High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1901/2013dismissed

Yadwinder Singh @ Jaddu v. State Of Punjab

2015-12-077 pages

! "!#$%$&' !#!()!* +

! "!#$%$&' !#!()!* +, - , - , - , -

".$&"!*/$&012""3 ! $ $&!* 4!*%3% / ! 3&5) !%6&"!& ' ' ' ' 7 8/// 7 8/// 7 8/// 7 8/// *!%!& '

*!%!& '

*/&5!!9&*$,/!&$*"9# !.$ 1 */3($ $&,"9# !

* 1!6! $ $&!* *//$"13,3&5) *&5$9&/$&01,"9# !

* 1!#(6:$&& ;;;;;

;;;;;

/ , / , / , / , ! $ $&!*1% $:!" 1$%6! $ $&#1::!&0$&0 1!

*"!* " !" - ,.1!*!)<, 1!.% *"!*!" )!

%3((&!" #! 1! *$:%&""$ $&:##3%!"&& 66:$# $&(9!")< 1!6*%!#3 $&3&"!*/!# $&

"! *$($&:*#!"3*!,+ 7*7 *%1* 8!*&!" /!&$* #3&%!: * 1! 6! $ $&!* 1% %3)($ !" 1 1!$(630&!"*"!*" !" - .% :$):! )!%! %$"!% 1! *$:3* 1"*"!*!" 1! %3((&$&0 1! 6! $ $&!* % & ""$ $&: ##3%!", (!*!:<,& 1!0*3&" 1 6*$(= #$!%3

$#$!& !9$"!&#!

.%9$:):!0$&% 1!6! $ $&!*& # , 1!"!0*!!

% $% # $& 3&"!*/!# $& * .% (3#11$01!*

1&6*$(= #$!#%!8!*&!"/!&$*#3&%!:1% 3* 1!* %3)($ !" 1 1! 6! $ $&!* .% 3&" $&&#!& "3*$&0 $&9!% $0 $&%1!.%& 3&"6*!%!& 1!%6 1!

$(! ::!0!"##3**!&#!! $ $&!*.%% 3"!& :!"!* &"1%&.)!!&*"!*!" )!%3((&!" !*06

)3 !:!9!&<!*% 1!##3**!&#! &%366* 1$% *03(!& %,:!*&!"/!&$*#3&%!:1%6:#!"*!:$&#!&

)3)1$ 1$()1$ >1$*$&"& 1!*%4!*%3%/ !

35* &" 1!*% 35* &" 1!*% 35* &" 1!*% 35* &" 1!*%, ?

*$($&:-,.1!*!$&, $ .%1!:"%3&"!*'= @/!# $& 1!"!#& !*%6.!*& 1!

*$:#3* $&"3 .1! 1!*6!*%&.1301 19! )!!& ""!" % & ##3%!" 1% !**&!3%:< )!!& ($ !" * 1% "!:$)!* !:< )!!&!A#:3"!")< 1!$&9!% $0 $&00!&#<&" 1 % $% # $&1% )!**$9!" & 1!)%$% 1!!9$"!&#!%:!""3*$&0 1! *$:& 1! "!0*!! % $% # $& *$&9>$&06.!*3&"!* /!# $& 1!"!, 1$%3* )%!*9!" 1 1301 1! !% 6*$( #$!#%!)!$&0("!

3 $%%(!% 1 .1!& 1!#0&$B&#! 1!

!&#!$% >!&&"6*#!%%$%%3!", 1!"!0*!!

% $% # $& 3&"!* /!# $& 1! "! $% (3#11$01!*C 8!*&!" / ! #3&%!: .1 $% %%$% !" )< 1! :!*&!"#3&%!: * 1!#(6:$&& ,& 1! 1!*1&"1% 66%!" 1!6! $ $&&"1%%3)($ !" 1 %6!#$ $#*:!

.% *$)3 !" 1!6! $ $&!* 1! $(! ##3**!&#! 1!6:! :$)$ >!&)< 1!6! $ $&!*#3:")!!% ):$%1!"

)<1$(.1$:!:!"$&01$%"!

