← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2340/2013dismissed

Jog Raj @ Yog Raj v. Usha Joel & ORS

2015-05-07Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul8 pages



     

 

     

        

    !  "#!

 $  #% !

&' (

!&  $ ) '*+*(,&()-(( & !&  $ $&*+*(,&&'- (' .*  !' (*$)*&/*+*(,&&'- ( 0   1)()&&-&(&',2*2 3'-*-&'/*45*223 ('678/ (9   5&,&&(&-&(&'& (9 0  1)()&()678/ (')725&-&( () 8'(9      

 

(( && 8 *6:8 *6)*',2()-&' &+' -(( *8* '(()/-78 678/ (*(;

0  0 -*''542*& ( *2$'' '78<*-7&()*2*3)&54 )'*--*2*8* '(()678/ (*(

  -*''54() 2*&   $-*2  7*2  !*8'(&*(  <*-7&()*2*  *=7(( 8  () &'- ('>*7'3*''/'' &,24'(*(()*(()-(( &>/-2* (3)2-'( *'*$ &+' *2!*2 ,,&*(  '-(*27''* -7& ,&/  . ? ;;.  (22    ;;;  )*'  5  ')*&8 8  )'  7('

28 (24  ) '(24 *   322  ,722 &'-(  *   ) 7&    ()  '(*,, &'- (   0>$/( $7&6( 8 '  @!*(& A  ,  ()  )'-(*2  )*

'/+&5*2=7*&&23() /-24 */24* ')*$ 8) $)28*   ..*(.

; ;;?7 'B? 0.*  ?  2$(*( $**&<*-7&()*2**8* '(()*( /-24 )/-2* (*--*&*'*, 3( '' ()*( *'* 72(/*(24 B . ;;B* ')*$ 8)3*'*=7((54 ()  (&*2 7&(  (  '    *7 (  ,  ()'  8&78  &'- (   0 '(*&(/*C 8,*2'/-2* ('*8* '(()-(( &>/-2*

(( &>/-2* ()*''(*( )'/-2* (()*( 0  ;;B 3) ))* 7( *&7( /*

&),7 5)*+7&, *7'  */24 62 *(5&7* *&&8* (3()'/ ()&  &&872*&('    *2'  ,7   ()  '*  /-24  *5' $/2*&24  ? ;;B),7 $/( ')*27&' 8$'(& (

-&-&7 ,&/3)2 *7'*2(47(4* ')3*',7 -2*4 3()  *  )2  7& 8  7(4 )7&'  $)  3*'  *2'  ,7   7' 8  ,2()4 2* 87*8*8* '(()(& ()-&' ,()-*( ('* &(* ()&&&872*&(' & 824-(( &''7*2((&( *7' $/(  ')*2&8*& 8()'&&872*&('* )& 5)*+7&    *2'  )* 8  ()  7('  ,  '(*,,  7&'  

*/ '(&*(+8&7 '   +3,()*,&'*)*&')*( *22()*7'3() //    ( (   )*()  *   '-&*4  (  ,*/  )/ @/-2* (D-(( &A* (23&()/*8,()/-2* (

()4',()/-24'3)3&3&C 8 () *2*)

*(&4&2*(+'* 22*87' 22()*7''(*&(/*C ,*2'  *   5*'2''  /-2* ('  *   &-&' (*( '  ( ()  )8)&

 *7()&('* '(*&(- 24,*/ 8()/-2* ( &&( 23&  )'  /*8  *   '-2  )'  &-7(*(  B ? ;;B  *7' '   (      

+*   3()  &'- (   ?  /*  *  ,*2' (*228 8()& ()*(()/-2* ('5)*+ 8&724  '*4 8 ()*(  () /-2* (  '  ()& ,&  *  ,7&()&  7' *57'+  *   &8*(&4  2* 87*8  )  ,*2'  *   ,*/*(&4 2* 87*87'54)/*'7 > 



 



  



  !

     !

 

  !    "

    

   

  !

 

  !    

"

!

 

# )'/-2* (3*',&3*&($/( !*/(** &6 )*&/* $(*  8//(( *23*4'3()*,&3*& 82((&, *'3* ($ 8)*7'7 &()&3 '8 *(7&'    ;;B *22()*7'*8*  

+* 3()*'3* ($ 8)*7' /**,*2'/-2* ((

 ! '(&,$(*(,& *23*43 2)*228 8/'5)*+&*  '72( 82* 87*85 87'54() ( )'3*'((*224,*2'* 5*'2''/-2* ( ''

()  *5+  *228*( '  *22  ()  *7'  3&  &'- '52  ,&  () -752*(  ,   '72( 8  ,*/*(&4  3'    E)  &57 F  

  ;;B  *   ;  ;;;  *   *2'    E)   7'(*  /'F 3'-*-&'    ;  ;;;  -  ()'  *228*( '   =7&4  3*'

 7(  *  () /-2* (  3*'  ,7  ,*2' 7'  *'3* $ 8) )',&3*& 82((&*(0 ? ;;B()*&/* $(* 

 //(( *23*4'32))*'*228()*(()/-2* )*'/*/5GG2/ ( ())'-(*2'(& 22()*228*( '

2+2254()*7'-&'  ()/-2* (3&,7 ,*2'*  *7 (,()',*2'*228*( '&-7(*( ,()/-2* )*'  8   3    ()  4'  ,  -752  ,& '  &2*( '  * /-24',() *23*4'  *7 (,,*/*(&4*228*( ') ,22'C7(-&'' * &/* 'C *23*4' 22,&/ ;  ;;;(22 B 

)&*,(&)3*'(&* ',&&,&/()-'(    ;;;* )72 (6 )'7('*( &G-7&7( -&'' * 'C ''

