Madan Lal And Others v. State Of Punjab And Another
!"#$%%
" &'(% ) () (( ' ****
!
" #$
% & ! ' ( )!*+ ,*- ./ %01.2 1.
!*+(,
, -
&./ ' 001 02 (2(1 ! 123415*41+(41(141* /, 0+52 6! (20 /, 7 & ! $
8 # ! 9
6: ;07 < - !& & = !& =& !
& 12 (2(* 6: (7 != 0> (2(*6: 17 # & !? != = -
&./ 03 2> (2(* < ! /- & 4) , ! & = <
& &
!= < !
) (* 2> (2(* ! = #" 9
& != ? < ?
! !
- 2 - & != = - :=? , ! < ./-
< !
! !123/, < ! ;!= !1(2 ,
, 0@31 * & !
9A = , 3)
*45 1* 461 , '78 15!!* 41 3/$902):;; ! & !
:=& ! !
== B&
;
!
" # $%
"
$&
'!
"
$ %
# "
)
'
" ') " "
)
# "
)
$* ' )
" !
+$% (
",
"
- )
" '$& )
'" ( "
. # "
",
) '
" #
'" # ! .
$ * '
" ) " '
" . " " #
!
$/ "
- 3 -
)
'" "
" " ) '" "
' '
) '!
" ) "
. '
' ) ' $0& .
" ,
" ' " '
' "
'"
) "
"
" ! $
"
'
) '" !
) " " "
!
'! ( "
) '!
) '" "
$, '! 1
)
!$ % "
'
""
') '
$ 2"
" )
) !
' ')
"
') '"
$ %! "
.
(
"$
'
'
) )) '
' )
' '
''! ''
) !
'' (
'" "
$&
) ! (
'
)
'
!
) "
'"
" # 3 " + % ! .
'
" $4
'
' "
''-
,
- 4 - '
!
" "
)"
$%
'" # "
"'
(
'"
! 1
'
" ) ")
$ %
(
"
'
! ) ''
'
$ /$ <
;
"
"
"
'
)
" '
",
+ " . "
')
'!
" "
'! ' ' '!
)) '
)
''
) '!"
" '"
"
)
)'3
. "
'"
"
) '" ! '
1) " "
! $ ,
"
)
!$
' '!
. "
" ' '
1
2 )) " ! '
' 1
!
( " )'!
) " "3
"
+ & " 2) 2 $
'" ''
!
"
" " )
! "
' '
"
"
+& "5 2) 2 $
)
!
( "
.
"
"
- 5 -
" '"
"
)'$
'"
"
)'! )
+&
6&7 )"
$ &
'"
. )
+& 1
'' " " "
'"' " )
"
+&$ 6
'"
!
# !
"
# !
'
"
'5"' "!
" $
. !
'" ) '
'! " '' "
" '"5 )" "5 "
'$ , .
) ' ) ''
$ % '
)
'
$0 " $ "
'" " )
'! " " ' "
) "
3 '.
"
" (
- )
" '
""
)
!
" ') 5 ) " "
(
"
" " "3
" )'! "
" !
" )
"
) $
- 6 - '< < ;!
< ! 6 7 &! ! = .
= ./ !
?
! !
?< !
& ? != !=<
< ! ? < ?
+ / ! != < & <
:=? ! !! 8? !- < !& <!< : ! ? ,
!" #$# $" % & < !*+(,
, : ! ."
#
!
, ) & <
: ! &?< = ! ! ! , : ; ?! ==!
!
@ ?& = ! < ? &! =??=& < !? < < =!
=& <
?! !&
9 & ! !! =!
! := = , ! !&?
!
!! ./' 001 02 (2(1 !
- 7 - 123415*41+(41(141* /, 0+52 6! (20 /, 7
& !$
8 # !9
6: ;07 < 12 (2(* 6: ;(7 - !& & = -
-
<!= 0> (2(*6: ;17 !! &? < 2> (2(* 8$8 ' 0)!*+ ,*- .2
,*-
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No