Dav Sr. Sec. School v. Epf Appellate Tri. & ORS
VIMAL KUMAR 2019.01.28 13:17
!"# #$%&%'(
!" # () * +
,
$ % # & #
" %
% '
&%
( % # &)
( ! *+, % - % -
( ! . %
( ! /
, - 1
4 5
4 **/ (4 -5 "
(
6 5
!
*. *77/
4
5*/ *778 5 "
( ( 9 : (
;
!"
7< *711 5 *
2
5 (( (
" (1/
8=>5
22 18/<( 4 5
? 4 5% 554 !"
5 (4 5
% 5
@ 1<1 ( ;
+ %
18=* 918=* : 1/ 2
5
18=* 6
" ,
( B (( ( 5
5 (
& A 4 5
"
'7* 1883"
B 4 5 (
5 5 4 5 ( 5 ( ( "
5 (& ( 4
A
B
4 2?
2
2 # 18/=918/=#:
(
C( ** 18<1 % 5 "
4 (
D3>
1E,
> ( (
=> (" "
4
, 1E,
> ( A ( 5
"
(A
. .
"
@ 18=* ' 1* 1838( (( @ ( ( ( "
5
7/ 188. ( @ "
(
!
*1 188= 51883 (
18=* =
#5
4 4 5
6 4 5
,7 188/ 5 (
5 5B
(4 5
(
(
( -5 @ ( 18=*
5
"
E (
A (? % ( !" *777 5 2 5 (( ( F " A
(
" 55 (
5
E /
5 '
13 *77="" 2
5
18=* " # 4 "
5
( 18=* "
5*77= ( (
5" <2 ( 18=* ( 555*, *77=
( "
( ( ( '
78 *77/(56
"
# 4 ((
11 *77/
5 6
( 2
5 (("( 71 183*
( "
1* *77/"
5 @ " ( *, ,< <.1E2 ((
G(( ;#
4 (*/ 33 =.1E2"( 71 183* "
( 5
!
*. *77/ "
"1=
( (
< 55
( "
<2C (18=* '
78 *77< # 4 & "
5
5*/ *77855 ;
!"
5
7< *711?"
?
4 55
3
( (
"
5 2
5 (( "
-5 55 ( (4
"18/=B # 5 (
( ( 2
5 ((
/
5 5 %
,1 *77/ ,, 1. *3=E2( " */ 33 =.1E2 @ 1/1 (18=* 8
% # & # 55 (
" (4
( 1/1 (18=* (
$2
! "
1/ - (
( 18=* 2
@ 55 (4
A
A " ( ( 4
G 5
" (
4
A A 5 ( @
5 (4
A 5 4
A 17
% # & # (4
A 5
& A " & (
0 @ 9 :( " "
(
( " )
5
( "55 $2 11
( " 5 (
A B @
( (4
( 18/= (
4
A
( ( 1/1 ( 18=* " @ 5 ( 4
A " ( (4
" (
4
A (
(
5 (
5
6 1* ? 2
( #$%
&
# ' ( ) * % + ) #
2**
2 5 ( (@ 1/1 (18=* @ (
5 ( (
( " "
( "
( A " ( (4
5 18/=#
'7* 1883
1 2*
4 5
"
( "5
5 " & 4
# 2? 2? ?? ???H
E5 E B A
4 !"
(
5 (( ( 5H&
4
(
& A ( ( 5
(@
(
5 2
5 H &
% 5 # 5F
E4 5 (
18<.
E & A (
E 5 (
B
4 5 ? (B
4 5 5 ( ( 1/1 (18=* 5 "
(
5 5( " 1,
( 2 ( *. ( ?
5 A B 4 5 ( " 5 5 5 (
-
( -
(
@ (
4 ( 5
" ( 2
5 (("
& !
C - !" 1.
( 4 4I! 11<1< (*77= G
7< *77=
#%+% %,% )
- %.
/
"
"
"
5
" 6 F "
(
2? 5
# 4(
44*=17E*77/" "
7, *77/
5 " - "
( "
5 " 5
1= % # & # 5 (4
( 13 31 8<8E2 '*1 *711 1. 1< /18E2 ** *711
1, 3< 3,.E2 ' *, *71* " # 4 4 5 5 ./ 3< .,*E2 1/ !@ (
( &
% 5 # 5F (
18<8 5
"
" ( 1/1 5 ( (A
5 5F ( *5 ( 18<8 ( "$2 0
0
)
)
)
2
) )
)
1 )
)
)
!"
