High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10926/2011dismissed

Sukhdev Raj & ORS. v. Union Of India & ORS.

2015-07-02Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan15 pages

"#$ $%&'&()*+,-

.) /0.

1 1 1

$ %&'& &(

)& * %&# *

)

& %&&&

) %&

! )

%&&

) %&#& &+

)

& ,,,, 1 1 - "

& - *) ! ( "

. &/0123

20//& 4 !

5 26&07&20//8

9/0:)*(4)5

( ""

4 9! "

;

! #

:8 :! ) 2007 8

= 2007 ! =: (

) ! 4 ( !" ) *! 5 (

& /1>7)/03

:* "& !

4 *"

(4 !

! !(*

4&< /7&0@&/1>/)

! "

!8A " !4

:!)/1>/& )

!( *

;(4

!+ 8

;

:)!)/1>28

=/1>2!=:& !

/3 /1>2!)

4) *

4 B&C

! &B&C<

! &B&

! &B& *

* !

(

!& < 21&0D&/1>3) 9! *

8": (!

8/: !

/3 /1>2!)

! 8

9 /:

;

" !

& ! * =

;

! #

:! )/1>3 8

=/1>3! =:& ! ( (5 4

4 /16>)/110) /113)2000

2007&

4)/1>3! *

(49! "

* !

/38/:8": /1>2!&- *)

* ! * (4-

2, 3*4"5 "($52$$6' (&( (7&"!

8 91

& ) /1>2 ! *

4 /16@ ! 4 *&&& 0/&0/&/1>7) 4 /1>2 !& +4

) *!

/>* !

* " *

! "

" 4!

! !

4 !5 "!

4 )

/3 "

)

83: !

/3*!

! !

4 !5 " !

! 4!

" !

)

!*)

!( &* ! * !

( 9! ! 4&

4 !

/>* 35&':"(5";"':1:"54"6' (&(

(7&"-891

& 2007! 8

97:)*!

" !

02&0/&2007& .

* -" !

" " !

" &

* 5

! &. &720D 2007* *! 7/&07&2007)* ! (

-" " *

* !

07&0D&2006)*! /"#&("+ ('*5"(%$ 4<"(, 0#7 6' $($5"+

('*5"(%$$=$+<4$(#

&%$5'''%&"#&(-!891

& *

( &

" "

( * ( <!

<!* * *

5 ( !

& "

* "

! )* !

!4 (

(

)/1>3! *

(4* 4

/1&03&20068

9D:& * !

;

! #

:8 :

! )20068

=2006! =:&* !

( !

0/&0D&2007&

!4 #

<! !

<!* !!

4/)/111&

/@ 2007! ) #

<!!

)* 94 4 !

! ! (

*(4

4 8 : !

4 ! " 8(: ! #

<!8

:&*

9! * 94 4) #

! 2007! & !

! "

" 2007! )

(

*!#

<!* 9! 2007! !

(9!(4 * 30 4 2007!

( 4

!4*

( * "

(

27&/2&2006

2/&/0&2006! 4&*

"(!

(4 -"

(5 4(4-

& * ) )5 4("

! 9!

2007 ! &< !

93& ! "

) #

! 4 !

&2 20/08

9>:

&3D 20/0( -

" !

9 " "

& /3&06&20/08

96:) !

* (* * * (4

( 4E &

/3&06&20/0)

" *

<!(

4 9!

2007! & 5 ( !

(4 "

01&07&20//8

9/0:&- !) *

& * ( (4

4 " !

& "

(9! (!

( 2007 !

02&0/&20078

92:* !

( !

;& * ( <!

;

07&0/&20070&

* (9!* 94 4& 94 4 9

07&07&2007& * (4 . &720D 2007

7/&07&2007)*!

(4 94 4

" 9!

" ( #

<! 9!

& B&

& B& "

" (

* " "#&("+('*5"(%$ 0#7= $($5"+ ('*5"(%$$=$+<4$(#

&%$5'''(-

* "

! )

!4 (

(

( !

9 "

! #

<! "2007 "

(

)(! "

! #

<!* *

&. !4 " * * (

" * "

) !

* (

! * ( 4#

4& ( ( "

! * !!

(4-

" /3 "

&B& "

! ! ( ! !

* "

( "

;

& .

* )4

) *!* (* * * (4 !

4E & - !

"5 "

!) !!

)

( ( 5 &

4 B&

2007! 4!

( $> (7&" ''*5"(%$ 0#7 =

"?:*=&5 1&(?: "5"(?- & !

* (9!* 94 4 ( !

)4 " 9!

! 9

( "

!& 4 "

4 " 4("

! (

)(

* "

* * * (4 ! & 4 "

<!( 9!

94 94 4

! & 4

( (9!

/24

2007! & 4 *

( !

"& 4 2007! ) "

(9!(4#

<!)(

! !

4& 4 * !

5 2007! *!

" ( ( !

8 #&#+$7 / "2$':5"':"56' (&( (7&""(7 #:$5'/:!

"(4

2007! ( (4-

( " !

)

4 4 4 "

& - "!

" B& )

( ( & -

!"#$ " "%

2007! 4 ! &* ( $ @

! "

# $%%& ' ! ( ) *+,# - . # */+$0 *+,#' ) ! ' ' 1 !

0 ', 2 *+,#

*+ ) ) ) ' 0 !

)

! # )

' ( ) ) 03

5 4)!

"4 * * ( !!

!)* ! (!

2007!

!" !

( * * &* ! ( " 4)

* "

!!&

/@)*!

*9!

*$ 4 & '(, * #" )( 1

! " #

$%%& ,

#( ,

# $*,#

#( 0 $

#" )( ', * ) (

1 !

" # $%%&0F

( 9!* 94 4 !

! ! &

94 4 9

7&7&2007 ! ( ( <!

;

7&/&2007) *! !

! ! & 4)

"94 4 &

2007! ) *! 9!

( 9 & 5 * (4

7/&7&2007)*! 94 94 4 9!

5 (4 !

( !!& 2007! ( -

)'*#+$',(

( !

4 " !

(

! 9!

)(!

" * 4

( 4

!4 *

!4*

( * "

(

27&/2&2006

2/&/0&2006! 4)-

4 * *

* (4 ! 4E & *)

4 ( !

(4 "

! 5!

( !! & * ! ! 4

)

9! "

( "

4 (

!! 5

4( !

! &! !

* ( (

4! * (

& -

* "

" "

4 ! )

)

! (4

& ! "( (4-

)

9 "

5 4)

( !

5 4!

(4 !

2>&0@&20//

8 :

)* )* (

) ' $%%&07 ' '08) '

$%%&))

$%%&$%%9 ' 0 ) ' $%%& ' )

) ' 8:'

! 0! $%%9 0 ) $%%&'

*/+2 ' 0 ) $%%&

) 0 $%%& ' ''0 ' ) ' '8:'

! 0$%%9 $%%& ) )'

' ) 8:'

! 0) '

) ' 0

'$%%& 03 !!

& *+,- 8 1 1 "

GIANENDER KUMAR 2015.07.06 10:38 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document