High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7355/2007disposed of

Mishra Singh & ANR. v. State Of Pb. & ORS.

2016-08-29Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri,Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri10 pages

!!!!!!!!!!

# $%& !!!!!!!!!!

( !!!!!!!!!!

# $%& !!!!!!!

! "

!!!!!!!!!!

) $ !!!!!!!!!!!

#$ % &'()* #+,-./* $%*-%0# 1*# % &'()* #+,-./*#-%*2%*#%$$&

* !

) $' "

+ # ' , -./00-122. -345-1262 '

!0 5, -12.54-1225!

# ' , -12.54-1225!

!$" $7( $%&!

!) "

+ '

-8 +9 &9 ) +9 ##+ !

!!:! ( "

+ # '

!0!

;;;

$%*-%0# 1*#3+

#$) 9 7 (( '

# & " 8 7 7 ' + 8'' (( # 8 8 +$

+ !

#+ & <+ # 8, -./00-122.!

' 7' #"((

( (

)+ $!

'$'

# =8 >7+ $+

& 7 # 8)(? # +(( @@# A

"(( # ' "(( 7(!

8 + $+ "(( & '

7 " 8 # 8 8 7 <' &(9 ++ $ (+) ##$ !$ "(( + $ & '"

) #+( " # ((73B)8# 8 !

" $((9 ##+( # '8 ( 8 8& "(( + 9+ ## ( 97((& '

$+ 8 #+( !

79<)( #( & ( ' "(( ( 7 $(C &9 '8 # $+ # 8 & # "(( ! ( # ' 7&#$+ &$ 9 ( &9 " ( & # # "(( !

+9' D$ ' # <+ # ( D$ " 8 +9( + 8' ) !603E3008$( !/3EE1?0-62A/8?2-62A' %8& 9 1221-2/! ## + 20!24!1220 ''

' <$ 6! <+ + $( " & ## + ++ + 7 $( '+$((9 + 0 # 456 1 77899)$3

7 #47: .456

1 77899) #847 #473

7+ <+

& ( 7* =- #847 :44; 3:7 < 9 < 6 < = ?6A ((( " " & " '+9 $ + ((& $(C '

#&9 '+9# & # # & # "(( + +

8 ' +& *

7 7 8 "(( " '+9 # +"((

((& $( '

#&9 '+9 & # # & #"(( * "

#$ 7 7 8

"((

((& $( '

#&9 '+9 & # # & #

* "

#$ 7 +$($&( ( #9"(( "

" & " '+9 <+ #7 - # ( #"((

? <+($ & A +$($&( $'

< #7 - #$+ ( ((& ( # '+9 (# # 8

+$($&( #8( ((& $(C

( 8 #( ( % + & % + #"((

8 +$($&( ((& $(C

&$ 8(((

7 #"((

&9 (( + + $( 7 '+9$+8 89& ' +& !G ?1A # & $(C '$'

# ' " $&- + ?6A ((& 8+ &9$+ ##+ + $( 7 '+9 $+8 89& ' +& ! ?/A " 8 9 ##+ $ &9& (#89# 88

8 7" 7 $ + 8'(+ 7 ' " # + ' " $&- + ?6A

$&- + ?1A$ 9'+9 $+

+ 89& + 9! F?3A + ' " $&- + ?6A $& + ?1A $&- + ?/A((''(9 =((9 >!G F?0A 7 9 + ' + $& + ( "

" & " '+9$ + (( & '

# &9 79 # ( # <+ ( " 7 '+9

+$($&( 7+( ##9' + (+$($&( " "

& " '+9!G #47:.4561 77899)

#847 #473

*>8:7!

?- ::$@ +9# # ' + 9

& # # & # "(( 89 7 ' '' "( # " 8 # 9( 8( &9 <+ 7 ( # D$"( FH($ !G F1;;;;;;;;;;;;G # +9+ + 9# (( $' 7## " + 9

+$8 ) '' "(

# '

!/7+7#$ # ( +) " ( '8

+9 ##+ ? # +(( @ @# A! < + 7 $+ (

) &( "($ #& ( 7+7 # $

& + 8'&( ! ( # ' $

$(C &$

"+ 7 <+ #( ' 8 &9 +9 ) '(+ '" '

' 7' #(

, -12.45-12257 # +9 <+ ( 7 ' 7((99 &$ " $((9 8 # 8 7' 97"+ !

