High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2195/2005disposed of

Krishan Lal Dutta v. Guddu Yadav And ORS.

2019-02-28Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi17 pages

!"!#$%$&'(

' )*

! "

# ! " $%& !#'( )))))

- * + , " -" .

" !' " !' - ' /( !! # ' +/ 0" 1 +/ 23 %! . /0 $ 1!" % ,2$%3& *1 4 5!2%4%4""4"5&" 3!2%!! ", ""/( '' !

!! -! !*$*4544* 5 # %

" !

*66"

*7880" 1 !

23 '

"" '

, ' !

!! ! *$*4544* /

4744 "+ 9 :- /; /( :* "

/ :9%*4%<5<6 -/( :5 - :$=&-

%5% !! !

, "" "" " /( !

, ( ''( .

"84>'

# #? !

."6

!'! ? ( -!/

! @ -/

AA(-*4 444' /(- B (" /

- -" !' " *< ! - ! :* $ $ + !

' - ! /( & , -

' :*5 !!

/ ( ( !' & -

' :$ '( /,!

%' / ( % , '%, " !

""!

! /! " ' ! " ! !(/( A & -"' -

( ! ! < C ' ! +/ "", !! ! *$*4544*/( /( :* "

/ :9%*4%<5<6 -/( :5 - :$ :* ""!

' " !! + +/ - ' " 5 68 *ADB% -.

'! *4 444B% !! " "" 68> ' / ( " -

%$%

'/ < 444B% - ! 5 444B% !! " ! 54 444B%!! ""

!' 54 444B%!! " "' " "!

:* $ (

!' "$ 5< 444B%- ! "6> ', (

( 6 = " "!" !' D

!(" !

-! 464D54*< - / ! 8 & /( # " ' ! 7

# "

" !(" !

' / "

" !' " !' - /( +/ *4

# "

+/ -'' "

"!' " ""

!' "" "' " "

, ( % ''(&E"D<> """'' / (" "

- '/ .

"68>++/ - , !' - " "

!' /( ( F '

' (!'++/ - " +" '( /

- !' -'(/!& " ! "

%A%

! !+&"!!6,3&478% 41&"!&" & 3!2..

/+90+ -,5$ 8%!!6:&" 3!2% ( +462!;!42 %!%90-"5,4;28%3!$5$%$&1 &<!2- $&1 &%42&#!* " 0 $5$1 - 25$&" ,4;2

$%32 8% != &"$ %%42&#! * " &" & 3!2 0 $5$1 . &" !%3; ,4;2$ &" 3!2% 8% "& 3& &" & 3!2/ $5$1 ( **

# # " :$ " !(" !

'/ (' (!' "!' *5

# # " :$ "

%, ! ( ! / ! ' (' !' ' " !' "

' / ( !F

!'++/ -, !' , +" '(/' *$ & ! !

"" , ' !

!! -! ! *$*4544*?" !

' "!' !

*66"

-" .

" 4$4A5445 -! -

- /( +/ ' - 5$45544< + +/ "", !! ! *$*4544*/( /( :*"

/ :9%*4%<5<6 - /( :5 - :$G :* ""!

! ' " !! G :* 5

%<% -% :$% ! !'( - , (

( / ( !' !

+ " / !

/( :* 5 $%& !#'(/(" !%/,!

- +"" +/ -! /! " ! / !! !

"( "! *A + +/ - ' " 5 68 *ADB% !

'! *4 444B%!! "" 68>' / (" - '/ < 444B%

- ! 5 444B% !! " 54 444B% !! ""

!' 54 444B%!! "' " "!

:* $ ( !' "$ 5< 444B%- ! "6> ' , (

(= "

-".

"484A544<!' !' -/( +/

!(" 4D**5446 ! *74<54*< # :**6D*%#&&%54*< - " " ' -- -! -

- 464D54*< *< +F -! 03- " !( " !

' / " - .

03 - (' "(' " - ' *6 +

!'' - " ( .

( ! " !

%6% .'.'1!

0 !

- 3/'" ! &/( !