,(&  && 8  -&2/ *&4  +   *7'  3& '7// (,*()(&*27 ' >

* .;  )*&8'3&,&*/  7& 8(&*2()/-2* (H*/  1> *&/ <*7&7&' 8$'(&3)'7--&(()+&' ,()/-2*   -&+    &&     *,,*+(  *(    ;;;  H 10D $/2*&24 1>$*( */$ 8))*'*2''7--&(()+&' ,() (* -&+ && 3'-752') 3'-*-&'

E)&57 F*(  ;;BH  1>0 */* -$ 8) 2&C  *23*4  '-(*2  )*'  -&+    &&  &(,  -4 H 10D3)) (* '/*2&-&(* ,( ''&(,*(,() (  1>.7&)*&* *'' ,,$7-& ( (-&+   && ()  3'  (/  *(    ;;B  H 1.D  1> *6 <7/*&  -&+    &&  ()  *(( *   &8'(&  ,  ()  )'-(*2 H 1D(H 1D.7(4'(&57( &8'(&H 1D-4

 , 8'(&H 1D2((&*( ? ;;BH 1DB-4, *(( *   H 1D;  *   H 1D   '(*(/ (  ,   62 H 1D'(*(/ (, ')*2%*& &! )*'* *&6 <*7&  H 1D  (  H 1D?  *--2*(  *(   B ;;B H 1D'(*(/ (,& 8 *6H  1DB/-2* (*(  ? ;;  *   ,&3*& 8  2((&  H 1D   &'/ (  1>? %*& &  <*7&  )*'  -&+    &&  )&  '8 *(7&'  +&  () (  H 1D  *2 8  3()  '8 *(7&'  ,  82 *  ')* *&6 &<*7&* ! )*'* ')*2' (,)&'8 *(7&'

+&  H 1D  1>  & *  )*   !* 8*(  3)  -' &8*& 8() 3'(/*(;  ;;;'7--&(()+&' ,() (&8*& 82'',)'&-7(*( 1>B&6!)* I *2 $&(*&4'*2'3( '', 3'(/*(;  ;;;* ,(2*'( -&8&*//  % *(  ;;;* 2((&3&(( *(.  ;;;

H 1BD  1>;& 8 *6/-2* (&(&*(()+&' , )'  /-2* (  *   -&+  *22  ()  H)5(  7/ ('  *2&*4 H)5( ()'(*(/ (,+*&7'3( ''' *2'-&+

&&  ()  3'  (/  *(  ;  ;;;  H 1D  /-2* ( & (+ -4,&&*(0 ? 

H J'* 2')'+  $(*(/ (',*7'7 00&  3& &&3)& *22() &/ *( 8+ *8* '(()/3& -7((()/57(()4 ()'*/* -2*

 

()5*'',+ 2*& (&*27&('/'' ()/-2* (+678/ (*(   88&+*8* '(()

 678/ (  *(       *--*2  3*'  ,2  54  () *--22* (D/-2* (* ()'**--*23*'*2''/''54() 2*&   2 $'' '  78  <*-7&()*2*  +  678/ (  *( ;

0  0  ('*'((22*3()*(()&+' *267&'( '+&4 2/(7 2''-&+&'(4''(*52') )&,&  (&,& '

3*&&* (   4   (&,&     ()   7&& (  ,  8'  ,  ,*( &&545()()7&('523'-*2243) -&+&'(4'

'(*52')' (3*&&* (  ,& /*45/*(*678/ , "52-H7&( *25&*(678/ (, %'

$ 

 



B@ A$.

*'    )*   5()  ()  7&('  523  )*+  && ,  8  ,  ,*(  ()*(  (  )*'  3)&  5  '(*52')  ()*(  () &'- ('+&,*/()-(( & )&&&+*2'()*(

  ! '(&  ,  $(*('  ,&  *23*4'  )*'  *7()&(4  +&  () (  (  3)/  ()  /-2* (  )*'  5  /+  54  () &'- ('*  ()'/-2* (*  =7&43*' 7(*  =7&4&-&(H 10D'*2&*4 (),2    8,()' =7&4 &-&(* ()&&// *( &*'*'7 >  ! !

  %& "

!

      "

 '     !  

        (     )    (  '        '       

 "

  ' 

 

    "       )  (

*  !

  

 !

!"

  

)    !   +  (         

 !

    "   !   

!    

(

  "   

, 

      + ( (

  (       

     (  ((  "     

!

!  (  )(    (

     (    -

    

(       

  

  "  " (  )  !

 . 

  

( (  

(        " (   

. (    

       

 (  (

    

          "



# )&,& ()5*'', =7&4&-&((3*',7 ()*( (3*',7 872(4,7' 8*57'+* ,722* 87*8( ()  '(*,,  //5&'  *   ()  //((  ,7&()&  &//   )'

(&* ',&*  ((*''8 * 4*/ '(&*( 7'* )&=7&'

7 '2 8,&)'-&52/'* *(((7   ()'/*

&('()&'- ('3)3&,7 (5 '7,,&&,&/()/'5)*+&* *57'+2* 87*8,()-(( & ()*'5 */((54()/-2* ( )'&''>H*/ *(

*57(()+*&7'2((&'3&(( *8* '()/&8*& 8/'5)*+& 3()  )'  22*87'    )*'  *2'  */((  ()*(  &   /*  * (*8* '()/&8*& 8/'5)*+& ()()7&('523)*+&8)(24)2()*( *'() &'- ('/-2* (()' &'*8* '(()/'5)*+&* 7',*57'+2* 87*8*(())* ',/-2* ((*

(5

 '*(5* ,, //((7 

  )&,& ,     /&(    ()  &+'  -((   *   ()  '*/  '  )&54 '/''   



 !"

    '