D$ (9 " ) +

#+ '' "( ' + $( & + 8' ++ $ # ( " & $(C & # +9!

, 89 + + #( '(9 & ' ' #+ 9 & "

( 8 &+) 7' +8 & 8 9 1224! (9 8 7) $'# $( " $ (

7' D$ 8' 7 + # + !

" 7 # 8 ##+ +8 '

7 ++ &$

97 + 7) $'

' + # ##+( # ! +$8$(" ## + #((7 " & '"

# # '

E '' "( # !

I + $ ( # '

7 $(

% + 7 " '' "

&9 ! 897 " & '"

# # 8

##+( & & + # $&9#( D$ '

! , ( ' + + $+ # ##+(

8 ' $! $8 7 '

++ 7+$8& $'

8 " $ ##+(

$ 8# '(97++ $( " & #( $ ($+ '' ' (9!

'" '

7 " #( , & !12.54-1225 " (9 ''

$ + 0 # $%&H(( I + $( 0

$ & " ( !

' $" '(+ + <$ 3

5! <$ 3( # 8 + " ( '8

+9 ##+ '' 8 # #+$(' + # $(C ' @ ( # 8 +9 7 <+ '$&(+ (( + #& ( !1!10(+' + !

'$'

# # + 7 89 <+ ( "'

# ( 14!24!1220*- =

" #$ % & ' ( ! ) * '$9 88 $+ 88$+ 25!66!1225

' 8) "($ #& ( & #< !5(+' +

' +#9 & + # ' 7 9'' + + <+ ++ + 7(7! 8 +9$'

63!20!122. ( 7+7' '

" ' " 7 '' "(& ) &+) (( #( + # 8 & # $!

+ D$ + # ' + $ & '

#<)( #8 +9@( '$$ " $

" 8'

'' "(!

# '" '

!0 % + <+ &$ + ' !

, ( + <$ 3 5''

, - ./00-122. $+ " 9# 8' # + #, -12.5412257 ((!

' $( # $( 0 # $%&H(( I

$( $( 64007 $( " (# ' # +9 + 9 <+ 8 ( & # # & # "(( 9897 ' '' "( # (( + # 9(

8( &9 <+ 7( # D$"( "($ !

" (9 +( $ # (77 $( D$ ' '' "(&$ " + 7 ' + # 8 +95 )( # ( # '

$(C

& #

# "(( !" 8 (98 & 8 ' 9&#$+ ( !' $( # $( 07 $(

#$ + 7 ( D$ + + 7 $( " ( '8

88 '

&9 " 8 +9897 '' "( # (( + # 9( 8( &9 <+ 7 ( # D$"( "($ !

$& ( # 8 +9+ & <+

' "

# D$"( "($ $&% + #+ $ ' '' "( # + 8' $ 9 D$ !

$&& $ #+$8 # ' '

8 +9( '$$ (

#+'' "( & 7+' " # 8 '' "( # <+

'+$((97 (#$(C ( # ' # $+ #=8 >!

#+" ## 'D$$ 7 ( # ' $(C &9 " 8 # + $+ 8 7 $+ 8' 8 8((9 9" $## 8 +9 " 9 7((#$((9 ## ( & # # & # "(( !

+ &" $(9& 7 ' D$ (9+ 8' &9 # $(C ( +

8 +97+ " ( ' <+ # D$"( "($ & + 8 &9 '' "(++ + 7(7!

# $ + 7 #$ # ' + ' + $ & '

#<)( #8 +9 ( # " ## ( $(C # & # # "(( '

!6& 8 '' "(

<+ 7'

#7 7 )@# 8 # + ' + # + '9 # !

89( & + '" '

7 ( 7' , -12.54-1225" + 8 ' # "(, !12.54-1225 8 7 #' +$ !

I + $ (# ' $&8 8'

!345-1262& #$+$ $ 8 89&

#$+!

++ (9!

0< +48 $ $141265 -AB 99 +48 , ' ) E

, '

&( E