$46" &

!!!

*75<-! % H

" (!

! !. " " '"! .!

' G .! ! " !

" "'

" & #0A<" *8643 , ! " (G.! !- "

" (

" !

/,( -

/ (I *D +F - !

! ! " !

**4%" !

*7$7/(!

- !(" ! - ! /( # 1#4 &%42&#! *$;$ !" 8% 346$&"!2+$&<3&" 3!2%-. . * .0&" - !

'!' " , - " , *8 +F - !" "!

!(" ! !

'" " -.'/( # $ ; &" 3!2%8%3;&*1&" 3!2%(090 - " !' -/ !

"'" '!/

" ("

**4%0*3" !

*7$7-!/

" ! !

' !' ' ' " !

(/ /( *7 & !1!642 3 +&:4&&$ >34 3%%& 8% 3!:$ $1 !61&:4 ?$2-(900+ ?2/

! "!

""' " " "

%D% !( " ?2/

'# :D" , ' / % H@ ""' ' "" " -

% "" "! "'""' / / ! " ! "

!(" + - "" - " "'

! " " "" /! ! ! ! " !

' ! ! / "' " "' !/( " /!'F " /" ' " ""% -! " " / /

! " ! % ""J 54 & 8!!2668%5!1?&+!@4!$2&" 3!2%- (( + 9 ?2/

' # " "" ! "'" ! / " "" ?2/

'# , ' / % J+ '.' K!

' '

K / ( !- "" !( " " /( ' " ' " , /('/

!- "" !("

# /

# !

' " /( # B =

# !'(/+ K" /(" ' /( # =

# ! '( / "" /" # ! 4&7A +$&<3 5 ;4 2 +$&<3

&(0 0 3 241665 "3?0 3 &$2;11 5 3 $A$ /. < 9 0 3 A11 5

; *1 < 0( 0 3 !1!642 3 +&:4&&$ >34 3%%& 5 3!:$ $1 !61&:4 ? $2- (900+ 0 3& 1&$663! $25 73 ;&" 9 " 0/ 0 3 $11 5 2&2?&- /;A?0(0 3 - !

-! / ! / !

" ' "! ! ""/( (+'.'"!

/ !/ ( ! - ( ! !

/ ( ""!

! !!

%8% " - 4% ;7$2A7$5B42%! " 0 3 &11 5 A11 - 9

0 3-

!- " ' " "'

, /( ""

!" "

""/! !! ! "!

/!' ' ! ! / "' " ""K "' !/( " /!'F "/" ' " "" -! "L615 ;#3&"2C* 9 ; .M0 3 !1!642 3+&:4&&$53!:$ $10 3J 5* & 2:$2 +$&<3 8% &"!27$ ,42 4&7A&"2?&$<342 - - "

" , " ! !

'!! 55 & 41A +$&<3 "!#!%!"

324<3 * % 8% 32 +$&<3 &" 3!2%- /(0 9- "!#$"!" & . # / % HC! " ! ( !

' -

/ " "

' !

( ! !

' !! &" -( " ! ! "!

&" ! ""!'! !

/"!

- !

' "' / " ! '(!

"" ! ( C /

(

' " ! -! I 5$ & ;%32$8!2%4%$;#31 2"!%3 "2&%62 262 $&- 9 0// $;#31 2"!%3 $<3 42 - /"

- % H& -

- !

" !

' " !' "'!! ", ""/( , + ! /! /( & / ! ! !" (

%7%

! '! . '

!?- '- "" "

"!' ! '

-! ! / ! "

"" !! I 5A + " - -! ' "' / F , ! !' '(/ ''; % 03 +! "

!/ ( !/ ('"/( "

$46" &

!!!

-!!

( ( -

"(!

! !. " " '" .! ! " !

" "'

, ! " ( !-!!' - ", + ! /( .! ! !

$46 " &

!!!

03 @, -" !

' "-" !' " !' " !' - ' !

' , !(" ! ' /! " , "" ' !

!! !

'"-"!' " !' " !' - " , -

/ "

' 03@, -" !

