High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/48854/2017allowed

Manpreet Singh @ Mani v. State Of Punjab

2019-05-15Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu7 pages

!"##$%&%'( )) * !'+,##"-%'./0!'% )))))))))))))))) #"%"%'#, 1#,&2& -"!"# 2'3!4 )))))))))))))))) #&+'5#'"

,#&#'" ,))-)-!'5/2657$!"#,"/#+#"%"%'#, ,)-!'5##+829!,66 2'3!4 :::

,#&#'" +#"%"%' /!& 4##' %;#5 2'5#, -#$"%' ,) )) , <2!&/%'.%9+2.'#5 ) 5!"#5

2'5#,-#$"%'&> *6

6,#.%&"#,#5!" ;%$#-"!"%'-/%9;!+2,%6%&",%$"?25/%!'!6!;'. @%"/!;;$'&#<2#'"%!;+,$##5%'.&,#&2;"%'."/#,#,9!'52,"/#,"+!&& !'A ,5#, , 5%,#$"%' !& "/%& 2," 9!A 5##9 %" %' "/# !$"& !'5 $%,$29&"!'$#&"/#$!&#) 47# @!&,#.%&"#,#5!.!%'&""/#+#"%"%'#,'"/#4!&%& &9#&#$,#"%',9!"%'""/###$""/!"/#%&!'/!4%"2!;&'!"$/#,!'5 "5!A.%'."@!,5&-/%9;!+2,%&%5#"&#;;"/#&'!"$/#5+/'#&B%!,!%5%& $'52$"#56/#!7A<2!'"%"A&'!"$/#5%"#9&$!'4#,#$7#,#5,9/%9) &+#,"/#$!&#"/#+#"%"%'#,6/#@!&%;;#.!;;A5#"!%'#54A -"!6?25/%!'!6'

))

!,2'5=)+)9)!'5/%&!"/#,%;#5! !4#!& ,+2& +#"%"%' 4#,#"/%& 2,"6 @/%$/ $!9#2+ , /#!,%'. '

>))

!'5 @/%;# %&&2%'. '"%$# 9"%', *))

6 !C!,,!'" %$#,@!&!++%'"#5)/#,#!"#,6'))

6"/%&2,"5%,#$"#5"/# /%#25%$%!;!.%&",!"#6?25/%!'!6 ,&/,"D6?25/%!'!E "/;5!'

%'<2%,A %'" "/# #'"%,# 9!""#,) ' +2,&2!'$# "/# ,5#, "/%& 2,"6 6 ?25/%!'!6 &249%""#5 ! ,#+," 5!"#5

) )

!'5 $!9# " "/# $'$;2&%' "/!" +#"%"%'#, @!& &243#$"#5 " %;;#.!; 5#"#'"%' 4A "/# +;%$# %$%!;&4#,#&/@%'./%&!,,#&"%'"/#+,#&#'" '

) "%&$'"#'5#54A;#!,'#5$2'&#;,"/#+#"%"%'#,"/!" %' <2#&"%'/!&4##',#.%&"#,#54A"/# +;%$#%$%!;&32&""$7#,2+"/#%, %;;#.!;!$"%'!'5%&"/#""!;9%&2&#+@#,&!.!%'&""/#%''$#'"$%"%F#' %'7%#@"/#,#+,"&249%""#54A6?25/%!'!) ' "/# "/#, /!'56 ;#!,'#5 -"!"# $2'&#; /!& ++&#5 "/# &249%&&%'& ,!%&#5 ' 4#/!; "/# +#"%"%'#, !'5 $'"#'5& "/!" ' $9+;#"%'%'7#&"%.!"%'%'"/#9!""#,6,#+,"2'5#,-#$"%'

>,) )) /!&!;,#!5A4##'&249%""#5!'5!"#,,!9%'."/#$/!,.#&6$!&#%&%G#5 , +,&#$2"%' #7%5#'$# !'5 "/# +#"%"%'#, @%;; /!7# ! ,#9#5A !" "/# !++,+,%!"#&"!.#";#!5/%&5##'$#4#,#"/#;#!,'#5",%!;2,") #!,54"/&%5#&!'5+#,2&#5"/#+!+#,4H) '$#5#5;A6!!4#!&,+2&+#"%"%'@!&%;#54A"/#!"/#, "/#+#"%"%'#,4#,#"/%&2,"%'7%#@"/#&2&+%$%'"/!"+#"%"%'#,/!5 4##' %;;#.!;;A 5#"!%'#5 4A -"!6 ?25/%!'! !'5 @/%$/ $!9# 2+ , /#!,%'.' >))

!'5"/#;;@%'.,5#,@!&+!&&#5(

! "

# "$ %

& '

(

'')*'+

'-)*'+ &

/ $

/ $ 0

0 / $

1 /#,#!"#,6 6 ?25/%!'!6 @!& 5%,#$"#5 4A "/%& 2," ' ))

"/;5!'%'<2%,A%'""/#9!""#,!'5/#&249%""#5/%&,#+," 5!"#5

) )

6@/%$/,#!5&!&2'5#,( &

! "

'')*'+

',)*'+

3 "

&" 4 "

& 5

! "

2! 5

68 # +9'+ %" "

( ',)*'+1

#,2&!;"/#,#;#7!'"+!,""/#,#+,"#G",!$"#5/#,#%'!47#6 $;#!,;A,#7#!;&"/!"+#"%"%'#,@!&%;;#.!;;A5#"!%'#54A-"!6?25/%!'! ,9

))