!&#!!9$"!&#!&%366* 1$% *03(!& %,:!*&!"#3&%!:1%6:#!"*!:$&#!&*"!!6 *"!!6 *"!!6 *"!!6 /$&01 9!*%3% / ! 3&5) &" 1!*% /$&01 9!*%3% / ! 3&5) &" 1!*% /$&01 9!*%3% / ! 3&5) &" 1!*% /$&01 9!*%3% / ! 3&5) &" 1!*% ?

*$($&:D

,.1!*!$&,$ .%1!:"%3&"!*'= @E3!% $&% E3!% $&% E3!% $&% E3!% $&% E F1 $% 1! % 0! .1$#1 6.!* 3&"!* /!# $& *#&)!!A!*#$%!"G EF1! 1!* 1!.*"H!9$"!&#!H3%!"$&/!# $&

*1%)!!&3%!"$&#(6*!1!&%$9!

%!&%!&"$&#:3"!% 1!!9$"!&#!#::!# !""3*$&0 $&9!% $0 $&* 1!.*"H!9$"!&#!H$%:$($ !" 1!!9$"!&#!*!#*"!""3*$&0 *$:G & 1*(:7%#%!, 1!&% $ 3 $& !&#1 1%:*!"<1!:" 1 !*#(($ :,#0&$B&#!

!&#!#&)! >!&0$&% 6!*%&& &(!"%&##3%!")3 0$&% .1(( !*$:% *!9$:):! *( 1!66!*% $:!")< 1!6:$#!

!* #(6:! $& $&9!% $0 $& /3#1 #0&$B&#! #& )! >!& 3&"!* /!# $&

*&" 1!/!%%$&%3"0!&!!"& .$ $:: 7!9$"!&#!7 3&"!* /!# $& * )!#(!% 9$:):! *%3((&$&0&""$ $&:##3%!"G /!# $& *, %$0&$ $#& :<, 3%!% . !A6*!%%$&% 1 19! )! >!&& ! $! &I3$*<

*$: % *$: #((!&#!% !*

*($&0 #1*0!, & $&I3$*< #& &:< )!

3&"!*% " )! 6*!= *$: $&I3$*< &I3$*$!% 3&"!*/!# $&% , ,

*J&"3&"!* /!# $& K * *! %6!#$!% 1! $&I3$*< #& !(6: !" )< /!# $& * !*$:% #($&0 )!

*! 1! 3* $& #3*%! %3#1 !&I3$*$!% #& )! 3%!" * #**)* $& 1!

!9$"!&#! *!#*"!" $& 1! #3* !* 1! *$:

#((!&#!%, * 1! !A!*#$%! 6.!* 3&"!* /!# $& *,&":% ""&##3%!"

.1%!&(!1%)!!&%1.&$&:3(& 1!

#1*0!=%1!! &9$!. 1!)9! 6%$ $& 1!

.*"7!9$"!&#!7$&/!# $& *1% )!

)*":< 3&"!*% " &" & :$ !*::< $! % !9$"!&#!)*301 "3*$&0 *$: EF1! 1!* 1!.*"H!9$"!&#!H3%!"$&/!# $&

*#3:"&:<(!&!9$"!&#! !% !"

)< #*%%=!A($& $&* 1! #3* #& !A!*#$%! 1!6.!*3&"!* 1!%$"6*9$%$&!9!&& 1! )%$% 1!% !(!& ("!$& 1!!A($& $&=

$&=#1$!

1!.$ &!%%#&#!*&!"G &%$"!*$&0 1! # 1 3&"!* /!# $& * 6!*%& 0$&% .1( ( !*$: $% "$%#:%!"$%&:<%3((&!" #! 1! *$:&"

$&%3#1&!9!& 3&"!*/!# $& ?* 1!

6*#!!"$&00$&% %3#16!*%&$% #((!&#!

*( 1!% 0! >$&0 #0&$B&#!, 1!3* &!!" & .$ * 1! !9$"!&#! 0$&% 1!

##3%!"6*6%!" )!%3((&!" )! !% !"

)<#*%%=!A($& $& E 4 F1 $% 1! & 3*! 1! % $% # $& *!I3$*!" $&9>! 1!6.!*3&"!*/!# $& * **$0&&##3%!"GF1! 1!* 1!6.!* 3&"!*/!# $& *#&)!!A!*#$%!"

