High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/22856/2025allowed

Amritpal Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-13Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages

8 6:5

% &' 3%2 &"+

% &' 3%2 &"+ (#(,

(#(,

91 8 1 8 1 8 1 8

"#$ ?.%

7%,(,

% &' (") ?.%, &"3%"

+ + + + %,%"

+ %,%"

+ 4- . !

! 4- . !

! - - - - . ) ;( (

1 37&2 % '&

&"%.

. ) "3% !

"#$ !1 33

&" (")*.

<<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< - - - -1 . 6-5 1 . 6-5 1 . 6-5 1 . 6-5 ! ! ! !

%,%"

,%2&"3

&" $, *%%"

" '

%3 ("3% !%2

&" @9 &'

# 0 !(0,$ !"$

1 89 6'& ,$& = !!45 '& #"

%#( *

" 2,% *% # &.> 3 %3 89.8.891 %# %%3 '& $% &''%"2%, ("

,$* % ("

3% !%2

&", : A &'

2 ( (#, "3 ,/2$&

2 !(*, %, 2 > 6'& ,$& = !

2 45 6!%2

&" > &'

! 2 33% % &"51 & 2% !

! 1 -(3$ ".

$% #7%" &'

$% %#

&", , #

, " 22(,%3 3 &' *% " "

"7& 7 .88 0# &' &

( %#%3 / %2&7%%3 '&

&"%.

-%"%3 2&(",% '&

" 2(, &3/ , 89.8.89. - -%"%3 2&(",% '&

"% $, '( $% ,(*

"3 &/

&7 &", &'

! 2

$7% "& ,2( ( &(, / *%%"

%3 B

$1 "3 $(,1

&" 2, ,% ,(''%, '& "$%%"

3%'%2 ,.

-%"%3 2&("

",% '&

&"% $,

, 3% /%3 "3

$%%&' 2""& *% ', %"%3 (

&"%. -%"%3 2&(",% $, '(

&"% $, , ,(''%%3

&" '& &%

$" 8 /%, ,.

$(,1 %#( *

/%3 '& .

-%"%3 !

% 2&(",% $, &

&,%3

&" */ #(

$% %#

&", ,%3 #

&"% % ,% &(, " "

(% "31 $(,1 $% % 3&%, "& 3%,%7% $% 2&"2%,,

$% %#( * . -%"%3

% 2&(",% $, '( $% ,(*

, %, %3 */

#&, &'

' !%2

&" 9A &'

$(,1 $% ,% &(#$

& *% , ,,%3. -% %"%3 !

% 2&(",% ,%%0,

2% &" %2&3 2(, &3/ 2%

.8. 8 " &( 1 B$ 2$ 0%" &"

" %2&3.

$7% $%3 2&(",% '&

%, "3 $7% #&"% $&(#$

$% 7 * % %2&3, &'

$% 2,%.

&"% B, %, &" 89.8.891 B$%% "'

"7%,

" B, 2 %3 &( $% 2$ "

" B, %3 &" 8A.8.89.

&,%2(

&" B

"%,,%, $7% *%%"

" 2

%31 *( &" / 8 $, *%%"

7 2&"

&", ,%3 # 7% ,% & 3%* * %

,,(%, ,$ * *%

&2 %3 ( &" 3( 2&(,% &'

, &( 3&%, 3%%

& 3% 7% 3%%

$%,% 7 2&"

&",1

#%1 %,

/ %)(3 2% * % $, *%%" *&(#$

'&B3

0% $&&3 &'

&"% *,2&"3 "# '&

&2%,, &' )(

2% & %'% "# B

&, ,%2(

&" %7 3%"2%.

"3(*

* /1

$% ,%2&"3

,%2(% %#( * $% ,

%'%%3 */

B, 3 , ,, %3 , B

$3B" &" 8.8.8 @. &B%7%1 0%%

" 7 %B '( "2 2%

&"% '&

&3 &' &% $"

$, "3 "& ,(*,

&#%,, ,

"2 & '7&(* / 2&", 3%

% '& * . &'

* % %'%%"2%1 , %#31 2"

*% 3% )(3#%"

, &(

,,%3 " !99 99 99 9989 89 89 89

%3 , '

D ;$" 7 '

D ;$" 7 7%,(, !

