 *
"
(223!
B "
(223
"
(@ 4 "" *
!
# "
1@2@(22@ ) B =13+ # *
"
"" #
)((= +
#
A$!
"
$!
"" ;
#"
"
/!
*
"
/ &11((223 * (< 4
!
" #
"
(129(22< * "
"
" "
#"
L
*(@2<(22&
!
*
" 6!% "(@23(22&)-7 8&919(221+F !
(: .
" # G! I
*
* "!
* * /
> !
0 "
! "
1:3( # 212<1:<( # "
!
!
0 - "
! "
"
"
*
- !
1?2:1:::
) B =12 #
+ " # * "
"
*
"
1:3( "
"
#
"
* "
$!
4
"
!
!
(329(22@) B =1(+ " #
"*
#
&11((223 #5
2121(22?#
"!
G8 #6
- * " I # "
!
#
(223 "
" !
0"
6 !
&2 "
#
$!
"
!
"
#
*
!
@2 3 !
!
#"
!
!
#
!
*
"
!
&1
!"
!
""
"
# *
!
* $!
!
(?2&1::? " " % $!
122C$!
4
-
"
"
"
$!
#"
!
$!
"
A
"
"
*
! #*1?9 1?@
& !
#"
# ""
;
# "
!
!
, - .
/
#"" #
!
A "
#
*
*
"
!
*
!
##
"
!
G
!
I , -
"
*
!
(&2&1::? " G
!
I ##
"
*
- -78&919(221 #"
#
#
!
# "
!
#
"
"
"
" *
#* !
""
"
*
## *
* !
"
!
#
!
- ;
"
*
* !
# (?2&1::? #
!
"
" *" !"
* (?2&1::? ; !"
"
"
" *
" *
!
"
* ;
*
!
5*-! !"
) "*
+
(223 ! *
#
&11((223 &(
%
"
*
# "
, - .
/
0 * )#E!
" "
4 " + #!
(223 #" ""
& , - .
#" #
" *#"
#
"
!" "
# &12((223
# # !"
!
" !
%
5 - -7 8(2&19(212
"
131((212 # #
*
#
"
&11((223
" *
! *
5 "
* 6!% "
"
!
*!
# # 5 "
&& . *
*
"
(223!"
" "
!
(223)
(129(22<+*
#
> !
!
!
" #
5
!
!
#
- "
/ "
/ " -
1@2@(22@) B =13+ #"
# = G"
* ""
" !"
# *
"
#
!
-
!
*
$!
B "
D 81A()9+:?=(0=..
@ (22(*5
#" = 1 4 #
!
*5 "
"
!
"
# # " * # " * !
#
" *
# 12C "
# 12C
"
)
+ $!
4 ( 4
#
"*
#
)*
!
-
*
$!
# 12C "
+ 4 "*
"
#
!
" * !
*
#
B"
$!
4 & 4 #
!
"
!
-
"
"*
!
-
# 21231::< 4 # "" "
06-!
!
, ED8&@?A2?=(06=..A&(92
2?2?(22@I &9 4 *
"
(223!" # &11((223
"
#
!
"
!
* #
> # " * !
# 12C
"
#
* # 21231::< *
!
!
!
"
#
"!
"
" * !
#
#
21231::<
" #
*! * # 21231::<
"
*
"
" *
"
#
!
*
*
$!
"
*
"
## #
" -
>"
" *
*
"
; ;
*
* " *
"
5 !
0
"
* "
- #
$!
!
#"#
#
!
" !
$!
"! -
"
&3 % "
- "
! #
"
! ""
& )(+)+*
(223
!
"*
## # &11((223
#
*"=
% ") !
+ 6!% " !
(32<(219 % 6!% " 5 -
>" #* "
-
" " ;
6!% " !
1(1((219
" # #
"
#= G.! # "
"
# !
*
"
*
I 4 "
! *! !*
6!% " - "
; # #
"
#"#
&? !"
#
"
"
" "
.
"
#
!
"
* !
(?2&1::?) B =?+
!*
! !
*
" "
$!
* "
" $!
4
$!
"
" "*
" #
* "*
"=
# "
- #
"
"
! " *
"
""
* #
!
# " *
!
* * !
" !"
# *
#
"
" $!
#
$!
* (223
"=
# !"
&11((223
4 "* ; "
"
*! "*
B""
*
- 5 4 ; #
"
B
!
&
&)(+)+
(223 &11((223 *
% "
"
1)&+
1 "
#= G1
" "
)1+ 4
* "
"" . ) - * !
0 +
(223 )(+ 4
!
" "
&1 6 * (223 )&+ 4
"*
"
# &1 6 * (223 )9+ 4
#
1 (22?
* !
* >8 # 6
- * " >!
"
*
0"
6 !
ED 8(A<A2@=
12 (22@I
&
#= G& " = )1+ /B"
# !
*5 " -
A%
4 ""
. "
0 .
* !
* *
* !
0.. 0...
# # #
"
* &1 6 * (223 # !
&1 6 * (223
#!
"
!
#
* "
D" $L
)(+ 4
)+
*
"
F )+
"
)+
#!
"
* &1 6 * (223
#
*
B"
# !
*
!
*
"
F )!+
!
= "*" "
*F )!+
1 (22?
"
I "
&)(+)+*
"
#
4
"
* * " ! *
# "
"
* " "
*!
" !
4
&@ -*"
"
## !"
&11((223
#
)
+4 #
*! "
"=
## !"
!
* !
1::?*
/ )
+
"
!"
&11((223 . - "
!
!
#
!
"
!
B
:
*
! *
*
"
1::?
## "
*
*
#
4 "
> " * !
#
*
"*
#
&11((223 "
!
"*
1<
(223 J
1<
>
F# "
"
"
"
" "*
K &< . . "
*
# "
- "
&11((223**
* "
"
!!
- (@23(22& -78&919(221 "" #
L
4
!
*
.
*
1:::
"
*
! /
!
0
"
! "
1:3(
!
0 - # "
"
"
"" # "
# B
4 #
*
!
*
*
"
1:3(
"
!
0 - 1::: &
!
* $!
#
!
"* &: .
"
#
2@2<(22< "
6 "" / "
) B =19+ # *
!
#!
&11((223 4 "
"
*#"
*
"
.
* !
*
"
B
B"
* # ( & !"
!
!
!
B =?
(?2&1::?# ""
!*
"
&11((223 B
!
&)(+)+
) !
1)&+ + #
#
*
!
#
$!
( :
!
.
"
!
" 1::?
# !
"$!
$!
" * *
#
@3C :3C "
B #
# . *
"
"
/ " 6
"
1::<. - "
!
" 92 "
. !"
# "
*
5 "
* 6! % "
" )+ )-7 8(2&19+ # * !
&)(+)+*
"
"
*# - !" *#" "*
*
- * "
"
# * 6!% " # "
!
"
#
*
"
1:3( 1::: #
"
## #
% -
*
5 6!% " #
#"#
* "=
91 .
*
"
B =13
1@2@(22@
"
(223 #
"
F#
#
"" / " 6 4 "" / " 6
- "
$!
/ " 6
/ " - D*!
/ " 6 *
4 "" / " 6 #"#
"
1@2@(22@" ="
"
!
#
"
4 "" / " 6
" #
!
"
#
!
* * ;
9( ! B
#
! # "
6!% "
"
*"=
!
5 *
* 6!% " # "
#
"
*
D
"" 8
" (2 (21@ ;6<
$*"$01= 7 0 7
A
M , A8 7
*
M , A8