&:< $ 1! #3* $% % $% $!" 1 1! ##3%!"

%3((&!".$::$&:::$>!:$1")!#&9$# !"G 1301 3&"!* /!# $& ? ) * 1!

##3%!"%3)%!I3!& :<$(6:!"!"$% )! *! !" % $ 1!1" )!!&& ##3%!".1!& 1! 3* $&$ $::< > #0&$B&#! 1!

!&#!, 1!

"!0*!! % $% # $& 1 .$:: )! *!I3$*!" * %3((&$&06!*%&3&"!*/!# $& * .3:")! 1!%(!% *G *($&0#1*0!1!

!*!&#! $& 1! "!0*!! % $% # $& * %3((&$&0 1! *$0$&: ##3%!" &" %3)%!I3!& ##3%!"$%&##3& 1! # 1 1! *$:(<19!:*!"<#((!&#!"0$&% 1!*$0$&:##3%!"&"$ $%$& 1!#3*%! %3#1 *$: 1 ( !*$:% *! "$%#:%!" 0$&% 1! &!.:<%3((&!" ##3%!"*!%1%3((&$&0

& ##3%!" .$:: *!%3: $& "!:< 1! *$: = 1!*!

*! 1! "!0*!! % $% # $& * %3((&$&0 1!

##3%!"

*$0$&:

%3)%!I3!& 1% )!"$

!*!& E3!% $&4 E3!% $&4 E3!% $&4 E3!% $&4 E4 !% 1! 6.!* 3&"!* /!# $& * !A !&" 6!*%&%& &(!"$& 1!*&(!" $& 1!)3 & #1*0!=%1!! !"*.119! )!!&"$%#1*0!"G 6!*%&& &(!"$& 1!*6!*%& 1301&(!"$& 1!)3 1%& )!!&#1*0!= %1!! !"*6!*%&.11%)!!&"$%#1*0!"#& )!%3((&!"3&"!*/!# $& *6*9$"!"

*( 1!!9$"!&#!$ 66!*% 1 %3#16!*%&#& )! *$!" :&0.$ 1 1! ##3%!" :*!"< #$&0 *$:.!9!*,$&% *%&##3%!".11% )!!& "$%#1*0!" $% #&#!*&!" 1! *!I3$*!(!& G/!# $&% &" K * 1% )!

#(6:$!" .$ 1 )!

*! 1! #& )! %3((&!"

*!%1 1! ( !*% )! 6:#!" )!

*! 1!

- 66*6*$ ! !&#1 * $&:"$%6%:$&##*"&#!

.$ 1:.!A6:$&!"1!*!$&)9!C *%!#3 $& % *<, $& )*$!

, $% 1 #(6:$&& B".$&"!*/$&01.%6*!%!& $&1$%%16& D

:&0.$ 1 1!*% & 1!(!& $(!,6! $ $&!*:&0.$ 1 1$%#=##3%!"!& !*!" 1!%16 *#$):<! $ $&!*&"1$% #=##3%!" .1 .!*! *(!" .$ 1 .!6&% 1" $& :$# !"

$&53*$!% & 1! 6!*%& 1! #(6:$&& 3*$&0 $&9!% $0 $& 1!#%!,6! $ $&!*.% 3&"$&&#!& &"

1$% &(! .% >!6 $& #:3(& 1! $(!

6*!%!& $& #1::&

3*$&0 1! 6!&"!&#< 1! *$:, 6*%!#3 $& (9!" & 66:$# $& 3&"!* /!# $& * * %3((&$&0 1!6! $ $&!* #! 1! *$:%&""$ $&:

##3%!"4$"! 1!$(630&!"*"!*, 1!%$"66:$# $&.% ::.!")< 1! *$:3* !&#!, 1!6*!%!& 6! $ $&)< 1!6! $ $&!* /!# $& **!"%%3&"!*'= @.!* 6*#!!" 0$&% 1!* 6!*%&% .!* 6*#!!" 0$&% 1!* 6!*%&% .!* 6*#!!" 0$&% 1!* 6!*%&% .!* 6*#!!" 0$&% 1!* 6!*%&% 66!*$&0 )!03$: <

!&#!