% &' /" "3 "& 7%,(, !

% &' /" "3 "&

$%H % %7"

B$%%&' %3, , ("3%+ 8.

, " %

&#(%

%, %%#%+ !%2&"3F,(22%,, %

"* % " B : $%"2% ,& % / &"

$% #&("3 &'

!(2$ ,%2&"3F,(22%,,

"* % B$% %

$3B"F3 , ,,%3 , "&

& %

&" B, 3 , ,, & $% ,%2&"3F,(22 ,(22%%31

&"%F

%D( %3 & ,$&B ,(*,

&' %% ,( %'

& &, %

$& 2 %C %,, &" &' ,%% &(#$ *% *, 2 ,(*,

1 %''%2

7% "3 2&",

& %C$(,

7% #( 3% B$ B&( 3 2&",

% ,(*, 2,% $,

, &B" ("

D(% '

, "& "# *( " ( *%, %'

$% )(3 ,3&

$ ,(2$ ,%2&"3F,(22%,, 7%

" 2,% &( 2$&&,

&"6,51 2&#%"

"3 (2

$% *&7% 3 ,2(,, $% '& &B %#(

&"6,5

,(2$

&" &(#$

& *% %)%2

$%%&'.

%#(

&"6,5

B, , ,,%3

%,,%3F3 , ,,%3 '& "&"

,%3 &" %

22%,, 7% %#( *

&"6,5

,$ *% %,,%"

"%"

2$"#% " 2 2(, "2%, "3 ,$&B * % 2$"#% B&( 3 "& ,(''

2%.

%%0 "# ,%2&"3F,(22%,, 7% *

%6,5

&", &'

&"6,5 B

,%D(%"

2$"#% " 2 2(, "2%,.

"%, 2"

&,, * / *% 3 3&B" ,

2$"#% " 2 2(, "2%, , %7%/ '2 ,F2 2(, "2%. 0 "# ,(2$ "

" %"3%7&(. #&1 ,,(% "3 3 ,2%

$% &( 3% %#( *

&"6,5.

,%, & #"

,%2&"3F,(22%,, 7% %#( (2 3 %,&", %

"%"

/ %D( %3

@ @ *% %2&3%3 '& #"

"# ,( ,%2&"3F,(22%,,

&"6,5.

$7 ,(22%,,'( / ,%2&"3F,(22%,,

&"6,5 3%2

$%* % '& $% , 3 &3 (2$ % 3%,

% ,(2$ % *%

" & $% B&3,1 $% 2(,% '& &(

2&("

%""2%3F%"

,(2$ 5 &(#$

& *% %3 / "3 2 % / 3% ,,%3.K ..

%(, &'

$% L "

&3%,

,,%3 */ 1 *&(#$

'& $ */

&"%1 %,

"3%%3 &2,

"# "3 '& / $%%&'

' 2""& *% ,33 %3 (

&"%. , % 2(, &3/ 2%

% 3

.8.8 '

%3 */ $% %"

"%3 !

% 2&(",% 1

$, %3/ , ,(''%%3

&" '& &3 &' 8 /%,1 89 &"

$, "3 8@ @ 3/,.

%B &'

%1 #& &,%3 ("3% !%2

&" 9A &'

! 2 "3, 3 #$ $%

2 % $% &",

&" &'

.9.

, &(

" )(3#%"

3 , ;( B "3% 7%,(, !

% &'

;( B "3% 7%,(, !

% &'

;( B "3% 7%,(, !

% &'

;( B "3% 7%,(, !

% &'

' ' ' '

(")* (")* (")* (")* ,,% " @8A@ @8A@ @8A@ @8A@8@ 8@ 8@ 8@ 68 ++88>5H '

% % /

& 3%2 3%"3 $% )(3#%"

$% &"4* % !( %% &(

(,, " ;

;$ &&" 7,. &% !%2/.1 !

% & ' $ 6 >85 ! H *3( %$" "

( / 7, .!.

/0 6 >>5

! H 7%3 (

!$ 0$ 7,. !