1< , ( 5 (
( . "
( "
@ "
(
( @ 5 @ "
( = /
5 4 (4
< 5 ( " ( ( A 5
5 A ?(
5 " ( ! 2 "
5 (5
22 11
" ( " @ (" @ 1777E2 " 1/ & (
18/8
- 13 % # & # "
( &
% 5 # 5F (
# 1831#** "
( "$2
1(
)1
2
)345!
6617% 67 1
8
% 9'
:/// & (
)'
( ) 32)
%;"
#**2 " (
$2
1'
<
)1
2
)345!
< 2
)3458
2
345!
)1 2
)345)
!
2
)345) & #
+ ( 7 +)33!
:
%;"
18
( " 4 5
55 A " (
A
@ 1/1 (18=* (
" #5
4
A
*77<144*/3 4 "
( 1/1 ( 18=* 1833 @ (
(# & ! 2A
? 1838@5
55 5F
( # &
9 55
(:A @ 18=* (
( @ (
5 " 6
56 (
4
( @
5
" 4 5
%- -4 5 # 4 '
1888144,8/""
2
(
( # & A
& ( " (
5 "
-5 (
"
(
@
( "
1< (18=* @5 ?
18 *, 4 @ "
9 55 ( 4
A A : ( "$2 3% /
)
%/ )
% '
0 0
%%
0 0
0 0%/
0=+0
: % > 0 0
0 0
% .
7) 0 0
8
. .
9 7)
0*
0% /
%'
% .
5 7)
-
%'
%.
4)
? <
%/
) :
% .
3)
@ 7
<
#
7 + %
A 7
%/
9 7)
7
% .
2)
%
B 7
&
% /
%
A/ 7
% %'
) ) ) 7%'
7 '
% '
: 7 % 5
4
<% 64
63 &
% 6@% / ) 7
:
0 %'
0 0 ( 7)326% 6% )
! "#$%&'( )*++ *+)
0 0
BB6 > D A %3)
( 8
/ 0'
0 0
)
) %0 /
!"
, # $%&')()&- .+%)
0 0 8 0'
0 0 <)
<
%0 66% >
) <
% /
) )
: E ( 7)326% 69% / :
!
#%&&&$%(/%'$(0$%&&&(% 1&*)
(% % %7
7% '
!
& % '
7
7 + &
%/ ) 8 06%%%%%'
7
%'
7 ?
:
7%0 *7 ?
4 ! <*1 ( *71, #$ F
<
% 7
0 *
%
78 *71< 4 5 4
"
,
?
*1 **5 "
F " 4
5 ( "$2 6% '
?
& 7
+ ) :
% =
-
7
+ )
, %/ ) 7
/ # ) 354)
:
8
%
63)66@
66 7)
% %
BB 7
, ( )
! % .
B 7)
<+
) ?
))
)
) 1
)
1
? <
% 7
) 7
#
% % .
B7 7) , (
? )
% %
2
)
7 % % .
7)
<
% '
% % '
+
)
7
%
% '
+
: <
1 <% % E 7
+ ) -
1
)
1
#
%7
?
)
$ % &% '
<
% <% E 7
<
% % '
)
:
) )
-
! )
! )
!
%'
$
!
!
%
: %
)
/// )
2
? !
!
%'
:
% 7
?
<
)
% 66% 7) +
: :
)
% '
) <
% /
)
@@G
1
1 < )
7%"
*1 ? ( 5 % # & #
( B (? %E5 '
*77,14 *7<" (
5
1/ 13 ( & 5 ** ?
( 5 ("
94 : ( #5 ?( *77=" "
9 :(
(
5 4 ("
4 C - (J
*71,1/443* 5 5 94 :
* (# ? ?
,1 ,. 4
( "$2 9%'
+'/7) )
)
) )
1
-
) )
)
6 % 7 ) )
- )
7 6 )
6 % "2
,"
H7
6 7% 7
)
)
< )
%
) ) ?
% "
,"
3
7
6 %I:
:
" :
+'/7
: :
" &
:
:
" 76 :
766 / % '
" " +'/7)
)
:
J K :
:
? %%
"
" % '
"
:% /
4
5
5 6 #7%&**))'
7 692 / )
C , ) "
<
?