66!*$&0 )!03$: <

!&#!

66!*$&0 )!03$: <

!&#!

66!*$&0 )!03$: <

!&#!'=

F1!*!,$& 1!#3*%! &<$&I3$*<$& ,* *$: , &

!&#!, $ 66!*% *( 1!

!9$"!&#! 1 &< 6!*%& & )!$&0 1! ##3%!" 1% #(($ !" &<

!&#! * .1$#1%3#16!*%&#3:")! *$!" 0! 1!* .$ 1 1!##3%!", 1!3* (<6*#!!"

0$&% %3#16!*%& * 1!

!&#!.1$#1 1!66!*% 19!#(($ !"

F1!*! %3#1 6!*%& $% & !&"$&0 1! 3* ,1!(<)!**!% !"*%3((&!",% 1!#$*#3(% &#!% 1!#%!(<*!I3$*!,

* 1!63*6%! *!%$"

&< 6!*%& !&"$&0 1! 3* : 1301 & 3&"!***!% *36&%3((&%,(< )!"! $&!")<%3#13* * 1!63*6%!

1!$&I3$*<$& ,* *$: , 1!

!&#!

.1$#11!66!*% 19!#(($ !"

? F1!*! 1! 3* 6*#!!"% 0$&% &< 6!*%&3&"!*%3)=%!# $& , 1!&=

1! 6*#!!"$&0% $& *!%6!# %3#1 6!*%& %1:: )! #((!&#!" *!%1, &"

.$ &!%%!%*!=1!*"

) %3)5!# 1!6*9$%$&% #:3%! , 1!#%!(<6*#!!"%$ %3#16!*%&1"

)!!& & ##3%!" 6!*%& .1!& 1! 3* >#0&$B&#! 1!

!&#!36&.1$#1 1!$&I3$*<* *$:.%#((!&#!"C 13%,%6!* 1!)9!6*9$%$&, 1!3* 1% (6:!6.!* %3((&&<6!*%&%""$ $&:##3%!" #! 1! *$: .$ 1 1! ##3%!" :*!"< #$&0 *$:,$

1!*!$%!&301( !*$:&*!#*" 6*#!!"0$&% 1! %$"6!*%& &&!A3*!= $% 1!% !(!& 1!#(6:$&& *!#*"!" "3*$&0 *$: 6!*3%: 1! %$" % !(!& *!9!:% 1 1!#(6:$&& 1%%6!#$ $#::<% !" 1 1!

6! $ $&!* 1" 0$9!& 1*!! $*& *" ):.% & 1$% 6!*%& .1$#11"1$ 1$(&1$%1!",#1!% &")#>6!*3%:

1! (!"$#=:!0: *!6* 1! $&53*!" *!9!:% 1 1!

$&53*!"1"%3

!*!"K$&53*$!%&9*$3%6* % 1$%)"< : 1301, 1! 6! $ $&!* .% "!#:*!" $&&#!& "3*$&0 $&9!% $0 $&)3 1!%$"%6!# #&)!#&%$"!*!")< 1! *$:3* .1$:!"!#$"$&0 1! *$: & 1!6*!%!& #%!, 1!*!.%%3

$#$!& ( !*$:

&*!#*" %3((& 1!6! $ $&!* #! 1! *$:%&

+ ""$ $&:##3%!"1!*!$%&I3**!:.$ 1 1!6*!6%$ $& :. %! :!"9$"!53"0(!& *!:$!"36&)< 1!:!*&!" /!&$* #3&%!: * 1! 6! $ $&!* )3 1! %(! $:% "9&#! 1!#%! 1!6! $ $&!*$& 1!6*!%!& #%!,% 1!*!$%%3

$#$!& ( !*$:9$:):!&*!#*" 6*#!!" 0$&% 1!6! $ $&!* %3((&1$( #! *$:%& ""$ $&:##3%!" !&#!,&0*3&" *$& !* !*!&#!$%("!3

$%($%%!"

!#!()!* +, -

!#!()!* +, - (19$*