% &' $,$ "3 "& 1 8@695 6 " 5 @>@H &$3 (, I (,, " 7,. !

% 6 ' % $ 5 % %3 , 89

H "

&.@F88 3 3 8A.8.88

%3 , E$

,B, , !(*$, 7,.

$% !

% &' J%,

%"# KH E

,$ 3$ 0/ I I " 7,.

$% !

% &' J%, %"# K1 !

%2 -%7% &

% 6 .5

&.988 3 %3 .8.8

%3 , E &$3 ! " "

' !$ 0$ 7,.

$% !

% &' () KH "

> &' 8 3 8.8.8

%3 , & ; ,$" I & (, 7,. "

"3 "0( $(3$/ 7,. !

% &' 3$/ 3%,$1 8@6@5 6 " 5 AH $, $% 31 $(,+ EA..

$% #$

& , %%3/

,'%#(3 %7%"

("3(% "3 "C / "3 2&"2%" 22& "/

$% *

/ &' " 22(, &7%2$ "# ,&2

%%,

"# B *%%" % %3 / 2 $% %2%"

*&7%%'%%3 & !( %% &( 4, )( 3%2 &", & "# ( "%B 7 %%3/

, # '("3%"

'% "3 /1 &",

&".

$% #$

& , %%3/

&,%3

% &'

$% %,

&" B$ 2$ 2&"

"(%,

"7%,

"D( /1

%)(3 2% / %,( 3(%

% &'

$% 2& ,, &" &'

$% & 2&",( & '

/1 2&( 3 * $% "# "3 D( 20 3 &, % , "% D( &7%2&B3%3 &( 3&20% ,1 $% $%7

%,,(% &"

&" "3 2 " )( (3%"

%2$"

, ( 2""& *% " %C2(,% '& 0%%

22(,%3 '& "

"3%'

&3 &'

2 " )(,

2% ,/, %1

#("

%% &' , %%3/

%"3 3% / */ &, "# &"

$% &(

&2%%3 B

$ %,&"*

$%%'& 3 ( &,%. , /1

,&"%"

H ,%2&"3 /1

(* 2 ,(,

&" 3(% & ("%,& 7%3 2

$% ,0 %7 3%"2% B

,,#% &'

%1 $(,1

,% '.

#&%, B

% #7%. 22(,%31 %,(%3 ,(*)%2 ,/2$& &# 2 "3 $/, ("3% &"%&(, 2&"3

&",. D( / ,(2$ " 22(,%3 '%D(%"

/ ' , $% ' /.

$%% , /% 2&", 3%

, , #%.

$% %# 22(,%3 *% " " 2&"

*"3 ("3% >

" 2,% "7& 7 "# 2&%2 D("

#&(, %"(% %3 ("3% !%2

&" 9A

, 2" #"

& " 2

& "3 '

% $7 "# ,

%,&"* % #&("3, '& *% %7 &''%"2% 2$#%3F %#%3 "3 1 $% / "3 %C

&(,

, "& &" / 3 &

%,,

&"H &

$% 22(,

&" , B% , & 2(

"/ ,%3 & 3%'%"3 $ ,% '1 *(

$%% , "

B/ '& , %%3/ , #$ $,

& 3%2 3%"3 )(3#%"

, $7% 3 3&B" ,% %, &'

' '("3%"

#$ ,.

$% 2&"2%

2 % , " %,,%"

1 #("

%%3 "3 %,%7%3 ("3% &(

*%# ", B

$% 2 ( %,

$% 22(,%3 "3 2&",%D(%"

#%,1 "% /1 $% , #% &'

"3 %7 &" ,& "/ &,, * %

% ,, * % "3 7& 3* % 3% / , &''%"2%

$% 2 &2%%3 "#, *% 7% %3.

$% , %%3/ 1 % / D( "&" &' 2 " )( (3%"2%.

7/ 7& (% &' B&0 "3 $% %,(

% & 2%1 "3(*

* / 0%% $% %"

% ("3% , %,, "3 , ". &B%7%1 % ,B&3 &' &2 %, $"# "# &"

3&%, "& ,%7% "/ 2%3

0%, '& ,3 ,

% &' ''

3%3 & 7& 3 &

%,, &" "3 %7%"

&" " &*

* % 3

2$.