"%;;&/@%'./%&!,,#&"'

%'"/#!47# !'5 &!%5,#+,"/!&'"4##'<2#&"%'#54A"/#,#&+'5#'""%;;5!"#) ?#!,'#5-"!"#$2'&#;6'%'&",2$"%'&,9- !'3##"-%'./6 @/%&+,#&#'"%'2,"6/!&!%;#5"+%'"2""/!"+#"%"%'#,%&!$%'.!'A "/#, $,%9%'!; $!&# #G$#+" "/# +,#&#'" '#) !H%'. " 4# ! @,&" $!&# !.!%'&" "/# +#"%"%'#, !& +#, "/# !7#,9#'"& 9!5# %' ,#;%9%'!,A -249%&&%'& "/# -"!"#6 /# @!& !++,#/#'5#5 '

!'5 "@ 94%;#+/'#&@#,#,#$7#,#5,9/%&+$H#")/#!%5!7%"!;&,#7#!;& "/!" 52,%'. 2,"/#, %'7#&"%.!"%' %" @!& 2'5 "/!" 2" "/# !47# "@ 94%;#+/'#&6'#@!&&'!"$/#54A"/#+#"%"%'#,,9!'5!/!52,' *) ) =!'5%'"/%&,#.!,56/%&&"!"#9#'"@!&,#$,5#52'5#,-#$"%'

= ,) ))6' ))

%)#)!"#,!+#,%5

5!A&"/#!,,#&""/# +#"%"%'#,) ' ,#&+'&# " ! +%'"#5 <2#,A 4A "/# 2,"6 ;#!,'#5 -"!"# $2'&#;%&'"!4;#"&24&"!'"%!"#"/!"!'A , @!&;5.#5!""/# %'&"!'$#!47#!'5!/!52,,#.!,5%'.&'!"$/%'./%&94%;#+/'#6 !" !'A +%'" "%9#) /#,#,#6 %" %& !++!,#'";A $;#!, "/!" +#"%"%'#, /!& 4##'9!5#!&$!+#.!"!'5 /!&4##',#.%&"#,#54A"/#+;%$#%$%!;&

32&""&!7#"/#%,&H%',9;#.!;$'&#<2#'$#&"/!"9!A;;@'!$$2'" "/# %;;#.!; 5#"#'"%' "/# +#"%"%'#, !'5 "/# &!9# $!' 4# "#,9#5 '"/%'.42"4;!"!'"9%&2&#"/#+;%$#+@#,&) /#$'$$"%'"/#&",A+#,+#",!"#54A"/#-"!$!'4# .!2.#5 ,9 "/# +;%$# +,$##5%'.&

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

!'5.,!'"#54!%;4A;#!,'#5 ",%!; 2," ' ))

6 "/2&6 ,#9!%'#5 %' 325%$%!; $2&"5A !& @#;; , !++,G%9!"#;A 5!A&6 !+!,",9 /%& %;;#.!; 5#"#'"%'6@%"/2" !'A !2;") ;& 5#&#,7#& " 4# 9#'"%'#5 "/!" "/#,# %& !4&;2"#;A ' 9!"#,%!; ' ,#$,5 , %' "/# +;%$# %;# " &24&"!'"%!"# "/!" +#"%"%'#, &'!"$/#5 !'A 94%;#+/'#4#;'.%'.""/%,5+#,&'!'5"/#&!9#@!&,#$7#,#5,9 /%9!""/#"%9#/%&!;;#.#5!,,#&"'

,52,%'.%'7#&"%.!"%')

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

$"& !'5 $%,$29&"!'$#& 5%&$2&&#5 /#,#%'!47#6 "/%& 2," %& "/# %,9 +%'%' "/!" %' <2#&"%' %& !4&;2"#9%&2&#"/#+@#,&4A"/#+;%$#%$%!;&4!&#5'''#G%&"#'" !;;#.!"%'&32&""%9+;%$!"#"/#+#"%"%'#,!'5"&!7#"/#9&#;7#&,9"/# ;#.!; $'&#<2#'$#& "/!" $2;5 ;;@ ' !$$2'" /%& %;;#.!; 5#"#'"%') '&#<2#'";A6 "/# +,#&#'" +#"%"%' %& !;;@#5 !'5 ) 5!"

2'5#, -#$"%'& > *6

6 ,#.%&"#,#5 !" ;%$# -"!"%' -/%9;!+2,%6 %&",%$" ?25/%!'!6 !;'. @%"/ !;; $'&#<2#'"%!; +,$##5%'.& ,#&2;"%'."/#,#,96!,#/#,#4A<2!&/#5) -%'$# "/# 5#"#'"%' "/# +#"%"%'#, @%"/ ##$" ,9

))

"%;;,#.%&",!"%'"/# '

/!&4##'2'5"4# %;;#.!;!'5/#/!&&2#,#5"/#%.'9%'A&24&#<2#'"325%$%!;$2&"5A' "/#4!&%&!;&#%9+;%$!"%'6!'5@/%$/,#&2;"#5%'";&&&#;,#&+#$" !'5 5%.'%"A ! +, 9!'6 "/#,#,#6 "/%& 2," 5##9& %" !++,+,%!"# "

42,5#'"/#-"!"#@%"/#G#9+;!,A$&" &) ;!$"4#+!%5""/#+#"%"%'#, @%"/%'2,@##H&,9"5!A!'5"/#&!9#4#,#$7#,#5,9"/##,,%'. +;%$#%$%!; & )

)) *

!"#$%&!'( )&'

!!"'! *+ )&'