8 '
J K) )
JK
%/
C
& % ) )
<
&
L%%%%/ & )
C
&
, L% >
: C ) C
?)
)%%%"
96%'
8
9 :
#$%&'&(1)7
6 " 5
# 5
6
# $%&-%('%))
239 * 7) 3B4) 8 B%/
"
?
1
MM%"
99% '
"
)
)
:
%'
/ ;
!"# $%&'( ) *++) " & 1 % '
"
!"
, < = # $%&')( )&-)
2B #
7) 323
" <)
<
%'
:
"
! !
"
<= #%&&&$%(/
. -)-0$%&&&(11&*) : 7692
:
"
)
) ) )
,L ,L
:1
%
%+
& 3 >
++$(/'*-0$++().)#
>" 7
>
$%&'*(&''#> 8 6 ?
2
%&&-$(/%1'0$%&&-(1'# " = /
$%&-.()*-# /!
++1$(/1-.0$++(-)-%#
@ / "#
#++)$%(/1**0$++)( %%*#
6 9B% >
:
"
"
")
%'
J K J K <
"
6 +'/7%/ &<
)
% : +
7
)
%#
#
E , 7
7%"
*, ?5 (
" 5 (B
(& A
( ( @ ( 1/1 /
A=
*. G % # & )
5( # 4 "
'
13 *77=
5 55 ( (4 2?
2
2 18/=# (A (18/= *. ( 2 - "
5 (( 2
5 (( (
5
5
( 5 5(5 ( */ 33 =.1E2 G "
( 183* *77/6 1/ 2
5 ((
5
5 ( 6 2
5 (( ( ( 5 ((
"
5
( 5
5 ( ( 2
5 ((
/
""
5 5
<2C (18=*
<2? 5 ( (
( (4 5
"
5
(
(( ( "
( ( 1/1 (18=*
*= % )
5
(
5 (4 5
5 18/=# @ ( " ( (
(A "
@ ( 1838 1888 1/ * (18=* ) " "5
4 5% 554 !"" @ 1< (18=* 1/*
(
" 5 5 "
5 B
*/ % )
5
"
4 5
5 ((
(
@
1/* 5
(B
"
0 ( B
)
C( (
18/= #
( 18=* ; 3,,> 6
5 (( 6 2
5 (( " ((
(
& A 18/="
B
) " 18=* " 4
"
"(%
7/ 183* (
18=* ) ( (4 4I! 1=33 ( 188. 513 *71<
( @
( "
(18=* "
$9'
N
!
)
(
# 7)326 7
7% +
7<(
# 7)326" *< % )
( (
1= ( "
58, ( 2 -
( 2
5 (( 4 5 % 554 !" ((
"
( ( '
*< *71/
5
5 (
1
6 1/ 2
5 ((
/ *,/ ( 2 -
" 4 5
!"?
11 *,8"
(
6 2
5 (("
"B
1 ( ((
18 *71/ *.= ( 2 -
4 ( "
5 4 5
!"? ((
G *= *713
. 3 ( ((
( 2
5 (( "
5 4 5
!" 55 !
,7 *711 ( 5 " # 4 4 5 ( % )
5 5 (
(
5 ( 2
5 (("
5 "4 5
!" 6 ( 5@
1/*
( 4 5
!"@ 1< (18=* 1/* (18=*
@ *3 " 1/* ( 18=* @ 5
H
(
5@ 1/* 5 $ ( A EB
H
(4
G 5
" (
A EB
*8 % )
55 (
5 (( ( " (4 5
-@ 1/ * ( 2
5 (( ( "5 (
!"" @
1< (18=* (
( - (
5 5" (
"
@ 1< (18=*
1< (18=* ( "
( (
18=*
(
18=*
2
5 (( ?
4 & 5
%
7= *7784I1,7<= (188, ( (1< "
" A 5 5
8=>5
22 ( A
( A " ( 17>
( ; " 5 % 5 ;5
"
? 5 B E4 5E " ( ( 5"
(18=* A (? "(%
7/ 183*
2 ( A (? (
5 *1 183.@
( " 1/* (18=* @5
(
(18=* ( ( " "
@ ( #5 (
6
4 ( 5 5 5 (
( 1/* (18=* " ( 5
E
(( ( @ A
( 1/* (
(
$2 9
)/
N :
6%@4%34B% "#
, 6
B
" ; C
6
2
1 , ;
6 %/ )
& ? <
7
)
)
:
6%@4%34B
: 3%@9%33% ? ) 8 '
.