$% #("

%% ,%7%, $% 22(,%3 #

%,, %

%7%, $% 22(,%3 &'

$% "C / "3 2 " 2$#%, "3 , /1

%2 *% &, & %& %, 3 %3 */ $% *

/ &'

$% 22(,%3 & 3%'%"3 $% 2&",%D(%"2%, &'

% 3%

""&2%"

&7%" & $%B ,%1 % 2 3%

&", &' ) '%1 (,( /

$% *(3%" &' 3%

/ &"

""&2%"

%*%, &' $ %2 $%

% B$ 2$ 3%,%7%, %#

&", 2,% % %

& 2&%2 D("

/ &'

>. J$ % 2&", 3% "# *

/1 $% &( $, & 0%%

" A &'

> B$ 2$ "3 %, 22(,%3 &" / '

% $% (*

,% ' &'

" 2&"3

&", B$ 2$ %

$% 22(,%3 , "& #(

/ &'

, "&

0% / & 2&

"/ &''%"2%

B$ % &" * $% , "#%"

#&(, & (, *% %

2( &(, / ,2(

L%3 '("3%"

& , %%3/ 2""& *% %"3%%3 "(# &/ */ ("B

2( / B$%% ,(2$ 3% /6,5 , "

)(,

$% %"3 &'

2""& *% 0%

*%$ "3 *, '& "

%'(#% " #&(, 3 3&B"

" !%2

%# (%

, B ,3&1 " &3%

$% 2,%, ("3% $% 2 1 $, &7 3%3 ("3% !%2

&" 9 &'

$% 2 . &B %/% 2 %3 3% /, "3 ,/,

( &,%. &( &' B *%2&% 2&

" 7

&" &

$, "# "/ "# 2&"

" 2,% #&7%"%3 */

>1 $% &( (, 0% )(3

& 2(* $% %"2% &' 3(#, "

& '

"3 %C

&(, . & &"

2(,%1 ,0, ",'& % 3% " &( 2&% "

#&1 $% ("%D( 7&2 & 2&"2 (3% B

" %,&

%, #

/ #"

%3 ("3% $% B &7% $% ,

&/ %*#& 2% 2 > &(#$

& *% 2&", 3%%3 , B&3,1 #"

&' *

" 2,%

#&("3 &' ("3(% 3% / 1 2""& >.K &' !%2

&" 9A &'

$% *203& &' 22(,%34,

'% "3 %,&"

%3 3% /, $% )(3

&2%,,1 "%

*( * % $% 22(,%3 "& )

&" */ 2&#%"

%,&",. "

"&3 &3 &'

% */

&" 9A &'

%",(% , %%3/ "3

% / 3 &, &'

3 '& $% 2&",

&" &' , %2 B%7%1 , &( 2""&

% ,&"4,

"%''

%"2/ '(, , 3( /*&("3 & %",(%

3&%, &' "

3( 4, '("3%"

#$ ,1

" ,

%. J$ % 3% "# B

$ *

#&(, &' !%2

&" 9A &'

&(, * "2% *% B%%"

$% %#

$% ,2&,"2 #$ $% 22(,%3 "#%3

&"1 B

)(,

* % 3%

,&"%"

% &' )(,

2% "3 %D(

"'%%"2% B$%% $, &"* %

%1 %,(

& &"#%3 %2 &(, '("3%"

#$ , &'

'% B "31 , ,(2$1 2&"3

%3 ("3% !%2

&" 9A &'

% '2 , &' # 7%" 2,%.

" &

& 2&%2 D("

/1 &"

*% , & *% '%

%%3 */ !%2

&" 9A .@.

( $%1 , $% , 3 2(, &3 3/ 2%

& *%

" (

% 6,5. & &B%7%1 , '2 ( 2""& *% #&("3 ,(''

,% '1 & 3%2 "% $% 2& &"2%,, &" &' %#( *

$% " D(%,

&" B$%" 2,% , 3% &( '& #"

&' %#( D( $% " D(%,

&" */

$% '2 ,F2 2(, "2%, &'

$% , 3 .