' "-" !' " !' " !' - , -

" !(" ! ' /! ", "" ' !

!! !

' " - " !' "!' "!' " , / /

'"-"!' " !' "!' " " -

/ "

' ' 03 @ " , !!

!( " '

!F !"/ ( , "" ' !

!! ' ! / !

/( !

' ! " ! !! /( "' !

03 &"!

'", "!' " ,

- ! "!

/!''

%*4%

" ! !F ! " , /('' !

!! /" " -' -!-

"' " -

" '!"!

5< &-" / '",

" !' " ,

- ! "!

' - " .

/" " -' "$ 5< 444B%-!"' "

- (' " " -!"!

/( 56 & --

, (!!' !/- "

- % 0*3

!#4&$2?";<!%+6!#$1";<!%3 03 N. ; '!

"'!

G 03 " 0 3 -! -

' /, !' 03 " " G 0/3 " "

!! " ' / (G 03 =

'! . 053 &D6!#4&$25";<!%!&!21";<!% 03

'" "" '!F !" , G 03 "' 0B "!

"'3G 03 ".!

" "0 "' (3 +!! 7,4;28!2%4%7?,4;2&"& 3!2 +462!;!42 %!%/0/&" &<"$8!2%4% !% & 21&"$ *$;$ !"&" 3!2%+ /99

%**% 5D &-" " , ' /" "

"!' "!' -" " -! -

' " . !

; '!

! " " '! " ' / (

-!"' " 58 + +/ - ' " 5 68 *ADB% % -.!

'! : ("

! "/( +/ # "

( ' - , !

( ' '! +" " -" ("

' -'! & !''-

, (!.!

+ +/ - ' " < 444B% - ! 5 444B% - /

+/ -(' -

&-"

", " , /( ' ' -

-! ! / /, F -

/, -' "*4 444B% -! *4 444B% - 54 444B% -

57 + +/ - ( ' - " " N @%* /

- *4 444B% ' /( - B ( " /

%*5% - /

'"' (' (' " ( ' (! "! - /( ! ! .' !! ""!B""! ' (:!

(!- ! - B ( " /

/( +" !

' ' (' " !( " / " - B ( " /

!' " / *4 444B% ' !

/ &-" "''

'-"5 <$<6< " /(/

-' -

/, -5 <<4B% ' '" !! ! " !( " /

" ' '

/ "" " " " ' " +" -

-"' "05<<4OA3*4 544B% - " " $4 @%* /

" ''(- / -+!

.'@%7

@%*4 # ( ' / ( " @%7

"" ' / ( " "

- '/ .

" 68> @%*4 # ( " ,

-D<>&E $* & 7 ,4;2 8!2%4% 7? ,4;2 &" & 3!2 +462!;!42 %!%/0/?2/

'# / % H@'(- '' ! !

%*$% 03

, 0 ' / "' , 3

"!! ( 03 + ! " ' / ( - "!

- /(" ! / ' / ! " " !! ( +

"" ( ! " " !! ( ' ! " ' / ( 0.! "-! - +/ /" ! !!

! " " !! ( ' ! " ' / (3 03 + !

- , - .' ' /F ( .

" ' / (!! ( .

"' / (+ "!! ( ' -

//( +/ - "! ! ( 03 + ' ' / ( '(

"" ! " " !! ( ""

" " !!

,/ ! "!

I $5 & ! @%7

"( /

' / (" F /( @%*4 # ( "( , ''(/!' ( / - & - " '! ! !

" , /( -

/ ' "

' / ( " /( " $<> + +/ -' "54 444B%!! ""

' / ( -

( '

' + +/ -F ""

' / (/( ( '

' / 7 ,4;28%7?,4;2&"& 3!2- +462!;!42 %!%/0/ +!

AA(-!'"5 <<4B% ' '" !! -! "5<>F / ' - "

- " / $&1 &%42&#!;6&?* "8% 2&?+! 3$&" 3!2%-.0

%*A% $5$1 -! ! !' 05<<4 P 6$D3 $ *8DB% & -" " '"!! '

"*A-

/ !/ ! " '

' !' (/

" " "

' / (" /( .

