← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2505/2005allowed

Rakesh Devi And ORS. v. Mahabir And ORS.

2024-09-13Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth8 pages



         



   $%& 

( &)*+*', #-./  

  !+ 600$  

        6 3$6$ 

 !   

 

      



 







!"#





 

$ %   



 

$ + 4444   "

 ! #   



&

' '



  "#(

 

 )7% #   (

)  * !# ( ") + ( ") 5 #  (

) )

,   (# )

  %-.%*..,  &   

  #   /   (0

  ) 

  

 

# 



 

'   

    ( 

%)

  "   /7 7 *.'.1,2 





% " &

  



   

'



%-.+*..* 



&  (  

  " #) )     " 

 

  #  (  )   

 

#   3           & 

/  

  "& # &

 

 

*'+  #

"







 " & 8 89 $  *.-  *..**..

.* "' *2-'5.+7 9    $  :

  



% 9     &

%   +, &     "" 

 

"

   - 

% 

 * 

       #     /*.

.7'.1,2



   

 





  "

;""($ )

 #"   

+7 "   &    

%

  



 



   #







 <

8 #  

 



" &     



      

      

    

                   



      

 

    



   "

#$#%&'   ( (

     

   !  / = 

"

%?*0  

=+7

'

"



&& <#

&

 &      

 &   "  #   # 

 

"&



 





" $

/7*.'.1,2 & 

(

%)



 /

 =5 >

7 

    # =+ 

 

 

  







  # 

 #

=*"!"#

  #



&



 



%

89$3*.-

*..+*..*;"9 "  &"    



"



 "



  

 $1

            

  

"    

      



"   "



0  





  

 

  



 





 

 





   & 

  

 

 

 &

#  



 "#    0   

 



 & =+ !"# 

&&



%( 

)

" $ /7 *.'.1,2  & 

& 

 

 &      



;"



 

 





#

/ 



"

 "# "  ( '

%)

 

   

   &

#

 =5>

(#

)

# 





 

         7

 "#  #"

 "   

  =*  " !"# (

 # ) 

     

89(6<%)



& ( 

)

 



"

 6<7*





%  





 & 



  & =+9   &

/

@ "$  !  "   ##

 #      

 



 



#   

"

 

"



 

"#    



 



"





%     #

  (" $  /7*.'.1,2 2 )  & 

*  

"  &  

+ 2 9 

 " 

#

"# 

 &   # 

 "





 

 #  "



 %-11  

 A"

  

  

"

  



  

  # 

   

#  

 "



 

 

89

"



&

&9  # >    A" #

 

 #'

>" '



  

  &

 



"  

 

  

 

"

 #

   

"   

A"

 # # 

>"&  "





"

 " 

" 

>"& " 

   

"

  "

&  &  



 $/ + %*  

 & 



 =*7"!"#=+7





=57>

 (#

)

 #

"  

$ /7*.'.1,2   6  ##

 =+7

=*7"  !"#(

# )  

"





  

 "  

    "

" $ % A"

   

& 

B&++&0%&  %& & &'(&% &)* *+%&  & & ! '''

' ,%&(- 

&& .

1(2

3& &4% 6&+%*', 7&86*7&+ %'

9& :&)*:& &:

*+ *++6& ' *& $:&86$%& & $1'6,% )'

'1;&,+$%*', $,:

<3'

3$+ %'

;$ $= *%

 



##"



  

' 

% 

 >"+, , &



+,..'#

 & 

; !

 "   %*...'7 #

  "" >  9  

  "      

 #





   

   

"

 "



  "

  #

 

  

  &  



&   #



  ##



 &  /

@ 

<  "   #> "  

; 

&

"

; 

"

$%*',$@ ,+67$,)& '1;$,= =

*1*%&:

?

7$,$= &%3* $,:

:

%3&7+ #

/

 *?*@

#.

$< (*, :&7 ')  A.#># /"

 "



 

"   

 #

 

>"

 

 "





>"

#

 

"

 ; 

 7$,$= &%3* + )$+& +6;7$ "  "   " *

% **

& '

*** ,)'1&



%   ""  

 #"

       # 

 

 

  "

#

#"#   %-.+*..*

   /&

 *%,.

6%67& 7'+;&)%+



&

  &  @ 

D "" @ 

  #   *%,.E1F   "

    !

   

  

"  &  #

  "

   

& 



 

& 

 

#

.'7 #



  &    +, ("

)

5.C

,

 # 

#

. .(5.C

 *%,.'7)G+.%.

7 #

 &:6)%*', '<$7:+ ;&7+',$@ 

  "#

 ',&('67%3 &4;&,+&+

 3"

  #

 # 

   *?

 ( ?

 % ?*

 !

  "

< @   

"

&#   **,2,'7 #

 ,,6$@ ,)'1&  

A" & (**,,<%*)*2.-.'7 

6@%*;@*&7

 



   $7@$ !&71$

7+ !+ &@3 ,7 .

 ##

<

2,*,'7

 " (+.%.72,*,) ) & 

"

#  #   

"#

   1% 3* 7$,+;'7% '7;'7$%*',

#"

 

  D%F@

 

& %FG5++55.'7



&

 #"

 #  *2.-. < < 

#    >"

#

6@&&1 ?

B$7,$*@ *,C3"

 -

$<*,:&7 ')

 

< 

 7$,$= &%3* + !&71$ + )$+& +6;7$  

  

 "

 "   $,C%$7*

*

 ' -> 2"

D:

) :

/>  



& )$+& +6;7$  

 1% $7@$ 1% ,E$@* $,:

'%3&7+ ?

'F&,:7$ $%3':

$,:

'%3&7+"

$<*,:&7 ') :

A>##/ - #

 *?*@

.

6,&7$@ &4;&,+&+

'++ +%$%&

*.

)

'++ )',+'7%*61

*,...'7 ....'7



 

 "#      "



 

 

515..'7 

 

 .8  

" &0  



"  

 "

# 7,'

 '1;&,+$%*', $<$7:&:

9= %3 7*96,$@ #     '1;&,+$%*', $<$7:&:

9= %3& *C3 '67% *%,. 1F. (5.C

*%,.) 2,*,'7 (%'5

*%,. E1F.) *2.-. 3&

:

% * 8"" +  "

"" 

 <   5  , "

&) F  

2 8"

 1  - 

%. 

%% 

 %* 

" # 

( +, $  %F *2.-.<%FG 5++55.'7 *,...'7 *....'7 515..'7

&  6<  

6 

"

 "# 

  

 "#  515..<+G %5,*..'7 515..'7



 "# 

 2*.5.. (

2*.55.) 

&      

    

+ ""/D   6;&&+ &?&,

$F3+  <&,%= 3'6+$,:

$,:

'67 36,:7&:

',@= =

# ;&

 "

 &  



>





 

  &

%



"    

 " 

"#  '



"

&9 "  &

"  

$ % 



& 

 

A" &

  " & 

" "# 

% #   

  

  

 

   

  "       #  &#

 

 >

&

 & ## 0      

 #       2*.5..'7 ("

      &   "

 

" "

) 

  

'   

   #

 #  

 





H2,C 

"# # 



" I



#  

&    #      

  

A" &  &

&  

     !  

  #-.

/    

  

$        5 5