. % , %#3 2" *%

2%3 ( $% )(3#%"

&"4* % !(

%% &(

" ( " &$3.

( " &$3.

,$3

7. !

% &' ..

,$3

7. !

% &' ..

,$3

7. !

% &' ..

,$3

7. !

% &' ..

"3 "& $%1 "3 "& $%1 "3 "& $%1 "3 "& $%1 8 6 5 6 " 5 8 6 5 6 " 5 8 6 5 6 " 5 8 6 5 6 " 5 H H &" %"2$ )(3#%"

$% &"4* % 2(

#$ &(

" 2,% &'

' ! 3$ , 7. !

%1 >> 65 ! 3$ , 7. !

%1 >> 65 5 5 5 5

6 6 6 6

" 5 @AA

" 5 @AA : )(3#%"

, & &(

" &.98

%3 , 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ %,$ !

"#$ 7. !

% &' /"

0$ %,$ !

"#$ 7. !

% &' /"

0$ %,$ !

"#$ 7. !

% &' /"

0$ %,$ !

"#$ 7. !

% &' /"

"1 3%2 3%3 &" >.

.8 1 "3 ) 7. !

) 7. !

% &' /"1 >> 695 6

% &' /"1 >> 695 6 " 5 > " 5 > " 5 > " 5 > !(''

2% & ,/1 '( $% 3%

&" &'

&"% , "

("3%

, "

$% '2 , "3 2 2(, "2%, &'

$% 2,%.

" 7 %B &' *&7%1

, &B%3. %

&3%%3 & *% % % %,%3 &" %#( * &" $ , '("

,$ "# * F,(% / *&"3,

$% ,

,'2

$% -3. 2&"2%"%3 & &( F( / # %. &B%7%1

" 33

& 2&"3

&", / *% &,%3 */ $% 2&"2%"%3

F( / # %1

&"% ,$ % " *&("3 */ $% '& &B 2&"3

&",+

&"% ,$ "&

3&2(%"

/1 3(

&"% ,$ "& ,(,% / #"

%3.

% B

$ "/ %7 3%"2%1 & &

*,%"

,% ' &" "/ 3 % *%'&%

&"% ,$ "&

"/ &''%"2% B$ % &"

&"% ,$ 3%

&"% ,$ #

"7%,

"# ''

2%F! "3 ,$ "& 2$"#% $ , 2

% ,, &

&"% ,$ "&

,, ' "/1 B

% $ , 2% $&"% "(*% &' 2&"2%"%3 & 2% !

2% $&"% "(*% B

( D # %.

" "/ ""% / & 3% /

&"% ,$ ,(*

1 &"

$% '

, B&0 "# 3/ &'

%7%/ &"

$1 " ''

37 $% %''%2

2& ,, &" &' "/ &''%"

" 2,%

&''%"2% '

% $ , *% "# % 1 &"

$% *, , &' $ , '

"3 & &7%1 '& $B

1 *%'&% $% 2&"2%"%3

$% $, "& *%%"

"2% '

% *% "# % %,%3 &" * , '&("3 & *% " "/ %" #%3 &" *

& & $%B ,%1 $% !

$1 '& 2"2%

&" &' $ , *

B$ 2$ %1 *( &' 2&( %

$%%&'.

,%1 ,$ *%

&2 %3 ( .

" 2,% &' *%2$ &' "/ &'

% '&%, 3 2&"3

&", "3 $&,% B$ 2$ / * *% &,%3 */ 2&"2%"%3 & &( F( / # % , 3 %2 $%% "*&7% ,$&B "/ ,(''

2(,%1

%F2&

,$ *%

& & &7% 2"2%

&" &' *

&"%.

3%%3 22&3 "# /.

"# , 3 $%% "*&7% ,$ * *% 2&", (%3 , " %C %,,

&" &"

$% %

$% 2,%.

$% " 2,% $, *%%" 3 3%2 3%31 %"3 "# ,2% "%&(,

' "/1 ,$ ,& , "3, 3 &,%3 3 &''.

(#(,

91 1 1 1 $7 J$% $% , %0 J$% $% %

8 8 8 8 6! - ! - ! - ! -5

"#F%,&"%3+ %,F

* %+ %,F