$<> !' 0$*8D O *5 O *A Q < $< A*6 O $<>3 * 8D $7<B% +" ! " -

/ - " !' " * 8D $75B% - " "

$<>"

' / (" /(/

" "

' / ( " /( / / ?- '( / / "" , ' !

!! *$*4544* 4D**5446 + " -! !

( "" "

" '!

$<> "

' / ( "' " -

/ ! '!

"!' ""/(

$<>"

' / (" /(!' 05<<4B%O<6 ' O$<B*44Q3A7 784B%

"-!' "54 444B%-/(

+/ - ""

!'-

/ / / $$ ?- - " " , ' /" !

' " ,

" !' "!' " ""

' / ( " /( -! -

"" "

'! "( F !" "" "' ".!

" "/ ' / !( " +

%*<% +/ - ' " *4 444B% - "" ' "54 444B%" "' -!!

/ /, F -" " ! "!

' ! " ! -

/ , - ' "54 444B% - ""$4 444B% - " ' - ( " "

" .!

" " -

/ ( !' " ' ! !

' " ,

"!' "!' " ""

' / (" /( "

'! "( F !" "" "'

" .!

" " / ' / "

-B!' "!' / $A +/ +&"!!6 ,3&47 8% 41 &"! &" & 3!2..

/+90+ -,5$ 8%!!6:&" 3!2% ( +462!;!42 %!%90-"5,4;28%3!$5$%$&1 &<!2- $&1&%42&#!* "0 $5$1 -25$&",4;2

$%328%!=&"$%%42&#!* "&"& 3!20 $5$1 . &" !%3; ,4;2$ &" 3!2% 8% "& 3& &" & 3!2/ $5$1 ( /( # "

3 - -!

! "

' " F

' " !' -! ( $< &-" /!

" !' " ' -

%*6% " "' 5 444B% *4 444B% ! "' < 444B% *4 444B% - " !' " 54 444B% -

*4 544B% - " '! A7 784B% - " $<> "

' / ( " /( "

" -! ' "54 444B%-/( +/ - ""

!' -

/ / / 3 D$ *84B%-!"' " /$ 5< 444B%-/( +/ $6 & ! +/ !

(' " !' ' - " 6> ' "' "" " '

; " - ' -! !

/F F -! - -

/ " $D & 4 ;; &" 3!2% 8% ,* 2?& !""? &" & 3!20 $5$1 00/-?2/

'# / 64 % H+ # A $ !>A243 8% !64 ? $2!# 2 !&!21- !1<$#1 +425!? &"$ &" & 3!2 / / +0( ! ( " /- /( +/ ?# # & !

# " '

/ , / "!

' !" !

/!"

! "!

!!'( !(/ /( 9"&"' ' ' - ! ",(' " !I & +46! !$ &" 3!2% 8% $&1 &%42&#! ;6&? * "&"& 3!20 +/ ?2/ .# 7> ' -

/ " / - !! # ' !' ! & +4A! +$&<3 &" & 3!2 8% +3?;+$&<3!"

&" 3!2%( $5$1 /+ "

%*D% "6> '-/( !! # '+/ -'"/(?2/

'# "& 7> ' $8 & - " / " ?2/

' #

4 ;;&" 3!2%8%,*2?& !""?&"& 3!20

$5$1 00/E +46! !$ &" 3!2% 8% $&1 &%42&#! ;6&?* "&"& 3!20 +/G+4A!+$&<3&"& 3!2 8%+3?;+$&<3!"

&" 3!2%( $5$1 /+

" " /( 9& '! " " "

-/(: ;9". ! "!

/ '"( -/( +/ 7> ' $7 & "

- "' / !

" ,

(' " !' " $ 5< 444B%- /( +/ D$ *84B%!/( # - ! "7> '"' "" "

; A4 & - " / !

(

- - ! '" /%' '"! " - 5$45544<

584554*7 kothiyal @ B B: @ / B: