← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12704/2024allowed

Esic And Others v. Manikant Kumar & ANR.

2025-10-29Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri14 pages



       !"#$ %&

'()* +! ,&!

&(&!!

$&  -- !& .& , !)!

!$&  --  (!

! 

'()* +! ,&!

&(&!!

$&  -- !& .& ,

&!'!

!$&  --  (!

! 

'()* +! ,&!

&(&!!

$&  -- !& .& ,

, $(!

!$&  --  (!

! 

'()* +! ,&!

&(&!!

$&  -- !& .& ,

$)'!

!$&  --  (!

!  

'()* +! ,&!

 &(&!!

$&  -- !& .& , /!0!1,'&!

!$&  --  (!

!

 /" 23/ - + +/ ++  23/ - +.1++

  

      

  

  

 

! 

 " #$ %&'#()*+ (*(+, 

   

 " # $ -% %&'#(.()'(*(+,

 

/    $ -%,  0   

      " #

$ %&'#(2..

(*(+,  3

%



  4  

 $ %&'#(2.)'(*(+,  +/ ++ 45 &)6 # 5

0

 

 () *6 (*(.

$7 '2,

 %

 

%    *. *8 (*(#



 

1  

 

:7 ;



!

< =<=



 ( % 

 

  5 (*#2





  :" > 1;













3 < 

   9

 

?  



  1

3 

# 

 3  7 

 3 !

< =<=



  3

0





9  3 @

1  5 %  $" % <





 (*#*

.

   

3 





 3 7

  1  3   3 



:" > 1;

 #+ *. (*#)

+   

 3 

1    

9





   

:" > 1;

5

3 

 

7 3   7 0   7

 =<=



! 

3

(*#*



  3 

 





3   3  

31 





 (*#* 1   

 <

1  3



 1

 *. *( (*(#  <

1 3 3    0

 (*#* 1  < )  '

1 



 

0

   () *6 (*(. 



3 

   



0

 B  



  

    '

1  1

 

1   3 0

  7 3  

9

3



:" > 1;



   0



3  3   

31  

  3  



1  7  

1  







   0



:" > 1;

B  





3

4    = ! = 1

3 

 (*#6



  



:7 ;



 =<=

! 01 

1

  

  #* B  

 





:" > 1;

 3  3 (*#* 1 

   

 (*#* 1   0 1

1 

 1 



1  3 





1

  

3



3 

0  (*#*



 3

  

0   

3

  ## B  



 

1 3 

  

9 



 



1

 

 

  3    '

1 #(  



#.

B  

  3 

>

  

 0

 3 

1 ?

 



0  1 

0 



1 



0 3   



 +  

 7 0 

1 ?



 = 3





 







#+ B  

'

1  0  =<=

3 3   = 1 



 =<=

 !







    =< =

 = 1

  1  (*#6

 :7 ;

 

 =< =

3 ! 

 

7





1   3

 

 

#2 B  

0 

0

3

  = 1



   C  

3



D 



 

 ; =;

7 





   B  



 0 



0

 3  

1    3

  

#A &  

 



   3 



#) 5

 



 3 1  



E

1 3 

0 



9 



5



>  1  (*#*

0







 

1 





>  (*#* 





0

 



9 #8  9

  3 3 



9

  



   





9 



 01  

#6 

  



3

 3











   <

 



  5

  



 3   0  

      

 9   

9 

3

0

     3 

   

9

  

 

0



  3 (*#* 



3



  

(*  4 =;0   % 5

   



      



4

'

 

     

   





     

 

 



  

 

   !



           





"



 

 

 

 !

  

   

 

! 

  

        !



     

   









 

 

 !       

 

  

 



    

   



 # ! $   !

         



  





!  "!   

 

 

     

  



%     

  

  



   

      "!   



 





      

   

  

  

 

!

!   &      % 

     

    ! 

    



   ! 

        



  !



!

  

!   

  

 !

  "! 



       

     

      



'

    



  !

  "





 

!

  

!  "! 

   



 

  



   



 ( 



    



   

  !



    

  



 



  ! !

)*+,

 !

   

 !

  

  

           

   

  !

      



          

    

 & 



 

   





   

  "

    





!    



 ! 





  !   



 

 !

 )*+-  







  !



.

 



 



 



!

      %

  

 "!   /

 &  



  



  

 





 

!     

!





!    %

  

"! . 

&      !0

'

  



 "

 

 !

       



   

  

    ! 



  

     





!0

 

  

     

 

   

  0 

 

    !



  

          

  





 



   



  

  





   

  



!

 

1 (# 



0 3 3 =;0   % 5



1   <



<0

 0 







1

 3



 3  



 1



3 

   0

  3   ;

3





(( B  

0   

1

  0 3  ?        7 0 

' =< =

 

  F

 



3 3

 





 @ 





  D





   0          



1 3

 

9



(.

B  

'

1

 4 D   %

 !" " #! $  !"#! %   

& 

 

(+ 5

 4 3

 

 

  1

0 1

  3

0 



 9 1

 

(2

 



3       = 1

 

  1 

=<  =

 (*#6

 3 7 

=

 (*#2 01      0    5



 

 3

  (*#* 1 

 

1



>

1 











  

 (*#*  







(A 5

  



 (*#* 1   

=

7 9  1

 

  3  

 7

!

< =<=



 = 1  =  (*#6

5





1    3

1

7 0

7  4  0 

  

(*#* 1 

3

 0 01 

 

 

() G 3

3 0 7  3  =  = 1

 3

  3 

0 3 

 0 3 3 7

  =< =

D    C  



     =< =

3 ! '7 3

 @   7  1

   3  

1   (8 G

'

1

  3

   3  3

  

3

  7







9   

 



3

 0 7 0 

 =<=

3

  3 

 = 9 7 

 =<=

? !



 

1 3  

3 

0  

 (6   

 

0  3 7 

0

(*#* 

0  

5 



1 3 0  <





  3

1 0  0

  3

3  4

4 <

 3 (*#* 

 3

   3

  



  3

  3



1 





  

  9



 0 3



(*#* 

9   

  3   3

 3   0  3

0 

3

  3 

 







.*  

 

  1

1

3

  3   1 

3

  3  



1 



  3

  

1 

5

  3



3

3  4

       .# 

 $, 

1   

.(  

   

5 +/ ++6   #$ %& 5.1++

6      3



4

   ! $