High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/50195/2018allowed

Jagdish Varinder Singh Sandhu And Another v. William Singh Sandhu

2022-08-31Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur5 pages

!"# $%$%&'&%#( )$*

$%$%&&%'( )$*

$! +,$ --

-. /

!"# $ " %& !"# $ " '() !"# $ * '&++ ( , !"# $ * '& " ---- -

-. /

0 ( ,* . ' '&++ ( $%$%&'&%#0 ' &++ & /* 0 '+ ! "!+ +" *$ &, + +"

1232.1!(/'

+#"& "'+(* ', "

4'+*"+$+ ,

+ 5$5""++ ,4+#+,"

6+ +#++ 7 + , !8'+ **$!$ +""$+ 9:244! "$+ .3;6.76"7 *'44! "8+'$+ .39 ".3.

*'4!($ ( "+"

#!' ' '&++ ( $%$% &&%'! ' &++ & / * ' + +" * ' $ 0+ ,' & $"+ !($ , $'"

+' &++ 5 $$"'+!(/'<+"+$+ ,,/& 8"4 9 +$( '' ( #&++ '$, $ $ &, +!'* !( ' (,* $ #"+$(+

: '* $ ,( $%" & *'+ "+&

' $ + ,++

($ ( "+"+$+#+,+( .2= * 2>292.2!($ + ++" '+ $ *'$ &,

+ ' &++ 5 $$" '+! $, ++ '+ ,+* 0

"++ * "$, / "$! 8,, ! "++ *

$ 0+ ,'8+',+* *& + +&$ *'+%'

(! ($ "$+("+?5: #!"+ ' &"$/ *' ( #$+#+,+!'&, ++**$ + " "93 "8+'$+ .;.44!8'+!'$, +"

,+* * "5+++<$+ (+ ""(/', "$+#+,4 $ $"!+&$ *'+& &/! "!' ! # ,"(/ ?59! **+ +# "($ $ ""!'$ ++

' "*"

5 &++ 5 $$" '+! * ++ / $ $+ '+& &/ - ; && ! '

"&+ ' ( # "5++ " * +<$+ ($ + $ ""(/', "4+#+,"

$ $"!' "*"

5&++ 5 $$"'+"+" $ &,+ $' !

"!(0,/'

+#"&, ++**++" $ &, +!

$ +"+?5..! &&""8+''+ &++ ' (* ' , " + ,

+ $ $" 4 0,/! ' , "+ ,

+ $ $"!"& + ,0 '&++ $ &, +6& 7! "! , " "* + '&++

$$"'++'$ &, + > ( # "! ' &++ 5 $$" '+

+#"* '$ &, + 6& 7! ($ ++"

+ '! "! , ($

+#"* $ 0' !+ 67 *+ ,!& '$ &, +! "!(+"'+ + $ +@ $ ' ,---

1 ( # "! ' "+&

' $ +

,++

+ $+#+, "+&! 8' ! ' +++ + * ' $++ , & $"+

+'"*"

5 $$"! ! #+"*

"+ *& > *'$ &, +6& 7!& 8' *($ ? $"'+ *!* '&++ 5 $$"'+&& ",/ ( $'+ "5++ "! ($ "" '&, ++**A

+ $ "8+'$+ .;.

44'* !#+*'8 #+"( $'' ! '& * ' "*"

5&++ 5 $$" + ' $ &, +! , ,/ ' "/* '" + *'( $'! '8 ' '!'++++

+ ""93 , *'44!(* ', "

4+#+,"

$ $"!'

'+& $"+ ++'&++ $ &, +( "/+ '+' ( # **$ B'

'& "'

#*,

,/#+ , "' " * +<$+ "(/' A(,4 "$'

"' #/ *', "+0+ (/$ $+ "

"(+,"+ '& '$ $+ * 8 * "&,? *, 8 + *,, 8+ (+" ' $ $+ $+#++# '"

/ *" $ + C

, - = ' * %+ ( #$ $,+ +!* '* $!'

'( $' *' " * "5+++<$+ " & '$+#+, + + 6& 7!(/', " 4+#+,"

$ $"!"+" $ &+ / "* '$ &, ! ,,

! '

' $$"5&++ '+! '$ $ ++ **$"$+ 9:244! "! '+$ ++ **$ ( "+"+$+ .3.! "!+$+ .39 *'4' ( # **$8 ,"( " ,/!+* /* ," $8 &, $"

(* ', "4+#+,"

$ $"! " !$ ,"( " !+*

* , **+"

#+8 8 ! "!+($ &, $" $ "(/' &++ 5 $$"'+!(* ', "4+#+,"

$ $"!

"!$ ,"#( " ! ,/& ! /&& "( $'(+

" (/ ' &++ 5 "*"

0 ' " * "5++ +<$+ ! ($ ""(/, "4+#+,"

$ $"!& '&, ++**A + $ "8+'

$+ .;.44 ""++ !#+*' ( #& ,+5" "+" $$! '& ! ,/ ' , " <+"+$+ ,,/ & 8"

4 !8'(* '/ $$! " ! 8' $ "'&& "

&<+!"+" %'* $+ " ! 8' $ "!' && "*+$++ " $($ ""$"! ' , < /"

'<+"+$+ ,& 8 $ ' "

6& 7! $ ,"#!'$ &, ?$&& '+ %+ + (* '+! % +"&",/ * " (+ "! (/ ' <+"+$+ ,,/ & 8" 4 ! ' # % ' $ &, +

+'&++ $ /+ '+' ( # **$ 3 #!+$ &$+*+$ /"/!+&$+("

+4 " *4+#+, $"!.32=!* " + ! "!"/+ '

( #( $'!+ $' !'"/0 ( #( $'($ +

$ ,!44!, ,/' * "/!8 '( && &+ "/! ''

'$ + (/'

+#"

&, ++**!'! (,"/!0 '+$ + $ &,,/+5 $ +" &++ $ &, +! (* ' , " 4+#+, "

$ $" .2 $ 0$!'+4 *+"++'&++ ! ( ' ' &++ ,, 8" ' $ &, + (

3D22;2.9D.=2:2.;! +" 1232.1+0 '"!

"! +"! "! , ' $ 0+ , ' & $"+ ! ($ , $'"! , 0 '" " +" ..

" $ . '& ,! "!/( "!+* /*+'"!(/' &++ ! "" (* '8+'$ $,,"! "!"+$'

" .9 +$' +$ +,*'

("$+""!'$! ,,' &"+ + 67!+* /! , "67"+& " * (-

-. /

* "# 12 34 .44561 375 8 !

7 .4455659: !