High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2660/2005dismissed

Surjit Singh v. Kapil Verma

2019-01-09Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!" " !""#$

%%&& ' (%&')"

$% *

+" ",- "%%&&

* &

'% & "),- "%. /01 2)%3

!""5 !"&)%

" '"&, 66!%

(%& ') 0 -, 7" ') 0 8, .& 1 2)%3 # 0 5! ! . 9* : ;// " " ! -"& &)!

)%" $

& 53 ")"

! " &), " 8 )%&3 : 25&8"< $ )5&2 !!&3$

,=% )">""8!5 ?3>" 5

,"8!!))5&85 )5&

2 &"">")8"&, 5!

-"!&!)53%.

0(%&') ))5"""%53!!"@)& ", &&3,"%&&"% 5)- ) &%&)%&!- & ! &)

","%8+ 2-&:%&,)5& 2 8"")) % :8%

%(&! >"8%%&) >""8&&!!)")&!" &)%"% ))"$ ?,=8" )&),% A"%&)""" 5)%)&35& ! " )"%85&38+>"""%) "&5 >"""+&-)" 3 " 53")" ,"%%% $%.

"& 8%&38"""3"+ %%&" %.

8-! )&%>"" %"&& , &!"> """)&8!&! A"%. /0 )%3"% 8%&3 ""&)%"+ - %&& !""%.

8"-!-& --!&")

&&3, && " % ) % 8" %3

/ )&"&)%

"%&!"%,&&8! 8) / ?

B""C ,8"" 8 53 "&),8 5 ""!&!-!

2, 5! ! . 9* :;//, 53 %.

D**

B"""&)&)%$

& 3") " 53")", "8) ")8")D**

/ B"""%5 3%D *$

B"""%"5&53"%&& 8"%.

D*$

B"""-"!-"&8"&!-& --!&")"D*$

B""% /8&5&%33)% "C &&!D*$

;

7""%&- %%"%- &)

1 %%","&)")&%%*B/

: "@) ( .!)*B , "

"+( ),2)& "&)*B, 1*8( )*B? "+. *B

? """,%. /0 )%3" - )E@ $

"!!

),"%8%%&3 8"53"A5 &)%$ 6,; =&!8"

FG% ))"&!&)%&& &H88&)%35&53%.

/ &3-&&3 A" 8 & " &) !!- " " %%""2 53&!"%%%&+!") ")%8") !%3"%%&" %%&&@%;

%%&"-!5&," &!&%-8&&855 !"

."%%&8!-% A"%%& 5!53%. /&3,8"-% .

"&35%8"

1"-"& &"%5!!

" !""

# &" )%3" 5) "8"""%%&&,"%%&5+5 1 %%","" &&7" !)53 (+:!"2

!"!8"8 5-"&))%%& & 8@%,&),&"5" &) & " 1

8 "5-" "3"8"" &) C "5&3 ") ""&!&%-% "&)& &""

# &" )%3 5)" "%%&&"" &"" & 53")" A","&!& %-&!3)% & - :" "%&& % "3 # # $ #%""&'()' )

%+ 53:)"&*":!"2 8"&!8")& 8"%%&&8 ,"8-" !%3"%%&"))% A" %%&8 "-55-!"8& %& ,5 53"&!&%- &))%)! 53 !"%&" ,8""5 53"&!&" # & " )%3 " " %&& % &&7" !) "3*":!"2 "! ,#-

, ,. / 0 %""!'

)' )!%(

" " ", & & " &) " "3

1-2 34 1 # %"

" &5" 53

:!"2 8"85-"-8 /" 1

,5&3 3 -- "% " !""&)-H %&,), -3 &&%%3&!&%- "&% %%&")8 &5" ""

"! & & !! " !" " "53"),1""%%&&

!",8"") "-3@ 8"" 53")","%%&5 5 E- "8)&,"))% ) A" ) ! " %%&& 8 " " 5&3 %-53")"-53@)!*B (

.!)"8!G5&3"5+53 " A5 & 8"& ! )% :8-, " ! 8" "A5 &"!--& &3! % 8"& ! " % ( .!),8""" ,""(&!> "%)! !3 %

!","8"!

>""%=&)") ") *%%-!"!&%E@ *&%E@ * E@ *6, "!"/ ;

/,"8))5"7 "3,"&!8""))5"7@)

!" ""8"-!G%)5&3%& &+&"% > "!5!

; E@ * 1"@),"""5&3 8

I)")" 3 53" "5%" &&3"& :")" "8J%)5&3J8)E@ *" % )E@ *?

,"%88&+ 8" %%," !"% 38-")

"&+,"A5 &8 &3! % E@ *

"), % "%% 5 <-) - 5! )%&3 : 25& <-) $&83 *& A""!"8""83 "&3 " 53")"" 3% 3&" ,") "") &-- 3% !"%")" )-!! % !!&& && 5 A"

" C " 5! & 3 )% %) 5&3, 8"" )!" "- &&"!%3 A" !"%- 53"%=&),"")&-%; 35 "&) ""8&&"-!)&&-

/3" A""!"8"""5! &-8" %3" &&")"

-& &- A" !" )% 8 ) % % ""&) &%%%) 53")",8""8"3

6 /5 ""&) )"-5 !"53 &)")&"""%%"%)&" @3 A", 53") &+5 )!"83"%) A"&)"" 3 / A"A5 &"-"& ""8 "%3&:25&%)&%3& & &3 " - )","A5 &"8)%" &) - " % ! ! 53 %5 53")"& ") &G5&38&&"% "%&H 2-& :%&, )5& 2 )

,)%$ /,="58 )&@%, )$ ,="58" &)

A"A5 &"@)"%"<-) -&)5 )")&@% 53 ")")&"%)&3))5 1"8," ") )!""-58"&)"-& ")% "8-5-") )5 53"<-),""!

)!""-)8 7 - "") &&8) A"A5 &53!-! &!")"& "%8 % % 53 *B "+ . 5&& E@ ; " 5 % 53"))*B "+.!"!"

)% )&&35&& ;

?, ? ?

8 5 5 & "3, " + A" !"&)8!$ ,=8%& ,$

,=8%-% ")!) &&!&3"53"%8@), )% &&! %")8! A" A5 &8! !"!)%$ 6,;

= "&))) )&&-3"% 8"%")&- &3)," "! "8 " " &- 8 8" %3

.-"&1%%%%%8"! ") "%%&)% &&38"5 " 5 5) 53 " )%3 3 " % A")%8$ 6,; =8"FG % ) 5C 8" "5!3 "")

,"%%&)

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#