High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1090/2019disposed of

State Of Haryana And Others v. Dr. Sudhir

2021-12-01Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri11 pages

!"#$%

!$&$'#$% % (

)))* (

)+,))

!" ))-$#.-/-01- 2 #$%&'($)$*+*% " "

"

, $% $* ,- -

" " - . !. ! - - "

! " $ "- " /"/ ," 0" - " # )$%+1+$*+%120 3 #

/ - )

4 #5$ &(%'$*+%1 +(+'*+%1 6 %7+'*+%1 !." .-

. "

-

" "8" "

" " " 9-"

.

33 ..:

" )

4

+;9+1+%*+%12

, $13.

!" 8:

" -. " !"

/"

"--

8:

. . " 6-! 9 " %;+;*+%;2

, $<3 /" -

)

4 "- " " "" !

" 8:

- .

- 6 " " #9#$ "

5 "

" / - !-!1$#!)$1+ )4-4-!5-$- 4.! 6

1"10 67 . " " . "" "

" .

. ! ) -

" . =0 /" # "

$ "" "# $ !"" . " !" "-

"-" .! " . =%. " =0# . ! * "-

$

383 . ! /"

6 %7+'*+%1 . . ! "

! $ !"" . " !" . (+> " ! " 6 " ". - " * !" # ""

"

%1+(*+%; 2

, $&3 # 2%3

. . "

& " !". * !" - " :. ""

"

. - " ! . -

! " " 8" "

- -

. ?

" " #( "

!

"- )

4 .

/

" :. - ! +&+&*+%12

, $%3.. .

*+> -+1+1*+%&%+%+*+%<

! . " 8:

8:

!"

6 %*%+*+%< . -

373 ! **+**+%;

. " - %(%%*+%;2

, $(3""

6*+%**+%7 2

, $&3

- 8:

. :. " . "- @ -

%++&*+%12

, $'3 # $.

- .

#5$&(%'$*+%1. - "

*++**+%1 ! . ! =0#

$ " " "# "" # " +%+&*+%12

, $%3 =% "-" . :

#

" A" - .

9

: ""

- ! - %*+&*+%1 #$'*&7$#5$*+%1

- =0# .. " "

?

)$<;1$*+%1

- %;+&*+%1.

2 3 : !?

) - (++&*+%1

- - "

: - " "%%+1*+%12

, $*3

.

:8 #

393 / 2 3 %1+<*+%1

-

:8 # .

-- "

# ""

- .

* .

- :8 # "" - . !

" **+'*+%1 ! :8 #

"-#! -": - $ "" "

" =% .

"

- $ # # .!

! " " .

. "! - "" !

- !

- " "

! . " . . . "0"

8: # 8: =% - %*+;*+%&2

, $%3 !" : ""

" . !

.

. "

. - -

3:3 8:

B -. "

- - - : 8:

" " %*%+*+%'2

, $(3.

. "

8: # #-- # 8,"!0"

0 ""

" . (

%- 8:

- %7+&*+%;?

.

" . "-

-8:

?

"- .

" . , 8: . "

8:

- - . !

: . - . !

.

!"

" ! C "- -.

!

. " ?

" . " "" A.

"

" !".

- $ "

. .

, $(?

)

4

3;3 .

" -

,- - .

. - - ) - -- ! " !

- -%&%+*+%< " : " "-

.

.

" !" 6 *+%**+%7!

, $& " " $ "

& . " ""

%*%+*+%< . " - " "%7+&*+%;

2

, $73.

. ! -+1+&*+%& %%%+*+%< ( %- ( -%*%+*+%<%7+&*+%;

!8:

. 7- ' .

. ?

" " .( < - < ?

. " !. " .

. - "#

- **+**+%;

. " - %(%%*+%; 2

, $(3 ?

A 6

=0# /"

*&+&*+%; " #5$*&%*($*+%;

363 *++1*+%; 2

, $;3 %;+;*+%;

.

-

+;9+1+%*+%1 . /"- "

. ?

! " "

%1+(*+%; D23 :

$ !"#9#" -

" 9 =88? ,-

= - - ! - . 6

",- A?

"

."- " - "-" *+%; " "

. "

A 8=8)#0=:?:0= 23

$ !"#9#" .

"-*

" !". =0#

-9 9=B " 5:?0E?F.! =0# . , !. ?

!" . " " -

"

. ! 2*3B "- * " .

. . !8:= - !" . " " 2(3

$ !"#9#" . 9-9=B" "- & " !". $* !"9 $* - " !" :

"

" . =0# 5:?CE))F 9 . .

" " . !" ?

" "- - -.

9 .

33 ! " 9

! - . /" "!9 "" " ? ?

" . 6

! " "9 ! 9 ! :

" "

!" G #2%3 !"

. .

$ !"#9#" "- * " !" . =0#

-9 9=B" -. .

?

. , $ !

. !". " "

" -

" - "

. ! : !"-- " +%+&*+%1 2

, $%3 ! " /" " - .

9

0

- . :8 #

%%+1*+%12

, $*3 /

%1+<*+%1

" .

-- 9

?

. -

!"

.

/ " .

!

" "

.

,".

3 3

$ " .

"-- #( ! !

& " !".

* - " !"

" .

=0# " "- ?

" . $ !" ?

- /" "! "" " ? : " & !" - (++;*+%& . " /

%1+<*+%1 -+1+1*+%&%%%+*+%< . (

%- ( . #: "" "

" . "

- -" ! "" " . . "

- - - -

" "

! - ! 8: -. "

- 8: =% -

B 8: =* (. "

- - 8: =% ?

"-

-" "-- "

%*%+*+%'2

, $(3

. -

3 3 8: =% 8: B H ?

8: - "

- ""

-?

)

4

-

. ?

(+> " !. " !"

"

!. " :8 #

""

!. !"

. .

" 2%3?

)

4 +(+'*+%1

. ! $ # "- * " )

4 . - , ".

.

!

$ :8 # . " " 2*3.! .

"!

- /

. ".

. - ))*

+,))

'<=!2

9 F9= F9=