) 11 & 7 7
3267) $
:
6%@4%34B% = 11 & ) 7 7 :
6
9
: !
/
517 3267
)
)
51/ 3267
$
: 6%@4%34B
7
7
:
7 7 ?
! ' N 7 7 7
7 )
) % / 7
:
6%@4%34B : ) %C ) 7 7
7 : )
3267
) )
) 7
%> <
. N ) 7 7 7
7
&
% ,7 !@ % )
C & 5 (
)54 I ! *=/*, (1883
%
*8 *71/
+ %( 7'D= 6 ( 4 "
9I
@ (
5 ( ;
%
18=* 1/* ( : C ( 5 5 5
( 1/* ( 18=* -@ (
(
(" 9 N N N N
7!
:
: %'
) )
<
: : 4
*. *= *3
$2 6B%= 9 ) )
:
: %'
.
( 7% 62%/
<
( 7) )
7% % ( 7
% #
7% % ( 7)346) ( 7 %'
-
) ): 7%/
7
'
1
)
%67
%*
:
% /
9 )
' )
%/ (
/
7 :
.. ) !
% 64%'
) : ( 7) ( 7)
< )
7% %( 7)346
+ )
% > :
< +
)
%7
< ( 7 7 %"
,1 % )
" " @ E1/* (18=* ) "" (" 1/ (18=* I
5 " (% 554 5 ( 2
5 (("
% 554 !" " @ E1< (18=* E1/ (18=* ? ( % )
5
6 1/ 2
5 (( (
.
,* % )
" (
4
(%E4 5 #5
4 183344=13 (
"$2 %
%O%E )
% >
( N
#
7)326
N 7N
% >) ) % 6%> 7
)344%>
7
# )346
) 344
+
% /
# )346 ) 344
+
%
%'
> %* %"
,,
"
(
5 18=* /
@/
,.
B
(
(
5
./
5
E
A 4 5
? (B
="
918/=#:
5 (
" 4 5
"
-5 ! 2
5 (( ( "
-5
E ?
5 (( ( ( B
"
-5 @ (
C(
A (? ,,,> 5 ( "
(
(
G F
'7* *711
B
5 (( (
(B 4 5 "
C( ( @ (
(18=* (
,=
" ( (
5"
"
6
# 4 ((
1*2( %
183* "
,3* ( ;
18=*9 :
1=. ( ;
18<19
: ( 2
5 ((( ( (
(
; ( ( "
.0 "
6 5(
G ( ( "
- ?
5 " (
5(
" ( (
(
5 ( ( ( " "
,31 ( ,/ 4 5 5
(
"
1/
(( "
( 4
G 5
( C )5 4 ##
%
4 *77<,'
=/1K*77<1=4 1/ "
5
5
22 ( %
A "
(
5 2
5 (( 4
< ( 5 ( ( G 188< *77, "
(( (
"
(
? **< "
5 5
22 (
(
(3,,> 5" " "
17> 1*>(
"
"
.1 ( & G F F 5 "
(( (
( "
5 ( (
4
-5 4 ( 5
22 "
( ( 9
( ( ; 5
22
:
9?( "4
5 5 - ( ;
"
(
A A ( %
-
( 53,,> ( E ; :
4
( / ( "
94 :4
9 4
4 (?
,,< (4
( 5 : 4
1.1 ( %
+G (J - +G ?#*77,4,==K*77*344.31 5 5
(
22
( 5?5 ( "
#
C & 5 "
" " (( - ,< ?
5 (
% )
( G
( B
(
.
( 5 C
( "5 (
$2
B
A
4 2?
2 2 # 18/=
5 2
5 ((
C(
"
-5 18=*
@ 1< (18=* (
5 ((
( @
5 2
5 (( ( (
@ (
" (
(
(
(18=*
(
?( 5
@ " F
@ 217
& ( 4 5
5@ 1/* 5 $ (
.2 EB
H (4
G 5
" (
EB
" (
4 ( @ 1/1 ( (
(
5 ( 2
5 ((
(18=* ( & 5 5 (
5
,
&E I -5E
L I L